Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-25

Preventing double counting of earthworks where trench, manhole pit and spread foundation pit overlap: physical overlap versus intersection of battered faces, assigning the manhole-length section by the larger cross-section, the pit deepening increment, pipe-joint working pits already included, and one trench width taken once for multi-pipe runs

Three tests prevent double counting: (1) physical overlap (the same space excavated twice) is counted once, and battered-face intersections are expressly 'not deducted' by most quota manuals (Hunan 2025 IV.4; SJG 111.1-2022 table 1.2.3-1 note 2; SJG 84-2020 table 7.2.9 note 1); (2) the BOQ quantity (GB/T 50857-2024, drawn dimensions plus working space, no batter) and the quota quantity (working space plus batter) are computed independently - never mix then deduct; (3) the manhole-length section is assigned by section size: if A-pit is no less than A-trench the section counts as pit and the trench length is reduced by that section, if A-pit is smaller the manhole length merges into the trench and no pit is listed, the total taking the max, not the sum; where the pit floor lies below the trench floor, the deepening increment delta V = A-pit x (H-pit - H-trench) is added; pipe-joint working pits and manholes along the line are covered by 2.5% of the trench earth and rock quantity (1.5% for wells and joint pits in the railway volume 12), not listed separately.

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 50857-2024 市政工程工程量计算标准 App. A Table A.1.1、A.4.1、A.4.2、A.4.4
  • GB 50861-2024 城市轨道交通工程工程量计算标准 附录A 第A.7.1条
  • GB 50268-2008 给水排水管道工程施工及验收规范 第4.3.2条及Table 4.3.2
  • CJJ/T 209-2013 塑料排水检查井应用技术规程 第6.3.1条及表6.3.1
  • GB 50819-2013 油气田集输管道施工规范 第11.2.3条
  • GB 50690-2011 石油化工非金属管道工程施工质量验收规范 第5.3.3条
  • DB11/T 2382-2024 建设工程施工消耗量标准 第7.1.3、7.1.6、7.1.7、7.1.8条
  • SJG 111.1-2022 城市地下综合管廊工程消耗量标准(Vol. 1)第1.2.3条
  • SJG 84-2020 市政维修工程消耗量标准(第二册)第7.2.9条及表7.2.9
  • SJG 181.4-2024 市政工程消耗量标准 Vol. 4 第1.2.3条及Table 1.2.3
  • 房屋建筑与装饰工程消耗量标准 土石方工程说明 第四~十一款
  • TB/T 10833-2024 铁路工程预算定额 Vol. 12 册说明 五
  • 国铁科法〔2017〕33号 铁路工程预算定额 第二册 第二章 管沟、基坑开挖
  • DB37/T 5031-2015 SMC玻璃钢检查井应用技术规程 第6.2.5条

Topic positioning

How to avoid double counting earthworks where pipe trenches intersect manhole pits or spread foundation pits: first separate 'physical overlap' from 'intersection of battered faces', then separate the BOQ basis from the quota basis, and finally assign the manhole-pit length section by section size - to which item the quantity belongs, and how much to deduct.

Core conclusions

1. Two kinds of 'overlap', opposite treatments

  • Physical overlap: the same space excavated once by the trench and once by the pit - true duplication, countable only once.
  • Intersection of battered faces: the wedge formed where the trench slope meets the pit slope - permitted duplication, not deducted. Sources:
    • Building and decoration works consumption standard, earthworks notes: when computing foundation earthwork batters, the duplicated quantity at batter intersections is not deducted; where sheeting is used for foundation earthwork, batter is not separately computed.
    • SJG 111.1-2022 table 1.2.3-1 note 2: when computing batters, the duplicated quantities produced at excavation junctions are not deducted.
    • SJG 84-2020 table 7.2.9 note 1: when computing batters, the duplicated quantities produced at pit and trench corners are not deducted.

2. Fix the item category first: trench / foundation pit / general earthworks

  • GB/T 50857-2024 Annex A A.4.1: a trench is a trapezoidal (rectangular) section excavation in earth (rock) with a floor width no more than 7m and a floor length more than 3 times the floor width (excluding widened working space); a foundation pit is an excavation in earth (rock) for building foundation construction (excluding widened working space); general earthworks covers all other types (hillside cuts, road construction, site levelling and the like).
  • GB 50861-2024 Annex A A.7.1 item 1: floor width no more than 7m and floor length more than 3 times the width is a trench; beyond those limits, a foundation pit.
  • GB 50861-2024 Annex A A.7.1 item 6: excavated earth (rock) volume is computed at the natural in-situ volume before excavation.
  • DB11/T 2382-2024 clause 7.1.3: floor width no more than 7m and floor length more than 3 times the width is a trench; floor length no more than 3 times the width and floor area no more than 150m2 is a foundation pit; beyond those limits, general earthwork.
  • Railway basis (China Railway Kefa [2017] No. 33, volume 2, chapter 2, V (5)): with floor width within 7m, a long side equal to and above three times the short side is computed as a pipe trench, a long side under three times the short side as a foundation pit.

