Reviewing tender bills of quantities: methods and criteria for detecting omissions, errors, and duplications
Check the BOQ against four baselines—tender documents, construction drawings, measurement standards, and the pricing standard: omissions via drawing cross-check + standard appendix tick-off + item description derivation + preliminaries check; errors via codes (twelve digits, no duplicate codes within one project), item descriptions (standard, concise, accurate, complete), units and quantities, and work-content attribution (operations must not be split); duplications via duplicate codes, substantively identical items, split-out operations, and overlaps between work items and preliminaries. Per GB/T 50500-2024 Article 4.1.4: BOQ defects are borne by the employer under unit-rate contracts (adjusted per Section 8.2) and by the contractor under lump-sum contracts (not adjusted per Article 6.1.7).
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准
- GB/T 50854-2024 房屋建筑与装饰工程工程量计算标准
- GB 50860-2013 构筑物工程工程量计算规范
- DB37/T 5096-2017 建设工程项目管理咨询规范
- T/CMEA 53-2024 市政基础设施项目全过程工程咨询指南
Topic Positioning
This card provides a complete checking framework for tender-stage BOQ review: how to systematically detect omissions, errors, and duplications—what to check, how, and by what criteria—plus review procedure, for cost consultants, employers (tenderers), and bidders reviewing BOQs.
Core Conclusions
Check one BOQ against four baselines: tender documents, construction drawings, measurement standards, and the pricing standard (GB/T 50500-2024).
- Omissions: (1) drawing cross-check—sheet by sheet by discipline; on drawing but not in BOQ = omission; (2) standard appendix check—tick off against the division/sub-division tables of the applicable measurement standard appendix; (3) item description derivation—necessary work mentioned in the item description (bedding, leveling, corrosion protection, waterproofing) must have corresponding BOQ items; (4) preliminaries checked against the envisioned project execution plan (construction methodology and site organization).
- Errors: (1) item codes must be twelve digits—positions 1-9 per the appendix, 10-12 per actual project; no duplicate codes within one tendered project (GB 50860-2013 Article 4.2.2, mandatory provision of the code); (2) item descriptions must be standard, concise, accurate, and complete, sufficient to determine all-in unit rates (GB/T 50854-2024 Article 4.1.2); (3) units and quantities re-verified per measurement rules; (4) work content should include all necessary work—single operations must not be split into separate items.
- Duplications: screen duplicate codes across the whole table; substantively identical items (different names but same item description/work content) identified by drawing location; operations already included in work content (vibrating, curing) listed separately are duplicates; overlaps between work items and preliminaries resolved to unique attribution per compilation rules. Procedure suggestion: first internal consistency (unique codes, uniform units, subtotals = totals), then table-vs-drawing (omissions/errors), then table-vs-tender (scope, pricing principles, provisional sums consistent with tender documents).
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to tender-stage BOQ compilation/review; each discipline must use its own measurement standard appendix (buildings: GB/T 50854-2024 Appendices A-R); bill of preliminaries defects are the contractor's responsibility under any contract type; this card is a checking-method framework, not a substitute for verifying local pricing bases.
Further Reading
GB/T 50500-2024 Article 4.1.4 (BOQ defect liability), Article 4.1.7 (compilation rules); GB/T 50854-2024 Article 4.1.2 (item descriptions and work content); GB 50860-2013 Article 4.2.2 (mandatory coding rule); review essentials in DB37/T 5096-2017 Article 6.3.2 and T/CMEA 53-2024 Article 10.2.4.
Keywords
- 工程量清单审核
- 缺项
- 错项
- 重复项
- errors and omissions in the BOQ
- item description (work item specification)
- 清单编码
- 工程量清单编制
- 招标控制价审核
Related Cards
- →
Quantity-price risk boundaries compared across lump-sum, unit-rate (re-measurable) and cost-plus contracts
The three contract types form a gradient of quantity and price risk transferred from contractor to employer: lump sum = both quantity and price fixed (the contractor bears quantity variances and cost fluctuations within the agreed range, except variations, changes in laws and regulations, and force majeure); unit-rate (re-measurable) = unit rate fixed, quantities measured as executed (BOQ errors / omissions and quantity variances lie with the employer); cost-plus = costs reimbursed as actually incurred (nearly all quantity and price risk lies with the employer). Basis: MOC Decree No. 107, Article 12; GB/T 50500-2024, Clauses 3.3.1-3.3.8; GB/T 50875-2013, Clauses 3.3.6-3.3.8.
