Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-09-25

Correction windows and settlement handling for obviously abnormal (over-high/over-low) tendered all-in unit rates: tender-stage clarification/rejection vs settlement-stage contract price lock-in

The correction window for abnormal unit prices (incl. unbalanced bidding) is at tender stage: bidders may be required to clarify and, without changing the tender total, provide corrected unit prices for evaluation reference (GB/T 50500-2024 3.5.3); offers obviously below cost that cannot be proven reasonable are deemed below-cost bidding and rejected (MOT Decree 2018 No. 13 Article 32; MOHURD Decree No. 47 Article 42). At settlement, contract prices are locked: bidders are responsible for consistency and rationality of priced-list entries and bear irrational-pricing risk (6.1.2); settlement review may not adjust unit prices except as contractually agreed (T/ZBD 100.5-2023 3.1.6); the only legitimate repricing path is contractual adjustment events — the 15% quantity deviation boundary (8.9.1/8.9.2) — which corrects price changes induced by quantity changes, not tender-time anomalies.

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第3.5.3、6.1.2、6.1.11、8.9.1、8.9.2条
  • T/ZBD 100.5-2023 建设工程结算审核作业指引 第3.1.6条
  • 铁路工程建设项目招标投标管理办法(交通运输部令2018年第13号)第三十二条
  • 房屋建筑和市政基础设施工程施工招标投标管理办法(住建部令第47号,2019修正)第四十二条

Topic Positioning

This card answers "how to handle obviously abnormal tendered all-in unit rates (over-high/over-low, incl. unbalanced bidding) at settlement": the correction window is at tender stage (evaluation/clarification); after entering settlement, contract prices are locked and cannot be unilaterally adjusted for "abnormal pricing" — the only legitimate path is contractual adjustment events (e.g., quantity deviation beyond 15%).

Core Conclusions

  1. The correction window is at tender stage; missing it means contractual lock-in.
  • Pricing rationality clarification (GB/T 50500-2024 3.5.3): where tender pricing raises rationality questions (e.g., provisional-estimate items' unit prices unreasonably low/high versus similar items; work-item unit prices unreasonably low/high versus competitive market prices of similar works), the bidder may be required to clarify, and to "without changing the tender total" provide corrected all-in unit rates for quantity increments/decrements and variation pricing of the priced list, submitted per 3.5.1 item 1 for the evaluation (or award) committee's reference.
  • Below-cost rejection: Railway Works Tendering and Bidding Measures (MOT Decree 2018 No. 13) Article 32 — where the evaluation committee deems a bid obviously below others', possibly affecting quality or honest performance, it may require clarification of whether it is below cost, with supporting materials; failing proof of reasonableness, the committee shall deem it below-cost bidding and reject the bid. Measures for Tendering of Building and Municipal Infrastructure Construction Works (MOHURD Decree No. 47, 2019 amendment) Article 42 — with a benchmark price, bids below the reasonable band; without one, bids obviously below others' that may be below enterprise cost: the committee may require written explanation with materials; upon finding the price below enterprise cost, the bidder cannot be recommended as winner.
  • Total-vs-detail consistency (6.1.11): the tender total shall equal the sum of work-item, measure, and other-items totals plus VAT; discrepancies are corrected per Section 3.5 keeping the total unchanged; the tender-letter total cannot be modified — "the winner is responsible for the contract unit prices".
  1. Settlement-stage price lock-in.
  • GB/T 50500-2024 6.1.2: bidders may price autonomously per Section 6.2 and "shall be responsible for the consistency and rationality of the priced-list entries, bearing the risks of irrational pricing and lump-sum BOQ defects" — over-high/over-low pricing risks are the bidder's own — the legal basis of unbalanced bidding's two-way risk.
  • T/ZBD 100.5-2023 3.1.6 (fixed-unit-price mode): unit prices within the contractual risk scope shall remain fixed; quantities per contractually measured completed work; settlement review shall "check item by item consistency with the priced list's unit prices. Where variations change priced-list items, unit prices adjust per the current national standard. Except as contractually agreed, unit prices shall not be adjusted otherwise." Review also verifies material/equipment conformity to contract, provisional-estimate and employer-supplied materials adjusted per confirmed prices and agreed principles, measure costs, dayworks, and general-contractor service fees per contract, over-drawn employer-supplied materials without replenishment orders or supplements deducted, and fees and VAT per contract and law.
  1. The only legitimate settlement-stage repricing path: contractual adjustment events (not "abnormal unit price" itself).
  • Unit-price contracts with quantity changes from variations or defects not exceeding 15% (inclusive) (8.9.1): identical characteristics under identical conditions adopt the contract price; similar characteristics/conditions adopt converted similar-item prices; different characteristics/conditions negotiate market-reasonable prices; variations that significantly change conditions negotiate variation prices.
  • Beyond 15% (exclusive) (8.9.2): for increased quantities, "reasonably reduce" contract and new unit prices considering labor/material procurement discounts from increased volume; for decreased, "reasonably increase" considering lost discounts. This is the channel that corrects "quantity-game" pricing at settlement — but it corrects price changes induced by quantity changes, not tender-time anomalies.

Applicable Boundaries

  • Applies to offer and settlement disputes under the GB/T 50500-2024 BOQ system; clarification and rejection procedures apply to works subject to mandatory tendering law.
  • "Obviously abnormal" has no unified national threshold (local rules and tender documents govern); the judgment bases are the tender documents + priced list + contract adjustment clauses.
  • At settlement, no unilateral repricing for "abnormal/unbalanced pricing"; the employer's only path is quantity deviation (8.9.1/8.9.2) or variation repricing; otherwise the contractor may assert contractual rights — the contractor cannot top up under-priced items (absorbing them per 6.1.2), and over-priced items without quantity growth yield no expected gain.
  • Variation facts and quantities must first be confirmed per Sections 7.1, 7.2, 7.4; explicit contractual adjustment agreements prevail.

Further Reading

  • GB/T 50500-2024 3.5.1, 3.5.3, 6.1.2, 6.1.11, 8.9.1, 8.9.2, with Sections 7.1/7.2/7.4; 15% boundary details in existing cards.
  • T/ZBD 100.5-2023 3.1.6.
  • MOT Decree 2018 No. 13 Article 32; MOHURD Decree No. 47 (2019) Article 42.
  • Unbalanced bidding definition/techniques and tender-stage countermeasures in existing cards; unit price composition in existing term cards.

Keywords