Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-11-08

Re-measurement and price splitting after rebar substitution: re-measure from the variation drawings, count the quantity once only (lap and wastage coverage), the splitting formula of the quantity difference at the contract rate plus the material price difference carrying VAT only, and the 15% clause boundary among adopting the contract rate / converting an analogous rate / building up a new rate (GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 7.4.2, 8.2.1, 8.9.1, 8.9.2 and 3.3.5)

After a rebar substitution, re-measure from the variation instruction and the as-built construction drawings (GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 7.4.2) and count the quantity once only (laps only where shown by the design or by codes; erection wastage enters the quota content). Price splitting: dC = dQ x P1 + Q2 x dp - the quantity difference is priced at the contract (or re-banded) all-in unit rate, and the material price difference carries VAT only, with no overheads or profit (cl. 3.3.5). Rate banding takes 15% as the line: where the billed quantity change does not exceed 15% (inclusive), the five bands of cl. 8.9.1 apply (same conditions and same item description -> the contract rate; analogous description or analogous conditions -> a converted analogous rate; otherwise a negotiated rate build-up); beyond 15% (exclusive), cl. 8.9.2 applies and the rate is lowered or raised for the change in procurement discounts brought by the quantity gain or loss. Routine grade and size substitutions mostly land in the 'adopt the contract rate / convert an analogous rate' bands, not in a new rate build-up.

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 50500-2024 第7.4.2条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第8.2.1条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第8.9.1条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第8.9.2条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第3.3.5条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 App. A.2
  • GB/T 50860-2024 App. A Table A.15.10
  • TB/T 10823-2024 Vol. 2 桥涵工程 册说明 工程量计算规则
  • TB/T 10821-2024 材料工地搬运及操作损耗率
  • SJG 181.2-2024 第5.1.3条
  • GB 55008-2021 第2.0.11条

Topic positioning

The 'two ledgers' after a rebar substitution lands: how the quantity is re-measured (counted once only), how the price is split (quantity difference at the original contract rate, price difference carrying VAT only), and the clause boundaries of rate banding (adopt the contract rate / convert an analogous rate / build up a new rate).

Core conclusions

I. Re-measure as a variation after the substitution (GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 7.4.2 verbatim) 'For variations under a unit-rate contract, the billed work items and quantities of the divisional works shall be recalculated from the variation instruction issued or confirmed by the employer and the as-built construction drawings, and compared with the BOQ items and quantities whose errors and omissions have been corrected, to determine the added or deducted variation items and their quantities.' 'Whether the works adopt a unit-rate or a lump-sum contract, where the as-built construction drawings per the variation instruction issued or confirmed by the employer are compared with the contract drawings, the differing part of the divisional works BOQ constitutes the variation items and shall be measured in accordance with the national and sector quantity take-off standards agreed in the contract and any supplementary measurement rules. Differences between the contract drawings and the contract BOQ are BOQ errors; a unit-rate contract shall correct its BOQ errors under the relevant provisions, while the BOQ errors of a lump-sum contract shall not be adjusted.' -> After the substitution the quantity must be re-measured from the as-built construction drawings and compared with the contract BOQ quantities to derive the change; the pricing precondition is a design variation instruction or document (GB 55008-2021 cl. 2.0.11).

II. Count the quantity once only: rebar measurement coverage

  • Rebar weight = design length x unit theoretical weight (0.00617d2 kg/m).
  • Laps: GB/T 50860-2024 Annex A Table A.15.10 - 'apart from the laps shown by the design (including code requirements), other erection laps (such as stock-length splices) shall not be measured'.
  • Railway coverage, TB/T 10823-2024 Volume 2 bridge and culvert works, volume notes: non-prestressed rebar weight is calculated as the design length of the bars (including holding and positioning bars) x the theoretical unit weight, and welding consumables, binding wire, coupler sleeves and spacers must not be counted into the quantity; prestressed tendons (wire, strand) are taken as the design cutting length x the theoretical unit weight, excluding anchorages, ducts, bearing and tie plates, anchorage sealing, binding and welding materials; concrete volume is the solid volume to the design dimensions with no deduction for rebar, embedded parts and reserved grout ducts.
  • Wastage and lap material enter the quota content, not the quantity: TB/T 10821-2024 appendix on site handling and operation wastage rates (rebar and connectors: plain bar d<10 and wire and strand 1.5%; plain bar d no less than 10 and ribbed bars welded 1.5%, mechanically connected 1%; small finished and semi-finished rebar products 0.5%; prestressed bars (wire), cold-drawn wire and prestressed strand 4%, excluding the working length needed for tensioning outside the structure). Counting wastage or laps in both the quantity and the rate is double counting.
  • Quota line-item conversion: SJG 181.2-2024 cl. 5.1.3 - 'where the rebar grade or size in the fabrication and erection line items differs from the design requirement, adjust to the design requirement with all else unchanged' - only the material item changes; labour and plant do not follow.

