Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-09-25

Claims under FIDIC 2017 (Red/Yellow Book Chapter 20) compared with construction claims under China's GB/T 50500-2024: institutional positioning, the hard/soft divide of the 28-day time bar, and the procedural nodes of claims in both directions

FIDIC 2017's Claim is a "procedure unifier" - clause 20.1 (a)(b)(c) covers both the employer's and the contractor's claims for additional payment, reduction of the contract price, extension of time (EOT/DNP) and "any other right or relief" (of any kind whatsoever); everything is asserted through the single procedure of clause 20.2, the employer's counter-claims included (20.2.7 prohibits direct set-off); the Notice of Claim must be given within 28 days of becoming aware of the event, failing which the claim is time-barred (hard bar). China's GB/T 50500-2024 positions the "construction claim" as the residual channel among the 11 contract price adjustment events listed in 8.1.1: it applies only to events not caused by the claiming party's own causes and outside the adjustment scope of clauses 8.2-8.10 (8.11.1); events already adjusted under the price-adjustment provisions may not be claimed again - double recovery is barred (8.11.2); the period for the Notice of Claim is "as agreed in the contract (28 days absent agreement)", and upon default the claimant "may be deemed to have waived" the claim (except as otherwise agreed in the contract and otherwise provided by laws and regulations) - the time bar has been softened from the 2013 edition's "loses the right to claim" to "may be deemed to have waived", but at contract level (e.g. Henan DBJ41/T 208-2018 supervision standard clause 9.4.4) the hard 28-day time bar remains mainstream.

Applicable Codes

  • FIDIC Conditions of Contract for Construction(红皮书 2017 第二版)第20章 20.1~20.2.7
  • FIDIC Conditions of Contract for Plant and Design-Build(黄皮书 2017)第20章
  • GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第8.1.1、8.11.1~8.11.6条
  • GB 50500-2013 建设工程工程量清单计价规范 第9.13.2条(已废止)
  • DBJ41/T 208-2018 建设工程监理工作标准(河南)第9.4.4条
  • GB/T 50319-2013 建设工程监理规范 App. CTable C.0.3
  • T/ZBD 100.4-2023 建设工程造价鉴定作业指引 第4.6.1条

Topic Positioning

A comparison of two regimes: Chapter 20 "Claims" of FIDIC 2017 (second edition) Red Book "Conditions of Contract for Construction" / Yellow Book "Conditions of Contract for Plant and Design-Build", and clause 8.11 "construction claims" of China's GB/T 50500-2024 "Pricing Standard for Bill of Quantities of Construction Works". It answers three practical questions: what fundamentally differs between the Claim and the Chinese "claim" in institutional positioning; which is harder - the 28-day notice period and its default consequences; and how the procedural nodes of claims in both directions correspond. For practitioners in cross-border works, Chinese/international contract comparison, claim management and construction cost disputes.

