Re-derivation of the all-in unit rate when a changed construction method makes the quota machine-shift consumption inapplicable: the three-path quota conversion test, the hierarchy of bases for recalculating plant consumption, the requirements for recasting the all-in unit rate analysis sheet, and the procedure for confirmation by the employer
Changes of construction method and plant usage are factors expressly listed in GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 8.9.1 as changes of item description or construction condition that can trigger adjustment of the all-in unit rate, but conversion must step down level by level: a conversion line item within the same chapter (DL/T 5468-2013 Clause 4.1.4 item 1: 'where the technical conditions prescribed by the quota (index) differ materially from the actual conditions of the works, the applicable quota (index) may be adjusted and applied according to the technical conditions of the works and the provisions of the quota') -> an express quota coefficient -> borrowing a similar process -> building up a rate from supplementary consumption (GB/T 51095-2015 Clause 5.3.12; TB 10801-2024 Clause 2.4.3); with no express coefficient, none may be invented. The hierarchy for recalculating machine-shift consumption is: contractor's in-house norms (GB/T 50875-2013 Clause 2.3.3) -> construction quotas (Clause 2.3.5) -> budgets or final accounts of similar works, or site measurement records certified by both parties (DL/T 5468-2013 Clause 4.1.4 item 2). After conversion, the all-in unit rate analysis sheet must be recast (GB/T 51095-2015 Clause 5.3.9; GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 6.2.12 and Annex E Table E.2.2-1) and submitted to the employer under the 'submission, checking, review, re-examination and confirmation' procedure (Clauses 8.1.2 and 8.1.3; for additional works, the project execution plan or implementation scheme and the priced offer must also be submitted before execution, Clause 8.10.2). The original quota line item must never be applied in departure from the approved construction scheme.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第8.9.1条、第8.9.6条、第8.10.2条、第8.10.3条、第8.1.2条、第8.1.3条、第2.0.9条、第6.2.1条、第6.2.12条、第6.2.13条及App. E
- GB/T 51095-2015 建设工程造价咨询规范 第5.3.2条、第5.3.9条、第5.3.12条及App. C
- GB/T 50875-2013 工程造价术语标准 第2.3.3条、第2.3.5条、第2.3.6条
- DL/T 5468-2013 输变电工程施工图预算编制导则 第4.1.4条
- TB/T 10821-2024 铁路工程基本定额 总说明第二、三、四、九条
- TB 10801-2024 铁路基本建设工程设计概(预)算编制办法 第2.4.1~2.4.3条及App. B Table B.0.1—8
- TB/T 10831-2024 铁路工程预算定额 Vol. 10 房屋工程 册说明
Topic positioning
Answers, where the actual construction method no longer matches the method assumed in compiling the quota and the original machine-shift consumption no longer applies: where the case sits among the three conversion paths; on what hierarchy of bases the plant consumption is recalculated; how the all-in unit rate analysis sheet is recast after conversion; how confirmation is obtained from the employer; and the negative test that the original line item must not be applied in departure from the construction scheme.
Core conclusions
I. First, characterise: what moves is the 'quantity', not the 'price'
A quota's machine-shift consumption is locked to an assumed construction method. General Note 2 of the Railway Engineering Basic Quota: 'This volume of quotas is compiled under sound construction organisation and normal construction conditions; the construction methods and quality standards adopted follow the current national and industry standards. Prices at the implementation stage of the works are to be determined by the market.' [Source type: general notes of an industry quota volume, TB/T 10821-2024 General Note 2]
GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 8.9.1 expressly lists two groups of factors as price-influencing factors of BOQ items [source type: recommended national standard]:
- Factors related to changes of item description: '1) changes of materials; 2) changes of the construction method; 3) changes to other divisional works items; 4) other changes of item description.'
- Factors related to changes of construction condition: '1) changes of the foundation of the works; 2) changes of the height of the works; 3) changes of member specifications (e.g. steel structures); 4) changes of the construction season; 5) construction in completed zones and changes of the protection measures for completed works; 6) construction under site access restrictions; 7) changes of the mode of material transport; 8) changes of plant usage; 9) changes of the attendance charge within the main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions (e.g. a decrease or increase in the quantities of nominated specialist subcontracts); 10) other changes of construction condition.'
So changes of construction method and plant usage are factors the standard expressly lists as able to trigger adjustment of the all-in unit rate - but 'may be adjusted' does not mean 'may be converted freely'; how is governed by the three paths and the hierarchy of bases below.
