Allocating the works cost saved through design optimisation in EPC (engineering, procurement and construction) contracting between employer and contractor: the Particular Conditions entry on 'value engineering benefit sharing' is the sole basis of a claim, and no statutory sharing ratio exists absent agreement; the saving must be verified through valuation of variations and stripped of price differentials and similar factors on a like-for-like basis, and under a fixed lump-sum contract the saving usually settles directly as the contractor's cost surplus
No statutory sharing - only contractual sharing: General Conditions of GF-2020-0216, Sub-Clause 13.2.3, reads 'Where a value engineering proposal reduces the contract price, shortens the time for completion or improves the economic benefit of the works, the parties may share the benefit as agreed in the Particular Conditions' - 'may' plus 'as agreed in the Particular Conditions' means there is no sharing claim without agreement; a blank, a slash, or 'to be negotiated separately' in that Particular Conditions entry is presumed to be no variation under Civil Code, Article 544. Sharing amount S = (C0 - C1) x r x k, where r is the contractually agreed ratio (r = 0 if not agreed; the industry '30/70 or 50/50' splits are negotiating convention, not a standard), C0 and C1 must share the same scope, VAT status and base period, and C1 is determined under the variation valuation rules of Sub-Clause 13.3.3.1. Under a fixed lump-sum contract (the default form under Sub-Clause 14.1.1) the contract price is not reduced for optimisation, the saving settles as the contractor's surplus, and no 'allocation' generally arises.
Applicable Codes
- 建市〔2020〕96号《建设项目工程总承包合同(示范文本)》GF-2020-0216 通用合同条件第13.1.1项、13.2.1项、13.2.2项、13.2.3项、13.3.3.1项、13.3.3.2项、13.4款、14.1.1项、14.1.2项;专用合同条件第13.2.3项、13.3.3.1项
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第五百一十条、第五百三十三条、第五百四十三条、第五百四十四条
- 法释〔2023〕13号《最高人民法院关于适用〈中华人民共和国民法典〉合同编通则若干问题的解释》第一条、第二条
- 法释〔2026〕12号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第九条、第二十三条
- 建市规〔2019〕12号《房屋建筑和市政基础设施项目工程总承包管理办法》第十九条、第二十一条、第二十六条
- 建市〔2004〕200号《建设工程项目管理试行办法》第十三条
- https://www.court.gov.cn/fabu/xiangqing/504221.html
Topic Positioning
This card answers how a cost saving achieved through design optimisation (contractually a 'value engineering proposal') in an EPC (engineering, procurement and construction) turnkey project is allocated between the employer and the contractor: whether it can be shared at all, under which clause, how the base amount is computed, the consequences of silence, and how 'who keeps the saving' splits across pricing methods. It applies to building and municipal EPC projects contracted on the Model Contract for Project EPC Contracting, GF-2020-0216.
Core Conclusions
I. Only contractual sharing; no statutory sharing. General Conditions of GF-2020-0216, Sub-Clause 13.2.3: 'Where a value engineering proposal reduces the contract price, shortens the time for completion or improves the economic benefit of the works, the parties may share the benefit as agreed in the Particular Conditions.' The Particular Conditions entry for Sub-Clause 13.2.3 reads 'agreement on benefit sharing for value engineering proposals by the contractor: ____' - a blank, a slash, or merely 'to be negotiated separately' all amount to no agreement, and the contractor cannot claim a share merely because 'investment was saved'. No current law, administrative regulation or national pricing standard sets any statutory sharing ratio for EPC design-optimisation savings.
II. The legal consequence of silence. Civil Code, Article 544: 'Where the content of a variation of the contract agreed by the parties is unclear, it is presumed that no variation has been made.' Article 510: unclear agreed terms may be supplemented by agreement; failing a supplementary agreement, they are determined by the relevant clauses of the contract or by usage. Under Article 2 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of the General Provisions of the Contract Part of the Civil Code (Fa Shi [2023] No. 13), usage must be proved by the party invoking it and is confined to 'the common practice between the parties in their transactions' or 'practice commonly adopted in the locality or field or industry of the transaction and known, or that should be known, to the other contracting party when the contract was concluded' - so the industry habits of '30/70' or '50/50' splits of savings cannot directly ground a judgment. Where the parties later reach agreement through negotiation, a new variation agreement arises under Civil Code, Article 543 ('the parties may vary the contract by consensus'), but it is a new agreement, not an interpretation of the original clause.