- →
Risk allocation for incomplete item descriptions in the BOQ (BOQ errors and omissions): employer responsible under re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts, contractor responsible under lump-sum contracts, contractor always responsible for the bill of preliminaries
Per GB/T 50500—2024, an incomplete item description is an "error or omission in the BOQ": under re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts the employer (tenderee) is responsible for the completeness of billed items, the accuracy of item descriptions and the accuracy of quantities, and at settlement the all-in unit rate is re-rated on the basis of the characteristics actually constructed to adjust the contract price; under lump-sum contracts the contractor is responsible and no adjustment is made except for provisional quantities; for the bill of preliminaries, the contractor is responsible under both re-measurable and lump-sum contracts.
- →
Liability for errors or omissions in the tender BOQ: GB 50500-2013 vs GB/T 50500-2024 (2013 Clause 4.1.2 mandatory provision vs 2024 Clause 3.1.8 split by unit-rate/lump-sum contract)
GB 50500-2013, Clause 4.1.2 (mandatory provision): 'the tender BOQ must form part of the tender documents, and its accuracy and completeness shall be the tenderer's responsibility.' GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 3.1.8, instead splits liability by the contract pricing method: for unit-rate contracts, the accuracy and completeness of the divisional and elemental BOQ rest with the employer (tenderer) - bidders may not alter it on their own, defects adjust the price per Section 8.2, with a 15% quantity change as the threshold; for lump-sum contracts they rest with the contractor, who may supplement the list, and per 8.2.3 the contract price and time are not adjusted for BOQ defects (except unit-priced items with provisional quantities); the item-priced measure list is in all cases the contractor's responsibility. The 2024 edition was approved by MOHURD Announcement No. 212 of 2024, is effective from 1 September 2025 with GB 50500-2013 repealed simultaneously, and changed from a mandatory (GB) to a recommendatory (GB/T) national standard.
- →
Maximum bid price (former tender price ceiling) compilation framework and cost composition under GB/T 50500-2024
State-funded projects must set a maximum bid price (the former tender price ceiling), compiled and reviewed by the tenderer or a commissioned cost consultant, published in detail with the tender documents, and not to be raised or discounted; compilation basis: the seven items of GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 5.2.1. Cost composition: divisional and elemental work costs (pre-tax fully loaded all-in unit rate, including risk costs and auxiliary work costs) plus preliminaries (statutory safety provisions, non-competitive) plus other-item costs (provisional sums, provisional prices, dayworks, general contractor's service fee, etc.) plus taxes (VAT listed separately). Note the 2024 edition abolishes the separate line item for statutory fees, absorbing them into the all-in unit rate - different from the 2013 edition and some local documents; confirm the applicable edition before compiling.
Cited By
- ←
Constituent requirements of BOQ item descriptions and the three common defects (vague description / missing measurable parameters / disconnect from the work process), with corrected drafting (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 2.0.5, 2.0.27, 4.1.7, 4.2.2, 4.2.4; GB/T 50854-2024 clause 4.1.2)
An item description, by definition (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 2.0.5), is 'a textual description stating the nature and requirements of the BOQ item itself ...'; a description written wrongly falls under clause 2.0.27, BOQ errors (including 'mismatched item description'), and enters the price-adjustment channel rather than mere textual polish. The hard yardstick of accurate description is GB/T 50854-2024 clause 4.1.2 - 'item descriptions must be given accurately and comprehensively ... sufficient to satisfy the need to determine the all-in unit rate' - and they must be 'prepared on the basis of the design documents and in combination with the completion and handover requirements' (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 4.2.2); any parameter whose variation would change labour, material and plant consumption or the basis of percentage charges must be stated, while decorative words that do not change the price are useless if stated.
- ←
Full workflow for preparing the tender bill of quantities: preparing entity and object, the seven bases of preparation, itemisation with the five elements and item description, the four-part BOQ composition, deliverables and appendix forms, error liability, and the interface with the tender price ceiling
Chapter 4 of GB/T 50500-2024 provides: the bill of quantities is prepared by a tenderer with preparation capability or by a construction cost consultant commissioned by it (4.1.1); it is itemised with the contract object or a single project or individual structure as the object and forms part of the tender documents (4.1.2); the deliverables comprise the cover, signature page, explanatory notes of the estimate, notes on measurement rules, and the BOQ and pricing forms (4.1.3), in forms B.1.1, C.1.1, D.4.1, E.1.1/E.2.1/E.2.3/E.3.1/E.4.1 to E.4.5/E.5.1 and G.1.1. The BOQ is prepared and priced in four parts -- the work-item BOQ, the preliminaries BOQ, the other items BOQ and VAT (3.1.2) -- and the current edition no longer carries a statutory levies and taxes section; the all-in unit rate and the sum are fully inclusive pre-tax prices excluding VAT, tax is entered under VAT, and the provisional sum for nominated specialist subcontract works already includes VAT and must not be taxed again (3.1.6).