II. The three-path test of quota conversion (A -> B -> borrowing a similar process -> C; step down level by level, stop on a hit)
A. A conversion line item in the same chapter / adjusted application: the quota contains a line item matching the actual construction method and plant (switching the process, the rig or plant type, or the haul-distance or height band), or a quota note directs 'execute line item so-and-so'. DL/T 5468-2013 Clause 4.1.4 item 1: 'Where the technical conditions prescribed by the quota (index) differ materially from the actual conditions of the works, the applicable quota (index) may be adjusted and applied according to the technical conditions of the works and the provisions of the quota.' [industry standard] Prohibited: mere differences of plant type or specification that are not differences of process; content the quota has already comprehended - TB/T 10831-2024 Building Works volume notes: 'the formwork support content comprehends both steel and timber supports; where different ones are actually used, no conversion is allowed.' [industry quota volume notes]
B. Conversion by coefficient: multiplication is allowed only where the chapter or volume notes of the quota give an express coefficient, and the coefficient value, the part it applies to and the base (which labour cost or machine-shift it multiplies) must follow the text. Example: TB/T 10831-2024 Building Works volume notes, 'for concrete walls cast indoors above 3.60 m height, apply the single-row scaffold quota multiplied by coefficient 0.3; for free-standing concrete columns and single (continuous) beams cast indoors above 3.60 m height, execute the double-row external scaffold quota items multiplied by coefficient 0.3'. Inventing a coefficient where none is expressed is over-pricing or mis-pricing.
C. Build up a rate from supplementary consumption per the project execution plan: where the quota has no matching line item (a gap) or the difference is too great to be adjusted by A or B, first borrow the quota of a similar process; only where nothing similar exists, compile a supplementary quota (index). GB/T 51095-2015 Clause 5.3.12: 'In preparing the construction-drawing based budget, for line items missing from the budget quota, supplementary unit-rate build-up schedules shall be compiled following the principles and methods of the budget quota.' [recommended national standard] DL/T 5468-2013 Clause 4.1.4 items 2 and 3: 'For items missing from the quota (index), priority goes to the quota (index) items of similar construction processes; where no similar or referable line item exists, a supplementary quota (index) may be compiled from the construction-drawing budgets or final accounts of similar works; for projects with no referable data, a supplementary quota (index) may be compiled according to the specific technical conditions of the works' and 'a supplementary quota (index) shall conform to the current administrative rules on quota compilation and may be used only after approval by the electric power quota administration'. TB 10801-2024 Clause 2.4.3: 'For works urgently needed by the construction project that the current quota does not cover or fit, the investor shall organise the compilation of a supplementary rate analysis according to the construction process requirements of the works and copy it to the industry standards administration.' [industry rule text]
Order of the test: A (is there a matching line item) -> B (is there an express coefficient) -> borrowing a similar process -> C (supplementary unit-rate build-up schedule / supplementary rate analysis). Where B fails, an 'experience coefficient' must not be substituted for A or C.
III. Hierarchy of bases for recalculating plant consumption (machine-shifts)
What is recalculated is machine-shift consumption; the machine-shift rate is set separately at the market prices of the compilation period or at industry base-period prices (TB/T 10821-2024 General Note 9: labour rates under TB 10811-2024, material prices under TB/T 10813-2024, machine and instrument machine-shift rates under TB/T 10814-2024). Consumption is redetermined in the following hierarchy:
- Contractor's in-house norms [source type: term of a recommended national standard] - GB/T 50875-2013 Clause 2.3.3: 'consumption standards for labour, construction machine-shifts and materials compiled by the construction enterprise according to its own construction technology, plant capability and management level.' Clause 6.2.1 item 7 of GB/T 50500-2024 lists 'the tenderer's in-house norms, construction cost data, market price information and price movement expectations' among the bases for preparing the tender price.
- Construction quotas [term of a recommended national standard] - GB/T 50875-2013 Clause 2.3.5: 'The construction quota is the foundational quota with the finest division of quota line items; it takes construction processes or basic operations of the same nature as its object of study, expresses the relation between the quantity of product and the consumption of production factors, is the basis for compiling the budget quota, and can be used directly by construction enterprises to organise production and manage construction. The construction quota comprises the labour consumption quota, the material consumption quota and the construction machine-shift consumption quota.'
- Budgets or final accounts of similar works, or determination from the specific technical conditions of the works [industry standard] - DL/T 5468-2013 Clause 4.1.4 item 2; industry practice is to use site machine-shift write-up records certified by both parties (plant model, number deployed, pure operating time, idle standby time) as the basis for determining machine-shift quantities, forming supplementary consumption submitted for review together with the supplementary rate analysis.
