Statutory grounds for challenging an arbitrator, the time limit and the decision procedure, and where 'formerly a party's standing legal counsel' lands; the boundary of the remedy, after rejection and under one-award finality, of applying to set aside the award for 'violation of statutory procedure' (Arbitration Law 2025 Revision, Articles 45-50 and 71-74; Fa Shi [2006] No. 7 Article 20; Fa Shi [2018] No. 5 Article 14)
A challenge may be filed, but 'formerly or currently serving as standing legal counsel' is not an automatic hit among the statutory challenge grounds; it must land on item (2) of Article 46 of the Arbitration Law (2025 Revision, effective 1 March 2026), 'has an interest in the case', or item (3), 'has other relations with a party or representative in the case, likely to affect impartial arbitration'. The time limit follows Article 47: raised before the first hearing, or, where the ground becomes known afterwards, before the close of the final hearing; the decision is made by the president of the arbitration institution (where the president acts as arbitrator in the case, collectively by the other members of the institution, and that decision is final). Rejection of the challenge does not stall the proceedings; the only remedy is to apply, within three months from receipt of the award, to set it aside under Article 71, item (3), 'the composition of the arbitral tribunal or the arbitration procedure violated statutory procedure'; a failure to recuse that ought to have been recused, verified by the court and capable of affecting the impartial outcome, is established under Fa Shi [2018] No. 5, Article 14, but a party who, knowing of the defect, took part or continued in the arbitration without objection is precluded. A new lever in the 2025 Revision: Article 45 for the first time establishes at statute level the arbitrator's written disclosure duty (with a threshold lower than the challenge grounds).
Applicable Codes
- 《中华人民共和国仲裁法》(2025修订,2026年3月1日施行)第四十五条、第四十六条、第四十七条、第四十八条、第四十九条、第五十条
- 《中华人民共和国仲裁法》(2025修订)第五章 第七十一条、第七十二条、第七十三条、第七十四条
- 《最高人民法院关于适用〈中华人民共和国仲裁法〉若干问题的解释》(法释〔2006〕7号)第二十条
- 《最高人民法院关于人民法院办理仲裁裁决执行案件若干问题的规定》(法释〔2018〕5号)第十四条
- 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》第二百三十七条第二款第三项
- 北京仲裁委员会/北京国际仲裁院国内仲裁规则(2026版)第二十六条、第三十五条、第三十六条、第三十七条
Positioning
Where one party discovers that an arbitrator has relations with the other side such as counsel engagement, representation or business cooperation: how to map this onto the statutory challenge grounds of the Arbitration Law, within what time limit, to whom to address it, and what remedy remains after rejection. For situations of challenging an arbitrator, preserving the procedural defect of 'ought to have recused but did not', and linking that to setting aside the award.
Core Conclusions
1. Statutory grounds (Arbitration Law 2025 Revision, Article 46, verbatim) 'An arbitrator must recuse himself, and the parties are likewise entitled to apply for his challenge, in any of the following circumstances: (1) being a party or representative in the present case, or a close relative of a party or representative; (2) having an interest in the present case; (3) having other relations with a party or representative in the present case, likely to affect impartial arbitration; (4) privately meeting a party or representative, or accepting entertainment or gifts from a party or representative.'
2. Layered mapping of 'formerly or currently standing legal counsel'
- Item (1) does not hit: a counsel relationship is a contractual relationship, not one of identity or close kinship. (Note: the 2025 Revision, relative to the 2017 amendment, newly adds the 'representative' himself as a challenge object under this item; the 2017 text read only 'being a party to the present case or a close relative of a party or representative'.)
- Item (2) 'has an interest in the present case': may be argued where the counsel relationship subsists (counsel fees still being collected), or the counsel matters relate directly to the works or settlement in the case (a legal opinion issued on this project, participation in drafting the contract or in settlement negotiations).
- Item (3) 'has other relations with a party or representative in the present case, likely to affect impartial arbitration': the most-used landing point - former or current standing legal counsel, other lawyers of the same firm acting for the opposing party, long-term business cooperation, teacher-student, colleague or superior-subordinate relations. This item requires two elements, 'relation exists + may affect impartiality'; its threshold is lower than item (2), but the institution has room for discretion.
