Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-11-09

The grid method for earthwork balance sheets - the step formulas, cut-and-fill closure checks, and the terrain contrast with the cross-section method (grid spacing, volume-state conversion, and the source of the economic haul distance)

Three passes complete the sheet: grid at 10~40m (20m preferred), corner natural and design levels with the working height h = design - natural ('+' fill, '-' cut), zero points by interpolation joined into the zero line, cell-by-cell net cut and fill listed apart; convert all to one volume state (fill compacted / 0.87 = about x 1.15 to natural dense) and close on 'cut - fill = spoil - borrow', the in-sheet closure being 0 (rounding residue only); computation by one and checking by another, a difference within 3% of the original submits the original, beyond 3% the cause is traced and recomputation follows; the cross-section method, less precise, suits ribbon ground of stronger relief (off-site roads, rail subgrades, trench runs) with sections at 50m (scheme / preliminary) and 20m (construction drawings).

Applicable Codes

  • RISN-TG014-2012 生活垃圾卫生填埋技术导则 第6.3.3条
  • GB 50869-2013 生活垃圾卫生填埋处理技术规范 附录A.0.1
  • GB 51047-2014 医药工业总图运输设计规范 第5.5.1条
  • GB 50489-2009 化工企业总图运输设计规范 第6.5.2条
  • JGJ/T 408-2017 建筑施工测量标准 第7.2.4条
  • CJJ/T 8-2011 城市测量规范 第9.8.7条
  • CJJ 83-2016 城乡建设用地竖向规划规范 第8.0.2条
  • GB 50842-2013 建材矿山工程施工与验收规范 第5.1.3条
  • GB 50201-2012 土方与爆破工程施工及验收规范 第4.1.3条
  • GB 51004-2015 建筑地基基础工程施工规范 第8.4.1条
  • GB 51276-2018 煤炭企业总图运输设计标准 第6.4.2条
  • JGJ/T 498-2024 施工现场建筑垃圾减量化技术标准 第4.0.2条
  • GB/T 50857-2024 市政工程工程量计算标准 App. A.4.6
  • TB/T 10822-2024 铁路工程预算定额 Vol. 1 路基工程 Ch. 1说明
  • DB63/T 2013-2022 公路养护工程预算定额 App. A.2.1.3、A.2.1.4

Positioning

The full steps and cell formulas of the grid method for earthwork balance sheets in site levelling (landfill basins, plant vertical design, development land), the closure-check bases, the terrain contrast with the cross-section method, and the code sources of grid spacing, volume-state conversion and borrow-spoil haul linkage.

Core conclusions

1. The steps (formulas as they run)

  1. Grid: squares over the vertical design, numbered with corner coordinates. Spacing by use - earthwork 10~40m, finer is more precise, 20m preferred; general-layout vertical design 20~50m - 50m x 50m at scheme, 20m x 20m at preliminary and working drawings; levelling survey 20m x 20m on flat, 10m x 10m on relief. Densify grids or add corners where ground is complex or design breaks.
  2. Natural levels: each corner's surveyed or mapped natural ground level, tied to the grid at equal precision.
  3. Design levels: each corner's vertical-design level.
  4. Working height: h = design - natural; '+' fill by convention, '-' cut.
  5. Zero line (the cut-fill divide): on edges whose corners oppose in sign, interpolate the zero points x1 = a x h1 / (h1 + h2) and x2 = a x h2 / (h1 + h2) (absolute values, a the side); join adjacent zero points.
  6. Cell volumes, cut and fill apart: all-cut or all-fill (prismoid) V = a2 / 4 x (h1 + h2 + h3 + h4); one-corner (triangular pyramid) V = b x c x h / 6 (b, c corner-to-zero-line distances, absolute); two-corner (trapezoidal wedge) V = a (b + c)(h1 + h2) / 8; three-corner per the five-face formulas of the guide's Figure 6-7. Signs: cut negative, fill positive.
  7. Totals: cut = sum of |cut cells|, fill = sum of fill cells - never netted.
  8. State unity: convert fill (compacted / as-built) to natural dense before comparing - 1 m3 natural dense compacts to about 0.87 m3, so fill demand (natural) = design compacted / 0.87 (about x 1.15); exact values from soil tests or the final bulking factor K2. Balancing 'must convert cut and fill to soil in the same state'.
  9. Zonal balancing: out_i = max(0, cut_i - fill_i natural), in_i = max(0, fill_i natural - cut_i), sum out = sum in; zones coordinate site-wide, fill (or cut) taken nearest, and soil reserved for works with buried works.
  10. Surplus and deficit: spoil = max(0, cut - fill natural), borrow = max(0, fill natural - cut); positive hauls surplus out, negative brings borrow in.
  11. Haul and disposal conversion: spoil to loose for truck and tipping counts, loose = natural x 1.30; total waste V_e = lambda-c x V_c - lambda-f x V_f - earth 1.30, rock 1.54, sand-gravel 1.07; loose fill earth 1.20, rock 1.18, sand-gravel 1.14; compacted fill interpolated at 0.90~0.98 compaction to 1.45~1.58.
  12. Closure check: below.