The overall basis of the recalculation is the approved project execution plan / implementation scheme: GB/T 51095-2015 Clause 5.3.2 lists 'the project execution plan and the construction method statements' and 'the market prices of labour, materials, equipment and construction plant at the location of the works' among the bases for compiling the construction-drawing based budget.
IV. Requirements for recasting the all-in unit rate analysis sheet after conversion
- Labour, material and plant consumption: take the factor consumption of the quota line item applied or converted (for recalculated parts, take the results of the hierarchy above); rate sources: the market prices of the report compilation period / contract prices / industry base-period prices. GB/T 51095-2015 Clause 5.3.9: 'The all-in unit rate of each line item may be determined through the budget quota and its supporting on-cost norms. Labour cost, material cost and plant cost shall be determined from the factor consumption of labour, materials and plant of the relevant budget quota line items and from market prices of the report compilation period; management fee, profit, statutory levies and fees and taxes shall be determined from the on-cost norms or charging standards accompanying the budget quota and from the actual circumstances and market level of the proposed project at the report compilation period. When compiling the budget of building works, an all-in unit rate analysis sheet shall be compiled at the same time.' The rate build-up follows the all-in unit rate analysis sheet in Annex C of that standard.
- Chain of charging bases: management fee, profit, statutory levies and fees and taxes are charged under the accompanying on-cost norms or charging standards, and their bases must be recalculated in step with the recalculated labour and plant costs (or the charging base prescribed by the quota); the bases in the original base price must not be carried over (inferred from the charging logic of Clause 5.3.9 'determined from the accompanying on-cost norms or charging standards', not the literal text).
- Sheets and consistency under BOQ pricing: GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 6.2.12 requires 'the complete submission of a schedule of the cost make-up consistent with the all-in unit rates and prices in the priced bill of quantities', on the forms of Annex E Tables E.2.2-1 and E.2.2-2 (all-in unit rate analysis of divisional works items, including the short form) and Tables E.3.2, E.3.3 and E.3.4; Clause 6.2.13 requires Table E.3.3, the breakdown of preliminaries costs, to state for each preliminaries cost its initial set-up cost, mid-term running cost and later dismantling cost, so that it can 'be applied after award, during the performance of the contract, to the payment of progress payments and to the valuation of claims'.
- Pricing basis: GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 2.0.9 - the all-in unit rate comprises labour cost, material cost, plant and small tools cost, management fee, profit and the risk allowance within a defined range, and excludes VAT.
- Railway supplementary rate analysis form: TB 10801-2024 Annex B Table B.0.1-8, 'supplementary rate analysis sheet', listing the rate number, name, unit, base price and its components (labour cost, material cost, plant usage cost) and the work content, signed by both the compiler and the checker.
V. Procedure for submitting the converted rates for the employer's confirmation (clause numbers)
- GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 8.1.2: 'Where an event of contract price adjustment occurs during the performance of the contract, the contractor shall calculate the quantities of the adjustment event under Chapter 7 of this standard, calculate the adjusted price under Sections 8.2 to 8.11 of this standard, and submit it with the relevant data to the employer for checking within the agreed time.' The procedure is 'submission, checking, review, re-examination and confirmation'.
- Clause 8.1.3: 'After receiving the contractor's contract price adjustment report and the relevant data, the employer shall verify them within the agreed time; if it confirms them, it shall notify the contractor in writing; if it does not confirm them, it shall reply to the contractor in writing with its checking comments on the price adjustment; if it neither confirms nor raises checking comments, the contract price adjustment report submitted by the contractor shall be deemed approved by the employer.'
- For additional works, the re-derived rate is submitted before execution - Clause 8.10.2: 'The contractor shall, before implementing additional works, submit to the employer for review its project execution plan or implementation scheme, its construction progress programme and its own priced offer for the costs it seeks (including the bills of divisional works items and of preliminaries items), and the employer shall approve them within a reasonable time.' Clause 8.10.3: 'Where the contractor converts a contract unit rate of a relevant BOQ item within the contract works into the all-in unit rate of the additional works, the adjusted all-in unit rate may be determined by the price effect of the pricing-related difference factors.'
- Variations carrying preliminaries - Clause 8.9.6: 'Where a variation touches substantive changes to the scope, period, quality or specifications of the contract works and causes preliminaries items to change, if the disadvantaged party proposes the adjustment of the preliminaries cost, it shall, before implementation, submit the scheme it intends to implement to the other party for review and account in detail for the changes against the measures of the original scheme. Where the intended scheme is implemented after confirmation by the employer and the contractor, the preliminaries cost may be adjusted under Clauses 8.9.4 and 8.9.5 of this standard.' And 'the contractor shall submit in writing to the employer for review the implementation scheme for the relevant variation, the extension of time caused by the variation and its request for the additional preliminaries costs it needs'.
