Settlement subject to government audit conclusion clauses cannot delay settlement indefinitely—the relationship between audit supervision and civil settlement, backstop deadlines in the settlement procedure, and the judicial-appraisal countermeasure under Article 13 of SPC Interpretation II
No. Audit is administrative supervision, not a precondition of civil settlement; a "settlement subject to government audit conclusion" clause only determines the basis for settlement (what number), not the payment deadline (when). Procedural backstops: the employer's overdue failure to reply to or reconcile the final account documents is deemed acceptance (Order 107 Article 16: 28 days absent agreement; GB/T 50500-2024 Article 10.3.8); overdue failure to verify and to issue a payment certificate is deemed acceptance of the payment application (Article 10.3.16); disputes over additional works must not delay settlement of the works within the contract scope (Article 10.1.8). New countermeasure under Article 13 of SPC Interpretation [2026] No. 12: where the parties agree that the price is determined by audit or government fiscal review of project cost results but, for reasons not attributable to the contractor, the result is not issued within a reasonable period (determined by the court absent agreement, but not exceeding one year from the date the contractor submits the final account documents) or is manifestly inconsistent with the contract, the contractor may apply for a construction cost expert assessment (judicial appraisal); where no agreement to settle by audit results exists, the employer's request to determine the price by audit results will not be supported.
Applicable Codes
- 中华人民共和国审计法(2021修正)第二十三条
- 中华人民共和国审计法实施条例(2010修订)第二十条
- 最高人民法院〔2008〕民一他字第4号答复
- 法释〔2026〕12号 建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)第十三条、第二十三条
- 法释〔2020〕25号 建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)第二十一条、第二十七条
- 保障中小企业款项支付条例(2025修订,国务院令第802号)第十二条、第十四条、第三十一条、第三十三条 https://www.mee.gov.cn/zcwj/gwywj/202503/t20250325_1104643.shtml
- 住建部令第16号 建筑工程施工发包与承包计价管理办法 第十八条
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第10.1.8、10.3.5、10.3.8、10.3.16条
Topic Positioning
Where the contract provides that settlement is subject to government audit conclusion or government fiscal review of project cost results, can the employer indefinitely delay settlement payment on the ground that "the audit is incomplete"? This card clarifies the relationship between audit supervision and civil settlement, sets out the backstop deadlines in the settlement procedure, and incorporates the new judicial-appraisal countermeasure under Article 13 of SPC Interpretation [2026] No. 12.
Core Conclusions
No. Audit is administrative supervision, not a statutory precondition of civil settlement: Article 23 of the Audit Law supervises the construction entity's fund management and does not directly bind employer-contractor settlement; the SPC [2008] Min-Yi-Ta-Zi No. 4 reply makes clear that government fiscal review of project cost does not affect the validity or performance of the contract—only an express contractual agreement makes the review conclusion the basis for settlement; Article 11 of the Regulation on Guaranteeing Payments to Small and Medium-sized Enterprises prohibits government agencies, public institutions and large state-owned enterprises from mandating settlement by audit results (unless otherwise agreed in the contract). Even where a valid "settlement subject to government audit conclusion" clause exists, it only determines "at what number settlement is made", not "when payment is made"—the payment obligation falls due as soon as the settlement conditions are satisfied. Procedural backstops: the employer's overdue failure to reply to or reconcile the final account documents is deemed acceptance of the contractor's documents (Order 107 Article 16—28 days absent agreement; GB/T 50500-2024 Article 10.3.8); overdue failure to verify and to issue a payment certificate is deemed acceptance of the payment application, payable at the declared amount (Article 10.3.16); disputes over additional works must not delay settlement of the works within the contract scope (Article 10.1.8). [Interpretation II Article 13 (effective 30 June 2026)] Where the employer and the contractor agree that the contract price is determined by the audit result of the audit authority or the review conclusion of the government fiscal review body: (1) if the audit result or review conclusion is not issued within a reasonable period for reasons not attributable to the contractor, or the contractor has evidence that it is manifestly inconsistent with the construction contract, the people's court shall grant the contractor's application for a construction cost expert assessment (judicial appraisal); (2) where no reasonable period is agreed, the court