III. The splitting formula for the quantity and price differences

  • Equal-strength check: As2 x fy2 no less than As1 x fy1; the required area As2 = As1 x fy1 / fy2 (HRB400 fy = 360 N/mm2, HRB500 fy = 435 N/mm2); when re-selecting the spacing, the maximum permissible equal-strength spacing = the single-bar area / the required area per unit length. Example: replacing the original HRB400 d20@150 (As1 = 2094.4 mm2/m) with HRB500 d18@150 (As2 = 1696.5 mm2/m), the capacity ratio = 1696.5 x 435 / (2094.4 x 360) = 0.98 < 1, not equal-strength; the required As2 = 2094.4 x 360 / 435 = 1733.3 mm2/m, giving a d18 maximum spacing of approx. 146.8 mm < 150 mm - dropping one bar diameter while holding the spacing often falls short, so recalculate.
  • Quantity difference dQ = Q2 - Q1 (design length after re-measure x theoretical weight, in t; negative means a decrease).
  • Quantity difference cost = dQ x P1, P1 being the contract (or band-determined) all-in unit rate.
  • Price difference cost = Q2 x (p2 - p1), p2 and p1 being the material prices after and before the substitution (published price information, employer-approved price or contract material price).
  • Contract price change from the substitution: dC = dQ x P1 + Q2 x dp (before tax); tax follows GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 3.3.5 - 'price differential adjustments of the labour cost, material cost and fuel and power cost within the plant and tools cost of the all-in unit rate shall include VAT and shall not include overheads or profit'; the same clause notes that price differentials from cost changes carry VAT only, while the overheads and profit risk is for tenderers to allow as risk cost in their tenders.
  • Splitting order: fix the unit rate first (see IV), then price the quantity difference at the banded rate; no factor is charged twice - where the material price has already been updated through rate conversion, no separate price difference is added.

IV. The boundaries of adopting a rate / converting an analogous rate / building a new rate (the 15% line)

  • GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 8.2.1: under a unit-rate contract, the divisional works BOQ items and quantities are re-measured from the contract drawings per cl. 7.2.1, and the contract price is adjusted for BOQ errors as follows: '1. where BOQ errors change the billed items (items added or removed), or the billed quantities increase or decrease and the change does not exceed 15% (inclusive) of the quantity contained in the contract BOQ for the item, the price shall be calculated under cl. 8.9.1 of this standard; 2. where the billed quantities increase or decrease by more than 15% (exclusive) of the quantity contained in the contract BOQ for the item, the price shall be calculated under cl. 8.9.2 of this standard.'
  • Cl. 8.9.1 (within 15%, item changes), five bands: 1. items with the same item description under the same construction conditions adopt the corresponding contract rate; 2. an analogous item description under the same conditions, or the same description under analogous conditions, adopts the all-in unit rate derived by converting the contract rate of an analogous billed item; 3. a different description under the same conditions, or the same description under different conditions: a market-reasonable all-in unit rate may be negotiated in light of execution, drawing on the contract pricing rules and tender level of analogous items; 4. a different description under different conditions: negotiated with reference to the all-in unit rates of analogous billed items in similar works; 5. where removing or cancelling items materially changes the construction conditions: negotiated per the execution, market prices, contract rate rules and tender level.
  • Cl. 8.9.2 (beyond 15%): for added items and quantities, price after reasonably lowering the contract rate and the new all-in unit rates in line with cl. 8.9.1 and the effect of procurement price discounts from the added quantities of labour and materials; for reduced items and quantities, price after reasonably raising them for the loss of such discounts.
  • Determination factors (cl. 8.9.1 commentary): on the description side, material changes, construction method changes and effects on other divisional items; on the conditions side, foundations, height, element sizes, construction season, protection of completed areas, access restrictions, material transport modes, plant usage, and coordination fees within the main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions.
  • Practical conclusion: routine substitutions of the same or a different grade, size or spacing mostly land in band 2 (analogous description -> a converted analogous rate) or band 1 (same description -> the contract rate), not a new rate build-up; only where both description and conditions materially change does the negotiated build-up band open.

V. Who bears the quantity difference Under a unit-rate contract the quantity difference adjusts with the measured quantity (BOQ errors and quantity differences fall to the employer, cl. 7.4.2 and cl. 8.2.1); under a lump-sum contract the BOQ errors are not adjusted and whether a substitution difference adjusts depends on the contract; cost-plus is paid as incurred.

Applicable boundaries

  • The splitting formula dC = dQ x P1 + Q2 x dp applies only where the billed item is comparable before and after the substitution and the contract rate can be adopted or converted directly; where a new all-in unit rate has been negotiated under bands 3 to 5 of cl. 8.9.1, that rate already embeds the material price change and no material price difference may be stacked on top.
  • The 15% line compares the re-measured quantity after the variation with the quantity contained in the contract BOQ; beyond 15% what is adjusted is the loss of quantity discounts in the original rate - it is neither a re-tender nor a new rate build-up; item changes and quantity deviations share the same threshold (cl. 8.2.1).
  • Wastage rates and lap counts belong to the quota / measurement standard coverage and vary widely by discipline and region (railway TB/T 10821, local BOQ measurement standards and SJG quotas each form their own systems); apply the system of the project and never borrow across systems.
  • Technical compliance of the substitution (equal strength or equal area, dedicated verification, design variation documents) is the precondition of pricing; a substitution without a design variation leaves both the quantity and the price difference without a pricing basis.
  • This card does not cover specific item rates or material price levels; prices follow the contract and the approved price sources.

Further reading

  • GB/T 50500-2024 'China national pricing standard for BOQ', cl. 7.4.2, cl. 8.2.1, cl. 8.9.1, cl. 8.9.2, cl. 3.3.5 and Annex A.2 (adjustment formula based on published price information: dP with the base price C0 and the risk band coefficient r).
  • GB/T 50860-2024 'Quantity take-off standard for structures works', Annex A Table A.15.10 (lap measurement).
  • TB/T 10823-2024 'Railway works budget quota manual, Volume 2, bridge and culvert works', volume notes, quantity take-off rules cl. 3 and 4 (rebar and prestressed tendon measurement).
  • TB/T 10821-2024 'Railway basic quota manual', appendix 'site handling and operation wastage rates of materials' (rebar and connector wastage rates).
  • SJG 181.2-2024 'Municipal works consumption standard, Volume 2, bridge and culvert works', cl. 5.1.3 (line-item adjustment for different rebar grades and sizes).
  • GB 55008-2021 cl. 2.0.11 (a substitution requires design variation documents - see the companion card on the technical determination of the same topic).

Keywords