Distinguishing the super-height construction addition from the vertical transport charge, judging whether taking both on one project double-counts, and the two charging forms of the addition - the item method (super-height floor area) and the factor method (labour + plant x efficiency-loss coefficient)
Different cost objects: vertical transport carries only the large vertical-transport plant shifts and their crews, on the whole building's gross floor area (basements included) banded by structure and eaves height; the super-height addition carries only the height-induced labour and plant efficiency loss plus booster-pump shifts, on the super-height floor area (or that part's labour + plant), banded by height alone with no structure bands. The compositions never overlap (vertical-transport items hold almost pure plant cost with zero labour; addition items hold mostly labour), so taking both on one project is normal, not double counting; the test is threefold - same cost object (shifts versus efficiency loss)?, overlapping bases (whole building versus super-height part)?, the same base twice factored or the whole building taken at the top band?
Applicable Codes
- TB/T 10831-2024 铁路工程预算定额 Vol. 10 房屋工程 Ch. 1 第八节 垂直运输及超高增加(FY-1015~FY-1028)
- GB/T 50854-2024 房屋建筑与装饰工程工程量计算标准 App. R Table R.1.1(code 011601)、R.2.3
- DB11/T 638-2016 房屋修缮工程工程量计算规范 App. B.9.2
- 天津市建筑工程工程量清单计价指引(2025)表R.1(011601301、011601303)
- 湖南省2025版房屋建筑与装饰工程消耗量标准 第二十章、第二十一章
- 江苏省2026版建筑与装饰工程消耗量标准 第十九章、第二十章
- 陕西省新编消耗量定额(2024征求意见稿)第十七章措施项目
Positioning
The super-height construction addition (railway and some locals: 'building super-height addition'; Tianjin 2025 list: 'super-height works surcharge'; in the code system 'super-height construction addition') versus the vertical transport charge - the distinctions, the no-double-count test when both run on one project, and the two charging forms: item method (super-height floor area) and factor method (labour + plant x loss coefficient).
Core conclusions
1. Different cost objects (same chapter, separate items, split by verbatim work content)
Railway TB/T 10831-2024 Vol.10 chapter 1 section 8 puts both in one section, work content verbatim apart:
- Mechanical vertical transport: within 20m - 'the vertical-transport plant shifts needed to complete all contracted items within a reasonable period'; over 20m - 'the vertical-transport and hoist shifts with their crews needed to complete all civil items'.
- Building super-height addition: 'time lost to workers' reduced efficiency commuting, going up and down and natural rest, to vertical-transport interference, mechanical efficiency loss induced by labour loss, and booster-pump shifts for insufficient water pressure.' - efficiency loss and booster pumps only, never shifts.
| Item | Vertical transport | Super-height addition |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Plant cost: tower-crane, hoist and builder's-hoist shifts + crews + communication | Efficiency compensation: labour loss, plant loss induced by it, booster-pump shifts - no shifts, nothing physical |
| Trigger | Over 3.60m (single-storey within 3.60m excluded; isolated basements under 3.60m excluded) | Single-storey over 20m eaves or multi-storey over 6 storeys (basements uncounted); some locals by 'eaves over 20m' alone |
| Bands | Structure first (brick-concrete; concrete frame below / over two storeys; bents; steel single / multi; precast and the like), then height: within 20m, 20-30m, 30-40m, per 10m beyond | Height only: 20-40m, 40-60m, per 10m - no structure bands |
| Base | Whole building GFA (basements included) | Super-height floor area only (factor method: labour + plant of the works above 20m) |
| Composition | Almost pure plant cost, zero labour (the 20-30m band) | Mostly labour, plant only the booster pumps and the like |
| Rounding | Per-10m items: remainders over 5m count 10m, under 5m ignored | Same |
| Exclusions | Plant haulage, first erection / dismantling, track bedding, tower-crane and hoist bases (under 'large-plant mobilisation' or separate) | No vertical-transport shifts of any kind |
Railway verbatim (Vol.10 ch.1 s.8): '2. Single-storey buildings within 3.60m take no vertical transport. 3. The super-height addition serves single-storey buildings over 20m eaves and multi-storey over 6 storeys. 4. Rules: 1 Mechanical vertical transport by structure and eaves height on GFA (basements included). 2 Per-10m items over 20m: remainders over 5m count 10m, under 5m ignored. 3 The super-height addition by the super-height part's GFA.' The list keeps them apart a priori: Tianjin 2025 Table R.1 - 011601301 vertical transport (items 15-1~27) beside 011601303 super-height surcharge (17-1~49), the latter's work content 'labour efficiency loss above 20m eaves and the mechanical loss so induced'; listing per GB/T 50854-2024 Appendix R Table R.1.1 (011601), R.2.3: 'vertical transport covers only the large vertical-transport plant; other lifting plant and manual aids sit in the work items' (2013's 011703/011704/011705 have merged into 011601).