determines it comprehensively, but not exceeding one year from the date the contractor submits the final account documents; (3) where the parties did not agree to settle by audit results, the employer's request to determine the contract price by audit results will not be supported. This is the judicial countermeasure outlet for "settlement subject to government audit conclusion" clauses—where the audit is delayed beyond one year, the contractor may apply directly for a construction cost expert assessment (judicial appraisal) and is no longer held hostage by the audit conclusion; together with "overdue non-reply = deemed acceptance" (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 21), these are two weapons on the same front: where the contract contains a deemed-acceptance clause -> settle at the submitted price; where audit is agreed but delayed -> apply for appraisal to bypass the audit.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to settlement disputes in government-invested and SOE-let scenarios. Where the contract expressly makes the audit conclusion the basis for settlement, the validity of that clause is still respected—this card negates only its "payment-delaying" effect. The contractor should serve the final account documents in writing and retain signed proof of receipt in order to start the backstop deadlines. Interpretation II Article 13 applies by time of case acceptance (first-instance construction contract disputes newly accepted by the people's courts after 30 June 2026); applying for a construction cost expert assessment (judicial appraisal) requires proof that the result was "not issued within a reasonable period for reasons not attributable to the contractor" or is "manifestly inconsistent with the construction contract"—the burden of proof lies on the contractor. Audit continues to operate as an administrative supervision procedure under the Audit Law—two separate tracks from civil settlement remedies.
Further Reading
Audit Law, Article 23; SPC [2008] Min-Yi-Ta-Zi No. 4 reply; Regulation on Guaranteeing Payments to Small and Medium-sized Enterprises, Article 11; MOHURD Order No. 107, Measures for the Pricing of Construction Contracting, Article 16; GB/T 50500-2024, Articles 10.1.8, 10.3.5, 10.3.8, 10.3.16; Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 21 (overdue non-reply deemed acceptance); Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 13—official full text on the SPC website https://www.court.gov.cn/zixun/xiangqing/504221.html and the SPC Civil Division I press briefing https://www.court.gov.cn/zixun/xiangqing/504201.html . For the article-by-article impact of Interpretation II on existing rules, see the referenced "Interpretation II impact map" card; for the deemed-acceptance rule itself, see the referenced settlement-acceptance card.
Keywords
- settlement subject to government audit conclusion
- 审计结论作为结算依据
- 财政评审结论
- 法释〔2026〕12号
- 工程造价司法鉴定
- 国务院令第802号
- 逾期不答复视为认可
- 合理期限一年
Cited By
- ←
How construction cost expert assessment handles defective site instruction records (signature proving receipt only without consent, records stating the work item but no quantity or price, verbal instruction only without physical evidence, certification out of time), the evidentiary force of pricing vouchers, and the paths of proof and corroboration
A defective site record is not automatically void; it is handled on three tiers. Where the employer only signed to prove receipt without indicating consent and the contractor can prove the work was completed, the expert assessor may issue an assessment opinion and list it separately for the entrusting party to judge (GB/T 51262-2017, Article 5.9.2, Item 1). Where the record states the work item but contains neither quantity nor price, the parties negotiate first; failing that, the assessor issues an inferential opinion under the principles and methods agreed in the contract (Item 2). Where there is only a verbal instruction, the employer does not acknowledge it and no physical evidence exists, a negative assessment is issued on the ground of lack of legal evidence (Article 5.9.3). Documents signed by on-site management personnel within their scope of duties are valid vouchers for construction pricing unless other valid evidence exists or falsity is proven by verification (GB/T 50500-2024, Article 12.2.1); where the employer fails to provide verification or review results within the time limit, the record content is deemed approved (Article 7.5.5); absent site records, actual quantities may be confirmed by other evidence (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 20); for off-contract sundry items where the contractor fails to apply for a site instruction record within 7 days, the responsibility for a dispute arising after construction rests with the contractor (Cai Jian [2004] No. 369).