III. Procedure comes first: no sharing without a variation instruction. Sub-Clause 13.2.1: where the contractor makes a value engineering proposal, it shall submit to the Engineer a statement of the proposal explaining its content and reasons and its effect on the contract price and the time for completion. Sub-Clause 13.2.2: unless otherwise agreed in the Particular Conditions, the Engineer shall complete its review within 7 days of receiving the proposal and report it to the employer, notifying the contractor to revise where technical defects are found; the employer shall complete approval within 7 days of receipt; where approved, the Engineer shall promptly issue a variation instruction, and the resulting contract price adjustment follows Sub-Clause 13.3.3 [valuation of variations]; where the employer disagrees, the Engineer shall notify the contractor in writing. Sub-Clause 13.3.3.2: the contractor shall submit variation valuation documents to the Engineer within 14 days of receiving the variation instruction; price adjustments arising from the variation shall be paid in the nearest progress payment. Reverse constraints: Sub-Clause 13.1.1, 'the contractor shall not vary any part of the works without permission', and Sub-Clause 13.1.2, the contractor shall execute per the variation instruction (it may only promptly notify the Engineer and explain that it cannot comply where safety, stability or serviceability would be reduced, the work content or scope is unforeseeable, equipment is difficult to procure, the clauses on labour employment, health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions, occupational health or environmental protection cannot be performed, delay would result, or the instruction conflicts with the contractor's general obligations).
IV. The sharing formula: S = (C0 - C1) x r x k.
- C0 (base price before optimisation) - one of three options, locked in the contract: (1) the corresponding portion of the contracted price; (2) the works cost under the approved design estimate; (3) the construction-drawing based budget recomputed under the contract pricing rules. The three must not be mixed, and C0 must share with C1 the same scope, VAT status and base period (aligned with the price-adjustment base period, so that price fluctuation is not mistaken for optimisation).
- C1 (verified price after optimisation) is determined under Sub-Clause 13.3.3.1 [valuation principles]: '(1) where the contract contains no price schedule, the contract price shall be adjusted at cost plus profit for the varied work; (2) where the contract contains a price schedule: 1) where the schedule has an item applicable to the varied work, the rates and prices of that item apply; 2) where the schedule has no applicable but a similar item, the rates or prices of the similar item may be referenced within a reasonable range; 3) where the schedule has neither, the item shall be re-rated at cost plus profit on new rates or prices.'
- Delta C = C0 - C1 must reflect only the contribution of the design optimisation itself; strip out: material and labour price differentials and price adjustment, adjustments for changes in law (Sub-Clause 13.7), BOQ errors and omissions, unused provisional sums, employer cancellation or reduction of scope, and claim amounts. Reason: for works to be settled at an agreed fixed price, a party requesting adjustment of the works price on the ground of major changes in labour cost or key material prices during the construction period is in principle not supported (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 9, unless otherwise agreed or meeting the change-of-circumstances test of Civil Code, Article 533); price differentials are the contractor's price risk and cannot be counted into the sharing base as 'optimisation savings'. Note also Sub-Clause 14.1.2(3): any quantity stated in the price schedule is only an estimated workload, is not to be taken as the actual or accurate workload required of the contractor, and serves only as reference material for variation and payment - so a reduction in physical quantity is not an equal saving; savings must be verified on a price basis (rates and prices).
- r (sharing ratio): the value agreed in Particular Conditions Sub-Clause 13.2.3; if not agreed, r = 0. The ratio locks at contracting; later unilateral claims fail.
- k (contribution coefficient): 1 where the contractor independently proposed and implemented; reduced per agreement where the employer specified the scheme, or the supervisor or employer led the implementation, or the scheme mainly originated from others (the reduction rule should be stated in the Particular Conditions, or disputes easily arise).
V. Who keeps the saving, by pricing method (the split when there is no sharing agreement). Sub-Clause 14.1.1: 'Unless otherwise agreed in the Particular Conditions, this contract is a lump-sum contract; save for adjustment under Clause 13 [variations and adjustments] and other agreed increases and decreases in the contract, the contract price shall not be adjusted'; Article 4(2) of the Letter of Agreement is to the same effect: 'the contract price takes the form of a lump-sum contract; save for amounts that must increase or decrease during implementation as agreed in the contract, the contract price shall not be adjusted, unless the contracting parties agree otherwise'.
- Lump-sum: the contract price is not reduced for optimisation; the saving accrues directly to the contractor as cost surplus, and the employer has no right to demand a reduction; and since the contract price has not been 'reduced', strictly the precondition of Sub-Clause 13.2.3 is unmet, so the contractor generally cannot additionally claim a share under that clause (to obtain an incentive, agree it expressly in the Particular Conditions).
- Re-measurement settlement / rate-discount (percentage-off) pricing / design-to-cost: the settlement base falls with the optimisation, the saving goes to the employer, and the contractor obtains an incentive only through a sharing clause.
- Cost plus fee: costs are reimbursed at actual; the saving goes to the employer unless a bonus mechanism is built into the fee.
VI. Design optimisation is itself an obligation of the EPC contractor. Article 19 of the Measures for the Administration of EPC Contracting of Building and Municipal Infrastructure Projects (Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12) requires the EPC contractor to 'strengthen design-procurement-construction coordination, refine and optimise the design, improve construction schemes and achieve effective management control of the EPC project'. The sharing clause is thus an agreed incentive for a 'contribution beyond the obligation', not statutory consideration - the substantive reason why no share may be claimed without agreement. Compare Article 13 of the Trial Measures for Project Management of Construction Projects (Jian Shi [2004] No. 200): 'the employer shall reward the rationalisation proposals put forward and implemented by the project management enterprise in proportion to the investment saved; the proportion of the reward shall be agreed in the contract between the employer and the project management enterprise' - likewise leaving the ratio to contract, not setting it by standard.