- ←
Determining missing items not listed in the BOQ appendices and setting supplementary items: the three-element comparison search path, the discipline-code + B coding rule (from 01B001), the five required accompanying elements, the tender-document explanation / filing requirements, and the boundary of error when fitting near-match items
Under GB/T 50854-2024 Clause 4.1.4, for items not covered in Appendices A~R the compiler may add supplementary items, coded with this standard's code 01 plus B and three Arabic numerals, numbered sequentially from 01B001, and must attach the item name, item description, unit of measurement, quantity take-off rule and work content (for preliminaries that cannot be measured: name, work content and scope of inclusion). The determination is a three-element comparison (item description + work content + unit of measurement with calculation rule): so long as any element can be carried by an existing appendix item, the existing item must be applied forward and the difference expressed in the item description, and no supplementary code may be created; work content lists only principal operations, auxiliary content such as plant movement and material transport is deemed included, and operations may not be split out and listed separately unless specifically stated. The 2024 editions (GB/T series) say 'may add' and no longer require filing; instead GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 3.1.3 requires the supplementary basis to be explained in the tender and contract documents; the 2013 compulsory national standards required 'shall add + file with the provincial or industry construction cost administration institution', and local standards may still retain the filing requirement.
- ←
Key points for the item description of earthworks BOQ items: how to set soil class and rock class (tables A.4.3-1 and A.4.3-2), the optional dry or wet soil supplement, the geotechnical investigation report as fallback, and the GB/T 50500-2024 compilation requirements for coding, names, descriptions, units and work content plus the itemisation principles
GB/T 50854-2024 A.4.3: soil class and rock class are set per table A.4.3-1 and table A.4.3-2, with dry or wet soil descriptions added where needed; where the class cannot be accurately determined, the description is based on the geotechnical investigation report. Item descriptions, together with coding, item names, units of measurement and work content, must be compiled per the national and industry quantity take-off standards (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 4.1.7); itemisation follows 'clear, unambiguous boundaries, easy to price and pay', with codes preferably ascending (clause 3.1.4); the description entries are governed by the exact wording of tables A.1.1, A.2.1 and A.3.1, and disposal of surplus excavated material is a separate item under table A.3.1, not an incidental entry in the excavation item's description.
- ←
The depth standard for describing item descriptions in the bill of quantities: describe item by item per the appendices, satisfy the needs of fixing the all-in unit rate, and never substitute the quota work content (trades)
The item description is the pricing parameter that fixes the all-in unit rate; the depth floor is 'describe item by item per the item descriptions prescribed in the appendices of the corresponding discipline measurement standard + satisfy the needs of fixing the all-in unit rate' (GB/T 50854-2024 clauses 4.2.4, 4.1.2). Citing a standard drawing collection or drawing number covers only 'the part it can satisfy' - the rest still needs words (GB 50860-2013 clause 4.2.4 commentary). Copying the work content (trades) of the quota / appendices replaces no item description: work content defines the included scope of the offer and the trade boundaries, and trades must not be split into separate items - copying produces no pricing parameters such as material, grade or strength class, and invites trade-splitting double pricing.
- ←
The twelve-digit rule for BOQ item codes: digits 1-9 unified per the appendices, digits 10-12 set by the compiler, the 01B supplementary code for gaps, the duplicate-check scope, and 2013 versus 2024 differences
BOQ item codes are twelve Arabic digits in five levels: discipline code (1-2), appendix class code (3-4), section code (5-6), work-item code (7-9), item-name code (10-12). Digits 1-9 must follow the appendices (national, no self-coding); 10-12 are set by the compiler from the item name and item description and may not duplicate within the same tendered works (GB 50854-2013 clause 4.2.2, mandatory; GB/T 50854-2024 clause 4.2.2 narrows to 'within the same single project of the tendered works'). Items absent from the appendices take supplementary codes 01B + three digits from 01B001 (the 2013 edition required filing with the provincial or industry cost authority; 2024 no longer requires it).