Core Conclusions

1. Institutional positioning: FIDIC's Claim is a "procedure unifier"; China's "claim" is a "residual channel"

  • Chapter 20 of FIDIC 2017 is titled "Employer's and Contractor's Claims". Clause 20.1 provides three types of claim: (a) additional payment the Employer considers itself entitled to from the Contractor (or a reduction of the Contract Price) and/or an extension of the Defects Notification Period (DNP); (b) additional payment the Contractor considers itself entitled to from the Employer and/or an extension of the Time for Completion (EOT); (c) any other right or relief which either Party considers itself entitled to against the other Party - in the words of the text, "may be of any kind whatsoever". That is, money and time entitlements arising under any substantive clause of the contract (variations, delay, changes in costs, force majeure etc.) are all channelled through the single procedural pipeline of clause 20.2; the Employer's counter-claims equally must comply with 20.2 (20.2.7: the Employer may claim payment from the Contractor or an extension of the DNP, or set off or deduct from amounts payable to the Contractor, only through compliance with this clause).
  • GB/T 50500-2024: the construction claim is one (the 10th) of the 11 contract price adjustment events of clause 8.1.1, and is an exclusive residual channel - clause 8.11.1 provides that only events "caused by the other party's causes, not falling within the adjustment scope of clauses 8.2 to 8.10 of this standard" and causing economic loss and/or delay may be claimed under this clause; 8.11.2 adds that "where the price of an event has already been adjusted under the contract price adjustment provisions (excluding claims), no construction claim shall be calculated again". BOQ errors, provisional sums, provisional sums for specified materials, changes in costs, changes in laws and policies, variations, additional works etc. each have their own substantive and procedural channel in China (8.2-8.10); the claim catches only what slips through the net, and double recovery is barred. The same event is a neutral act of "claiming" in FIDIC language, whereas in the Chinese context the "claim" is a settlement account item parallel to variations and site instructions.
  • The Chinese clauses also make clear: a claim rests on breach liability under the Civil Code (where a party fails to perform its contractual obligations or performs them otherwise than as agreed and causes loss to the other party, the injured party is entitled to require performance, remedy, and compensation for loss / reimbursement of cost); its nature is economic compensation, not punishment; the employer and the contractor may both claim in both directions; where economic loss and time adjustment occur together, they must be claimed together.

2. The 28-day notice time bar: hard bar under FIDIC vs a softened bar in China

  • FIDIC Red Book 20.2.1: the Notice of Claim shall be given "as soon as practicable, and not later than 28 days after the claiming Party became aware (or should have become aware) of the event or circumstance"; in the words of the text, "If the claiming Party fails to give a Notice of Claim within this period of 28 days, the claiming Party shall not be entitled to any additional payment..." - after the deadline, no additional payment (or corresponding time benefit). The Yellow Book words it more completely: "If the Contractor fails to give notice of a claim within such period of 28 days, the Time for Completion shall not be extended, the Contractor shall not be entitled to additional payment, and the Employer shall be discharged from all liability in connection with the claim." A hard procedural bar, with no "may" and no exemption tail.
  • GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 8.11.3 (contractor's claims) and 8.11.4 (employer's reverse claims): the Notice of Claim shall be submitted within "the period agreed in the contract (28 days where the contract is silent)"; upon default it "may be dealt with as agreed in the contract"; the closing paragraphs of both clauses summarise: "where, after a claim event arises, the injured party fails to make its claim within the agreed time, then except as otherwise agreed in the contract and otherwise provided by laws and regulations, it may be deemed to have waived the relevant construction claim." The line of evolution: the superseded GB 50500-2013 clause 9.13.2 was a hard bar ("where the contractor fails to issue the notice of claim intention in time, it loses the right to claim"); the 2024 edition changes this to "may be deemed to have waived" - the bar is stepped down from "mandatory loss of right" to "contract first + 28-day fallback + room for exemption" (see the dedicated card on this evolution).
  • Note that at domestic contract level the bar is not uniformly soft: clause 9.4.4 of Henan DBJ41/T 208-2018 "Standard for Construction Supervision Work", restating the supervision engineer's processing procedure, is still a hard bar - "where the contractor fails to issue the notice of claim intention within the said 28 days, it is deemed to have waived the right to additional payment and/or extension of time". Under the model-text system the 28-day time bar remains the mainstream contractual agreement.