- Item (4) 'private meetings, entertainment or gifts': a counsel relationship is an open contract and does not fall under this item; concrete facts and proof of meetings, banquets or gifts are separately required.
- Practical grading: current tenure (still engaged during the hearing) > engaged within the last three years with involvement in this case or like business > briefly engaged long ago, terminated years ago and unrelated to this case. Institutions mostly do not recognise the last tier, but a written challenge should still be filed for the record - failure to object in time works as preclusion at the later setting-aside or non-enforcement stage (see below).
3. Disclosure duty linked to challenge (Article 45) 'Where circumstances exist that may give rise to justified doubts in the parties about an arbitrator's independence or impartiality, the arbitrator shall timely disclose them in writing to the arbitration institution. The arbitration institution shall notify the parties in writing of the arbitrator's written disclosure and the composition of the arbitral tribunal.' Disclosure adopts the wider standard of 'may give rise to justified doubts', a threshold lower than the challenge grounds, and the two must not be conflated: any 'ought to have disclosed but did not', even if ultimately not constituting a challenge ground, should be fixed as evidence of a procedural defect (written objection + request to record it in the file) for use in the post-award setting-aside proceedings.
4. Time limit for application (Article 47) 'A party applying for a challenge shall state the reasons and raise the application before the first hearing. Where the grounds for challenge become known after the first hearing, the application may be raised before the close of the final hearing.' That is, raise upon learning, at the latest before the close of the final hearing; where the ground is learned before the first hearing, it must be raised before that hearing. Institutional rules shorten this further: for example, Article 36 of the Beijing Arbitration Commission / Beijing International Arbitration Court Domestic Arbitration Rules (2026 edition) states that a party shall, within 10 days of receiving the arbitrator's written disclosure, submit written observations on whether to apply for a challenge; after expiry it may no longer apply for a challenge on matters the arbitrator has disclosed; a challenge application shall be filed in writing within 10 days of receiving notice of selection or appointment of that arbitrator, or within 10 days of learning of the grounds for challenge, stating the reasons and providing the corresponding evidence.
5. Decision procedure (Articles 48, 49) 'Whether an arbitrator is challenged is decided by the president of the arbitration institution; where the president of the arbitration institution acts as arbitrator, whether he is challenged is decided collectively by the other members of the arbitration institution.' Under institutional rules that decision is final (BAC 2026 Rules, Article 36, item (6)), not subject to review or suit; before the decision is made, the challenged arbitrator continues to perform his duties. Where one party applies for a challenge and the other party agrees, or that arbitrator voluntarily withdraws, the arbitrator no longer takes part in the hearing, but this 'does not imply that the grounds for challenge raised by the party are established' (same article, item (5)). Where the challenge succeeds or the arbitrator cannot perform his duties for other reasons, Article 49 governs the re-selection or re-appointment of the arbitrator; a party may request that proceedings already held be conducted anew, subject to the tribunal's decision on whether to permit it.
6. Boundary of the remedy: under one-award finality, only setting aside after the award Arbitration is itself final and the challenge decision is immediately final, so the only path is setting aside after the award is made:
- Arbitration Law Article 71, item (3): 'the composition of the arbitral tribunal or the arbitration procedure violated statutory procedure'; paragraph 2 of the same article: where the people's court, upon examination by a collegial panel, verifies any of the circumstances in the preceding paragraph, it shall rule to set aside; where the award is found contrary to the public interest, it shall rule to set it aside.
- Time limit and examination period: Article 72 - apply within three months of receipt of the award; Article 73 - the people's court shall rule to set aside or to reject within two months of accepting the application; Article 74 - where the court considers re-arbitration possible, it notifies the arbitral tribunal to re-arbitrate within a period and rules to suspend the setting-aside procedure; once the tribunal begins re-arbitration the setting-aside procedure ends, and if the tribunal refuses, it resumes.
