Detecting mismatch between reported progress output value and actual quantities: a three-layer mutual-verification method — procedure, evidence, data
The benchmark for judging mismatch is "reported output value vs measured output value", not "output value vs progress". Verify through three layers: at the procedure layer, exclude unaccepted/out-of-scope portions per the measurement sign-off procedure; at the evidence layer, back-calculate actual quantities from supervision/construction logs, concealed-work acceptance records, key-process records, and material requisitions; at the data layer, use output-progress conversion deviations, unit productivity, per-square content, and cumulative-measurement-vs-drawing-total cross-footing to circumscribe anomalies.
Applicable Codes
- DB37/T 5028-2022 第6.2.3条
- DB13(J)/T 8161-2019 第8.2.2条
- GB/T 50522-2019 第6.4.2条
- DB11/T 382-2017 第7.3.6条
- DB22/T 5016-2019 第7.5.1条
- GB/T 50326-2017 第11.4.3条
Topic Positioning
A verification method for detecting "mismatch between progress output value and actual quantities": it does not explain why the two naturally differ (caliber issues in the cited card) but gives procedure, evidence, and data mutual verification to pin down genuinely inflated or miscounted portions.
Core Conclusions
The judgment benchmark is "reported output value vs measured output value", not "output value vs progress": reporting is a claim, measurement is review; reported greater than signed-off is normal, and construct-first-sign-later plus unbalanced pricing (high-price items first) both cause deviations — do not call every deviation an anomaly. Three-layer mutual verification: (1) Procedure layer (measurement gate): per DB37/T 5028-2022 Clause 6.2.3, the procedure "submission -> review/re-check/spot measurement -> sign-off"; portions not accepted or failing acceptance or not per contract are never measured (DB13(J)/T 8161-2019, Clause 8.2.2; GB/T 50522-2019, Clause 6.4.2). (2) Evidence layer (hardest): reported portions must appear in that day's supervision/construction log records (DB11/T 382-2017, Clause 7.3.6); concealed portions locked by acceptance records + position-tagged imagery (DB22/T 5016-2019, Clause 7.5.1); key-process records (pouring, grouting, tensioning) corresponding one-to-one with quantities; material requisition ÷ quota content ≈ completed quantity — severe divergence is an anomaly. (3) Data layer (cross-footing to circumscribe): deviation between physical-progress percentage and output-value completion percentage > 10 percentage points (empirical) triggers key verification, especially concentrated reporting of high-price items; unit productivity below normal work efficiency and per-square content deviating from similar-project indicators flag suspects; cumulative measurement exceeding drawing totals (without changes) is hard-evidence-grade anomaly; cost accounting insists on synchronization of progress, output value, and cost (GB/T 50326-2017, Clause 11.4.3).
Applicable Boundaries
Applies mainly to progress-payment review and supervision measurement under unit-rate contracts; lump-sum contracts apply the same logic benchmarked to contract drawing quantities. The evidence layer depends on complete site records — logs, concealed-work records, imagery; when missing, only the data layer can circumscribe suspects and supplementary evidence can be demanded; the 10-percentage-point threshold, productivity, and per-square content are empirical references, to be adjusted per contract and comparable projects.
Further Reading
Measurement procedures and non-measurement per DB37/T 5028-2022 Clause 6.2.3, DB13(J)/T 8161-2019 Clause 8.2.2, GB/T 50522-2019 Clause 6.4.2; supervision logs per DB11/T 382-2017 Clause 7.3.6; concealed-work imagery per DB22/T 5016-2019 Clause 7.5.1; cost three-synchronization per GB/T 50326-2017 Clause 11.4.3; root causes of caliber differences in the "planned completion rate, output-value completion rate, and physical progress caliber differences" card.
Keywords
- 进度产值与实际工程量不匹配
- 报量产值
- 计量产值
- 形象进度
- measurement of the works
- 虚报工程量
- 进度款审核
- 三层互证