Selection conditions for earthwork quantity methods (cross-section method, square-grid method, triangular-network method), and rules for cross-section spacing, density, survey point layout and accuracy tolerances in cross-section surveying
Earthwork calculation should match the method to landform, area size and topographic-map accuracy, and should be checked with a second method: elongated strips such as roads, pipelines and channels with sharp relief or irregular cut and fill suit the (cross-)section method; site levelling suits the square-grid method (grid side 10~40 m, 20 m preferred) or the triangular-network method. Section spacing follows the works type - for the section method L should be 5~20 m; in elongated road and pipeline strips the spacing of section points and of adjacent sections should not exceed 5 m; railway subgrade cross-sections are usually at 20 m, with sections also taken at kilometre posts, hectometre posts and sharp terrain changes, and rebuilt railways need no fewer than 3 sections per 100 m; the smaller L, the higher the accuracy and the larger the computation load - a tension between accuracy and speed.
Applicable Codes
- RISN-TG014-2012 第6.3.3条、表6-8
- GB/T 50633-2023 第10.5.4条
- DBJ51/T 108-2018 附录B B.0.1
- TB 10101-2018 第5.5.1~5.5.5条
- TB 10105-2009 第5.4.1~5.4.4条
- CJJ/T 8-2011 第9.6.8条
Topic scope
Selection conditions for earthwork quantity methods (cross-section method, square-grid method, triangular-network method) and their grid / section layout parameters, plus cross-section surveying rules on spacing, density, point layout, drawing scale and checking tolerances - to settle 'which method to use, and how dense the sections must be for accuracy'.
Core conclusions
I. Method selection
- Earthwork calculation should choose a rational method in light of the landform, area size and topographic-map accuracy at the site, and should be checked with a second method; site levelling should choose the method from the terrain data and the vertical design, and where cut and fill volumes differ greatly the basin design level should be shifted (raise the design level if cut exceeds fill, lower it if fill exceeds cut) (RISN-TG014-2012, 6.3.3 and its commentary).
- Cross-section method: suits elongated strips such as roads, pipelines and channels; on terrain that is complex and sharply undulating, or on long, narrow strips with deep and irregular cut and fill, the cross-section method should be chosen (GB/T 50633-2023, 10.5.4). Its field work is relatively involved and the computation load heavy, especially over large areas with high accuracy demands; widening the section interval to cut computation lowers accuracy - hence the tension between computational accuracy and speed (GB/T 50633-2023, 10.5.4).
- Square-grid method: divide the site into square grids of side 10~40 m - the smaller the grid, the higher the accuracy, with 20 m preferred; mark the design level and the natural ground level at each corner, their difference being the construction height (by convention '+' for fill, '-' for cut). The zero line is the cut-fill boundary (construction height zero on the line); on grid edges whose corner points are one cut and one fill, find the zero point by interpolation (x1 = h1/(h1+h2).a, with h taken as absolute values) and join the zero points to trace the zero line; then compute the volume prism by prism (five cases: all cut or all fill, one corner cut, two corners cut, three corners cut) and total them (RISN-TG014-2012, 6.3.3 computation notes).
- Triangular-network method: first subdivide the grid into triangles following the contour lines; the zero-line principle is the same as for the square-grid method; where a triangle's corners mix fill and cut, the zero line splits it into a pyramid on a triangular base and a wedge on a quadrilateral base, the two volumes computed separately (cut negative, fill positive) and totalled (RISN-TG014-2012, 6.3.3).
- For a comparison of applicability see RISN-TG014-2012 table 6-8 'comparison of earthwork calculation methods'.
II. Section spacing and density
- Building geotechnical surveying, section method: set cross-sections at a length L, L preferably 5~20 m (DBJ51/T 108-2018, annex B, B.0.1).
- For earthworks surveying in elongated road and pipeline strips the section method is preferred: the spacing of section points should not exceed 5 m, and the spacing of adjacent sections should not exceed 5 m; above and below scarps where the terrain breaks sharply, survey points should be set separately (GB/T 50633-2023, 10.5.4).
- Railway subgrade cross-sections: spacing generally 20 m; the survey width and density follow terrain and geology together with the plan and profile, meeting the subgrade design needs; cross-sections must be taken at kilometre posts, hectometre posts and marked longitudinal and transverse terrain changes, at the lowest and highest points of embankments and cuttings, and at the starts and ends of major and minor bridge heads, tunnel portals, subgrade retaining and load-bearing structures (TB 10101-2018, clause 5.5.2, items 1 and 2).
- The survey width for railway subgrade cross-sections follows the subgrade centre cut / fill level and the side slopes, generally extending at least 10 m beyond the slope (cut crest or embankment toe); roads, ponds, ditches, boulders, cavities, boreholes, land-class boundary points and other features must all carry survey points marked on the cross-section drawing (TB 10101-2018, clause 5.5.2, item 3).
