The source definition, pricing basis and final account aggregation of the three kinds of quantities (contract BOQ quantities / variation quantities / dayworks record quantities), including the comparison baselines for BOQ errors - variation - additional works and the one-gateway-only rule against double measurement (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 7.2, 7.3, 7.4, 7.5, 8.2, 8.6, 8.9, 8.10, 8.11, 10.3; compared with GB 50500-2013 clauses 9.3, 9.14, 11.2)
Clause 7.4.1 of GB/T 50500-2024 draws the boundary with three comparison baselines: the difference between the contract drawings and the contract BOQ = errors and omissions in the BOQ (corrected under unit-rate contracts, not adjusted under lump-sum contracts); the difference between the contract drawings and 'variation instructions + as-executed drawings' = variation; work outside the contractual scope of works completed at the employer's request = additional works (8.10.1); sundry items and events not attributable to the contractor are measured on dayworks vouchers (7.5.3 to 7.5.6). In-contract quantities are re-measured under 7.2.1 (BOQ items priced per item are not re-measured or adjusted); deviations within 15% (inclusive) go to 8.9.1 and beyond 15% to 8.9.2, the rate progressing 'contract rate -> converted similar rate -> negotiated market-reasonable all-in unit rate'; dayworks take the contract dayworks all-in unit rate under 8.6.2, or where no such BOQ item or no applicable rate exists the published price information under 8.6.3 and, failing that, the contractor's purchase price as confirmed by both parties, the rate already covering the sporadic extra costs and preliminaries of dayworks (8.6.4). Settlement aggregates in the 13-item order of 10.3.2, with preliminaries and the main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions recalculated at final account (10.3.3). No double measurement: variation quantities are determined only after comparison with 'the BOQ items and quantities as corrected for BOQ errors' (7.4.2), and what has already been adjusted under 8.2 to 8.10 may not be claimed again under the claims provisions (8.11.1).
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第7.1.7、7.1.8、7.2.1、7.3.1、7.4.1、7.4.2、7.4.4、7.5.3~7.5.6、8.2.1、8.6.2~8.6.4、8.9.1、8.9.2、8.10.1、8.11.1、10.3.2、10.3.3条
- GB 50500-2013 建设工程工程量清单计价规范 第9.3.1、9.3.2、9.14.1~9.14.4、9.15.2、11.2.4条
What this card covers
This card resolves the most common classification dispute in cost practice: whether a quantity is 'inside the contract BOQ', 'generated by variation' or 'a site-record / dayworks quantity'; how each kind is measured, at what rate it is priced, into which final account item it is aggregated, and why one event may pass through only one gateway and must never be counted twice. Based on GB/T 50500-2024, the China national BOQ pricing standard (a recommended standard; the contract prevails), compared with the former GB 50500-2013.
Core conclusions
1. The master test: three comparison baselines decide the class (key points of clause 7.4.1)
'Whatever unit-rate or lump-sum contract the works adopt, comparing the variation instructions issued or confirmed by the employer and the as-executed drawings with the contract drawings, the divisional and sub-divisional BOQ items in the differing part are variation items, and the variation shall be measured under the national and sectoral quantity take-off standards agreed in the contract and any supplementary measurement rules. The difference between the contract drawings and the contract BOQ is errors and omissions in the BOQ; unit-rate contracts shall correct those errors and omissions as provided, and for lump-sum contracts the errors and omissions in the BOQ are not adjusted.' (clause 7.4.1)
Four classes follow, decided only by the gaps between the two pairs of baselines:
- Contract drawings <-> contract BOQ -> errors and omissions in the BOQ (corrected under unit-rate contracts, not adjusted under lump-sum contracts);
- Contract drawings <-> (variation instructions issued or confirmed by the employer + as-executed drawings) -> variation items;
- Outside the contractual scope of works, completed at the employer's request -> additional works (clause 8.10.1: may be priced by itemising under the national and sectoral quantity take-off standards and supplementary calculation rules agreed in the contract, with contract rates and the tender pricing level, or by separately negotiating measurement and pricing rules and signing a supplementary agreement; the preliminaries cost shall include the costs of preliminaries items used for longer or added);
- Sundry items, events not attributable to the contractor, etc. -> dayworks measurement + certified vouchers (clauses 7.5.3 to 7.5.6).
