Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-29

Five elements of substantive review and the assessment boundaries of critical path analysis opinions in delay assessment (validity of the baseline programme, the critical path identification algorithm, placement of delay events, the dynamic network as at each event, and no overstepping into findings of liability)

A critical path analysis opinion can and must be reviewed substantively: it resolves only 'time impact', not 'attribution of liability'. Review proceeds on five elements: (1) the baseline programme must be the construction programme approved by the employer or the supervising engineer (GB/T 51262-2017, Art. 5.7.5; a path back-calculated from the as-built network has no baseline effect); (2) identification of the critical path must follow 'activities with the least total float are critical activities; a path composed throughout of critical activities, or the path with the longest sum of durations, is the critical path' (JGJ/T 121-2015, Art. 4.5.1), and in time-scaled networks the test is 'a path from start node to end node on which no wavy line appears' (Art. 4.5.2); (3) delay events must be placed in the three bands of GB/T 50500-2024, Art. 8.11.8 (activity on the critical path: the delay time is the extension of time claimed; non-critical activity whose delay exceeds its total float and turns critical: the difference between the delay time and the total float; still non-critical: no extension-of-time claim arises); (4) the test uses the progress state at the time of each event, with every event assessed independently (Art. 8.11.7); (5) the expert may not determine the attribution of liability for delay (GB/T 51262-2017, Art. 5.7.6, power of suggestion only; Fa [2020] No. 202, Art. 1, item (6): 'determination of the division of responsibility between the parties' will not be commissioned). Disposition falls into four grades: admit / admit after rectification / supplementary assessment / re-assessment.

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 51262-2017 · Code for Construction Cost Appraisal 第5.7.5条、第5.7.6条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第8.11.7条、第8.11.8条
  • JGJ/T 121-2015 · Specification for Engineering Network Planning Technology 第2.1.35条、第4.5.1条、第4.5.2条
  • 法〔2020〕202号《最高人民法院关于人民法院民事诉讼中委托鉴定审查工作若干问题的规定》第1条、第3~5条、第11条
  • 法释〔2019〕19号《最高人民法院关于民事诉讼证据的若干规定》第40条、第41条
  • 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第81条、第82条
  • 《中华人民共和国仲裁法》(2025修订)第56条、第57条
  • 法释〔2020〕25号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第8条、第9条、第10条
  • https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zc_flfg.htm

Topic scope

This card addresses how to substantively review a 'critical path analysis opinion' issued by an expert (including by a construction cost expert assessment institution) in a construction delay dispute: what to review, on which provisions, whether the identification algorithm is right, whether the events were correctly placed, and whether the expert overstepped into findings of liability. It is for judges, arbitrators, counsel, cost and delay experts, and the technical leads of both parties.

Core conclusions

Conclusion first: a critical path analysis opinion is technical evidence that can be challenged and re-computed, and must be reviewed substantively; it must not be admitted merely because it is a 'technical conclusion'. The core reason: critical path analysis answers only 'time impact', not 'attribution of liability'. The former can be independently re-computed from the approved construction programme plus network algorithms; the latter is by law not a matter for expert assessment. The disposition falls into four grades: admit / admit after rectification / supplementary assessment / re-assessment.

Element 1: whether the baseline programme stands (threshold)

GB/T 51262-2017, Art. 5.7.5: 'Where the parties dispute an extension of time for the assessed project due to design changes, the expert shall refer to the construction programme and determine whether the change in the period was caused by an increase in the quantities of works on the critical path or of critical activities; if the period increased, the time shall be extended accordingly; if the period did not increase, no extension shall be given.'

Review points: lock onto 'the construction programme approved by the employer or the supervising engineer', and check its date of preparation (before commencement), version number, logic links, durations, calendar, resources and milestones; a 'critical path' back-calculated after the event from the as-built network, bar charts or settlement records has no baseline effect.

Element 2: whether the critical path identification method is correct (algorithmic)

JGJ/T 121-2015, Art. 2.1.35 [terminology]: 'critical path: in a double-notation (activity-on-arrow) network, a path composed of critical activities or the path with the longest total duration; in a single-notation (activity-on-node) network, a path composed of critical activities with zero intervals between them, or the path with the longest total duration.'

Art. 4.5.1: '1 The activities with the least total float shall be critical activities. 2 A path composed throughout of critical activities, or a path on which the sum of the activity durations is the longest, shall be the critical path, and it should be marked in thick, double or coloured lines. 3 Where there is no need to compute the time parameters of every activity and only the computed duration or the critical path of the network is to be determined, the node labelling method may be used.' (Node labelling method: the start node carries a label value of zero, every other node b_j = ET_j = max{ET_i + D_i-j}, the label value of the end node is the computed duration T_c, and tracing back from the end node to the start node by source nodes yields the critical path.)

Art. 4.5.2: 'In a double-notation time-scaled network, a path from the start node to the end node on which no wavy line appears shall be determined to be the critical path. The activities on the critical path are critical activities.'

