Differences among plan completion rate, output-value completion rate, and physical image progress, and root-cause analysis of their inconsistency
The three indicators are three different rulers: plan completion rate measures against the time axis and the plan, output-value completion rate measures money against the contract sum, and image progress measures physical positions — different bases naturally produce inconsistent readings. Six root causes: different measurement dimensions, unbalanced unit-price structure, plan looseness and adjustments, lagging measurement certification, different conversion weights, and inconsistent statistical conventions. In practice the three are used in division of labor: physical image progress is the main line on site, output value follows certified measurement, and a deviation analysis report is prepared when discrepancies are large.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准
- GB/T 50326-2017 建设工程项目管理规范
- DB37/T 5028-2022 建设工程监理工作规程
- DB37/T 5096-2017 建设工程项目管理咨询规范
- DB37/T 5164-2020 建筑施工现场管理标准
Topic Positioning
Analyzing the basis differences of the three common progress indicators — plan completion rate, output-value completion rate, and physical image progress — explaining why they often fail to reconcile, and giving practical division of labor and unified-basis approaches.
Core Conclusions
The three are three different rulers measuring the same physical works: plan completion rate = actual ÷ planned quantity (time axis × plan, often spread on an S-curve), measuring "time"; output-value completion rate = cumulative output value ÷ contract total (monetary basis), measuring "money"; image progress = the completion state of physical parts/processes (e.g., piling done, structure topped out), measuring "the entity". With different bases, inconsistent readings are the norm, not an anomaly. Six root causes: ① different measurement dimensions (money/physical/plan); ② unbalanced unit-price structure — when high-price items finish first, output-value completion surges while weight-based image progress lags; conversely, bulk cheap items like earthwork move image progress fast with little output value; ③ plan looseness and mid-course adjustments change the denominator; ④ lagging measurement certification — output value counts only after measurement per contract and supervisor certification (monthly), while image progress reflects site inspection immediately, so at any moment image progress usually leads certified output; ⑤ different conversion weights (position weights vs value share vs plan curve); ⑥ inconsistent statistical conventions (cumulative vs monthly, owner-supplied materials included or not, payment-as-completion, etc.). Practical division: plan completion rate warns of time-axis deviation, output-value completion rate tracks money and contract performance, image progress tracks physical state — on site image progress is the main line, output value follows certified measurement, and a deviation analysis report is prepared when readings diverge significantly.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to progress and output-value statistics and supervisor measurement certification during construction. The definitions and weighting algorithms of the three indicators must first be agreed by contract or project management rules; algorithms differ across projects, so the size of reading gaps is not horizontally comparable. This card covers only basis analysis and the general procedure — earned-value quantification (SV/SPI) and duration-claim determination are on separate cards. Not applicable to single-point price queries or settlement audit.
Further Reading
See GB/T 50500-2024, Standard for Valuation of Construction Works with Bills of Quantities, Clause 7.1.2 (measurement nodes and basis of contract works) and Section 9.4 (progress-payment measurement); GB/T 50326-2017, Clause 9.3.4 (schedule checking contents and methods); DB37/T 5096-2017, Clause 8.3.2 (contents of the schedule deviation analysis report); DB37/T 5028-2022, Code for Supervision of Construction Works, Clause 6.2.3 (supervisor measurement procedure: image-progress submission → review and certification); DB37/T 5164-2020, Clause 7.3.4 (schedule plan checking contents).
Keywords
- 计划完成率
- 产值完成率
- 形象进度
- 进度偏差分析
- measurement of the works
- 进度管理