- What counts as 'violation of statutory procedure': SPC Interpretation on Several Issues Concerning the Application of the Arbitration Law (Fa Shi [2006] No. 7), Article 20 - circumstances violating the arbitration procedure prescribed by the Arbitration Law or the arbitration rules chosen by the parties, likely to affect the correct decision of the case (the 'Article 58 of the Arbitration Law' cited in that provision is the old numbering, corresponding to Article 71 after the 2025 Revision).
- Failure to recuse and preclusion: SPC Provisions on Several Issues Concerning the Handling by the People's Courts of Enforcement Cases Involving Arbitral Awards (Fa Shi [2018] No. 5), Article 14 - violation of the arbitration procedure prescribed by the Arbitration Law, the arbitration rules chosen by the parties or a special agreement on the arbitration procedure, likely to affect the impartial decision of the case, verified by the court upon examination, is a circumstance under Civil Procedure Law Article 237, paragraph 2, item (3); where a party asserts that an arbitrator ought to have recused under the rules but did not, likely affecting the impartial award, and this is verified upon examination, the court shall support it; but where the applicable arbitration procedure or rules were specifically flagged, and the party knew or should have known they were not observed yet took part or continued in the arbitration without objection, a post-award claim of non-enforcement on the ground of violation of statutory procedure is not supported.
7. Consequences of serious circumstances (Article 50) Where an arbitrator falls under Article 46, item (4) with serious circumstances, or under Article 71, paragraph 1, item (6) (soliciting or accepting bribes, favouritism, perversion of the law in the award), he shall bear legal responsibility according to law, and the arbitration institution shall remove him from the panel.
Scope and Limits
- This card addresses challenge under the Arbitration Law (2025 Revision, effective 1 March 2026); for cases accepted before 1 March 2026 or governed by the old law, the numbering and the 'disclosure duty' rules differ (the 2017 amendment had no standalone arbitrator disclosure clause, and the challenge-grounds clause did not include the 'representative' himself).
- The challenge grounds are statutorily enumerated; institutions have discretion over 'other relations'; 'a lawyer of the same firm acting for the other side' does not by itself constitute automatic challenge at most institutions; it must be argued by reference to whether it is the same team and whether interests are shared.
- Judicial review of setting aside examines only 'whether statutory procedure was violated and the impartial outcome may be affected', not the merits; that a challenge ground fails does not mean the procedure was lawful - the two findings are independent.
- Specific periods in institutional rules (10 days, 15 days and the like) vary by institution; the current rules of the seised institution govern; the institutional clauses cited here are examples only.
Further Reading
- Arbitration Law of the PRC (2025 Revision), chapter IV section 2 'Composition of the Arbitral Tribunal', Articles 42 to 50 (number and selection of arbitrators, disclosure, challenge grounds, challenge time limit, challenge decision, re-selection, removal from the panel); chapter V 'Application to Set Aside an Award', Articles 71 to 74.
- SPC Interpretation on Several Issues Concerning the Application of the Arbitration Law of the PRC (Fa Shi [2006] No. 7), Article 20 (definition of 'violation of statutory procedure').
- SPC Provisions on Several Issues Concerning the Handling by the People's Courts of Enforcement Cases Involving Arbitral Awards (Fa Shi [2018] No. 5), Article 14 (finding of failure to recuse, and preclusion for 'knew but did not object').
- Civil Procedure Law of the PRC, Article 237, paragraph 2, item (3) (the 'violation of statutory procedure' ground for non-enforcement of an arbitral award).
- Beijing Arbitration Commission / Beijing International Arbitration Court Domestic Arbitration Rules (2026 edition), chapter IV: Article 26 (arbitrator duties and declaration), Article 35 (continuous disclosure), Article 36 (10-day challenge limit, decision-maker and finality), Article 37 (replacement of the arbitrator and conducting the proceedings anew).
- Directions of evidence gathering: the counsel contract and payment records, service outputs (legal opinions issued on this project, contract drafting / negotiation records), the firm's website and case-representation information, materials on joint posts or cooperation between the representative and the arbitrator - all fixed in writing in the challenge application.
Keywords
- 仲裁员回避
- 回避事由
- 常年法律顾问
- 仲裁员披露义务
- 申请撤销仲裁裁决
- 违反法定程序
- 仲裁法2025修订