Review points: require submission of the time-parameter computation sheets and the P6/Project source files, and independently re-compute the total float; for single-notation networks also verify that the intervals between adjacent critical activities are zero; without this the identification conclusion does not stand.

Element 3: whether delay events are placed on critical activities (causation)

GB/T 50500-2024, Art. 8.11.8: 'When a delay event occurs, it may be determined, on the basis of the approved construction programme, whether the event falls on the critical path and whether it causes delay to the critical path; the parties shall compute the extension of time claimed in accordance with the following: 1 Where the delayed event is an activity on the critical path, the delayed time is the extension of time claimed; 2 Where the delayed event is an activity not on the critical path but becomes an activity on the critical path because the delay exceeds its total float, the difference between the delay time and the total float is the extension of time claimed; 3 Where, after the delay, the event remains an activity not on the critical path, no claim for extension of time arises.'

Companion test (GB/T 51262-2017, Art. 5.7.5): 'An increase in quantities caused by a design change does not necessarily lead to an increase in the period. If the increased quantities are not on critical activities, parallel and cross construction may be organised, and additional workers and construction plant may be deployed as organisational measures; the contractor may claim an increase in the cost of the works but should not claim an extension of the period.'

Element 4: whether the judgment uses the dynamic network as at each event (time-point)

GB/T 50500-2024, Art. 8.11.7: 'When computing the delay (or extension) of the period and the claim costs arising from it under the relevant provisions of this section of this standard, the activities corresponding to the claimed extension of time shall be activities on the critical path, or activities whose critical path is changed by the claim event, and the extension of time approved by the employer to the contractor under the contract shall be the extension of the contract period. The employer shall independently assess each claim event in respect of all the contractor's claims for costs of delay (or extension), and shall not include claims for the costs of the corresponding delay (or extension) caused to the works carried out later by delay (or extension) occurring earlier.'

Review points: the critical path shifts as progress advances; the test must use the progress state at the time of the event (window analysis / time impact analysis), not a back-calculation of history from the final actual network; each event is accounted for independently, with concurrent and simultaneous delays listed separately, and responsibility proportions determined by the commissioning party, not by the expert.

Element 5: whether the expert overstepped into findings of liability (boundary)

GB/T 51262-2017, Art. 5.7.6: 'Where the parties dispute a claim for delay on the assessed project, the expert shall first determine the actual period under Articles 5.7.1-5.7.5 of this code, then compare it with the contract period, and thereby determine whether delay occurred and its exact length. On the attribution of liability for the delay, the expert may offer suggestions from the angle of professional discernment and judgment; the final determination is made by the commissioning party on the basis of the parties' evidence.'

Fa [2020] No. 202, Article 1, lists the matters for which the people's courts will not commission an assessment; its item (6) is 'determination of the division of responsibility between the parties'; the same article also excludes 'facts that can be presumed from common knowledge and rules of experience', 'non-specialised questions to be proved by the parties', and 'questions of application of law'. Therefore, where phrasings of the type 'the contractor shall bear xx% of responsibility' appear in an opinion, that part must be struck out; the correct form for the expert is to give opinions on the number of days of delay and the time impact of each event and to offer professional suggestions, leaving attribution of liability to the adjudicator on the evidence.

Disposition and remedies on review (defect findings)

Fa [2020] No. 202, Article 11: 'Where an expert opinion report falls under any of the following circumstances, it is deemed not to have completed the commissioned assessment, and the people's court shall require the expert to supplement the assessment or re-do it: (1) the expert opinion and the other parts of the report contradict each other; (2) the same finding uses uncertain phrasing; (3) the report has other obvious defects. Where the assessment still cannot complete the commissioned matter after supplementation or re-doing, the people's court shall order the expert to return the assessment fees already received.'

Fa Shi [2019] No. 19, Article 40: 'Where a party applies for a re-assessment and any of the following circumstances exists, the people's court shall permit it: (1) the expert lacks the corresponding qualification; (2) the assessment procedure is seriously unlawful; (3) the expert opinion rests on an obviously insufficient basis; (4) other circumstances in which the expert opinion cannot be used as evidence. Where items (1) to (3) exist, the assessment fees already received by the expert shall be refunded... Defects of the expert opinion that can be resolved by rectification, supplementary assessment, supplementary or renewed cross-examination shall not lead to permission of a re-assessment. Where a re-assessment is made, the original expert opinion shall not serve as the basis for finding the facts of the case.'

Procedural accompaniments: Civil Procedure Law (2023 revision), Article 81: 'Where a party objects to the expert opinion or the people's court considers it necessary for the expert to appear in court, the expert shall testify in court. Where the expert, notified by the people's court, refuses to appear and testify, the expert opinion shall not serve as the basis for finding facts, and the party that paid the assessment fees may demand their return'; Article 82: a party may apply to have notified a person with specialised knowledge appear in court and give opinions on the expert opinion or on specialised questions. In arbitration the counterparts are Articles 56 and 57 of the Arbitration Law (2025 revision) (a party may apply for an assessment; the expert, notified by the tribunal, shall attend the hearing, and the parties may, with permission, put questions to the expert; evidence shall be produced at the hearing and may be cross-examined by the parties).

