Applicable conditions and type selection for fixed-rhythm, varying-rhythm (unequal-step varying-rhythm / multiple-beat) and non-rhythmic flow construction: a four-axis comparison across beat pattern, specialist crew configuration capacity, applicable works conditions and duration effect, plus hard selection constraints such as m no less than n and not adding crews where avoidable
The type is not chosen by the name of the works but by a three-step test: (1) are the beats of the same construction process equal on every section - if not all equal, non-rhythmic; (2) are the beats equal between processes - if all equal, fixed-rhythm flow, K = t, T = (m+n-1)t; (3) are the beats between processes integer multiples of one another - if yes, a multiple-beat flow can be organised, K0 = greatest common divisor of the beats and n' = sum of bi. Beats constant within a process but unequal between processes is varying-rhythm; with no crews added it uses the same staggered-subtraction largest-difference method as genuinely non-rhythmic flow, T = sum K + sum of the last process's beats over all sections + sum Z - sum C. On works conditions: fixed-rhythm suits divisional works with balanced labour content between sections and strong standardised repetition; multiple-beat suits batch-type works whose beats are true integer multiples, with many sections, ample working faces and permission to add crews; non-rhythmic suits works with quantities unevenly distributed across sections, large cross-section or structural changes, or constraints of site, traffic, season or surrounding rock that prevent even sectioning (municipal road sections, tunnel reaches with changing rock, high and low piers, etc.). m no less than n is the precondition, and multiple-beat flow trades resources for duration - it is not an optimised solution.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50502-2009 · Code for Construction Organization Planning of Building Works 第5.2.2条、第6.2.2条
- GB/T 50903-2013 · Code for Construction Organization Planning of Municipal Works 第4.2.4条、第4.5.2条
- JGJ/T 121-2015 · Specification for Engineering Network Planning Technology
Topic positioning
The three flow construction organisation modes - fixed-rhythm (equal-beat), varying-rhythm (covering unequal-step varying-rhythm and equal-step / multiple-beat) and non-rhythmic - suit different works conditions. This card gives the method, order and hard constraints for type selection along four axes: beat pattern / specialist crew configuration capacity / applicable works conditions / duration effect.
Core conclusions
1. Test order (three elimination steps: look at beats first, crews second)
- Are the beats of the same construction process on every construction section all equal? If not all equal -> non-rhythmic flow (K can only be found by staggered subtraction taking the largest difference).
- If all equal -> are the beats equal between processes? If all equal -> fixed-rhythm (equal-beat) flow, K = t.
- If not equal -> are the beats between processes integer multiples of one another? If yes, and the working faces can be subdivided and crews may be added -> multiple-beat flow (K0 = greatest common divisor of the beats, n' = sum of bi); if no, or adding crews is impractical -> unequal-step varying-rhythm flow (same staggered-subtraction largest-difference algorithm as genuinely non-rhythmic flow).
2. Applicability table for the three types (four axes)
| Type | (1) Beat pattern | (2) Specialist crew capability required | (3) Applicable works conditions | (4) Duration effect |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed-rhythm (equal-beat) | Beats of all processes on all sections equal, t(i,j) = t = constant, flow step distance K = t | One specialist crew per process works continuously; no added crews and no raised resource peak; precondition m no less than n, otherwise crews inevitably stand idle | Balanced quantities (labour content) between sections, highly standardised structure, processes of similar mechanisation and output magnitude: standard-floor residential main structures, rows of identical foundations and piers, standardised plant buildings, standard reaches of utility tunnels and tunnels, masonry and pavement - divisional works with strong repetition | T = (m+n-1)t + sum Z - sum C; shortest of the three and best predictability; most sensitive to imbalance between sections - a quantity deviation in one section breaks the rhythm, requiring re-sectioning or crew adjustment |
| Varying-rhythm (unequal-step) | Beats of the same process constant across sections, unequal between processes (e.g. 2/3/4 days) and not integer multiples | Still one crew per process; K fixed by staggered subtraction taking the largest difference; every crew continuous, later crews do not disturb earlier ones, no crews added | Marked differences in output or mechanisation between processes (earthwork, rebar, formwork and concrete of different magnitudes), but the sections themselves are regular and working faces should not be split at will | T = sum K + sum of the last process's beats + sum Z - sum C. Worked example m = 4, n = 3, beats 2/3/4 days -> K(A,B) = 2, K(B,C) = 3, sum K = 5, T = 5 + 16 = 21 days |
| Varying-rhythm (equal-step / multiple-beat) | Same precondition, but the beats are integer multiples of one another; K0 = greatest common divisor of the beats | Crews must be added: bi = ti/K0, total crews n' = sum bi > n; requires subdividable working faces and an allowed higher resource peak | Batch-type works whose beats are true multiples of K0, with large quantities, many sections and ample working faces (many standard floors; several crews can be inserted in parallel) | Same example with crews added: K0 = gcd(2,3,4) = 1, bi = 2/3/4, n' = 9, T = (4+9-1) x 1 = 12 days, 9 days saved against 21, at the cost of crews rising from 3 to 9 and a much higher resource peak |
| Non-rhythmic | Beats of the same process not all equal across sections (quantities or output differ between sections); the number sequence has no pattern | One crew per process; K found by cumulative-sequence staggered subtraction taking the largest difference; beats have no common multiple, so adding crews has no solution - only re-sectioning, changing the method or adding resources | Quantities unevenly distributed across sections, large cross-section or structural changes, or sectioning that cannot be balanced because of site, traffic, season or surrounding rock constraints: municipal road sections, tunnel reaches with changing rock, high and low piers, alteration and interleaved works | T = sum K + sum of the last process's beats + sum Z - sum C; K uniquely fixed by the sequences; duration runs long and is highly sensitive to the sectioning scheme (change the sections and the duration changes); no compressible slack of its own |
3. Hard constraints on selection
- m no less than n is a precondition, not a conclusion: with fewer sections than processes, every type necessarily idles crews; the only fixes are splitting sections or merging processes.
