Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-29

The reporting-for-review (baohe) procedure for arbitration-related judicial review cases: the six categories of cases including applications to confirm the validity of arbitration agreements; reporting levels for non-foreign-related versus foreign-related or HK/Macao/Taiwan-related cases (Higher People's Court / Supreme People's Court); and cascaded reporting where a second-instance court in civil cases proposes to find an arbitration agreement non-existent, invalid, expired, or unclear and incapable of performance

Yes, a ruling may be made only after the report has been reviewed. A people's court handling a non-foreign-related arbitration judicial review case that proposes to find an arbitration agreement invalid must first report to the Higher People's Court of its jurisdiction for review; in foreign-related or HK/Macao/Taiwan-related cases, after the Higher People's Court reviews and agrees, the case must further be reported to the Supreme People's Court, and a ruling may be made only after that review and in accordance with the review opinion (Fa Shi [2017] No. 21, Article 2). Applications to confirm the validity of an arbitration agreement are arbitration judicial review cases (Article 1); where a civil ruling of refusal to accept a case, dismissal of the suit, or on an objection to jurisdiction was made because of the validity of an arbitration agreement, and the second-instance court proposes to find the agreement non-existent, invalid, expired, or unclear and incapable of performance, the same cascaded reporting applies (Article 8). The procedural threshold for a finding that 'the arbitration clause is void' is therefore high and the cycle long.

Applicable Codes

  • 最高人民法院关于仲裁司法审查案件报核问题的有关规定(法释〔2017〕21号,2021修正)第一条、第二条、第八条
  • 中华人民共和国仲裁法(2025修订,2026年3月1日施行)第二十七条、第二十九条、第三十一条
  • 最高人民法院关于适用《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》的解释(法释〔2015〕5号,2022修正)第二百一十五条

Positioning of the topic

The cascaded reporting-for-review procedure that people's courts must complete before finding an arbitration agreement invalid (or non-existent, expired, or unclear and incapable of performance) in arbitration judicial review cases: case scope, linkage with the substantive validity standards of the Arbitration Law, the two reporting levels, and the second-instance reporting requirement. Used to assess the availability and time cost of the outcome 'the arbitration clause is found invalid'.

Core conclusions

I. Scope of application: which cases are arbitration judicial review cases (Article 1)

'Arbitration judicial review cases under these Provisions include the following: (1) applications to confirm the validity of an arbitration agreement; (2) applications to set aside arbitral awards made by arbitration institutions in mainland China; (3) applications for enforcement of arbitral awards made by arbitration institutions in mainland China; (4) applications for recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards made in the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, the Macao Special Administrative Region or the Taiwan region; (5) applications for recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards; (6) other arbitration judicial review cases.' An application to confirm the validity of an arbitration agreement (for example asserting that 'no arbitration institution was agreed, so the agreement is void') falls under item (1) and is subject to the reporting procedure.

II. Reporting levels (text of Article 2)

'Where an intermediate people's court or a specialised people's court, in handling a foreign-related or HK/Macao/Taiwan-related arbitration judicial review case, proposes upon review to find an arbitration agreement invalid, not to enforce, or to set aside, an arbitral award made by an arbitration institution in mainland China, not to recognise or enforce an arbitral award made in the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, the Macao Special Administrative Region or the Taiwan region, or not to recognise or enforce a foreign arbitral award, it shall report to the Higher People's Court of its jurisdiction; where the Higher People's Court, upon review, proposes to agree, it shall report to the Supreme People's Court. A ruling may be made only after review by the Supreme People's Court and in accordance with the review opinion of the Supreme People's Court.'

'Where an intermediate people's court or a specialised people's court, in handling a non-foreign-related arbitration judicial review case, proposes upon review to find an arbitration agreement invalid, or not to enforce, or to set aside, an arbitral award made by an arbitration institution in mainland China, it shall report to the Higher People's Court of its jurisdiction; a ruling may be made only after review by the Higher People's Court and in accordance with the review opinion of the Higher People's Court.'