2. Closure formulas and tolerances

  • The in-sheet identity: delta = cut - fill (natural dense) - spoil + borrow = 0 - a change of basis; a correct sheet closes at 0, rounding residue only (two decimals of m3), no directional gap allowed.
  • Computation check: one computes, another checks; a difference within 3% of the original submits the original, beyond 3% the cause is traced and the work redone. A second method (grid against cross-section) is the preferred cross-check.
  • Planning balance ratios (scheme quality, not sheet tolerance): (cut-fill difference / total earthwork) x 100% - plains 5%~10%, low-to-mid hills 7%~15%, deep hills and mountains 10%~20%; per-hectare norms plains under 10,000 m3, hills 20,000~30,000, deep hills 30,000~50,000 m3.
  • Large cut-fill gaps adjust the design level: cut over fill raises it, fill over cut lowers it.

3. Grid versus cross-section terrain

Method Terrain Precision Spacing Objects
Grid gentle relief, wide benches higher 10~40m (20m preferred); layout 20~50m (scheme 50m, detailed 20m); survey flat 20m, relief 10m site levelling, basins, plant verticals
Cross-section stronger relief, complex ground below grid scheme / preliminary 50m, working drawings 20m off-site roads, rail subgrades, large buried pipe runs
Triangulated grid squares split to triangles on the contours as grid with the grid irregular ground

Choose by relief, area and map precision, check by the other method, finer grids read more precisely. Landfill capacity: base and cap levels on the grid corners, prismoids summed, 10~40m sides, grid-based software acceptable.

4. Borrow-spoil volumes and haul

  • Balance 'near and reasonable', by construction sequence and neighbouring borrow / spoil conditions; balance within the block or estate, haul 250~400m preferred.
  • Economic haul rules of thumb: hand 200m, powered 1000m.
  • Haul basis: shortest distance between the cut centroid and the fill (or stockpile) centroid.
  • Quota caps checked: railway subgrade truck haul serves 10km and under, the excess x 0.85 (loader haul 20m); highway maintenance trucks 15km average, beyond as public carriage, sub-unit remainders under half ignored, half and over counted whole.
  • Quantity bases: cut in natural dense, fill in compacted, blasted rock in natural dense; compacted quantities on natural-dense items convert by the loose-dense factor, borrow adding 0.03 wastage.
  • Existing or imported burying soil offsets fill: cut (loose) = required fill + exported spoil - existing or imported bury; initial bulking K1 = cut / original, final K2 = cut / fill, both over 1 with K1 > K2, the compaction factor derivable from them.

5. Common earthwork-chapter bases (for citation)

  • Transport in natural dense: total cut less backfill (as natural dense), positive hauling surplus out, negative bringing in; haul centroid-to-centroid shortest.
  • Backfill by volume: trench and pit backfill = cut volume - embedded parts below outdoor level (bedding, foundations); pipe trench deducts pipe and base, none under DN500; room backfill = net area x depth; site (above basement slabs) = area x average depth.
  • Site levelling by building perimeter plus 2m each side, m2.
  • Surplus disposal = cut items less reused backfill (positive); trench, pit and general items carry on-site haul only - off-site under the surplus-disposal code.

Applicable boundaries

  • The grid serves gentle, wide-benched sites; ribbon ground of strong relief (roads, rail subgrades, trench runs) takes the cross-section method - the two differ in precision and share no tolerance.
  • The formulas and spacings come from landfill and general-layout codes; other sectors (railway, highway, water) carry their own volumes and factors - follow the project's current standards.
  • Sheet bases are not list bases: BOQ cut and backfill run on drawn dimensions, generally without state conversion; bulking and compaction factors serve balance, truck and tipping counts - never the BOQ quantities.
  • 3% is the two-person check tolerance of one method and software, not an allowed balance gap; the 5%~20% balance ratios are planning-stage quality indices - neither interchangeable.
  • Conversion factors (0.87, 1.30, 1.45~1.58) follow site tests and the local quota - estimates at scheme stage, corrected by measured compaction in construction.

Further reading

  • Grid formulas, zero points, the four cell volumes, bulking and compaction, the balance equation: RISN-TG014-2012 clause 6.3.3 (Table 6-8, Figures 6-2~6-8).
  • Grid capacity: GB 50869-2013 Appendix A.0.1.
  • Method and spacing by stage: GB 51047-2014 clause 5.5.1; GB 50489-2009 clause 6.5.2; survey grids: JGJ/T 408-2017 clause 7.2.4.
  • Two-person check and 3%: CJJ/T 8-2011 clause 9.8.7; near-balancing, ratios and economic haul: CJJ 83-2016 clause 8.0.2.
  • Balancing principles: GB 50842-2013 clause 5.1.3; GB 50201-2012 clause 4.1.3; GB 51004-2015 clause 8.4.1; balance entries: GB 51276-2018 clause 6.4.2.
  • Waste conversion: JGJ/T 498-2024 clause 4.0.2 with Table 2; disposal and backfill rules: GB/T 50857-2024 Appendix A.4.6 and the local earthwork chapters; rail and road haul caps: TB/T 10822-2024 Vol.1 ch.1; DB63/T 2013-2022 Appendix A.

Keywords

  • 方格网法
  • 土方平衡表
  • 挖填平衡
  • 闭合校核
  • 零线
  • 断面法
  • 松散系数
  • 经济运距