Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-29

The complete procedural rules for applying to the arbitral tribunal for expert assessment of the construction cost in arbitration of project payment disputes: the tribunal's power to initiate assessment, application conditions and scope limits, evidence materials transferred and time limits for proof, advance payment of assessment fees, determination of the assessment period, examination of the assessor at the hearing and preservation of evidence, and remedies to set aside the award after rendition (Arbitration Law (2025 Revision), Articles 56 to 74; GB/T 51262-2017, Chapter 4)

In arbitration of quantity and cost disputes, expert assessment may be applied for, but only to the arbitral tribunal seised of the case - under the Arbitration Law (2025 Revision), Article 56, the parties have only a right to apply; whether to assess and who assesses are decided by the tribunal (it may entrust the assessor agreed by the parties or directly designate one, without the mandatory 'negotiation first' stage of litigation); the application must be limited to the disputed part, be made in writing by the party bearing the burden of proof within the time limit for proof set by the arbitration rules or the tribunal, and be accompanied by advance payment of the assessment fee; a party that does not apply, does not pay in advance or refuses to provide materials bears the consequences of failure of proof (by reference to Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 32); materials for assessment are transferred per the schedule of GB/T 51262-2017 Article 4.2.1 and the assessment institution issues a receipt list; where parties submit materials directly, the entrusting party must determine the time limit for proof (Article 4.3.1), and materials not cross-examined may not serve as assessment materials (Fa [2020] No. 202, Articles 4 and 5); against the assessment opinion the only path is cross-examination -> requesting the assessor to attend the hearing and question with permission -> applying for supplementary or renewed assessment; the award takes effect upon rendition (Article 70), there is no appeal, and the only remedy is to apply under the six grounds of Article 71 to set aside the award within three months of receipt (Article 72), and those grounds do not include 'substantive error of the assessment conclusion'.

Applicable Codes

  • 《中华人民共和国仲裁法》(2025修订)第五十六条、第五十七条、第五十八条、第六十二条至第七十条、第七十一条至第七十四条
  • 《建设工程造价鉴定规范》GB/T 51262-2017 第3.7.1条及表3.7.1、第4.2.1条及附录E、第4.3.1条及附录G
  • 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》法释〔2020〕25号 第二十条、第三十二条、第三十四条
  • 《最高人民法院关于人民法院民事诉讼中委托鉴定审查工作若干问题的规定》法〔2020〕202号 二、对鉴定材料的审查第3~5项
  • 《诉讼费用交纳办法》(国务院令第481号)第十二条(鉴定费谁主张谁负担、不得代收代付,诉讼路径参照)
  • 《最高人民法院关于适用〈中华人民共和国民事诉讼法〉的解释》法释〔2015〕5号(2022修正)第一百二十一条(诉讼路径申请时点对照)

Topic Positioning

In arbitration of project payment settlement disputes (measurement of quantities, build-up of all-in unit rates, cost of completed works), how to apply for construction cost expert assessment, to whom, what materials to submit, how long until the conclusion, how to challenge the opinion, and what remedies exist after the award. This is the procedural track of the arbitration route; it does not resolve substantive questions such as 'should settlement follow the audit result' or 'is the submitted price deemed approved'.

Core Conclusion

1. The power to initiate lies with the arbitral tribunal; the parties have only a right to apply. Arbitration Law (2025 Revision), Article 56: 'A party may apply to the arbitral tribunal for expert assessment on specialised questions for ascertaining facts. Where the tribunal, upon a party's application or on its own judgment, deems assessment necessary for a specialised question, it may entrust an assessor agreed by the parties or an assessor designated by the tribunal. Upon a party's request or the tribunal's requirement, the assessor shall attend the hearing upon the tribunal's notice. A party may, with the tribunal's permission, put questions to the assessor.'

Three operational points differ from litigation:

  1. The application is addressed to the arbitral tribunal (the bench constituted after formation), not to a people's court, nor to the case-filing or business departments of the arbitral institution;
  2. The order of determining the assessor is 'agreement of the parties prevails -> designation by the tribunal as fallback', without the two-stage mandatory 'negotiate -> the court designates on failure' sequence of litigation;
  3. The assessor's attendance at the hearing is conditioned on the tribunal's notice, and questioning requires the tribunal's permission; a review opinion issued by a cost consultant unilaterally engaged before arbitration or outside it is merely evidence submitted by a party and has no effect of an assessment opinion.