- ←
Judging the code non-compliance of 'cut only, never add' in final account review, the clause basis for the contractor's claim to symmetric upward review (the full-review method, objective and fair deliverables, two-way quantity-difference pricing, BOQ errors on the employer), and the entrances for upward adjustment and the written-objection remedy
'Cut only, never add' has no code basis: GB/T 51095-2015 clause 8.3.5 requires the full-review method for final account review, barring key, sampling or analogy methods, and clause 1.0.3 requires fair stand, conduct, procedure, method and deliverables; T/ZBD 100.5-2023 clause 4.2.3 requires the review report to state the disallowed and the added prices and rates with item-by-item reasons. The quantity-difference rules are themselves two-way: GB 50500-2013 clause 9.6.2 lowers the all-in rate on the added part beyond +15% and raises it on the remaining part beyond -15%; GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.2.1 splits at 15% (inclusive / exclusive) with the mirrored pricing of clauses 8.9.1 and 8.9.2. The accuracy and completeness of unit-rate work-item lists rest on the employer (clause 3.1.8) - the normative entrance for upward review - but the contractor must file itemised written objections within the agreed time, silence being deemed acceptance (clauses 10.3.8, 10.3.10).
- ←
Whether the employer may refuse to pay for additional works when the actual investment in a government-funded project exceeds the approved estimate: the estimate as an administrative control instrument, who bears the duty to apply for an estimate adjustment, attribution of the causes of overruns, and risk allocation under an EPC lump-sum contract
In principle it may not. The verified investment estimate is an administrative investment-control indicator for a government-funded project, not a cap on the civil contract price nor a condition of payment. Article 23 of the Regulation on Government Investment Projects (State Council Decree No. 712) places the duty to apply for an estimate adjustment on the project unit (the employer); its failure to file the application cannot be turned against the contractor. Whether the price can be adjusted truly turns on the cause of the overrun: employer-instructed variations, raised standards, errors in basic data, and major policy, price or geological changes are payable; contractor design defects, omissions and pricing errors are borne within the lump sum. Failure of the audit or the government fiscal review likewise does not automatically ground a defence ([2008] Min Yi Ta Zi No. 4; Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Art. 13).
- ←
Independence of the employer's payment obligation where fiscal funds for a government-invested project are not disbursed in place: the fiscal appropriation relationship is not a payment condition; funds must be secured in place and contractors must not be required to advance financing (Articles 19, 22 and 34 of the Government Investment Regulation; Article 8 of the SME Payment Regulation, State Council Order No. 802); validity grading of pay-after-appropriation clauses (30 days, 60-day maximum, for state organs and public institutions; large enterprises must not condition payment on third-party payment; invalidity under Fa Shi [2024] No. 11; fiction of condition fulfilment under Articles 153 and 159 of the Civil Code); audit and fiscal review fix only the settlement amount, not the payment date; interest accrual and demand documentation
Payment can be demanded. Non-disbursement of fiscal funds is a budget-appropriation relationship between the employer and the finance authority, not a payment condition or an exemption vis-a-vis the contractor: the payment obligation arises from acceptable completion and the contract (Articles 799, 579 and 465 of the Civil Code). Article 19 of the Government Investment Regulation requires the finance department to disburse 'promptly and in full', Article 22 requires funds to be secured in place and prohibits building on contractor advance financing, and Article 34(5) lists requiring the contractor to advance financing for a government-invested project among the sanctionable scenarios, so proceeding while the funds are absent is itself the employer's violation. As to pay-after-appropriation clauses: where the contractor is a small or medium enterprise and the employer is a state organ or public institution, payment is due within 30 days of delivery, extendable by agreement to no more than 60 days (Article 9(1) of the Order No. 802 Regulation); where the employer is a large enterprise, clauses conditioning payment on receipt of third-party payment or paying in proportion to third-party receipts are void (Article 1 of Fa Shi [2024] No. 11; Article 153(1) of the Civil Code), and a condition long obstructed may be deemed fulfilled under Article 159. Audit or fiscal review only decides how much to settle, not when to pay. Interest runs from the date the payment falls due (Article 27 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25); absent an agreed rate, the loan prime rate applies (Article 26) or 0.05% per day (Article 17 of the Order No. 802 Regulation).