3. Node-by-node comparison (where the contract agrees no periods)

  • FIDIC (2017 clause 20.2): Notice of Claim within 28 days (20.2.1) -> maintain contemporary records (20.2.2; the Engineer may monitor / instruct further records and has the right of inspection during working hours) -> submit a fully detailed Claim (20.2.4; where the Engineer requires further particulars it must state the reasons, but must still respond on the contractual or legal basis of the claim within the clause 3.7.3 period) -> for claims with continuing effect (20.2.6), submit interim fully detailed Claims monthly with the cumulative claimed amounts, on which the Engineer comments within the 3.7.3 period -> until the claim is agreed or determined, the Engineer shall include in each payment certificate the amounts reasonably shown to be due (20.2.7).
  • China (GB/T 50500-2024 8.11.3-8.11.6): within 28 days after the event arises, submit a written Notice of Claim (stating the cause and the intention to claim) -> within 28 days after the notice is issued, submit the written construction claim report (detailing the cause, the contract clauses relied on, the cost claimed and/or the number of days of extension of time, attaching records, supporting documents and the claim calculation schedule); where cost and time are both involved, claim both together -> for continuing effects, submit further Notices of Claim at contract-agreed intervals (not exceeding 28 days absent agreement) or at reasonable intervals, listing the cumulative amounts / days -> within 28 days after the influence ends, submit the final construction claim report. Receiving-side nodes: where further particulars are needed, request them in writing within the agreed period (14 days absent agreement) of receiving the notice; reply in writing with the decision within the agreed period (28 days absent agreement) of receiving the claim report or the further particulars, failing which the claim "may be deemed accepted"; the agreed claim cost is paid at the contractual percentage in the current progress payment or the interim settlement by construction stage, the remainder in the final account payment (an employer's claim against the contractor may be deducted from the amounts payable). The standard form of the Notice of Claim is GB/T 50319-2013 Appendix C Table C.0.3.
  • Common ground: both run from awareness of the event, with 28 days as the fallback where the contract is silent; both require written form + contemporary records + reasons and quantified particulars; both construe overdue silence into an adverse consequence (FIDIC: time bar; China: deemed acceptance / deemed waiver, symmetrical in both directions).

Applicable Boundaries

  • The FIDIC side is based on the 2017 second edition Red Book (Construction) and Yellow Book (Plant and Design-Build); the clause numbering, time-bar wording and period details differ in the 1999 and earlier editions, and this card's conclusions do not apply to older contracts.
  • The China-side position comes from GB/T 50500-2024 (a recommended national standard, GB -> GB/T); its procedural provisions bind the parties only once incorporated by the contract; the general/particular conditions (e.g. the GF-2017-0201 model text) prevail over the standard's fallbacks.
  • The 28 days are a procedural time-bar period, not the limitation period for litigation (three years under Civil Code Article 188); the two mechanisms coexist.
  • In the Chinese context the event is characterised first: in cost expert assessment the assessor first determines, on professional knowledge, whether the event constitutes a "variation" (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.6.1 lists 5 situations where a variation may be found established), then selects the adjustment channel; in the FIDIC context the classification mainly affects the substantive basis clause, not the procedural entry point. This card does not cover the specific pricing rules of "variations" and "claims" respectively, nor other dispute types such as insurance claims.

Further Reading

  • FIDIC "Conditions of Contract for Construction" (Red Book, 2017 second edition) Chapter 20, 20.1-20.2.7; "Conditions of Contract for Plant and Design-Build" (Yellow Book, 2017) corresponding Chapter 20 clauses; the Engineer's agreement/determination periods in clause 3.7.3; the definition and procedure of variations in clause 13.
  • GB/T 50500-2024 "Pricing Standard for Bill of Quantities of Construction Works" clause 8.1.1 (the 11 price adjustment events), clauses 8.11.1-8.11.6 (construction claims), terms 2.0.28 "variation" and 2.0.30 "additional works"; the superseded GB 50500-2013 clause 9.13.2 for the evolution comparison.
  • DBJ41/T 208-2018 "Standard for Construction Supervision Work" (Henan provincial standard) clause 9.4.4 (the project supervision body's procedure and periods for handling cost claims); GB/T 50319-2013 "Code for Construction Project Supervision of Construction Works" Appendix C Table C.0.3 (Notice of Claim); T/ZBD 100.4-2023 "Guidelines for Construction Cost Expert Assessment Practice" clause 4.6.1 (the 5 determining situations for variations in cost expert assessment).

Keywords