2. Constituent elements, measurement basis and diversion where a class fails
(1) Contract BOQ (in-contract) quantities: under unit-rate contracts, re-measured under clause 7.2.1 from the drawings of the works as actually constructed provided by the employer and the variation instructions issued and confirmed, under the national and sectoral quantity take-off standards and the supplementary rules agreed in the contract; 'divisional and sub-divisional BOQ items priced per item shall not be re-measured or adjusted'; preliminaries works listed as BOQ items (such as formwork) and other preliminaries items the contract requires to be measured follow the same clause. Where the BOQ items and quantities show no difference from the priced BOQ and the deviation is within 15% (inclusive) -> in-contract quantities, at the original contract rates.
(2) Variation quantities: clause 7.4.2 - 'for variations under unit-rate contracts, the divisional and sub-divisional BOQ items and quantities shall be recalculated from the variation instructions issued or confirmed by the employer and the as-executed drawings, and compared with the BOQ items and quantities as corrected for errors and omissions in the BOQ, to determine the varied items and their quantities.' Constituent elements: a written variation instruction issued or confirmed by the employer (an oral instruction alone cannot be measured); the difference is genuinely that between the as-executed drawings and the contract drawings; what has already been corrected as errors must be deducted; the change is within the scope of the contract (outside it, it becomes additional works). Changes in preliminaries items caused by variation follow clause 7.4.4: per the employer-approved implementation method or the content actually occurring, measure the additional site management personnel deployed, the additional temporary facilities erected and other additional preliminaries works; the additional costs of the extended use of existing preliminaries items and management personnel caused by variations off the critical path need not be measured.
(3) Dayworks / site-record quantities (2024 edition): the voucher form is the 'dayworks record report', filed day by day - 'the name, content and quantity of the work; the names, trades, grades and hours consumed of all personnel deployed on the work; the names, classes, specifications, brands and quantities of materials deployed on the work; the models, quantities and machine-shifts consumed of the construction plant deployed on the work; other records and vouchers the employer requires to be submitted' (clause 7.5.3); for work not finished on the same day, a summary report is submitted within the agreed time after it ends (7.5.4); where the employer fails to provide the verification/review results in time, 'the content of the statements or dayworks record reports submitted by the contractor is deemed approved by the employer' (7.5.5); after joint confirmation the parties sign the confirmed dayworks results, which serve as the basis for pricing under clause 8.6 (7.5.6). Exclusions from the measurement scope: the personnel, material and plant quantities in the dayworks record report submitted by the contractor 'shall be the quantities measured for the relevant works or work, and do not include the contractor's own on-site management personnel and the construction plant already on site, which are not measured'.
3. Pricing basis compared (three routes, not to be interchanged)
| Class | Source of the all-in unit rate | Clause |
|---|---|---|
| In-contract quantities | the original contract BOQ all-in unit rate (deviation within 15% inclusive) | 7.2.1, 8.9.1 |
| Variation quantities (within 15% inclusive, or items added/removed) | five-tier progression: same construction conditions + same item description -> the corresponding contract rate; similar item description under the same conditions / same item description under similar conditions -> the contract rate of a similar BOQ item converted and adjusted; different item description under the same conditions / same item description under different conditions -> a market-reasonable all-in unit rate negotiated with reference to the pricing rules and tender level of similar items; different item description under different conditions -> negotiated with reference to the all-in unit rates of similar BOQ items of comparable works; items reduced or cancelled materially changing the construction conditions -> negotiated per the circumstances, market prices, the contract pricing rules and the tender level | 8.9.1 |
| Variation quantities (beyond 15%, exclusive) | on top of 8.9.1: for increases, the contract rate and the new all-in unit rate are reasonably reduced to reflect the procurement discounts on labour and materials gained from the larger quantities; for decreases, reasonably increased to reflect the discounts lost | 8.9.2 |
| Dayworks / site records | the all-in unit rate of the dayworks items in the contract BOQ (8.6.2); where no such BOQ item or no applicable rate exists, labour, material and plant costs determined from the prices published by the market price source agreed in the contract; where the agreement is unclear, from the VAT-exclusive market rental prices of labour, materials and plant published by the cost administration department of the place of the works or by the sector, broken down with reference to the rate build-up of similar BOQ items; where the published price information also carries no price, from the contractor's purchase price confirmed by both parties (8.6.3). The all-in unit rate 'shall include the extra costs caused by the sporadic, small-scale occurrence of dayworks items and the preliminaries costs arising from dayworks items; the preliminaries costs in the contract price shall not be adjusted because dayworks occur' (8.6.4) | 8.6.2 to 8.6.4 |
Former standard comparison (GB 50500-2013, applied only where the contract expressly carries it over or for historical comparison): clause 9.3.1, four tiers - where an applicable item exists, that item's rate is adopted (where the quantity deviation exceeds 15%, the rate must be adjusted under 9.6.2); where no applicable item but a similar one exists, it may be referenced; where neither applicable nor similar exists, the contractor proposes a rate from the variation documents, the measurement rules and the pricing method, the published price information issued by the cost administration institution and its quoted floating rate, for the employer's confirmation (with separate formulas for tendered / non-tendered works); where even the published price information carries no price, a rate is proposed from the variation documents, the measurement rules, the pricing method and a lawful market price obtained by market survey, for confirmation. Clause 9.3.2: where the variation changes the construction method and thereby changes preliminaries items, the intended method must be submitted in advance to the employer for confirmation; failing which it is 'treated as the variation not causing adjustment of the preliminaries costs, or as the contractor waiving its right to adjust them'.
