Goal relations and yielding order of the three controls, three managements and one coordination: how the standards rank quality, schedule, cost and safety goals
The standards set no fixed single-goal ranking - GB/T 50326-2017 Articles 3.5.1 and 3.5.3 require quality, schedule, cost, safety and environment to be treated as mutually compatible, mutually supporting system-integration goals, priorities set dynamically per project and stage. On conflict, the yielding order: safety holds the floor; quality yields nothing to schedule (RISN-TG 012-2011 Article 7.3.5 - where schedule conflicts with quality, quality comes first); cost must not be one-sidedly saved (GB/T 50502-2009 Article 7.6.3); cost, schedule and quality must be co-ordinated (GB/T 50358-2017 Article 12.1.3). GB/T 50852-2013 Article 12.2.3 lists construction-stage management as seven parallel functions - investment, schedule, quality, contract, information, coordination, safety - with no choosing among them.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50326-2017 第3.5.1条
- GB/T 50326-2017 第3.5.3条
- GB/T 50852-2013 第12.2.3条
- GB/T 50502-2009 第7.6.3条
- GB/T 50358-2017 第12.1.3条
- RISN-TG 012-2011 第7.3.5条
Scope of the question
The three controls, three managements and one coordination is the colloquial summary of supervision and project management functions at the construction stage: quality, schedule and investment (cost) control; contract, information and safety management; and organisational coordination. This card asks whether the goals carry a fixed most-important ranking and what the standards' yielding order is when goals conflict.
Core conclusions
1. Seven parallel management functions, no choosing. GB/T 50852-2013 Classification Standard for Construction Engineering Consulting, Article 12.2.3, lists construction-stage project management content: 1 investment control; 2 schedule control; 3 quality control; 4 contract management; 5 information management; 6 organisation and coordination; 7 safety management - seven parallel functions forming a complete system, with no pick-one approach.
2. The standards require systems management, not a fixed ranking. GB/T 50326-2017 Code for Construction Project Management, Article 3.5.1: project systems management integrates management measures around the overall project goal - a dynamic process in which quality, schedule, cost, safety and environment management are mutually compatible and mutually supporting; it must meet each goal's needs and secure the overall goal of the whole system. Article 3.5.3: applying systems methods, analyse and justify the project goals on the basis of the internal links among quality, safety, environment, time and cost, combined with the priorities of each goal, integrating decision-making, tendering, survey, design, procurement, construction and commissioning. The wording combined with the priorities of each goal means priorities are set dynamically by the project's constraints and stage - not a fixed global constant. So which is most important has no single answer day-to-day; the answer appears only in the yielding order when goals collide.
3. Yielding order on conflict:
- Quality before schedule - RISN-TG 012-2011 Practice Guidelines for Construction Project Managers, Article 7.3.5: the project manager shall properly handle the relation of construction quality and schedule ... quality is the foundation of reputation; where schedule conflicts with quality, quality comes first. Within the three controls, schedule yields to quality - expressly written.
- Cost not one-sidedly saved - GB/T 50502-2009 Code for Construction Organization Planning of Building Works, Article 7.6.3: correctly handle the relations of cost with schedule, quality, safety and environment; cost management proceeds together with them, part of the management of the whole construction goal system; do not one-sidedly stress cost saving. Cost is a constrained variable, not a club overriding the rest.
- Cost co-ordinated with schedule and quality - GB/T 50358-2017 Code for Management of Engineering Procurement Construction (EPC) Projects, Article 12.1.3: the project department co-ordinates cost, schedule and quality control decisions, preventing improper responses to cost deviations from harming quality and schedule or courting late-project risk.
- Safety at the floor - safety sits alongside quality, schedule, cost and environment in systems management (GB/T 50326-2017 3.5.1, 3.5.3); practice treats it as an inviolable floor because accidents are irreversible (stoppage, accountability, qualification damage).
In sum: day-to-day running is system balance with multiple goals; on conflict, safety holds the floor, quality yields nothing to schedule, cost is not one-sidedly saved.
Applicability limits
- Applies to goal management of construction and EPC projects and goal-relation discussions in supervision and employer-side management.
- All provisions are principles: they set dispositions on conflict, not licence to sacrifice time or cost unilaterally - yielding still follows the contractual variation, claim and approval procedures.
- The three managements and one coordination serve as instruments (authority basis, decision data, interface channels); they do not produce works directly and are not ranked on the same scale as the three controls.
- The provisions address different subjects (project managers, construction planning, EPC, consulting classification) - match subject and stage when citing.
- Safety's floor status here rests on its inclusion among system goals; stronger mandatory requirements lie in the special safety legislation.
Further reading
- GB/T 50326-2017, Section 3.5 (3.5.1, 3.5.3).
- GB/T 50852-2013, Article 12.2.3.
- GB/T 50502-2009, Article 7.6.3.
- GB/T 50358-2017, Article 12.1.3.
- RISN-TG 012-2011, Article 7.3.5.
Keywords
- 三控三管一协调
- 项目目标优先级
- 质量与进度矛盾
- 系统管理方法
- 费用进度质量协调
- 不能片面强调成本节约