In short: where a non-foreign-related case proposes to find an arbitration agreement invalid - one level of review by the Higher People's Court; where a foreign-related or HK/Macao/Taiwan-related case does so - two levels of reporting, Higher People's Court plus Supreme People's Court. In both, a ruling may be made only after the review and in accordance with the review opinion; the intermediate or specialised court may not find invalidity on its own.

III. Second-instance reporting in civil cases (text of Article 8)

'In civil litigation cases, where a party appeals against a people's court ruling of refusal to accept a case, dismissal of the suit, or on an objection to jurisdiction, made because the validity of an arbitration agreement is involved, and the second-instance people's court, upon review, proposes to find the arbitration agreement non-existent, invalid, expired, or unclear and incapable of performance, it shall report level by level in accordance with Article 2 of these Provisions, and a ruling may be made only after review by the higher people's court and in accordance with the review opinion of the higher people's court.'

This extends reporting from 'arbitration judicial review cases' to jurisdiction-type appeals in ordinary civil litigation: where the first instance refused to accept the case or dismissed the suit on the ground of an arbitration clause, and the second instance proposes, on appeal, to accept the case instead under the proviso of Article 215 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law (Fa Shi [2015] No. 5) (the arbitration clause is non-existent, invalid, expired, or unclear and incapable of performance), the same cascaded reporting must first be completed.

Boundaries of application

  • Reporting constrains only 'negative' findings (proposing to find an arbitration agreement invalid, not to enforce, set aside, or not recognise or enforce an award); a proposed finding that an arbitration agreement is valid, or the dismissal of an application, is not subject to reporting.
  • Reporting is an internal court review procedure. It does not change the parties' evidence and allegations, and it does not suspend the parties' obligation to raise objections within the time limit: an objection to the validity of an arbitration agreement must still be raised before the first hearing of the arbitral tribunal; the party may request the arbitration institution or the arbitral tribunal to decide, or request a court to rule; where one party requests the institution or tribunal and the other requests a court, the court rules (Arbitration Law (2025 revision), Article 31).
  • The outcome of reporting depends on the substantive standards: where no arbitration institution was agreed or the agreement is unclear, Article 29 of the Arbitration Law (2025 revision) applies: the parties first conclude a supplementary agreement; if none is reached, the arbitration agreement is void. Reporting raises the procedural threshold and the cycle of a finding of invalidity, not the substantive standard.
  • These Provisions are the 2021 amended version; verify the currently effective version when citing. The court levels stated (intermediate or specialised people's courts, Higher People's Court, Supreme People's Court) are procedural provisions; in practice the accepting court must also be determined under the local division of jurisdiction among courts.

Further reading

  • Provisions of the Supreme People's Court on Issues Concerning the Reporting for Review of Arbitration-Related Judicial Review Cases by People's Courts (Fa Shi [2017] No. 21, as amended in 2021): Article 1 (six categories of arbitration judicial review cases), Article 2 (two reporting levels, foreign-related and non-foreign-related), Article 8 (cascaded reporting at second instance in civil cases proposing non-existent / invalid / expired / unclear and incapable of performance); the remaining articles cover reporting materials, time limits and document handling.
  • Arbitration Law of the People's Republic of China (2025 revision, effective 1 March 2026): Article 27 (three essential contents of an arbitration agreement), Article 29 (supplementary agreement where the institution or subject matter is unclear, and invalidity as the consequence), Article 31 (dual-track handling of validity objections and the time limit before the first hearing).
  • Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (Fa Shi [2015] No. 5, as amended in 2022), Article 215 (notice where a suit is filed despite an arbitration clause, refusal to accept, and four exceptions).

Keywords

  • 仲裁司法审查
  • 报核
  • 确认仲裁协议效力
  • 认定仲裁协议无效
  • 高级人民法院
  • 最高人民法院
  • 不予受理
  • 管辖权异议

Cited By