2. Both on one project - the three-point no-double test
Normal pairing (whole-building transport + super-height-part addition) is not double counting; only breaking any of these is:
- Same cost object? Crane and hoist shifts with crews enter transport only; the super-height part carries efficiency loss only - never the same shifts twice (the addition's 'vertical-transport interference time' compensates loss, not shifts).
- Overlapping bases? Transport on whole-building GFA (basements included); the addition on super-height GFA, or labour + plant of works above 20m - different ranges; putting the whole building on the addition item is up-rating.
- Twice factored / whole at top band? Where the addition ran by area, no second decorative-height factor on the same part; buildings of several heights split vertically, each banded - never the whole at the top band. Layering note: transport items exclude haulage, first erection / dismantling, track bedding and machine bases - those run under 'large-plant mobilisation', in neither of these two.
3. The two charging forms
Form 1, item method: railway FY-1026 (20-40m), FY-1027 (40-60m), FY-1028 (per 10m), per 100m2 GFA; the local 'other chapters' addition by area above 20m eaves belongs here. Form 2, factor method: Hunan 2025 chapter 21 - 'eaves over 20m compute the addition'; 'chapters 11-17: labour + plant x the coefficients'; at 40/60/80/100/120/140/160m - 4.50/6.43/8.36/10.29/12.21/14.14/16.07%. Shaanxi 2024 draft (17-169~177) bands 40~200m with all-in workdays + multistage pump shifts and idle + other plant loss (1.125%~7.125% of plant), matching the railway's four loss heads. Common features: the base takes only the super-height part's labour and plant (never the whole building, never materials), the coefficient rises monotonically with height, and mechanical loss rides inside as a percentage of plant cost.
Applicable boundaries
- Thresholds and bands never cross systems: railway 'single over 20m / multi over 6 storeys'; Hunan 'eaves over 20m'; Jiangsu dual 'height or storeys'; DB11/T 638-2016 (repair and ancient works) 'work point over 25m' - a building over 25m with work points under it takes nothing, and that repair basis never interchanges.
- Eaves height: outdoor ground to the drip edge (flat roofs at slab soffit, sloped at the wall-to-soffit meet); roof projections (stair towers, lift rooms, tanks, skylights) excluded; several heights split vertically with each banded; several structures computed apart.
- Some systems cap applicability (say 150m); above, price on the actual scheme - never force the top band.
- Distinctions and the no-double test only, no amounts or bid strategy; follow the local standard and contract.
- Editions: 2013 codes (011703/04/05) coexist with GB/T 50854-2024 Appendix R (011601) - fix the version first.
Further reading
Railway TB/T 10831-2024 Vol.10 ch.1 s.8 (FY-1015~1025 transport; FY-1026~1028 addition) with s.9 repair works; GB/T 50854-2024 Appendix R Table R.1.1 and R.2.3; Tianjin 2025 guide Table R.1 (011601301, 011601303); Hunan 2025 chapters 20-21; Jiangsu 2026 chapters 19-20; Shaanxi 2024 draft chapter 17 (17-84 up, 17-169 up); Beijing DB11/T 638-2016 App.B.9.2.
Keywords
- 超高施工增加费
- 垂直运输费
- 建筑物超高增加费
- 人工机械降效
- 超高部分建筑面积
- 超高增加费系数
- preliminary items
- 檐高