Deducting construction water and electricity at settlement and the un-metered dispute: contract first, metered use at actual prices, the claimant bears the proof for tender-quantity deduction, local rate fallbacks
Utilities are not a single line in the contract price - they ride inside materials, machine-shift rates and temporary-facility preliminaries, so the deduction basis must mirror the pricing basis. Order: (1) contract or tender documents govern; (2) with meterable water and power meters, deduct metered use at actual prices (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.5.8); (3) where the contractor seeks deduction on tender (quota) contents, it bears the burden of proof and the amount must be reasonably fixed; (4) failing meters and agreement, local cost-quota fallback ratios apply (Shaanxi's rules clause 8.6: 0.6% of the works cost, power 0.45% within) - never transplanted across regions. "Deduct by quota content" is no automatic default: the claimant proves.
Applicable Codes
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023 建设工程造价鉴定作业指引 第4.5.8条
- T/ZBD 100.5-2023 建设工程结算审核作业指引 第2.1.8条
- GB/T 51262-2017 建设工程造价鉴定规范 第5.5.2条
- GB/T 50857-2024 市政工程工程量计算标准 App. M.2.3
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第3.2.6条
- TB 10801-2024 铁路基本建设工程设计概(预)算编制办法 第3.2.6条、TB 10811
- DB11/T 638-2016 房屋修缮工程工程量计算规范 App. C.11(code 931101)
- 陕西省建设工程费用规则 第8.6条 水电费
Topic Positioning
How construction water and electricity are deducted, and how much, at final account and cost assessment - above all where the site has no meters (or none meterable): may the deduction run on quota contents / tender consumption, and who proves.
Core Conclusions
1. Characterisation first: utilities are not a single line - what is deducted is the part "already priced in, actually paid by the employer"
- GB/T 50857-2024 (municipal measurement standard), Annex M.2.3, original: "absent special contract agreement, water and power in the divisional works are included in the corresponding materials and plant; temporary site water and power are included in the temporary-facility preliminaries. The contractor shall provide subcontracts with water and power take-off points."
- GB/T 50500-2024 clause 3.2.6 item 1: preliminaries pricing covers "temporary facilities on and near the site, temporary water, temporary power, ventilation and like charges".
- TB 10801-2024 (railway estimate measures) clause 3.2.6: "material budget prices and works water and power unit prices follow TB 10811." -> Utilities ride inside materials, machine-shift rates and preliminaries. The employer's deduction is sound because the contractor priced the cost yet the employer paid it; the deduction basis must mirror the pricing basis - else "more is deducted than the price ever contained".
2. Order of preference
- Contract / tender agreement governs (by quota content, by ratio, by meter - anything agreed); all standards premise "absent special agreement".
- With meterable meters, deduct metered use at actual prices. T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.5.8, original: "on utility disputes - sites generally carry meterable water and power meters; where the tender priced the utilities, deduct by metered volume and actual price. Where the contractor seeks deduction on its tender consumption, it bears the burden of proof, and the amount shall be reasonably fixed."
- This clause settles the "un-metered, deduct by quota content" dispute: tender-content deduction is no automatic default - the claimant (contractor) proves and the amount is "reasonably fixed". An employer unilaterally imposing a quota figure meets the defence exactly on the burden of proof.
- Failing meters and agreement, local cost-quota fallback ratios may apply. Shaanxi's Cost Rules clause 8.6 "utilities": "the contractor entering site shall set separate meters; utility charges (living included) settle per contract. Subcontractors using the main contractor's water and power pay by meter or negotiation. Where metering is impossible, 0.6% of the works cost may be used (power 0.45% within, ...)." A provincial rule - never transplanted.
3. Procedural companions
- GB/T 51262-2017 clause 5.5.2: on objection to a jointly certified measurement - "1 objection without specific evidence: assess on the original result; 2 objection with specific evidence: re-check the original, on site if necessary, and assess on the re-checked result."
- T/ZBD 100.5-2023 clause 2.1.8 item 5: for "utilities, labour and government charges withheld on behalf", collect both parties' payment proofs and details.
- DB11/T 638-2016 Annex C.11 "works utilities" (931101), table note: "where the employer supplies water and power, this charge is not taken" - the no-list, no-double rule where the employer supplies.
4. Why "deduct by quota content" always disputes (the technical root) Most quotas list no standalone "water" or "power" material items - utilities ride inside concrete mixing and curing materials and welder, pump and hoist machine-shifts. "Deduct by content" must first fix which items, which edition, whether plant power is drawn - change the scope, change the number; each side runs its own arithmetic, hence the dispute. The quotas assume "water and power on site" (local notes commonly read "the quota assumes water and power on site; absent, charge separately").
Applicability Boundaries
- For employer-paid, contractor-used construction and living utilities at settlement / assessment; not for employer-supplied materials, government charges and other withholdings (own rules).
- Contract agreement always first; clause 4.5.8 serves absent, unclear or disputed agreement.
- "Metered x actual price" presupposes meters in place with readings and payment vouchers.
- Fallback ratios like Shaanxi's 0.6% (power 0.45%) are provincial - never cross-region; with no local clause, return to contract and the local current cost rules.
- Certified results bind: objection without evidence cannot overturn them (GB/T 51262-2017 clause 5.5.2).
Further Reading
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023, clause 4.5.8 (deduction and burden of proof).
- T/ZBD 100.5-2023, clause 2.1.8 item 5 (withheld-charge payment proofs).
- GB/T 51262-2017, clause 5.5.2 (objections to certified measurements).
- GB/T 50857-2024, Annex M.2.3 (utility attribution; take-off-point duty).
- GB/T 50500-2024, clause 3.2.6 (preliminaries content).
- TB 10801-2024, clause 3.2.6, with TB 10811 (works water and power prices).
- DB11/T 638-2016, Annex C.11 (931101).
- Local bases: current provincial cost quotas / rules (e.g. Shaanxi clause 8.6).
Keywords
- 施工水电费
- 水电费扣除
- 未挂表
- 定额含量扣除
- 投标报价消耗量
- 举证责任
- 代缴费用
- 临时用水用电