Companion rules at the stage of determining the actual period

Review of delay starts from 'actual period versus contract period' (GB/T 51262-2017, Art. 5.7.6); where the commencement or completion dates are disputed they are determined under Fa Shi [2020] No. 25: Article 8: the commencement date is the date stated in the commencement notice issued by the employer or the supervising engineer; where conditions for commencement are not yet ready after the notice is issued, the date the conditions became ready governs; where commencement was delayed for reasons attributable to the contractor, the date stated in the notice still governs; where the contractor has actually entered site and commenced with the employer's consent, the actual entry date governs; where there is no commencement notice and no evidence, the date is determined by weighing the dates stated in the commencement report, the contract, the construction permit, the taking-over report or the taking-over filing form together with the readiness of commencement conditions. Article 9: where taking-over is passed, the date of passing is the completion date; where the contractor has submitted a taking-over report and the employer delays the taking-over, the submission date is the completion date; where the employer uses the works prematurely without taking-over, the date of transfer of possession is the completion date. Article 10: an agreed extension must be confirmed by site record of the employer or the supervising engineer; where the contractor failed to obtain the confirmation but can prove that it applied for the extension within the period agreed in the contract and the ground for extension qualifies under the contract, its extension claim shall be supported; where the contract provides that failure to apply within the period means no extension, that provision governs, except where the employer agrees to the extension after the period or the contractor raises a justified defence.

Boundaries of application

  • This framework applies to the substantive review of delay assessment opinions in litigation and arbitration (including delay or critical path analyses issued by construction cost expert assessment institutions), and equally to review of opinions by the parties and their representatives themselves.
  • Critical path analysis answers only 'whether the total period is affected and by how many days', not 'whose responsibility and in what proportion'; apportionment of concurrent delay, acceleration costs and delay damages or penalties are handled separately under the contract and the applicable law.
  • A design change does not necessarily extend the time: only an increase of quantities on the critical path and its critical activities that actually changes the period extends it; the cost claim for increased quantities and the extension-of-time claim are two independent paths.
  • There is at present no dedicated national standard for delay matters; GB/T 51262-2017 is a 'delay chapter inside the construction cost expert assessment code' and must not be treated as a specialised delay code; the review must also check whether the technical standards relied on in the assessment actually apply to delay (and not merely cost) matters; where a standard expressly excludes delay assessment, the method basis is misplaced and may serve as a ground of 'obviously insufficient basis' for the expert opinion.
  • Factual and documentary premises: assessment materials may be used only after cross-examination before the court; materials disputed by the parties are to be determined by the people's court and may not be handed directly to the assessment institution or the expert for selection (Fa [2020] No. 202, Articles 3-5). Where the authenticity of the baseline programme itself is in doubt, the determination of materials must be settled before any talk of the critical path.

Further reading

  • Chain of rules on extension of time and delay assessment: GB/T 51262-2017, Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment, Arts. 5.7.1-5.7.6 (Art. 5.7.5 extension of time for design changes; Art. 5.7.6 delay claims and determination of the actual period).
  • Rules for computing claimed extensions of time: GB/T 50500-2024, national pricing standard for bills of quantities, Art. 8.11.7 (independent assessment per event), Art. 8.11.8 (three-band placement on the critical path).
  • Algorithms for identifying critical activities and the critical path: JGJ/T 121-2015, Specification for Engineering Network Planning Techniques, Art. 2.1.35 (terminology), Art. 4.5.1 (total-float method, longest-path method, node labelling method), Art. 4.5.2 (wavy-line test in time-scaled networks), and Arts. 4.3.1-4.3.2 on time parameters and the computation of earliest node times.
  • Admissibility of assessment matters and review of opinions: Fa [2020] No. 202, Provisions of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Review of Commissioned Appraisal Work in Civil Procedures of the People's Courts, Article 1 (nine circumstances in which assessment will not be commissioned), Articles 3-5 (review of assessment materials), Articles 10-11 (review of expert reports and defect circumstances for supplementary or re-assessment).
  • Re-assessment and cross-examination remedies: Fa Shi [2019] No. 19, Several Provisions of the Supreme People's Court on Evidence in Civil Procedures, Article 40 (four circumstances in which re-assessment must be permitted), Article 41 (treatment of unilaterally commissioned opinions).
  • Appearance in court and cross-examination: Civil Procedure Law (2023 revision) Articles 81-82; Arbitration Law (2025 revision) Articles 56-57.
  • Judicial determination of commencement and completion dates and extensions of time: Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Interpretation (I) on construction contract disputes, Articles 8, 9 and 10.
  • Entry point for verifying original texts (State Council policy and regulation databases): https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zc_flfg.htm

Keywords

  • critical path
  • 关键工作
  • 工期鉴定
  • 工期延误索赔
  • total float
  • 鉴定意见审查
  • 不予委托鉴定
  • 补充鉴定与重新鉴定