3. Section values (which of A-trench and A-pit is larger)

  • Pipe trench: GB/T 50857-2024 Annex A A.4.2: where the pipe (trench) structural width (pipe base outer edge with a cradle, pipe outer diameter without) is no more than 1000mm, add 400mm working space per side; where over 1000mm, add 600mm per side; for pit construction add 600mm per side beyond the structure foundation edge.
  • GB 50268-2008 clause 4.3.2: trench floor width B = D0 + 2 (b1 + b2 + b3); b1 is the working space width on one side of the pipe (per table 4.3.2), b2 the sheeting thickness on one side where support is required (150 to 200mm), b3 the formwork thickness on one side of cast-in-place concrete or reinforced concrete conduits. Notes: where a drainage channel is needed in the trench floor, b1 should increase; where the pipe carries a field-applied waterproofing layer, b1 is best taken as 800mm.
  • Manhole pit: CJJ/T 209-2013 clause 6.3.1: minimum clear pit size B = D + 2b (D the manhole base outer diameter, b the working space width on one side of the manhole base, per table 6.3.1; widened by the drainage channel width where one is needed in the pit floor). Both that specification and the note to DB37/T 5031-2015 clause 6.2.5 state that the clear pit size should be wider than the pipe trench (axial and transverse pipe joints must be installed).
  • Sheeting: SJG 111.1-2022 clause 1.2.3 item 2: width is the drawn trench or pit floor width plus 100mm on one side, 200mm on both sides; sheeting area is the vertical supported area of the trench or pit, and once sheeted no batter is computed.
  • Trench section basis (consumption standards): the trench section area includes working space width, batter width or the permitted rock overbreak area; permitted overbreak per side of rock slopes - 0.20m for soft and fairly soft rock, 0.15m for fairly hard and hard rock - with no overbreak counted at trench and pit floors.

4. Assigning the manhole (pit) length section

Tests:

  • Trench quantity V-trench = sum of A-trench-i x Li (Li the net length after deducting the manhole sections)
  • Manhole / foundation pit quantity V-pit = sum of A-pit-j x Hj
  • A-pit no less than A-trench -> the manhole section takes V-pit and the trench length is reduced by that section;
  • A-pit smaller than A-trench -> the section merges into the trench and no pit is listed (only the deepened part may be added);
  • the total takes max(V-trench section, V-pit), not the sum of both.
Case Trench Manhole or foundation pit Note
Pit section no less than trench section Net length, manhole section deducted Manhole section as pit section x pit depth Larger section kept, avoiding two counts of one section
Pit section smaller than trench section Full length including the manhole section Not listed separately Manhole section already inside the trench
Pit floor below the trench floor Trench depth only Deepening increment only delta V = A-pit x (H-pit - H-trench)
Batter wedges intersecting at the manhole section No deduction No deduction Batter intersection duplication not deducted

Length and depth bases:

  • Pipe trench length runs the whole drawn pipeline (summed manhole centre to manhole centre) (SJG 111.1-2022 clause 1.2.3 item 5); foundation trench length is the drawn centreline length in metres, the volumes of internal and external projections (piers, pilasters and the like) merging into the trench earthworks (item 4 of the same clause).
  • Consumption standard basis: pipe trench length follows the design; where the design is silent, by the drawn pipe centreline length, deducting no well or basin with a bottom diameter or side no more than 1.5m - small wells (up to 1.5m) are not deducted and stay inside the trench; only larger wells and basins need the larger-section assignment and deduction.
  • GB/T 50857-2024 Annex A A.4.4: the excavation depth of trench and pit earthworks is the average height from original ground level to the trench or pit floor.
  • DB11/T 2382-2024 clause 7.1.6: excavation depth runs from natural ground level to the design foundation (including bedding) floor level; clause 7.1.7: earthworks for pipe ancillary structures follow clause 7.1.6 (wells are computed separately under the foundation earthwork rules, apart from the trench).
  • SJG 111.1-2022 clause 1.2.3 item 6: trench and pit depth runs from natural ground to the trench or pit floor; pipe ducts run from the drawn duct floor to the design outdoor ground level.