4. Aggregation into final account items (clause 10.3.2, the statement compiled in the 13-item order)
(1) total contract BOQ price (in-contract quantities counted on this basis) -> (2) adjustment for BOQ errors and omissions -> (3) adjustment for provisional sums -> (4) adjustment for provisional prices (materials / specialist works) -> (5) adjustment for the main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions -> (6) dayworks adjustment -> (7) adjustment for changes in costs -> (8) adjustment for changes in laws, regulations and policies -> (9) variation increases and decreases -> (10) additional works -> (11) claims -> (12) liquidated damages for non-performance as agreed in the contract -> (13) other amounts. Key aggregation rules:
- Divisional and sub-divisional works: contract BOQ quantities enter item (1); corrections of errors enter (2); variation increases and decreases enter (9); additional works outside the contract are listed separately under (10) - not merged into item (1).
- Preliminaries items: preliminaries in the priced BOQ are in principle not re-measured or adjusted (clause 7.3.1 lists five exceptions: preliminaries works listed as divisional and sub-divisional BOQ items and preliminaries items the contract requires to be measured follow 7.2.1/7.2.2; the statutory safety provisions follow the contract; those caused by variation follow 7.4.4; those caused by BOQ errors follow 8.2.2 and 8.2.3; those arising from the works included in the provisional sums that could not be fully foreseen or detailed follow 7.7.2). At final account, all preliminaries costs contained in the completed works (including adjustment of the statutory work safety levy) must be recalculated under clause 7.3 and Chapter 8, and 'the preliminaries costs listed in interim settlement by construction stage shall not serve as the basis of the final account of the works' (clause 10.3.3).
- Other items: dayworks enter item (6) (priced under clause 8.6); provisional sums, provisional prices and the main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions enter items (3), (4) and (5) respectively, the attendance and coordination provisions being recalculated at final account under clause 8.5, with interim settlement listings not serving as the basis (10.3.3). The 2013 edition counterpart is clause 11.2.4: dayworks are computed from the events actually certified by the employer; site instruction record costs are computed from the amounts confirmed in the parties' records; any surplus of the provisional sums after deduction of the contract price adjustments (including claims and site instruction records) belongs to the employer.
5. One gateway only: the same event must not be measured twice
- The error gateway and the variation gateway run on separate tracks by nature: clause 7.2.1 makes clear - differences between the BOQ items and quantities measured from the contract drawings and the priced BOQ are errors and omissions in the BOQ, adjusted under clause 8.2; differences between the contract drawings and the as-executed drawings are variations, adjusted under clause 8.9. The same difference may not be treated both as an error and as a variation.
- Variation quantities must first deduct corrected errors: clause 7.4.2 requires variation quantities to be compared with 'the BOQ items and quantities as corrected for errors and omissions' before the increases and decreases are determined - the key anti-double-counting step; final account review must first correct the error baseline, then compute the variations.
- The claims gateway is residual, not parallel: clause 8.11.1 - 'where the price adjustment of an event has already been calculated under the contract price adjustment provisions (excluding claims), no claim for the works shall be calculated again.' Events within the scope of clauses 8.2 to 8.10 follow those provisions; only events outside them go to the claims provisions.
- Dayworks rates already include preliminaries and the sporadic extras: preliminaries costs must not be counted again (8.6.4); for specialist works carried out under provisional prices for nominated specialist subcontracts, the preliminaries costs are already inside the subcontract lump sum and must not be re-measured (7.3.1).