- Rebuilt railways: no fewer than 3 cross-sections per 100 m; cross-sections must be surveyed at hectometre marks and longitudinal and transverse terrain changes, the highest (deepest) points of embankments (cuttings), the zero sections at the cut-fill boundary, soil-rock boundary points, abutments and bridge ends, tunnel portals, retaining walls, slope protection, subgrade defect zones, subgrade width changes and track-centre-distance control points; the width should extend beyond the slope toe or cut crest, widened as needed on the rebuilt line or second-track side; cross-section drawings at 1:200, exceptionally 1:100 or 1:500 (TB 10105-2009, clause 5.4.1). Ballast shoulder and toe, side ditches, berms, subgrade slope change points, embankment toes and cutting crests must all carry survey points, distances and levels taken to the centimetre (clause 5.4.2).
- Urban roads and pipelines: the cross-section survey width must meet design needs; the section direction is perpendicular to the centre line on tangents and on the normal on curves; where design quality is unaffected, the number of sections may follow the transverse terrain changes, with extra chainage and levels set on the centre line when sections are added; road widening and drainage ditch works may be surveyed at representative positions (CJJ/T 8-2011, clause 9.6.8, item 2).
III. Accuracy and checking tolerances
- Checking tolerances for rebuilt-railway cross-sections: within embankment shoulders and cutting side-ditch berms, the elevation tolerance should be +/-5 cm and the distance tolerance +/-10 cm; beyond that range, the elevation tolerance and the distance tolerance to prominent feature points follow the computed values of formulas (5.4.4-1) and (5.4.4-2) (TB 10105-2009, clause 5.4.4).
- Urban survey cross-sections: surveyed by total station, or by level for heights and tape or rope for distances; height readings to the centimetre, distance readings to the decimetre; the misclosure between adjacent bench-mark height differences on longitudinal profiles and profile checks should not exceed 20 mm (CJJ/T 8-2011, clause 9.6.8, items 1 and 5).
- Railway subgrade construction setting out: side stakes by total-station coordinate method or GNSS RTK, tolerance no more than 10 cm; dimensional errors of retaining walls, slope protection and like structures, and the base and top level tolerances, all no more than 5 cm; setting-out point tolerance of subgrade improvement works 5 cm (TB 10101-2018, clauses 5.5.4 and 5.5.5).
Applicable boundaries
- For road and underground pipeline works in plain areas with flat ground or narrow work faces, cross-sections may be omitted, the ground level at centre stakes representing the flanking terrain (CJJ/T 8-2011, clause 9.6.8 commentary).
- Section spacing differs by standard (section method L preferably 5~20 m; no more than 5 m in elongated road and pipeline strips; railway subgrade generally 20 m; rebuilt railways no fewer than 3 per 100 m) - the industry standard matching the works type must be used, not applied across industries.
- Method choice affects accuracy and workload, not the legality of measurement; important or disputed works should be checked with a second method, using the divergence between the two to judge whether to densify sections.
- Sharp terrain changes, above and below scarps, zero sections at the cut-fill boundary and soil-rock boundary points are positions where survey points / sections are mandatory and must not be skipped on an average spacing.
Further reading
- RISN-TG014-2012 'Technical Guide for Sanitary Landfill of Domestic Waste', clause 6.3.3 and its commentary, table 6-8 (comparison of earthwork calculation methods), computation notes (square-grid zero-line formulas 6-25 and 6-26, pyramid and wedge volume formulas of the triangular-network method)
- GB/T 50633-2023 'Standard for Engineering Surveying of Nuclear Power Plants', clause 10.5.4 (section method for elongated strips, spacing of section points and adjacent sections, the accuracy versus computation-load tension)
- DBJ51/T 108-2018 'Standard for Building Geotechnical Engineering Surveying of Sichuan Province', annex B B.0.1 (section method L preferably 5~20 m)
- TB 10101-2018 'Code for Railway Engineering Surveying', clauses 5.5.1~5.5.5 (spacing, width, survey points and setting-out tolerances of subgrade cross-sections)
- TB 10105-2009 'Code for Surveying of Rebuilt Railways', clauses 5.4.1~5.4.4 (cross-section density no fewer than 3 per 100 m, scales, checking tolerances)
- CJJ/T 8-2011 'Code for Urban Surveying', clause 9.6.8 and its commentary (longitudinal and cross-section surveying, width and direction of cross-sections, reading precision)
Keywords
- 土方计算方法
- 断面法
- 方格网法
- 三角网法
- 断面间距
- 横断面测量
- 断面加密
- 地形突变