Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-09-25

Derivation of new (built-up) rates when a design change changes the construction process (construction method): qualifying the source + the three-tier path of GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.9.1

"Change of construction method" is a price-impact factor of "item description change" expressly listed in GB/T 50500-2024 8.9.1: process changes caused by design changes or employer requirements are variations requiring derivation of new (built-up) rates; a contractor's autonomous process switch is construction method statement optimization, generally not adjusting the contract price, costs borne by the contractor itself. Pricing follows three tiers: identical conditions + identical item descriptions retain the contract unit rate; similar item descriptions/conditions convert via the original all-in unit rate analysis, replacing only differing elements; different item descriptions/conditions (complete method change) negotiate at "reasonable cost + profit" with a new all-in unit rate analysis. Confirm the pricing path in writing before implementation and keep evidence; accompanying quantity changes beyond 15% (exclusive) follow 8.9.2 — for increases, reasonably reduce; for decreases, reasonably increase.

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第8.9.1条、第8.9.2条、第8.9.3条
  • GB/T 51095-2015 建设工程造价咨询规范 第5.3.9条
  • DB11/T 382-2017 北京市建设工程造价管理暂行规定 第5.3.2条

Topic Positioning

This card answers "how to adjust and derive new all-in unit rates after a design change changes the construction process (construction method)": first qualify the change source, then follow the three-tier path of GB/T 50500-2024 8.9.1 and 8.9.2. For pricing and settlement disputes over method/process changes caused by variations under re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts.

Core Conclusions

(1) Qualification — does the method change trigger derivation of new (built-up) rates: GB/T 50500-2024 8.9.1 expressly lists "change of construction method" among price-impact factors of item description change (original: "price changes of BOQ items caused by the following factors related to item description change: 1) change of materials; 2) change of construction method; 3) changes to other work items; 4) other item description changes"), an adjustable circumstance. But first distinguish the source: process change caused by design change or employer requirement (e.g., bored piles changed to rotary-drilled, cast-in-situ changed to precast) -> a variation, requiring derivation of new (built-up) rates; contractor's autonomous process switch (contract unchanged, method changed merely to cut cost or ease construction) -> construction method statement optimization, generally not adjusting the contract price, costs in principle borne by the contractor (local practice reference: DB11/T 382-2017 5.3.2). (2) Three-tier pricing path (summarized from 8.9.1):

  • Tier 1: "billed (BOQ) items with identical item descriptions under identical construction conditions shall adopt the corresponding contract unit rate" — no adjustment;
  • Tier 2: "billed (BOQ) items with similar item descriptions under identical conditions, or identical item descriptions under similar conditions, shall adopt all-in unit rates converted and adjusted from similar billed (BOQ) items' contract unit rates";
  • Tier 3: "billed (BOQ) items with different item descriptions under identical conditions, or identical item descriptions under different conditions, may, per implementation circumstances and combining similar items' contract pricing rules and offer levels, negotiate market-reasonable all-in unit rates"; "billed (BOQ) items with different item descriptions under different conditions ... combining similar items' unit rates of similar works, negotiate market-reasonable rates"; "where variations reducing or canceling billed (BOQ) items significantly change construction conditions, variation unit rates may be negotiated per the specific circumstances, market prices, contract pricing rules, and offer levels". Process changes usually fall in Tier 2 or Tier 3: new vs old processes differing in materials/machinery but close in BOQ item description -> Tier 2 conversion; complete method change (e.g., hand-dug to rotary-drilled piles) -> Tier 3 negotiation. (3) Operating points: Tier 2 conversion takes the original contract all-in unit rate analysis sheet and replaces only differing elements — new rate = original rate - original consumption x original material/machinery cost + new consumption x new material/machinery cost (at original consumption and offer levels), with overheads (company and site), profit, and risk allowance levels unchanged; Tier 3 negotiation follows "reasonable cost + profit": norm resource consumption x compilation-period market price + overheads (company and site) + profit, with a complete all-in unit rate analysis sheet (GB/T 51095-2015 5.3.9); recommend a separate analysis sheet per affected item for verification and settlement. (4) Linkage and procedure: variations also causing quantity changes beyond 15% (exclusive) follow 8.9.2 — for added items/quantities, price "after reasonably reducing contract and new unit rates considering labour/material procurement discounts from increased volume"; for reduced items/quantities, "after reasonably increasing ... considering lost discounts". Before implementation, the parties shall agree in writing on which tier applies and keep three evidences: the designer's change instruction, the original bid/contract all-in unit rate analysis (conversion base), and compilation-period market price bases (published price information (government guidance prices) or quotations). Explicit contractual provisions on valuation of variations prevail; the national standard is the fallback.

Applicable Boundaries

Applies to pricing of method changes from design changes/variations under re-measurable (unit-rate) BOQ contracts; lump-sum contracts follow 8.9.3 — adjust or negotiate depending on whether contract unit rates suit the variation. Not applicable to: contractor's autonomous construction method statement optimization (generally no adjustment), adjustment for cost fluctuation (Section 8.7), provisional-sum determination (Section 8.4) — independent rules. Contracts with explicit valuation-of-variations terms ("material price differences only", "no adjustment within the risk band (no-adjustment tolerance, e.g. ±5%)") take precedence. The 2024 edition is more flexible than 2013. Local practices (e.g., DB11/T 382-2017) yield to contract and local rules for cross-region projects.

Further Reading

See GB/T 50500-2024 8.9.1 (three-tier adjustment and price-impact factors), 8.9.2 (beyond-15% linkage), 8.9.3 (lump-sum contracts), Sections 7.1/7.2/7.4 (variation and BOQ errors/omissions quantity confirmation); pricing methods in GB/T 51095-2015 5.3.9; contractor's autonomous optimization cost bearing in DB11/T 382-2017 5.3.2; design change definition and procedure, market price enquiry pricing without quota norms, and all-in unit rate composition — see referenced cards.

Keywords

Cited By