- No written instruction, no right to measurement: variations require an instruction issued or confirmed by the employer (7.4.1, 7.4.2); clause 9.14.4 of the 2013 edition is blunter - 'where a site instruction record event occurs on the contract works and the contractor performs the work without the employer's certification, unless the employer's written consent is obtained, the resulting costs shall be borne by the contractor.'
- The evidentiary anchor of measurement: measurement results signed and confirmed by both parties serve as the basis for contract price adjustment and settlement (clause 7.1.8); failing agreement, the dispute resolution provisions of Chapter 11 apply (clause 7.1.7).
6. A numbering trap
'Site instruction records' sit at clause 9.14 in GB 50500-2013 (9.14.1 the employer's written instruction and the contractor's request for a record; 9.14.2 the contractor submits the site record report within 7 days, the employer verifies within 48 hours, and failure to confirm or comment in time is deemed approval; 9.14.3 two filing modes depending on whether a dayworks rate exists; 9.14.4 the costs of unauthorised work performed without certification borne by the contractor); clause 9.10 is force majeure, and clause 9.15 is provisional sums (9.15.2 any balance after payment returns to the employer). Citing 'clause 9.10 site instruction records' invites an immediate challenge that the clause does not exist. GB/T 50500-2024 sets no standalone 'site instruction records' section; only the voucher form 'dayworks record report' survives (7.5.3 to 7.5.6), substantive matters being diverted by nature into four gateways: BOQ errors (8.2), variations (8.9), additional works (8.10) and claims (8.11).
Applicable boundaries
- The separate-track rules above take unit-rate contracts as their typical object; under lump-sum contracts errors and omissions in the BOQ are not adjusted (7.4.1), and the measurement and pricing of variations and additional works follow the contract - the unit-rate conclusions must not be transplanted to lump-sum contracts.
- The 15% boundary is based on 'the quantity contained in the contract BOQ for the item concerned' (8.2.1), a single-item basis, not that of a whole divisional section or the unit works; items added or removed (changes in item count) and item description mismatches go to 8.9.1 and are not judged by 15%.
- GB/T 50500-2024 is a recommended standard; where the contract expressly agrees otherwise, that agreement governs; clause 7.1.8 also allows exceptions 'where the contract provides otherwise or both parties expressly agree that the results serve only as the basis for progress payments, or where the measurement results are rough estimates'.
- The 2013 clauses are cited only where the contract expressly carries the former standard over, for historical final accounts or for version comparison, and must not drive quantitative conclusions under the 2024 system.
- This card gives the classification and aggregation logic of the standard's clauses; actual rate values and quantity computations must be made item by item under the contract and the quantity take-off standards, and the card is not a pricing conclusion for any individual project.
Further reading
- GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 7.1.7 and 7.1.8 (confirmation and effect of measurement results), 7.2.1 (re-measurement of divisional and sub-divisional BOQ items under unit-rate contracts), 7.3.1 (no re-measurement adjustment for preliminaries and the five exceptions), 7.4.1 to 7.4.4 (master test for variation measurement, variation quantities net of errors, measuring the preliminaries effects of variations), 7.5.3 to 7.5.6 (dayworks daily reporting, summary reports, verification time limits, confirmed results).
- GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.2.1 (error adjustment and the 15% split), 8.6.2 to 8.6.4 (dayworks pricing and rate composition), 8.9.1 and 8.9.2 (the five-tier variation rates and the up/down adjustment beyond 15%), 8.10.1 (additional works), 8.11.1 (claims as the residual route, no double counting), 10.3.2 and 10.3.3 (the 13-item final account statement, recalculation of preliminaries and attendance).
- GB 50500-2013 clauses 9.3.1 and 9.3.2 (four-tier variation valuation and the quoted floating rate, advance confirmation for preliminaries adjustment), 9.14.1 to 9.14.4 (site instruction record procedure and effect), 9.15.2 (surplus of the provisional sums), 11.2.4 (pricing of other items at final account).
- Extensions: the evidence chain of variations and records (instruction sheets, record reports, signed measurement results), and the three-step review order 'correct the errors first, then compute the variations, then verify the records'.
Keywords
- 合同清单工程量
- 工程变更计量
- errors and omissions in the BOQ
- 计日工签证报告
- variation record / site instruction
- 竣工结算价款列项
- 重复计量
- GB/T 50500-2024