The employer's duty to respond after a contractor's claim: 28-day response period (restarting after supplementary evidence), 14-day window to request evidence, and judicial attitude toward deemed acceptance on silence (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 8.11.5)
The employer shall reply in writing with its handling opinion within the contractual period (28 days if silent) after receiving the contractor's claim report or supplementary evidence; if it deems evidence insufficient, it shall request supplements in writing within the contractual period (14 days if silent) after receiving the claim notice, and the response period restarts as a new 28 days from receipt of the supplementary evidence. If the employer fails to respond, the contract may deem the claim accepted; absent such a clause, relying on GB/T 50500-2024 (a recommended standard) alone for "deemed acceptance" - judged by the three elements of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 21 (express contractual agreement + duly served complete documents + no reply within the period) - is rejected by most courts. The supervision procedure (DBJ41/T 208-2018 Clause 9.4.4) matches: the supervisor reviews and forwards the claim within 14 days, and the employer issues a signed claim decision within 28 days of receiving the report or further evidence, failing which the claim is deemed accepted.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第 8.11.3、8.11.4、8.11.5 条
- DBJ41 T 208-2018 · Standard for Construction Project Supervision Work (Henan) 第 9.4.4 条
- 法释〔2020〕25号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第 21 条
- GF-2017-0201《建设工程施工合同(示范文本)》第 19.2 条
Topic Positioning
Three timing issues in the employer's (client's) duty to respond to a contractor's claim: the latest response period, the period to demand further evidence, and whether silence means acceptance, plus the corresponding limits in the supervision procedure - per GB/T 50500-2024 "Standard for measure and valuation of construction work with bills of quantities" Clause 8.11.5 and the supervision standard aligned with the model contract. All limits are "contractual period first, then the stated defaults".
Core Conclusions
- Response period - 28 days (from receipt of the claim report or supplementary evidence). Clause 8.11.5 item 2: "The employer shall, within the contractual period (28 days if none) after receiving the contractor's claim report or supplementary evidence, reply in writing with its handling opinion. If the employer replies late or not at all, the contract may so provide; absent provision, the claim may be deemed accepted." Key: if the employer demands supplements mid-way, the response clock restarts as 28 days from receipt of the supplementary evidence - each supplement defers once; this is the employer's lawful channel for delay.
- Evidence-request period - 14 days (from receipt of the claim notice). Item 1: "The employer shall, within the prescribed time after receiving the claim notice, review the records and evidence; if it considers supplements necessary, it shall so request in writing within the contractual period (14 days if none) after receiving the notice." The demand is tied to 14 days from the notice; first raising it only after the 28 days lapse is textually indefensible - in practice the contract governs.
- Silence as acceptance - clause level vs judicial level. Clause level: item 2's last sentence and the general rule of 8.11.3 both state "where the responding party does not reply within the agreed time, the claim may be deemed accepted". Judicial level: GB/T 50500-2024 is recommended (GB/T), so "deemed acceptance" is not automatically legally binding; the SPC's approach to analogous issues (silence on final accounts) is the three-element test of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 21 - express contractual agreement + duly served, complete documents + no reply within the period; absent agreement, claims resting only on a standard or model text are rejected by the overwhelming majority of courts. Whether default acceptance holds therefore turns on whether the special conditions state "silence means acceptance" and whether the claim report was completely served (retain receipts, EMS slips, supervisor sign-offs).
- Payment path. Item 4: "After the parties agree on the claim cost, the employer shall pay it in the current progress payment / in-process settlement at the contractual payment ratio, with the balance in the final account."
- Supervision procedure (DBJ41/T 208-2018 Clause 9.4.4, aligned with the model contract): the contractor shall submit the claim notice within 28 days of knowing or should have known of the event (waiver beyond); submit the claim report within 28 days of the notice; continuing effects - interim notices at reasonable intervals; final report within 28 days after the effect ends. The supervisor reviews and forwards the report to the client within 14 days (may request full original records); the client shall, within 28 days of the supervisor receiving the report or further evidence, issue the signed claim decision through the supervisor; on the employer's silence, the contractor's claim is deemed accepted.
Applicable Boundaries
- All limits are "contractual period first, defaults if silent" - always check the special conditions first.
- Clause 8.11.5 covers contractor-to-employer claims; the employer's reverse claims (8.11.4) follow the same 28/28-day notice-report pattern.
- The effect of "deemed acceptance" presupposes express contractual agreement; GB/T 50500-2024 is recommended, not mandatory law.
- The supervision clause is from Henan's DBJ41/T 208-2018, aligned with GF-2017-0201; other regions follow local standards and the contract.
- A claim not lodged in time is, absent other agreement or legal provision, deemed waived (8.11.3 last sentence).
Further Reading
- GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 8.11.3 (contractor claims: 28/28 pattern, continuing notices, final report), 8.11.4 (employer claims), 8.11.5 (handling procedure and limits).
- Supervision: DBJ41/T 208-2018 Clause 9.4.4; model contract GF-2017-0201 Clause 19.2.
- Judicial attitude: SPC Interpretation (I) on construction contract disputes (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25) Article 21 (three elements for settling at the submitted price on silence); drafting of effective "silence equals acceptance" clauses per contract-design guidance.
- Contractor practice: on stonewalling, send a written demand stating "absence of written response within X days means acceptance" to fix evidence for arbitration/litigation; serve claims with proof and file complete evidence at once to shrink the supplementation-deferral room; write into special conditions "employer silence means acceptance" and "supplementation demands must be made in writing within 14 days of the notice, else evidence is deemed complete".
Keywords
- 工程索赔
- 发包人答复期限
- 28 days
- 14天
- 补证材料
- deemed approval upon lapse of the response period
- GB/T 50500-2024
- 8.11.5
- 法释〔2020〕25号
- 监理索赔处理