2. Application conditions (item-by-item self-check)

  • Occasion: the case has been accepted by the arbitral institution agreed in a valid arbitration agreement;
  • Object: a 'specialised question for ascertaining facts' (e.g. the quantity of a certain part, the price payable for a certain variation or claim), connected to and meaningful for the facts to be proved; facts inferable from common knowledge or rules of experience, determinations of the allocation of responsibility, and questions of law application are unsuitable as assessment items;
  • Scope: assessment only of the disputed part; a blanket application for 'the entire construction cost' is impermissible; undisputed parts are fixed by the measurement and pricing results signed by both parties;
  • Standing: filed by the party bearing the burden of proof on the disputed fact. Consequence of failure of proof (applied by reference in arbitration): Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 32(1) - 'Where the parties dispute specialised questions such as the construction cost, quality or repair cost and the people's court deems assessment necessary, it shall elucidate this to the party bearing the burden of proof. Where that party, after elucidation, fails to apply for assessment, or applies but fails to pay the assessment fee or refuses to provide relevant materials, it shall bear the legal consequences of failure of proof.' Basic evidence for quantity disputes: Article 20 of the same interpretation - 'Where the parties dispute over quantities, confirmation shall follow the site records and other written documents formed during construction. Where the contractor can prove that the employer consented to its construction but fails to provide site records proving the occurrence of the quantities, the actual quantities may be confirmed according to other evidence provided by the parties.'

3. Materials transferred and time limit for proof (GB/T 51262-2017) Article 4.2.1: 'The evidence materials transferred by the entrusting party should include, without limitation: 1 the statement of claim (arbitration application), statement of counterclaim (arbitration counterclaim) and defence, counsel's submissions; 2 the evidence and the Schedule of Evidence Materials for Assessment (format with reference to Appendix E of this code); 3 cross-examination records, hearing records and other case files; 4 other materials the assessment institution deems necessary.' It also provides that 'after receiving the evidence materials, the assessment institution shall issue a receipt list'. Article 4.3.1: where the entrusting party requires the parties to submit evidence directly to the assessment institution, the institution shall request the entrusting party to determine the parties' time limit for proof and promptly issue a letter to the parties (format with reference to Appendix G) requiring submission within that time limit. Material review rules (Fa [2020] No. 202, Part II, sub-items 3, 4 and 5): the court shall inform the parties of the legal consequences of failing to provide assessment materials meeting the requirements; 'materials not cross-examined in court (including supplementary materials) may not serve as assessment materials' (where a party cannot be reached, is served by publication or waives cross-examination, the assessment materials shall be confirmed by the collegial panel); 'materials disputed between the parties shall be determined by the people's court and may not be handed directly to the assessment institution or the assessor for selection'. In arbitration the tribunal presides correspondingly: evidence shall be produced at the hearing and the parties may cross-examine it (Arbitration Law, Article 57).

4. Fees and time limits

  • Fees: the cost assessment itself requires no security; the applicant pays in advance the amount and proportion determined by the tribunal and pays the assessment institution directly; the final burden is determined by the tribunal in the award by responsibility ratio (in litigation, the same principle of 'whoever claims bears, and the court may not collect or pay on their behalf' appears in Article 12 of the Measures for Payment of Litigation Costs).
  • Assessment period: GB/T 51262-2017, Article 3.7.1 - 'the assessment period is determined by the assessment institution and the entrusting party within the periods in Table 3.7.1 according to the construction cost amount involved in the disputed subject of the assessment project, the complexity and other factors', and 'where the assessment institution and the entrusting party otherwise agree on the period for completing the assessment, the agreement prevails'. Timing of application: the Arbitration Law sets no unified period; apply in writing within the time limit for proof set by the arbitration rules or the tribunal (litigation contrast: before expiry of the time limit for proof, Article 121 of the Interpretation on the Civil Procedure Law); the tribunal may refuse a late application.
  • Preservation of evidence: Arbitration Law, Article 58 - 'where evidence may be lost or become difficult to obtain later, a party may apply for preservation of evidence. Upon a party's application, the arbitral institution shall submit the application to the basic people's court at the place where the evidence is located, and the people's court shall handle it timely according to law'; in urgent circumstances, a party to the arbitration agreement may, before applying for arbitration, apply to the court for preservation of evidence under the relevant provisions of the Civil Procedure Law.

5. Challenge paths against the assessment opinion (raise promptly within the procedure) Cross-examination (Article 57: evidence shall be produced at the hearing and the parties may cross-examine) -> requesting or requiring the assessor to attend the hearing and questioning with permission (Article 56, paragraph 3) -> applying for supplementary or renewed assessment (whether to permit lies with the tribunal). Where the assessor relies on materials disputed by a party and not cross-examined, and upon cross-examination they are found unfit to serve as the basis, the opinion made on the basis of those materials may not serve as the basis for finding the facts of the case (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 34).