Illustrative example (pipe outer diameter 0.85m, no support, working space 0.4m per side; manhole base outer diameter 1.2m, working space 0.4m per side; trench depth 3.0m, pit depth 3.6m, manhole section 2.0m long): trench floor width 1.65m (A-trench = 4.95m2), pit clear width 2.0m (A-pit = 7.2m2); trench quantity over the manhole section 9.9m3, pit quantity 14.4m3. Adding both gives 24.3m3, duplicating 9.9m3; the correct net increment is 4.5m3 = widening increment (2.0 - 1.65) x 3.0 x 2.0 = 2.1m3 plus deepening increment 2.0 x 0.6 x 2.0 = 2.4m3.

5. When the deepened part of the pit is measured separately

  • Counted only where H-pit exceeds H-trench (pit floor below the trench floor): delta V = A-pit x (H-pit - H-trench), taking only the part below the trench floor; the upper part must not overlap the trench or pit quantity.
  • The depth datum is uniform: original (natural) ground level to the trench or pit floor; batter starts from the foundation (including bedding) floor level, and where bedding is placed in the existing trench or pit the batter starts from the bedding surface (SJG 111.1-2022 table 1.2.3-1 note 3). With different soil strata the batter start depth and gradient are weighted by stratum thickness.

6. Pipe-joint working pits: already included, not counted separately (negative conclusion)

  • Consumption standard earthworks notes: the extra earth and rock excavation for pipe-joint working pits and the various manholes along the line is computed as 2.5% of the whole trench earth and rock quantity.
  • Railway works budget quota (China Railway Kefa [2017] No. 33), volume 2, chapter 2, V (3): the extra earth and rock for pipe-joint working pits (cast-iron spigot-and-socket water pipes excepted) and the various manholes along the line is computed as 2.5% of the whole trench earth and rock quantity.
  • TB/T 10833-2024 volume 12, volume note V.1: trench length is the designed trench centreline length, including the lengths occupied by the various wells and joint pits; the extra quantity for the various wells and joint pits is computed as 1.5% of the trench excavation quantity.
  • Conclusion: the working pits dug for spigot joints and the manhole additions are already covered by these percentages and must not be listed again at actual size; under the 2.5% basis the percentage already contains the manhole additions along the line, so no further claim overlaps the whole-section deduction for manhole lengths.

7. Multiple pipes in one trench: one width for the whole bundle, not one per pipe

  • GB 50819-2013 clause 11.2.3: with several pipes in one trench, the floor width builds on the single-pipe floor width - add 400mm of width for each additional pipe of nominal diameter under 300mm, and 600mm for each additional pipe of nominal diameter no less than 300mm.
  • GB 50690-2011 clause 5.3.3: for single pipes assembled at the trench side and multi-pipe runs, a = sum of D + sum of s + c (a the floor width, sum of D the sum of pipe outer diameters, sum of s the sum of design clear spacings between pipes, c the working width: 800mm for floor assembly, 500mm for side assembly); pipe joints or places needing manual work get separate working pits meeting the operational needs.
  • SJG 111.1-2022 table 1.2.3-3 note: for two or more pipes laid in one trench, without cradles measure by the spacing between the outer walls of the outermost pipes of the bundle, with cradles by the pipe base outer edge of the bundle.
  • Conclusion: multi-pipe runs set one trench width from the whole-bundle outline (largest diameter plus clear spacings or bundle outer walls) plus working space on both sides, measured as one trench; each pipe must not get its own trench with the results stacked.

8. Backfill and surplus basis (avoiding duplication in the opposite direction)

  • Consumption standards: conduits with a structural width no more than 500mm need no volume deduction on backfilling; over 500mm, deduct the volumes of the conduit bedding, base, outer envelope and manholes and other annexes; with native soil backfill the surplus haul-off equals excavation volume minus backfill volume; with replacement fill the surplus equals the excavation volume.
  • No-deduction on backfill and no-duplication on excavation are two directions of one problem: backfill is measured compacted, excavation at natural in-situ volume, and the same deduction percentage must not be applied twice.