VI. Negative tests (red lines)
- The original quota line item must not be applied in departure from the approved project execution plan / implementation scheme: quota consumption presupposes an assumed construction method (TB/T 10821-2024 General Note 2); once the method has materially changed, carrying over the consumption of the original item fails; the project execution plan and the construction method statements are themselves bases for compiling the budget (GB/T 51095-2015 Clause 5.3.2).
- Content the quota already comprehends must not be converted on the ground that 'the actual differs' (TB/T 10831-2024 Building Works volume notes: formwork supports comprehend steel and timber).
- No coefficient may be invented absent an express quota coefficient (DL/T 5468-2013 Clause 4.1.4 item 1 limits this to 'and the provisions of the quota').
- Bypassing an available line item to compile a supplementary quota, or compiling a supplementary quota not in line with the quota compilation principles, or without approval by the electric power quota administration or without copying to the industry standards administration, all fail (DL/T 5468-2013 Clause 4.1.4 item 3; TB 10801-2024 Clause 2.4.3).
- Where the contractor prices directly from its own offer without submitting the implementation scheme and priced offer for review before execution, the pricing fails procedurally (Clause 8.10.2); where preliminaries costs are involved and were not submitted for review and confirmation before implementation, later adjustment requests lack a procedural basis (Clause 8.9.6).
Applicable boundaries
Applies to changes of BOQ items under re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts caused by variations or errors and omissions in the BOQ (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 8.9.1, including quantity changes not exceeding 15%, 15% included), and to the conversion of all-in unit rates for additional works (Clauses 8.10.2 and 8.10.3); the compilation of estimates and budgets under the quota pricing mode likewise follows the three paths and the hierarchy of bases. The five-tier rate determination rules listed in Clause 8.9.1 are: same construction condition + same item description - use the corresponding contract rate; same construction condition + similar item description, or similar construction condition + same item description - use the contract rate of a similar BOQ item with conversion adjustment; same construction condition + different item description, or different construction condition + same item description, or different construction condition + different item description - negotiate a market-reasonable all-in unit rate combining the pricing rules of similar items and the level of the offer; where reducing or cancelling BOQ items materially changes the construction condition - determine by negotiation. Not applicable: price adjustment for pure market fluctuation with the item description and the construction condition unchanged (governed by the rules on material prices and cost fluctuation adjustment, not by re-derivation of rates); lump-sum contracts with no adjustment agreed; content the quota already comprehends. The volume division, conversion coefficients and approval channels of the industry quotas differ (railway supplementary rate analyses are copied to the industry standards administration; electric power ones must be approved by the quota administration before use); coefficients and conversion rules follow the notes of the quota volume in use; building-type works (passenger station buildings, station complexes, canopies, footbridges and the like) may use the provincial local quota of the place of the works, with the labour, material and plant prices and the on-cost norms adopted in matching sets.
Further reading
GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 8.9.1 (five-tier rate determination rules), 8.9.6 (preliminaries adjustment and the pre-implementation submission of the scheme), 8.10.2 and 8.10.3 (offers and conversion for additional works), 8.1.2 and 8.1.3 (adjustment procedure and deemed approval on lapse), 2.0.9 (all-in unit rate basis), 6.2.1 (tender pricing bases), 6.2.12 and 6.2.13 with Annex E Tables E.2.2-1/E.2.2-2, E.3.2, E.3.3 and E.3.4; GB/T 51095-2015 Clauses 5.3.2 (budget compilation bases), 5.3.9 (rate build-up principles and the Annex C all-in unit rate analysis sheet) and 5.3.12 (supplementary unit-rate build-up schedules); GB/T 50875-2013 Clauses 2.3.3 (contractor's in-house norms), 2.3.5 (construction quota) and 2.3.6 (budget quota); DL/T 5468-2013 Clause 4.1.4 (quota adjustment, borrowing for gaps, and the approval of supplementary quotas); TB/T 10821-2024 General Notes 2, 3, 4 and 9 (compilation premises; the documents governing labour, material and machine-shift rates); TB 10801-2024 Clauses 2.4.1 to 2.4.3 (adoption of quotas and supplementary rate analyses) and Annex B Table B.0.1-8, supplementary rate analysis sheet; TB/T 10831-2024 Building Works volume notes (comprehended formwork and scaffold content, conversion by coefficient, measurement rules).
Keywords
- conversion of quota items to suit conditions
- 机械台班消耗量
- 综合单价重新组价
- 施工方法改变
- supplementary unit-rate build-up schedules
- contractor's in-house norms
- 综合单价分析表
- 工程变更价款确认