- ←
Double-counting test for BOQ items of anti-corrosion coating and fireproofing coating in steel structures: duplicate item-description wording is not double counting; the test is whether both point to the same coating operation / the same coat
Repetition of item-description wording is not in itself double counting - anti-corrosion paint and fireproofing coating are brushed onto the same member surfaces, so similar descriptions are normal. The test is whether the two point to the same coating operation / the same coat: coats in different systems (primer / intermediate coat / topcoat vs fireproofing coating) are independent items settled as executed; only where the same operation is described in two line items, or where one line item's quota work content already covers the other's operation (e.g. a fireproofing coating item whose work content already includes surface rust removal and primer), is the duplicated portion disallowed. Basis: GB/T 50854-2024 Appendix F.10.11 and GB 50205-2020 Appendix J.0.4 (two independent measurement bases), and GB/T 50854-2024 Article 4.1.2 (necessary work already included in the work content must not be split out as a separate item).
- ←
Judging quantity overstatement in construction-drawing based budgets (pre-tender estimates): five audit methods and cross-check verification
The sole yardstick for judging whether quantities are overstated is whether they are taken off per the item classification and method of measurement of the quota norms (GB/T 51095-2015 Clause 5.3.8). Auditors may choose among five methods — comprehensive audit, standard-based audit, grouped-calculation audit, comparative audit, and key-point sampling (Clause 5.1.5); focus on high-quantity, high-cost, structurally complex items such as foundations, walls, columns, doors and windows, and reinforced concrete beams and slabs (T/ZBD 100.5-2023 Clause 3.2.3), and use cross-checks — typical-floor consistency, wall-to-floor ratio, cut-and-fill balance, formwork-concrete agreement, rebar content ranges, wall opening deductions vs. door/window schedules — to quickly screen suspect items, then confirm each by item-by-item recheck.
- ←
Overview of bills of quantities: composition, compilation, item descriptions and handling of errors/omissions (GB/T 50500-2024)
A bill of quantities comprises four sections — trade items, preliminaries, other items and VAT; the five BOQ elements (code/name/item description/unit of measurement/quantity) are compiled per the national and industry measurement standards. Division of responsibility: under unit-rate contracts the trade-items BOQ is the employer's responsibility, under lump-sum contracts the contractor's, and the bill of preliminaries is always the contractor's. BOQ defects are per definition 2.0.27; unit-rate contracts re-measure under section 8.2 with price adjustment at the 15% boundary; lump-sum contracts are generally not adjusted except provisional-quantity items.
- ←
Audit of pricing by applying quota line items: identifying over-application, misapplication, and duplicate application via the three-way comparison
Identify problems of pricing by applying quota line items using the "three-way comparison": actual works (drawings / construction method statement) ↔ the work content of the quota line item ↔ the quota chapter notes and calculation rules. For over-application, check specifications, machinery, process, haul/height brackets, and unsupported coefficients; for misapplication, check cross-volume applications, wrong pairings, unsupported borrowings (missing items require supplementary unit-rate build-up schedules), conversions lacking the "换" (converted) mark, and superseded versions; for duplicate application, check work-content coverage (cast-in-place concrete already includes formwork, etc.), line-item splitting, and double-counted preliminaries. Rank items by amount to lock high-value items for focused audit.
- ←
Screening double counting in budget documents: five high-frequency duplication scenarios and judgment principles
The general principle for judging double counting: content already included in the work content must not be charged again, separately listed items must not be recomputed, and mutually exclusive items can be taken only once. High-frequency duplication falls into five classes: ① between quota line items (cast-in-place concrete already includes formwork — no separate formwork item; auxiliary content such as machinery relocation and material transport already included); ② between preliminaries and work-sections (vertical transport covers only large machinery, the rest already being in the work-sections; costs of separately listed preliminary items must not be double-counted); ③ within preliminaries (comprehensive vs. individually priced scaffolds — choose one; birdcage (full-area) scaffold and wall-finishing scaffolding are mutually exclusive; height-increase fee keyed to work points above 25 m); ④ other-item fees (provisional sums reduced at settlement by price adjustments; claims carry taxes and duties only); ⑤ fee accrual and taxes and duties (the base to which percentage rates are applied and taxation of free-issue materials (by the employer) must not be duplicated).