Boundaries of application

  1. 'Keep the larger section, deduct the overlapped volume' is not standard wording - it is an operating rule derived from the trench-versus-pit classification rules plus 'one and the same entity must not be measured twice'. Usable in pricing and review, but cite those two rules as the basis; do not invent a clause number.
  2. The two bases must not be mixed: the BOQ quantity (GB/T 50857-2024 table A.1.1 - trench and pit earthwork computed as the design foundation (including bedding) floor area plus working space, times excavation depth, by volume) excludes batter; the quota quantity (DB11/T 2382-2024 clause 7.1.6 adds the volume from batter or local deepening) includes batter. Each is computed independently and without internal duplication; never mix then deduct.
  3. Sector differences: GB 50861-2024 Annex A A.7.1 item 7 for urban rail transit provides that 'earth (rock) works do not measure the quantities added by working space and batter not identified on the design drawings; they are included in the work content', unlike the municipal GB/T 50857 basis of adding working space - the volumes must not be applied across sectors; railway quotas and local consumption standards each have their own volume notes and percentages (1.5% / 2.5%) and must not be mixed either.
  4. Deducting well length is not an earthwork deduction: drainage pipe laying is measured in metres along the centreline from design manhole centre to manhole centre less each well's length (SJG 181.4-2024 clause 1.2.3, deduction per well from table 1.2.3) - a pipe-length rule; whether earthworks deduct the manhole section follows the section tests in section 4 above and the 'no deduction for wells up to 1.5m' basis.
  5. Trench and pit earthworks follow the design data or drawn dimensions first; failing that, the approved project execution plan; only where neither exists do the default annex values of the quota or standard apply (SJG 111.1-2022 clause 1.2.3; DB11/T 2382-2024 clause 7.1.8 takes batter gradients from the design).
  6. Once sheeted, no batter is computed; when batter is computed, duplicated quantities at batter intersections are not deducted - where both apply, the section takes the sheeting widening (100mm one side, 200mm both sides).

Further reading

  • GB/T 50857-2024 municipal works quantity take-off standard, Annex A: table A.1.1 (earthworks, code 040101), A.4.1 (trench / pit / general earthworks classification), A.4.2 (working space widths), A.4.4 (definition of excavation depth).
  • GB 50861-2024 urban rail transit works quantity take-off standard, Annex A clause A.7.1 earthworks (9 items) with table A.7.1-1 soil classification and table A.7.1-2 rock classification.
  • GB 50268-2008 code for construction and acceptance of water and sewerage pipeline works, clause 4.3.2 and table 4.3.2 'working space width on one side of the pipe'.
  • CJJ/T 209-2013 technical specification for plastic drainage inspection wells, clause 6.3.1 and table 6.3.1 'working space on one side of the manhole base'; DB37/T 5031-2015 clause 6.2.5 (note that the clear pit size should be wider than the trench).
  • GB 50819-2013 specification for construction of oil and gas field gathering pipelines, clause 11.2.3; GB 50690-2011 acceptance specification for non-metallic piping works in the petrochemical sector, clause 5.3.3 and table 5.3.3.
  • DB11/T 2382-2024 construction works consumption standard: clauses 7.1.3, 7.1.4 (soil classification table 7.1.4), 7.1.5 (hand trimming of the floor at 300mm), 7.1.6 (table 7.1.6-1 foundation earthwork working space, table 7.1.6-2 pipe earthwork working space), 7.1.7, 7.1.8; similar rules at landscape works clauses 8.1.3, 8.1.6 and 8.1.7 make a useful contrast.
  • SJG 111.1-2022 utility tunnel works consumption standard (volume 1, earthworks, retention and piling), clause 1.2.3 with table 1.2.3-1 batter coefficients, table 1.2.3-2 working space widths and table 1.2.3-3 added working space per side of pipe trench floors.
  • SJG 84-2020 municipal maintenance works consumption standard, volume 2 water and sewerage maintenance, clause 7.2.9 and table 7.2.9 batter coefficients (backfill deductions, surplus haul-off basis).
  • SJG 181.4-2024 municipal works consumption standard, volume 4 water and sewerage networks, clause 1.2.3 and table 1.2.3 length deducted per well.
  • Building and decoration works consumption standard, earthworks notes items 4 to 11 (batter start, weighted averaging, no deduction at intersections, trench / pit / general earthworks computation, pipe trench length and the 2.5% joint pits, the 300m3 manual-versus-plant band for isolated foundations and pipe ducts, permitted rock overbreak).
  • Railway: TB/T 10833-2024 railway works budget quota manual, volume 12 (locomotive and car machinery works), volume note item 5 on measurement rules (1.5% wells / joint pits, the 500mm pipe-diameter split for backfill deductions); China Railway Kefa [2017] No. 33, railway works budget quota manual, volume 2 (bridges and culverts), chapter 2 pipe trenches and pit excavation, item 5 (2.5% joint pits, trench-versus-pit classification, sheeting widening 0.1m).

Keywords

  • 沟槽
  • 基坑
  • 检查井坑
  • 扩大基础
  • 重叠扣减
  • 重复计量
  • 井位段归属
  • 管道接口工作坑
  • 多管同沟
  • 工作面宽度