- ←
Procedural rules for applying in construction-cost litigation or arbitration for a person with specialised knowledge (expert assistant) to appear in court: the application time point (before expiry of the evidence-production period), the number (one to two), the mandatory court permission and notice to both parties, the essential contents of the written application (basic particulars and purpose), the questioning and confrontation rules, the nature of the opinions (deemed statements of the party), costs borne by the applying party, and the boundary between the appointed expert, the expert assistant and a cost consultant unilaterally engaged by a party
A party may under Article 82 of the Civil Procedure Law (2023 amendment) apply to the people's court to notify a person with specialised knowledge (expert assistant) to appear in court and give opinions on the expert opinion or on specialised questions; permission rests with the court and a party has no independent power to start it; the application must be made before expiry of the evidence-production period for one or two persons (Article 122(1) of the SPC Interpretation on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law); the person's opinions in court 'are deemed to be statements of the party', are not an independent category of evidence and cannot alone ground the determination of the cost; the related costs are borne by the party making the application (Article 122(3)); and the person may not take part in court activities beyond the specialised questions (Article 123(2); Article 84(2) of the SPC Provisions on Evidence in Civil Procedures).
- ←
The complete procedural rules for applying to the arbitral tribunal for expert assessment of the construction cost in arbitration of project payment disputes: the tribunal's power to initiate assessment, application conditions and scope limits, evidence materials transferred and time limits for proof, advance payment of assessment fees, determination of the assessment period, examination of the assessor at the hearing and preservation of evidence, and remedies to set aside the award after rendition (Arbitration Law (2025 Revision), Articles 56 to 74; GB/T 51262-2017, Chapter 4)
In arbitration of quantity and cost disputes, expert assessment may be applied for, but only to the arbitral tribunal seised of the case - under the Arbitration Law (2025 Revision), Article 56, the parties have only a right to apply; whether to assess and who assesses are decided by the tribunal (it may entrust the assessor agreed by the parties or directly designate one, without the mandatory 'negotiation first' stage of litigation); the application must be limited to the disputed part, be made in writing by the party bearing the burden of proof within the time limit for proof set by the arbitration rules or the tribunal, and be accompanied by advance payment of the assessment fee; a party that does not apply, does not pay in advance or refuses to provide materials bears the consequences of failure of proof (by reference to Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 32); materials for assessment are transferred per the schedule of GB/T 51262-2017 Article 4.2.1 and the assessment institution issues a receipt list; where parties submit materials directly, the entrusting party must determine the time limit for proof (Article 4.3.1), and materials not cross-examined may not serve as assessment materials (Fa [2020] No. 202, Articles 4 and 5); against the assessment opinion the only path is cross-examination -> requesting the assessor to attend the hearing and question with permission -> applying for supplementary or renewed assessment; the award takes effect upon rendition (Article 70), there is no appeal, and the only remedy is to apply under the six grounds of Article 71 to set aside the award within three months of receipt (Article 72), and those grounds do not include 'substantive error of the assessment conclusion'.
- ←
Determining the basis for settlement where the awarded contract fixes the price and a later supplementary agreement switches settlement to the conclusions of government audit or government fiscal review of project cost: sorting supplementary agreements into departure-type, procedural-type and closing-type, the exceptions that can be valid, and the effective reach of audit clauses
In principle the fixed price agreed in the awarded contract is the basis for settlement: a supplementary agreement that changes the pricing method or the settlement method to settlement 'governed by the audit result or the review conclusion' departs from the substantive content of the awarded contract and, under Article 46 of the Bidding Law and Articles 2 and 22 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, has no effect of varying the fixed price. Only three exceptions can be valid: a closing settlement agreement after completion (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 29 excludes cost assessment), a procedural verification provision that keeps the fixed price and the all-in unit rates and does not change the pricing basis, and, on a project not subject to mandatory tendering, an agreement concluded because of objective changes unforeseeable at tendering (Article 23). An audit clause decides only 'which figure applies', not 'when payment falls due': even a valid clause is constrained by the rule of Article 13 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 that 'the reasonable period may not exceed one year from submission of the final account documents', and by the counter-remedy of expert assessment; absent agreement, a request by the employer to settle by the audit result is not supported; government agencies, public institutions and large state-owned enterprises may not force the audit result to be the settlement basis (Article 12 of the Regulations on Ensuring Payment to SMEs, 2025 revision).