- ←
Composition and determination of the work content of quota sub-items / BOQ items: main processes + auxiliary content included by default, under "unlisted not separately counted, auxiliary must be included, processes not split"
The work content of a quota sub-item = the listed main construction processes + auxiliary content included by default (machinery movement, material transport, etc.), executing the three rules "unlisted not separately counted, auxiliary must be included, processes not split"; items considered as finished products include the fabrication content when precast on site; the work content boundary corresponds one-to-one with the composition of labor consumption (basic labor / auxiliary labor / over-transport-distance labor / labor differential allowance).
- ←
Quality control of AI-generated budgets: a systematic framework against quota misapplication and quantity omissions
Preventing quota misapplication relies on "verifying quota codes back against the database + two-way checking of item characteristics against sub-items + the work-content inclusion principle + locking a single pricing basis"; preventing quantity omissions relies on three lines of defense: "mandatory calculation rules + item-list completeness (drawing cross-check / characteristic deduction / appendix checklist) + cross-footing verification" — defenses set item by item against the three hallucination sources of AI: fabricated codes, cross-version mixing, and plausibly imagined missing items.
- ←
Measurement units for landscape plant installation (plant/m/m2/clump), plant specification terminology, and item-characteristic description essentials (GB/T 50858-2024)
Plant installation measurement units are fixed by category and planting method, not self-invented: trees/single-shrub/scattered bamboo/palms/climbers by plant (count), massed shrubs/flower ground-cover by m2, hedges by m (hedge length, not plant count), clumping bamboo/single-clump aquatics by clump (GB/T 50858-2024 Appendix A Table A.3.1, 4.2.5). Plant specification terms have unified definitions: DBH = trunk diameter at 1.3 m above ground (landscape caliber, not highway 1.2 m); crown diameter = mean of max and min vertical-projection diameters; ground diameter at 0.1 m; trunk diameter at 0.3 m; meter diameter at 1.0 m; plant height = ground to top. Item characteristics must be standard, concise, accurate, complete (4.1.2); survival rates above CJJ 82, shaping requirements, and grass-brick inlay ratios must be stated in characteristics.
- ←
Determining quantities where drawing dimensions are incomplete: three-tier fallback plus provisional quantities at the tender/preparation stage; re-measurement plus five-tier progressive determination at the settlement stage
Where drawings are incomplete, quantities are determined along two tracks. At the preparation stage, values are taken by the three-tier fallback "design documents -> approved project execution plan (construction methodology and site organization) -> code/quota norm measurement rules"; where accurate measurement remains impossible, the item description (work item specification) notes "provisional quantities" and an estimated quantity is provided (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 4.1.4, 4.1.6). At the settlement/dispute stage, re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts are re-measured against the final construction drawings (not the as-built drawings); where the drawings cannot reflect the work, determination follows the five-tier progression from certification and sign-off to site inspection (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clauses 4.3.5, 4.3.6).
- ←
Intermediate processes to retain in AI quantity takeoff: a five-layer trace framework (input basis, calculation derivation, result mapping, AI traces, archiving)
AI takeoff traces fall into five layers: (1) input basis (drawing version / calculation-rule version / construction-organization parameters / data sources); (2) calculation derivation (formulas + formula sources + intermediate-quantity chains + deduction/inclusion records + significant digits); (3) result mapping (formula <-> BOQ code <-> item-characteristic correspondence, aggregation paths, cross-footing verification); (4) AI generation traces (model version + intermediate expression chains + manual review of at least 10% + differences between draft and final); (5) archiving (working papers archived as process documents). Goal: every final figure can be traced back through derivation to the drawings — traceable, re-checkable, auditable.
- ←
Correspondence between the subcontract BOQ and the main contract BOQ: four-layer mapping of scope, BOQ elements, price, and fees
The subcontract BOQ is not built from scratch but the implementation-level refinement (projection) of the specialist-works portion of the main contract BOQ, and the two must be reconcilable item by item: (1) scope without overlap or omission; (2) the five elements (code/name/features/unit/calculation rules) consistent item by item, with codes reusable from the main contract; (3) on price, the specialist works provisional sum is wholly replaced by the tax-inclusive awarded price of the subcontract tender (material provisional sums are pre-tax prices — do not mix calibers); (4) measure costs are included in the subcontract total without double counting, the general contractor's service fee is listed separately on the main contractor side, and progress payments flow along the employer → main contractor → subcontractor chain.