VII. Special limits on provisional prices and government-invested projects.
- Where the optimised object falls within a provisional-price item, Sub-Clause 13.4 [provisional prices] applies first: for items subject to mandatory tendering by law, 'the difference between the tendered amount of the provisional-price item and the provisional price listed in the price schedule, together with taxes and other costs, shall be included in the contract price'; for items not so subject, 'the difference between the determined amount of the provisional-price item and the provisional price listed in the price schedule, together with taxes and other costs, shall be included in the contract price'. That difference is a contract price adjustment event and must not also enter the optimisation sharing base (avoiding double counting of the same money). Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12, Article 21: works, goods or services within the EPC scope included by way of provisional price, falling within the scope of mandatory tendering by law and reaching the state-prescribed scale thresholds, shall be tendered by law.
- Government-invested projects: Article 26 of Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12 makes clear that 'the construction investment of a government-invested project shall in principle not exceed the approved investment estimate', and 'the funds required for government-invested projects shall be secured in place under state provisions and may not be advanced by the EPC contractor or its subcontractors'. The approved estimate, the government fiscal review of project cost and the audit form the external cap on sharing money; sharing money must have a contract basis and a funding source and may not crowd out other costs.
- Where local documents impose mandatory rules on sharing ratios or approval procedures, verify them separately; industry practice is no substitute.
Applicable Boundaries
- This card takes the contract mechanics of the GF-2020-0216 model text as its baseline. Companies' own contract texts and the FIDIC suite (Red, Yellow and Silver Books) phrase the corresponding clauses differently; apply their own provisions and the actual agreement, and do not transplant Sub-Clause 13.2.3 directly.
- 'No agreement, no claim' concerns the Sub-Clause 13.2.3 sharing clause; it does not affect the contractor claiming a price adjustment for employer-instructed variations under Clause 13 [variations and adjustments], nor the parties reaching a new sharing agreement by negotiation under Civil Code, Article 543.
- Variation pricing under unit-rate contracts and construction-only contracting follows GB/T 50500-2024 Section 8.9 and the other pricing standards (the 15% boundary and the three-tier progressive rate build-up), running in parallel with this card's contractual sharing clause without conflict.
- Timing and version: Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 (adopted at the 1969th meeting of the Adjudication Committee on 17 March 2026, promulgated on 29 June 2026) takes effect on 30 June 2026; its Article 23 provides that 'first-instance cases involving disputes over construction contracts of construction projects newly accepted by the people's courts after this interpretation takes effect shall apply this interpretation' and 'where judicial interpretations previously issued by the Supreme People's Court are inconsistent with this interpretation, this interpretation prevails' - when citing Article 9, determine the application threshold by when the disputed conduct occurred and when the case was accepted.
- The 7-day review and approval periods of Sub-Clause 13.2.2 and the 14-day submission period of Sub-Clause 13.3.3.2 are all subject to 'unless otherwise agreed in the Particular Conditions'; where the Particular Conditions provide otherwise, those terms govern.
Further Reading
- Jian Shi [2020] No. 96, Model Contract for Project EPC Contracting, GF-2020-0216: General Conditions, Clause 13.1 [employer's right to vary], Clause 13.2 [contractor's value engineering proposals], Clause 13.3 [variation procedure] (13.3.3.1 valuation principles, 13.3.3.2 valuation procedure, 13.3.4 time adjustment arising from variations), Clause 13.4 [provisional prices], Clause 13.5 [provisional sums], Clause 13.7 [adjustment for changes in law], Clause 14.1 [form of contract price], Clause 14.3 [progress payments]; Particular Conditions, Sub-Clause 13.2.3 (benefit sharing agreement), Sub-Clause 13.3.3.1 (agreed valuation principles), Clause 13.8 (market price fluctuation adjustment); Letter of Agreement, Article 4, 'contracted price and form of contract price'.
- Civil Code of the PRC, Articles 510, 533, 543 and 544.
- Fa Shi [2023] No. 13, Interpretation on the General Provisions of the Contract Part, Articles 1 and 2.
- Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Interpretation (II) on Construction Contract Disputes, Articles 9 and 23; official text at https://www.court.gov.cn/fabu/xiangqing/504221.html
- Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12, Measures for the Administration of EPC Contracting of Building and Municipal Infrastructure Projects, Articles 19, 21 and 26.
- Jian Shi [2004] No. 200, Trial Measures for Project Management of Construction Projects, Article 13 (reference clause: the reward ratio for rationalisation proposals is agreed by contract).
Keywords
- 合理化建议
- 设计优化
- 利益分享
- 节约额分成
- 工程总承包EPC
- 变更估价
- 固定总价合同
- GF-2020-0216
- 建工解释二第九条