Three-way comparison of acceleration compensation, early completion bonus and delay damages: employer-instructed acceleration is borne by the employer, acceleration for the contractor's own causes is self-borne, and the bonus is contractually agreed consideration (GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 2.0.32, 2.0.33, 3.3.2 and 8.11.17~8.11.19; GB 50500-2013 Sections 9.11~9.13; GF-2017-0201 Clause 7.9)
Time-related payments are classified by nature first, then by the direction of the money: (1) acceleration cost (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 2.0.32) is limited to additional costs, paid extra by the employer, arising from measures taken by the contractor 'at the request of the employer' involving uneconomical use of labour, construction plant or materials to shorten the duration; where the employer requires earlier completion, the acceleration compensation is borne by the employer and the contract price and duration are adjusted (Clause 8.11.17 paragraph 1); (2) where completion is advanced by the contractor on its own initiative and not at the employer's request, the employer's consent must be obtained and the cost is borne by the contractor (Clause 8.11.17 paragraph 2); (3) where the contractor accelerates to catch up a lag caused by itself, the acceleration cost is still borne by the contractor (GB 50500-2013 Section 9.12 commentary); (4) delay damages run the opposite way: where the contractor fails to construct as agreed so that the actual duration exceeds the contractual duration, it compensates the employer as agreed in the contract (Clause 2.0.33), and the amount is included in the final account documents and deducted from the settlement payment (2013 Clause 9.12.2); (5) the early completion bonus is consideration agreed in the particular contract conditions (GF-2017-0201 Sub-clause 7.9.2), standing alongside acceleration compensation, which is by nature reimbursement of actual additional costs; (6) the sister clauses on the employer's claim side are Clause 8.11.18 (including delay caused by the contractor) and Clause 8.11.19 (choose one or more of: extended quality defect warranty period, additional costs incurred, delay damages, liquidated damages under the contract).
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第2.0.32条、第2.0.33条、第3.3.2条、第8.11.17~8.11.19条
- GB 50500-2013 建设工程工程量清单计价规范 第9.11.1~9.11.3条、第9.12节、第9.13节
- GF-2017-0201 建设工程施工合同(示范文本)第7.9.1项、第7.9.2项
Positioning
This card settles the directional question of which way the money flows when the construction programme is compressed: it places acceleration compensation (instructed by the employer), the early completion bonus (contractually agreed consideration) and delay damages (contractor default) on one comparison table, with trigger requirements, clause numbers and a decision path, for use in final account review, claim defence and drafting of particular contract conditions.
Core conclusions
1. The definitions decide the direction of payment
GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 2.0.32 'acceleration cost' reads: 'During performance of the works, costs payable by the employer in addition to the contractor that arise from measures taken by the contractor, at the request of the employer, to accelerate the progress of the works such that the contractual duration, or the contractual duration of phased completion works (including extensions of time approved by the employer), is shortened.' The term note states: 'Acceleration cost includes the additional costs incurred by the contractor, when complying with the employer's request, in taking measures involving uneconomical use of labour, construction plant or materials to achieve the shortened duration.'
Two cores: (1) one-way trigger - it arises only from 'the employer's request'; (2) uneconomical input - not ordinary optimisation of construction planning but the increment produced by over-resourcing to buy time.