- ←
Conversion judgment and methods when a quota item's work content differs from site reality (no conversion for aggregated content; convert by difference type; supplementary valuation for missing items; "换" mark traceability)
Before converting, judge "whether conversion is allowed": content already aggregated in the quota (formwork support content aggregating steel/wood props, external scaffolding aggregating ramps/loading platforms, on-site handling already included) may not be adjusted even if inconsistent with reality; adjustment is allowed only where technical conditions differ significantly from the quota's basis. Convert by difference type: coefficient adjustment; strength grade / mix-proportion conversion (per mix tables or formulas); thickness increment/decrement items; material substitution (bracketed materials priced separately, ready-mixed concrete deducting mixing-equipment consumption). Missing items are not converted — prepare a supplementary unit valuation table per the quota compilation principles (GB/T 51095-2015 Clause 5.3.12); converted quota codes must carry the "换" mark for traceability.
- ←
Method for judging obvious omissions in a construction method statement: lock the statement type -> check against the framework -> four-dimension depth review
Three steps to judge whether a construction method statement has obvious omissions: (1) lock the statutory content framework by statement type — for sub-divisional works involving significant hazards (China's 危大工程 regime), check against the 9-item framework of Jianban Zhi [2021] No. 48 (missing any single item is an obvious omission); ordinary method statements are checked against the 8 basic contents of GB/T 50502-2009 chapter 6; (2) check item by item; (3) use four dimensions — procedural, completeness, relevance, compliance — to review substantive depth and identify hidden omissions where "a section exists but has no substance" (parameters, verification calculations, monitoring, staffing, emergency, seasonal measures).
- ←
Avoiding mispricing when material names are similar but specifications differ: three lines of specification-checking defense across preparation, pricing, and audit
The three forms of mispricing (specifications missing from item characteristics, near-name mismatches, missing specification/unit dimensions) can be intercepted by three lines of defense: at preparation, write full specifications and models into the item characteristics (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 4.2.2); at pricing, check the quota item's bracketed specification against the drawings + match material price on three fields simultaneously — name/specification/unit (do not pick the published price directly; mark conversions with "换"); at audit, use same-name specification gradients (C30>C25, DN32>DN25) to back-detect mismatches.
- ←
Item description vs method of measurement in the BOQ: the item description column must not stipulate the method of measurement; supplementary rules belong in the BOQ calculation-rules statement and apply as contractual agreement
Item description and method of measurement are two parallel, independent elements of the bill of quantities (BOQ): the item description must be drafted in accordance with the annexes to the measurement standard and the actual works, its function being to fix the all-in unit rate; quantities must be computed under the method of measurement prescribed in the annexes (mandatory provisions of codes) — the item description column must not stipulate the method of measurement. Where supplementary rules are genuinely required, they must be set out in the BOQ calculation-rules statement (naming the national and industry standards adopted, with their titles and numbers, or setting out the detailed supplementary rules) and made part of the tender documents/contract documents, applying as "contractual agreement". Hierarchy of measurement bases: contractual agreement -> national standard matching the contract type -> industry/local standard.
- ←
Rapid completeness review of a budget document: four-layer quick check — document set integrity, scope consistency, inter-table cross-checks, and content elements
Review budget completeness with a four-layer quick check: ① document set integrity — tick off per the industry depth-of-preparation provisions (cover, signature page, contents, explanatory notes of the estimate, summary budget table, discipline summary tables, unit-work budget tables, other-cost tables and appendices); one missing item means incomplete, with the explanatory notes the most frequently missing; ② scope consistency — the "three-way check" of contract documents, software, and explanatory notes to find omissions and over-inclusions; ③ inter-table cross-checks — upper and lower summary levels equal, cost chains closed, sampled unit rate × quantity = amount, figures in words and numerals consistent; ④ content elements — no empty-price/zero-price items, no unitless list entries, quantity magnitudes reasonable, mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions accrued as prescribed, comparison against the approved preliminary estimate, and unit-cost indicator benchmarking. Suspicious parts are then confirmed item by item with the five audit methods.
- ←
A seven-step process for systematically checking BOQ errors and omissions (BOQ defects) and defect-liability handling
With tender drawings, the calculation-standard appendices, and the tender documents as three benchmarks, check in seven steps: "procedure check -> five-element verification -> item completeness -> preliminary items -> other items -> data format -> check records": prevent omissions using drawing back-check + construction-process walk-through + appendix comparison; any item listed without a drawing basis is a surplus item. After finding defects: clarify and correct via tender query and clarification at the compilation stage; under re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts the employer bears liability and adjusts per GB/T 50500-2024 Section 8.2; under lump-sum contracts the contractor bears liability and no adjustment is made.