A seven-step process for systematically checking BOQ errors and omissions (BOQ defects) and defect-liability handling
With tender drawings, the calculation-standard appendices, and the tender documents as three benchmarks, check in seven steps: "procedure check -> five-element verification -> item completeness -> preliminary items -> other items -> data format -> check records": prevent omissions using drawing back-check + construction-process walk-through + appendix comparison; any item listed without a drawing basis is a surplus item. After finding defects: clarify and correct via tender query and clarification at the compilation stage; under re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts the employer bears liability and adjusts per GB/T 50500-2024 Section 8.2; under lump-sum contracts the contractor bears liability and no adjustment is made.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准
- GB 50860-2013 构筑物工程工程量计算规范
- DBJ51/T 040-2015 四川省工程建设项目招标代理操作规程
- DB37/T 5096-2017 建设工程项目管理咨询规范
Topic Positioning
A methodological framework for systematically checking BOQ errors and omissions (i.e., "BOQ defects", GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 2.0.27) and the handling of defect liability.
Core Conclusions
Check in seven steps against three benchmarks — tender drawings (the sole benchmark for item listing and quantities), calculation-standard appendices (the compliance benchmark), and tender documents (the requirements benchmark): (1) Procedure check: complete explanatory notes, complete signatures and seals, complete document composition, the BOQ consistent with the tender price ceiling (DBJ51/T 040-2015, Clause 5.2.11); (2) Five-element verification (mandatory provision of GB 50860-2013, Clause 4.2.1): first 9 digits of the code match the appendix and all 12 digits are free of duplication, names correspond to the drawings, item descriptions accurate and complete (missing specification/strength grade is the most common), units unified across the whole works, quantities re-checked per the method of measurement (t takes 3 decimals, m/m2/m3 take 2, counts are integers); (3) Item completeness against omissions: drawing back-check + process walk-through + appendix comparison used together; any item listed without a drawing basis is a surplus item; (4) Preliminary items listed reasonably, without duplication with divisional and sub-divisional items; (5) Other items: provisional sums, provisional sums for specified materials / nominated works, and the main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions listed correspondingly as required; (6) Data verification: independent recalculation spot-check of key items at about 20%~30%, plus code duplication check; (7) Check records: record defect location, type, and handling suggestions; feedback, correction, and re-check close the loop.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to tender BOQ compilation review and pre-tender re-check; where drawings are unclear, "provisional quantities" may be listed on a re-measurable (unit-rate) basis; local procedures for signatures and seals and for the tender price ceiling not exceeding the approved design estimate follow local regulations; defect liability (re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts: the employer adjusts per Section 8.2; lump-sum contracts: the contractor bears it, with no adjustment) and the 15% price-adjustment boundary are detailed in the cited cards.
Further Reading
GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 2.0.27, 4.1.4, 4.1.7, 6.1.5~6.1.7, Section 8.2; GB 50860-2013 Clause 4.2.1; DBJ51/T 040-2015 Clause 5.2.11; DB37/T 5096-2017 Clause 6.3.2.