Why the 'statutory withdrawal coefficient' of the work safety levy and the fee rates of pricing bases differ: the hierarchy of Work Safety Law article 23, the withdrawal standards of Cai Zi [2022] No. 136, and the differences of base, content and function across sector fee schedules
Work Safety Law (2021 revision) article 23 itself sets no percentage - only three duties, to withdraw, to use exclusively and to charge to cost as actually incurred, delegating the rates to the finance and emergency-management departments; the so-called statutory coefficient is in fact article 17 of the Measures for the Administration of Withdrawal and Use of Enterprise Work Safety Expenses (Cai Zi [2022] No. 136): withdrawal on the construction and installation cost of works - mining 3.5%; railway, building and urban rail transit 3%; water conservancy and hydropower, and power 2.5%; smelting, mechanical and electrical installation, chemical and petroleum, and communications 2%; municipal utilities, ports and waterways, and highway 1.5%. The rates in the BOQ pricing standard and sector fee schedules are price standards - how the money enters the contract price and who pays (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 2.0.4 and 3.2.5; statutory safety provisions are non-competitive) - and differ in base and content (cost of works versus labour plus machine costs; work safety expenses versus the wider mandatory HSE provisions including civilised construction, environmental protection and temporary facilities); the two are not on one yardstick and their figures cannot be compared directly; within one sector they mostly agree (TB 10811-2024 clause 2.11.9: 3.0%; JTG 3830-2018: not less than 1.5%).
Applicable Codes
- 《中华人民共和国安全生产法》(2021修正,主席令第88号)第二十三条
- 《企业安全生产费用提取和使用管理办法》(财资〔2022〕136号)第十七条 http://www.mof.gov.cn/gkml/caizhengwengao/wg2022/wg202212/202304/t20230407_3877736.htm
- 财资〔2022〕136号 办法全文附件 https://www.mof.gov.cn/gkml/caizhengwengao/wg2022/wg202212/202304/P020230407569760184890.docx
- 财资函〔2024〕5号 http://zcgls.mof.gov.cn/jytafwgk_8292/2024jytafwgk/zxwytafwgk/202408/t20240822_3942307.htm
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第2.0.4条、第3.2.5条
- JTG 3830-2018 · Measure for Compilation of Preliminary Estimates and Budgets of Highway Construction Projects 建筑安装工程费·安全生产费条款
- TB 10811-2024 · Fee schedule for design estimates and budgets of capital railway works 第2.11.9条
- TB 10801-2024 Table 3.11.11
- 交通运输部令2017年第25号《公路水运工程安全生产监督管理办法》第二十一条
- GB 50656-2011 · Code for Work Safety Management of Construction Enterprises 第3.0.6条(引财企〔2006〕478号,已被替代)
Subject positioning
Why the 'legal-level withdrawal rate' of the work safety levy differs in figure from the fee rates in the BOQ pricing standard and the sector and local fee schedules - sorting out the hierarchy of sources, the function of each figure, the withdrawal base and the content covered, and giving the correct conversion-and-compare method.
Core conclusions
The statute contains no coefficient. Work Safety Law (2021 revision, Presidential Decree No. 88) article 23: the funding necessary for work safety conditions is guaranteed by the operating unit's decision-making body, principal officer or individual investor, who answer for shortfalls; relevant units shall withdraw and use work safety expenses as prescribed, dedicated to improving work safety conditions; work safety expenses are charged to cost as actually incurred; the specific measures for withdrawal, use and supervision are formulated by the finance department jointly with the emergency-management department after consulting the relevant departments. The law sets only three duties - withdraw, use exclusively, charge to cost as incurred - and delegates the percentage. There is no 'rate fixed by the Work Safety Law'; the real comparison is between 'the enterprise withdrawal standard fixed by the finance department' and 'the rates of the sector pricing bases' - two different levels.
The actual source of the coefficient: article 17 of Cai Zi [2022] No. 136. Construction enterprises withdraw on the construction and installation cost of works, monthly by progress: mining 3.5%; railway, building and urban rail transit 3%; water conservancy and hydropower, and power 2.5%; smelting, mechanical and electrical installation, chemical and petroleum, and communications 2%; municipal utilities, ports and waterways, and highway 1.5%. Tenders shall include and single out the levy, not to be cut in bidding; 'where the State provides otherwise for capital construction investment estimates, those provisions prevail'.
Schedule rates are price standards, not withdrawal standards. GB/T 50500-2024 clause 2.0.4 defines 'safe production costs' - the contractor's costs of measures taken and completed under national, sectoral and local work safety requirements, including those the Employer specifies in the tender documents and the contract; clause 3.2.5: statutory safety provisions in the preliminaries bill are priced per national, provincial and sector rules and are non-competitive.