- Prefer fixed-rhythm over varying-rhythm; prefer unequal-step over blindly adding crews: multiple-beat flow is a 'trade resources for duration' scheme, not an optimised solution; with K0 down to 1 it holds in form only, and the working faces often will not allow it - so before quoting a duration, the position on 'whether crews are added' must be settled.
- Two frequent mis-calculations: n processes have only n-1 pairs of step distances; and the end term added is the sum of the last process's beats over all sections - not the last K, nor the single beat of the last section.
Applicability boundaries
This card is selection and judgement knowledge at the level of construction organisation principles: the codes give only principled requirements and do not prescribe organisation types. GB/T 50502-2009 'Code for project execution plans of building works', clause 5.2.2: 'Construction flow sections shall be divided reasonably according to the characteristics and quantities of the works; the basis of division and the direction of flow shall be stated, and balanced flow construction shall be ensured', and 'the construction arrangement shall make overall arrangements for the main divisional (sub-divisional) works and the dedicated works of this building works, and shall state the milestone nodes of the construction process'; clause 6.2.2 of the same code: 'The construction sequence and the construction flow sections shall be fixed in the construction arrangement.' GB/T 50903-2013 'Code for project execution plans of municipal works', clause 4.2.4: 'The overall construction arrangement shall, according to the characteristics of the works, fix the construction sequence and spatial organisation and arrange the interfacing of construction operations overall', and shall 'on the premise of ensuring the duration, achieve continuity and balance of construction in the overall sense'; clause 4.5.2: 'combine the characteristics of the works, current national standards, the drawings and the available resources to fix the starting point, direction and sequence of construction.' Hence the 'applicable conditions' of the three flow types are technical-economic judgements under the principles of balanced flow and process logic, not mandatory code provisions, and must not be cited as clause-based requirements in approvals. Preconditions: every specialist crew works continuously and no finer working face is divided within a section; flow beats have been determined from quota norms or measured output; multiple-beat flow requires every beat to be an integer multiple of K0 and working faces that can be subdivided. Not applicable: rough planning before the beats have been measured; where float and critical-path analysis, resource levelling or duration compression is needed, network planning should be used for checking; where cost or peak-resource comparison is needed, separate quantitative analysis is required - this card gives only suitability judgement and the direction of duration effects.
Further reading
For the basis of flow section division, flow direction and balanced-flow requirements see GB/T 50502-2009 'Code for project execution plans of building works', clause 5.2.2 (progress arrangement and spatial organisation within the construction arrangement, including the division of the construction stages of a building works into the foundation, main structure, and decoration and building-services installation stages), and clause 6.2.2 (construction sequence and flow sections fixed in the construction arrangement). For the continuity, balance and spatial organisation requirements of municipal works see GB/T 50903-2013 'Code for project execution plans of municipal works', clause 4.2.4; construction starting point, direction, sequence and process flow in clause 4.5.2 of the same code. For network planning verification see JGJ/T 121-2015 'Specification for engineering network planning technique'. The principles of flow construction (organisation conditions and duration calculation of the fixed-rhythm, multiple-beat and non-rhythmic types) are covered in the 'flow construction principles' chapter of project execution plan and construction progress control textbooks.
Keywords
- 流水施工
- 等节奏流水
- 异节奏流水
- 成倍节拍流水
- 非节奏流水
- 流水施工适用条件
- 流水步距
- 流水工期