- ←
Admission and scope of judicial construction cost expert assessment in fixed lump-sum construction contract settlement disputes: when a full re-assessment of the whole works cost is not supported, and when it should be permitted
In principle, no. Where the contract is valid and provides settlement at a fixed price, and the dispute targets the contract price itself, a party's application for assessment of the whole works cost is not supported (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 28); assessment is likewise refused where a settlement agreement was reached before suit, the final account documents were signed off by both parties, or the contract provided 'deemed approval of the final account documents upon failure to reply in time' and the time limit has lapsed. Even where an assessment proceeds, only the disputed facts are assessed (Article 31), and the fixed lump-sum pricing principle of the contract must be maintained: a 'recalculation from scratch' cannot replace what the contract agreed.
- ←
Application requirements and admissibility review for judicial construction cost expert assessment: the party bearing the burden of proof applies within the specified period and prepays the fee; the matter must be a specialised issue for ascertaining facts; only disputed facts are assessed; the 9 categories of matters for which assessment is not commissioned; cross-examination review of assessment materials and assessment opinions; and special admissibility where pricing is agreed by audit or government fiscal review conclusions
Construction cost expert assessment may be applied for, but the following must be satisfied together: within litigation / arbitration, the party bearing the burden of proof for the facts to be assessed applies in writing before the evidence production period expires or within the period specified by the court and prepays the assessment fee (failure to apply in time, failure to prepay, or refusal to provide materials resulting in the facts being unascertainable leads to the consequence of failure of proof - Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 32; Fa Shi [2019] No. 19, Article 31); the matter is a 'specialised issue for ascertaining facts' and is connected to and meaningful for the facts to be proved (Civil Procedure Law Article 79; Fa Shi [2015] No. 5 Article 121); only disputed facts are assessed (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 31); the case does not fall into the 9 categories of non-commission under Article 1 of Fa [2020] No. 202 (including determinations on allocation of liability, issues of application of law, lie detection, etc.); the assessment materials must be cross-examined in court (Fa Shi [2019] No. 19, Article 34).
- ←
The evidentiary character of a settlement report produced by a cost consultancy unilaterally commissioned by the contractor, and the court's rules for admitting it: its positioning as a private document, admissible scenarios with a comparison table, and the statutory channel by which it is displaced by judicial appraisal (Article 41 of Fa Shi [2019] No. 19; Articles 29 and 30 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25)
A settlement report from a cost consultancy unilaterally commissioned by one party is not an expert opinion but a private document formed on a party's own commission: where the other party raises no objection, or, on cross-examination, makes no valid rebuttal, the court may admit it as the basis for finding facts; where the other party has evidence or reasons sufficient to rebut it and applies for appraisal, the court 'shall permit' under Article 41 of Fa Shi [2019] No. 19, and the report is displaced by the judicial appraisal. Where the parties reached a price-settlement agreement before litigation, or expressly agreed to be bound by a jointly commissioned consultancy opinion, the application for appraisal is not permitted (Articles 29 and 30 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25).
- ←
Initiation and procedural rules of judicial construction cost expert assessment: timing of the application in litigation/arbitration; admissibility review of 'specialised issues'; the competent court; selection of the expert by agreement or by appointment; bearing of the assessment fee; the expert's duty to appear in court and the consequences of refusal; determination of the assessment time limit
Judicial cost assessment cannot be initiated unilaterally before litigation; it can only be sought within litigation or arbitration: in litigation, a written application must be filed before the evidence period expires, and the matter applied for must be relevant and meaningful to the facts to be proven, otherwise the court will not permit it (Civil Procedure Law Article 79; SPC Civil Procedure Interpretation Article 121); in arbitration, apply to the arbitral tribunal (Arbitration Law (2025 revision) Article 56). The expert is determined by agreement of both parties, failing which the court appoints; in arbitration, by the parties' agreement or the tribunal's appointment. The assessment fee follows 'whoever asserts, bears': the court orders the party to pay the institution directly, and may not collect or disburse on its behalf (Measures for Payment of Litigation Fees Article 12). Where the expert refuses to appear after being notified by the court, the opinion may not serve as the basis for finding facts, and the party that paid the fee may demand its return (Civil Procedure Law Article 81). Construction contract disputes are governed by the jurisdiction rules for real-property disputes (SPC Civil Procedure Interpretation Article 28(2)).