Within a sector the figures mostly line up
- Railway: TB 10811-2024 clause 2.11.9 - the levy at 3.0% of the construction and installation cost - identical to the 136 Measures' 3% for railway works.
- Highway: JTG 3830-2018 - the levy equals the cost of works (excluding the levy itself) x a rate not less than 1.5% - a floor-style restatement of the statutory 1.5%; content: eight classes (improving and maintaining safety facilities and equipment; emergency rescue equipment and its upkeep; major hazard and hidden-hazard assessment and rectification; inspections, evaluation and consultancy; workers' protective articles; publicity, education and training; testing of safety facilities and special equipment; construction safety risk assessment, emergency drills and other directly related costs).
- Building and municipal: the local schedules' mandatory HSE provisions, base commonly 'labour plus machine costs', rates covering four components - safe construction, civilised construction, environmental protection, temporary facilities - rising across the compliance / green / model tiers and split by VAT mode. The rate figures far exceed 1.5% to 3%, but the base is far smaller than the cost of works: the two figures do not compare directly.
The four real causes of the 'discrepancy' (1) Function: the 136 Measures govern how much the enterprise must put into safety - a financial withdrawal-and-expenditure basis (monthly accrual, actual-cost booking); the schedules and pricing standard govern how the money is priced into the contract and who pays. (2) Base: cost of works (statutory withdrawal) versus labour plus machine costs (most local schedules) versus norm base prices. (3) Content: work safety expenses cover only safety-related outlay; the HSE provisions additionally carry civilised construction, environmental protection and temporary facilities - wider. (4) Stage and manager: at estimate / BOQ stage the cost bases govern; in construction the contract and financial measures govern withdrawal and use. Ministry of Transport Decree No. 25 of 2017, article 21: units shall guarantee the funding for work safety conditions; the Employer shall fix the levy in tender documents and estimates, not below the State standard; the Contractor's bid shall include it, withdrawn separately, never a competitive item; the levy is certified by the supervising engineer, approved by the Employer, charged to project cost as actually incurred, misappropriation forbidden. Plus the priority rule: 'where the State provides otherwise for capital construction investment estimates, those provisions prevail' - where a sector estimate schedule already fixes the levy, that provision applies first.
The correct comparison: convert the fee rate onto the cost-of-works denominator - converted rate = schedule rate x (the fee base's share of the cost of works). A converted figure somewhat above the statutory standard usually reflects the wider content (temporary facilities, environmental protection, civilised construction) - neither over-standard nor unlawful.
Applicability boundaries
- For the pricing and comparison of China's work safety levy and HSE provisions in construction works only; not for the financial accounting of mining or hazardous-chemicals producers.
- Verify current editions before citing any rate. The extraction standards of Cai Qi [2006] No. 478 quoted by GB 50656-2011 clause 3.0.6 (building and mining 2.0%; power, water conservancy and hydropower, and railway 1.5%; municipal, smelting, mechanical and electrical installation, chemical and petroleum, ports and waterways, highway, communications 1.0%) were superseded by Cai Qi [2012] No. 16 and then Cai Zi [2022] No. 136 - historical reference only, never a current basis; GB 50500-2013 is likewise superseded by GB/T 50500-2024.
- Local rates are regional and tiered by VAT mode and grade - take the project's own current schedule; no cross-region transplanting.
- Neither the statutory standard nor the schedule rate implies 'a contract below a figure is void': the former is the enterprise's withdrawal floor, the latter the pricing and settlement basis; actual payment follows the contract and actual-cost booking.
Further reading
- Work Safety Law (2021 revision), article 23 (withdrawal duty and delegation).
- Cai Zi [2022] No. 136, article 17 and the 'State provides otherwise' clause (text and annexes via mof.gov.cn; the Ministry's reply Cai Zi Han [2024] No. 5 explains why sector rates stay at different levels).
- GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 2.0.4 (term) and 3.2.5 (non-competitive, priced per rules).
- JTG 3830-2018 (levy clause: not less than 1.5%, eight content classes).
- TB 10811-2024 clause 2.11.9 (3.0% of the cost of works); TB 10801-2024 table 3.11.11 (ten classes of use, no double listing).
- Ministry of Transport Decree No. 25 of 2017, article 21 (singled out, non-competitive, engineer-certified, actual-cost booking, no misappropriation).
- GB 50656-2011 clause 3.0.6 (the 2006 historical standards, for tracking the evolution only).
Keywords
- statutory work safety levy (earmarked funds)
- mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions
- 企业安全生产费用提取和使用管理办法
- 财资〔2022〕136号
- 取费费率
- cost of works (construction and installation)
- 不可竞争项目