2. Three-way comparison (the initiating party decides who bears the cost)
| Scenario | Initiating / responsible party | Who bears the cost | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Employer requires earlier completion (acceleration) | Employer instruction | Borne by the employer, with the contract price and duration adjusted | GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 8.11.17 paragraph 1 |
| Completion advanced by the contractor on its own initiative, not at the employer's request | Contractor itself | Borne by the contractor, subject to the employer's consent | Clause 8.11.17 paragraph 2 |
| Contractor behind schedule for its own reasons and compelled to accelerate | Contractor itself | Borne by the contractor, without release from delay liability | GB 50500-2013 Section 9.12 commentary |
| Contractor in delay | Contractor default | Contractor compensates the employer (deducted from the settlement payment) | Clause 2.0.33; 2013 Clause 9.12.2 |
Original texts:
- Clause 8.11.17 paragraph 1: 'Where the employer requires the contract works to be completed ahead of schedule, the contractor shall formulate reasonable measures for accelerating progress and revise the programme, and implement them after the employer's consent; the additional early completion costs (acceleration compensation) arising therefrom shall be borne by the employer';
- Clause 8.11.17 paragraph 2: 'Where completion is advanced by the contractor for its own reasons and not at the employer's request, the employer's consent shall be obtained and the additional costs arising therefrom shall be borne by the contractor';
- Final paragraph of the same clause: 'Where the employer requires the contract works to be completed ahead of schedule (acceleration), the employer shall bear the additional costs incurred by the contractor in using uneconomical labour, materials and construction plant';
- GB 50500-2013 Section 9.12 commentary: 'Even if the contractor has taken acceleration measures, the acceleration cost shall still be borne by the contractor'; Clause 9.12.1: 'Where the contractor fails to construct in accordance with the contract so that actual progress lags behind planned progress, the contractor shall accelerate progress and achieve the contractual duration';
- Clause 2.0.33 'delay damages': 'Costs which the contractor shall pay to the employer under the contract as compensation where the contractor fails to construct in accordance with the contract, causing the actual duration to exceed the contractual duration or the contractual duration of phased completion works (including extensions of time approved by the employer)'; for works with contractually agreed phased completion and handover, the damages are calculated separately according to the delay time of the works concerned and the contractually agreed calculation method.
3. Explicit constitutive requirements (all must be met for Clause 8.11.17 paragraph 1)
- Written instruction - GF-2017-0201 Sub-clause 7.9.1: 'Where the employer requires the contractor to complete ahead of schedule, the employer shall issue an early completion instruction to the contractor through the supervising engineer, and the contractor shall submit an early completion proposal to the employer and the supervising engineer, covering the implementation scheme, the time to be shortened, the increase in the contract price and other contents'; 'Where the contractor considers the early completion instruction impossible to execute, it shall raise a written objection to the supervising engineer and the employer, and the employer and the supervising engineer shall reply within 7 days after receiving the objection. Under no circumstances may the employer compress a reasonable duration.'
- Measures consented by the employer and revised programme approved - same sub-clause: 'Where the employer accepts the early completion proposal, the supervising engineer shall, in consultation with the employer and the contractor, adopt measures to accelerate progress and revise the construction programme, and the additional costs arising therefrom shall be borne by the employer.'
- The input is an 'uneconomical' increment - the core of the Clause 2.0.32 term; ordinary efficiency improvement and scheme optimisation are not acceleration cost.
4. Early completion bonus versus acceleration compensation
GF-2017-0201 Sub-clause 7.9.2: 'Where the employer requires the contractor to complete ahead of schedule, or the contractor proposes early completion capable of producing benefit for the employer, the contracting parties may agree in the particular contract conditions a bonus for early completion.' - the bonus is agreed consideration: it may be set as a per-calendar-day amount or a lump sum, may coexist with reimbursement of actual additional costs, or may be agreed in the contract in place of calculating them.
Acceleration compensation is reimbursement of actual additional costs: limited to the additional costs of uneconomical labour, materials and construction plant incurred by the contractor in executing the employer's instruction. GB 50500-2013 Clause 9.11.3 provides the contractual route: 'The employer and the contractor shall agree in the contract the compensation amount per calendar day for early completion; this cost shall be included as an increase in the contract price in the final account documents and paid together with the settlement payment.'
Decision order: where the contract provides a bonus amount or a per-calendar-day compensation -> follow the agreement; where it does not -> prove the actually increased costs. Both are opposite in settlement direction to delay damages: acceleration compensation increases the contract price and is paid together with the settlement payment, whereas delay damages are deducted from the settlement payment (2013 Clause 9.12.2). The Section 9.12 commentary adds that 'unless otherwise agreed in the contract, delay damages may be 5% of the contract price' - a commentary-level reference value without binding force, which must be written into the contract.
