Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-09-25

Comparing suppliers' quotes by true comprehensive cost (unified basis, whole-life cost, non-price scoring, compliance red lines)

Price comparison must not just pick the lowest quote: ① convert quotes to a unified basis — the tax-inclusive delivered comprehensive price (correcting delivery point, tax rate, payment terms' capital cost, measurement lot sizes); ② count the whole-life comprehensive cost (purchase price + inspection + warehousing + wastage + quality risk + delivery delay + after-sales); ③ weight-score non-price factors (the five elements of GB/T 50430-2017, Clause 8.2.2: qualifications and reputation, technical performance, supply capacity, price, after-sales); ④ observe the tendering compliance red lines (goods with uniform standards shall use the lowest evaluated price method; comprehensive scoring weights must map to quantified indicators; the lowest evaluated bid price method excludes bids below enterprise cost).

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 50430-2017 工程建设施工企业质量管理规范
  • GB/T 50326-2017 建设工程项目管理规范
  • T/SCIA 002-2020 建设工程全过程质量控制管理规程
  • 政府采购法实施条例(国务院令第658号)
  • 住建部令第43号 房屋建筑和市政基础设施工程施工招标投标管理办法

Topic Positioning

Comparing different suppliers' quotes by true comprehensive cost — upgrading "pick whoever quotes lowest" into a four-step framework of "unified basis + whole-life accounting + quantified non-price factors + compliance red lines" — for material, component, and equipment procurement price comparison and tender evaluation by construction enterprises.

Core Conclusions

① Unified basis: quotes must be converted to the same benchmark — the tax-inclusive delivered comprehensive price — correcting delivery point (ex-works / delivered / to-site), invoice tax rate, payment terms (credit converted to capital cost), measurement units, and order lot sizes. ② Whole-life accounting: comprehensive cost = purchase price + incoming inspection + warehousing + construction wastage differences + quality risk (returns, re-inspection, schedule loss) + delivery delay + after-sales spares and maintenance; looking at unit price alone, the price edge is often eaten by wastage and delay. ③ Quantified non-price factors: per GB/T 50430-2017, Clause 8.2.2, evaluate suppliers on qualifications and reputation, technical performance related to quality/safety/energy saving/environmental protection, supply capacity, product price, and after-sales service; a weighted scorecard may convert these into a composite score; suppliers shall be re-evaluated when their service changes. ④ Compliance red lines: goods with unified technical and service standards shall use the lowest evaluated price method; in the comprehensive scoring method, score weights must correspond to the quantified indicators of the evaluation factors, and standards not set in the tender documents may not serve as evaluation bases; the lowest evaluated bid price method shall exclude bids below enterprise cost; comparison awards may not earn extra points.

Applicable Boundaries

Applies to procurement price comparison and tender evaluation by construction enterprises/project departments. Not applicable to rental selection (different basis); abnormal low-price determination must combine enterprise cost estimation, not quotes alone; score weights have no unified statutory standard and are set by enterprise systems; government-invested projects must also follow local government procurement procedures.

Further Reading

Supplier evaluation elements: GB/T 50430-2017, Code for Quality Management of Construction Enterprises, Clause 8.2.2; procurement plans: Clause 8.2.1 of the same code and GB/T 50326-2017, Code for Construction Project Management, Clause 6.2.1 (including supplier qualification review); supplier selection principles: T/SCIA 002-2020, Rules for Whole-Process Quality Control Management of Construction Works, Clause 7.3.1; evaluation methods: Implementation Regulation of the Government Procurement Law, Article 34, and MOHURD Order No. 43, Measures for the Administration of Tendering and Bidding of Housing and Municipal Infrastructure Works, Article 40.

Keywords

  • 供应商比价
  • 综合成本
  • 供应方评价
  • 合格供应商
  • 最低评标价法
  • 综合评分法
  • 全寿命周期成本
  • procurement management

Cited By