6. Remedies after the award: one award is final, only application to set aside

  • 'The award takes legal effect from the date of rendition' (Article 70); no appeal; where part of the facts is clear, an advance award may be made (Article 68); the award is made by majority opinion of the arbitrators, and where no majority is formed, by the opinion of the presiding arbitrator (Article 66).
  • Article 71: where a party produces evidence proving that the award falls under one of six circumstances - there is no arbitration agreement; the matters decided exceed the scope of the arbitration agreement or the arbitral institution has no power to arbitrate; the composition of the arbitral tribunal or the arbitration procedure violates the statutory procedure; the evidence on which the award is based is forged; the other party concealed evidence sufficient to affect a fair award; an arbitrator committed solicitation or acceptance of bribes, bent the law for personal gain or perverted the law in arbitrating the case - it may apply to the intermediate people's court at the place where the arbitral institution is located to set aside the award; where the court finds that the award violates the public interest, it shall rule to set it aside.
  • Time limits: Article 72, 'an application to set aside the award shall be filed within three months of receipt of the award'; Article 73, 'the people's court shall, within two months of accepting the application to set aside the award, rule to set aside the award or reject the application'; Article 74, where the court deems renewed arbitration by the arbitral tribunal possible, it notifies the tribunal to re-arbitrate within a certain period and rules to suspend the setting-aside procedure.
  • Separate correction channel: Article 69 (before Article 79) - 'for textual or computational errors in the award, or matters already decided by the arbitral tribunal but omitted from the award, the arbitral tribunal shall correct them; a party may, within thirty days of receipt of the award, request the arbitral tribunal to correct them'.
  • Key reminder: the grounds for setting aside are a closed list of procedure- and evidence-type grounds and do not include 'substantive error of the assessment conclusion'. Attacks on the assessment opinion must therefore be completed promptly within the arbitration procedure (cross-examination, requiring the assessor to attend the hearing, applying for supplementary or renewed assessment); after the award, claiming 'the assessment miscalculated' is generally beyond remedy.

7. Closing modes (may affect the necessity of assessment) After applying for arbitration, the parties may settle themselves; upon reaching a settlement agreement they may request the arbitral tribunal to render an award on it, or may withdraw the arbitration application; after withdrawal, if a party resiles, it may apply for arbitration under the arbitration agreement (Articles 62 and 63). Before rendering the award the tribunal may first mediate, and shall mediate where the parties voluntarily seek it; upon a mediation agreement, a mediation statement is made or an award on the result of the agreement, and the mediation statement has the same legal effect as the award (Article 64); the mediation statement takes effect upon signature and receipt by both parties, and where a party resiles before receipt, the tribunal shall render an award promptly (Article 65).

Scope and Limits

  • This card is the arbitration track; for the litigation track - jurisdiction over cost assessment (construction contract disputes follow the exclusive jurisdiction of immovable-property disputes), negotiation and designation of the assessor, and exclusion of the opinion where the assessor notified refuses to attend - see the cards on litigation procedure; the two rule sets must not be mixed.
  • Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Articles 20, 32 and 34 are litigation rules; in arbitration they serve as persuasive reference for reasoning; whether and how they are followed is affected by the arbitration rules, the practice at the seat and the tribunal's discretion; written grounding should rest first on the Arbitration Law and the rules of the chosen arbitral institution.
  • The Arbitration Law was renumbered as a whole in the 2025 revision; citations must follow the revised numbering and the old numbering may not be carried over; the effective date follows the officially promulgated text.
  • This card only addresses 'may one apply, how to apply, how the procedure runs, and remedies after the award', not the substantive pricing content of the assessment conclusion (pricing basis, application of quota items, fee standards).
  • Access to assessment where the price is agreed by audit result or fiscal review conclusion and the audit conclusion is unissued in time or manifestly inconsistent with the contract (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 13) is a substantive access question; see the cards on audit-based settlement.

Further Reading

Arbitration Law of the PRC (2025 Revision), Chapter 4 'Arbitration Procedure': Article 56 (expert assessment), Article 57 (production at the hearing and cross-examination), Article 58 (preservation of evidence), Articles 59 to 70 (debate, records, dismissal of claims, settlement, mediation, rendition and correction of awards, advance award, effect of the award); Chapter 5 'Application to Set Aside Awards', Articles 71 to 74; GB/T 51262-2017 Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment, Article 3.7.1 and Table 3.7.1 (tiers of assessment periods), Article 4.2.1 with Appendix E (schedule of evidence materials for assessment), Article 4.3.1 with Appendix G (letter format for direct submission to the assessment institution); Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 20 (quantities confirmed by site records and other written documents), Article 32 (failure of proof in assessment), Article 34 (cross-examination of assessment opinions); Fa [2020] No. 202, Part II on the review of assessment materials, sub-items 3 to 5.

Keywords

  • 仲裁法2025修订
  • 工程造价鉴定
  • 向仲裁庭申请鉴定
  • 送鉴证据材料目录
  • 鉴定期限表3.7.1
  • 撤销仲裁裁决
  • 鉴定举证不能
  • 工程量争议签证

Cited By