5. The superior clause on risk allocation
GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 3.3.2 item 4 lists 'acceleration, early completion, suspension or deferred execution required by the employer' among the measurement and pricing risks borne by the employer, which 'need not be considered in the contractor's priced offer'; where the matter affects the duration and meets the contractual conditions for duration adjustment, the contract duration shall be adjusted. Acceleration cost must therefore not be demanded of the contractor as pre-packaged in its tender price.
6. Sister clauses: the employer's claim side
- Clause 8.11.18: where, due to causes attributable to the contractor, any of the listed events causes delay and (or) economic loss to the employer, the employer may, according to the affected delay time and (or) the economic loss, bring one or more claims, including loss to the employer from delay of the contract works caused by the contractor, the contractor's failure to discharge its obligations as contractor, failure to perform main contractor's attendance and coordination for employer-supplied materials and specialist subcontracts, government fines or third-party compensation attributable to the contractor, and quality not conforming to the agreement.
- Clause 8.11.19: 'Where loss to the employer is caused by the contractor, the employer may choose one or more of the following means of recovery: 1 extending the quality defect warranty period; 2 requiring the contractor to pay the additional costs incurred by the affected event; 3 requiring the contractor to pay delay damages; 4 requiring the contractor to pay liquidated damages as agreed in the contract.'
- GB 50500-2013 Section 9.13 commentary: claims are 'in nature an act of economic compensation rather than punishment'; 'where the employer considers that its loss was caused by the contractor, it shall make a claim by reference to the contractor's claim procedure'.
Boundaries of application
- GB/T 50500-2024 is a recommended national standard; where the contract still invokes GB 50500-2013, early completion (acceleration compensation) is written as Clauses 9.11.1~9.11.3, delay damages as Section 9.12 and claims as Section 9.13, and Clause 8.11.17 is not used.
- A claim for acceleration compensation must simultaneously satisfy 'written instruction of the employer (issued through the supervising engineer) + measures consented with the revised programme + uneconomical input'; early completion on the contractor's own initiative without a written early completion instruction cannot support a compensation claim.
- Clause 9.11.1 of the 2013 edition - 'the number of days of compression shall not exceed 20% of the quota-based duration; where exceeded, the increased acceleration cost shall be indicated in the tender documents' - constrains duration setting at tendering stage; the 2024 edition no longer retains that quantitative threshold, so it can serve only as a reasonableness red line and as a prior disclosure duty at tendering, not as a rate cap during construction.
- The 5% delay damages figure is a reference value in the 2013 edition commentary; the early completion bonus and the per-calendar-day compensation follow the particular contract conditions, and absent agreement must be proven by actually increased costs - percentages must not be applied directly.
- The General Principles of the Civil Law of the PRC cited in the 2013 edition Section 9.13 commentary was repealed when the Civil Code came into force; the civil liability basis should now be cited to the breach of contract provisions of the Civil Code, and the old clause numbers must not be copied.
- This card settles only the direction and allocation of the costs; specific calculation formulas, cost components and de-duplication rules are covered by the cards on calculating acceleration costs.
Further reading
- GB/T 50500-2024 Standard for pricing of bills of quantities for construction works: Clause 2.0.32 (acceleration cost), Clause 2.0.33 (delay damages), Clause 3.3.2 item 4 (measurement and pricing risks borne by the employer), Clause 8.11.17 (bearing of early completion and acceleration costs), Clause 8.11.18 (employer claim events), Clause 8.11.19 (employer's means of recovery), and Chapter 8 adjustment of the contract price.
- GB 50500-2013 Code of valuation with bills of quantities for construction works: Clauses 9.11.1~9.11.3 (20% duration compression, bearing of early completion compensation, per-calendar-day compensation amount and listing in settlement), Clauses 9.12/9.12.1/9.12.2 (delay damages), Section 9.13 commentary (nature of claims and the employer's claim procedure).
- GF-2017-0201 model construction contract: Sub-clause 7.9.1 (early completion instruction, proposal contents, 7-day reply to objections, no compression of a reasonable duration), Sub-clause 7.9.2 (agreement of the early completion bonus).
Keywords
- 赶工补偿
- 提前竣工奖励
- 误期赔偿费
- 赶工费
- 加速施工费用
- claim
- 工期压缩