- ←
Whether quantities confirmed at the progress-payment stage can be re-measured and reduced at the final account: the line between provisional payment and lock-in (lock-in by signed measurement results, stage settlements absorbed into the final account, rough measurement as no basis for settlement)
No single answer; the determinant is the nature and level of the confirming document, not whether payment has been made: the three confirmations that are provisional in nature - issue of an interim payment certificate, provisional payment, and rough measurement (by physical progress or proportion) - may be re-measured and reduced at the final account (GB/T 50500-2024 Articles 9.1.14 and 9.4.14); once both parties sign the measurement results without limiting them 'for progress payment use only' (Article 7.1.8), or the interim settlement by construction stage documents have been signed (Article 10.2.3, 'the final account must not re-measure or re-price them'), the quantities are locked and may not be reduced, the sole exception being preliminaries and main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions, which must be recalculated under Articles 10.2.7 and 10.3.3; once the final account documents are signed and sealed by both parties, no repeated checking is allowed in any case (Article 10.3.12; Article 19 of MOHURD Decree No. 16).
- ←
The access rules and negative exclusions for a contractor's application for judicial expert assessment of the construction cost where the contract stipulates determination of the price by the government audit result or the government fiscal review conclusion, but that conclusion is manifestly inconsistent with the construction contract (or not issued within a reasonable period for reasons not attributable to the contractor) (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 13)
Yes, but what the contractor obtains is a right of access to judicial expert assessment, not a direct re-pricing by the court under the contract: under Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 13, paragraph 1, where the price is agreed to be determined by the audit result or the fiscal review conclusion and that result is manifestly inconsistent with the construction contract (or not issued within a reasonable period for reasons not attributable to the contractor), the people's court shall permit the contractor's application for judicial expert assessment of the construction cost, and the final price is re-determined by the assessment on the basis of the pricing standards and pricing methods agreed in the contract; the reasonable period follows any agreement, and absent agreement is determined comprehensively by the court but may not exceed one year from the contractor's submission of the final account documents; where pricing by audit/review conclusion was not agreed, the employer's request to determine the price by that conclusion is not supported (paragraph 3). The interpretation takes effect on 30 June 2026 and applies to first-instance cases newly accepted after that date (Article 23).
- ←
Whether the employer's overdue non-reply to the final account documents is deemed acceptance of the submitted amount - the three-requirement test of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 21, and interface with GB/T 50500-2024
Where the contract stipulates 'overdue non-reply is deemed acceptance', under Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 21, the people's court shall support the contractor's claim for settlement per the final account documents (submitted price); three requirements must be met simultaneously: an express contractual stipulation, delivery of complete settlement documents, and no reply within the agreed period. Absent such stipulation, claims based only on ministerial rules or model contract texts containing 'deemed acceptance' wording are not supported by the SPC and the overwhelming majority of courts. GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 10.3.8, points the same way but is a recommendatory national standard that becomes a contractual obligation only when incorporated by the contract; at the rule level, Article 16 of the former MOC Decree No. 107 has been carried over by Article 18 of MOHURD Decree No. 16, with 28 days as the default period absent agreement.
- ←
Reviewing the employer's defence of long-term refusal to pay the project price on the ground that 'the final account is not settled / review is not completed': whether the payment obligation has fallen due (Civil Code Articles 799, 577, 579), the three trigger points for interest on arrears (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 27), settlement at the submitted price requires an 'deemed approval upon failure to respond in time' agreement (Article 21), and the statutory cost of delay (the 18-month priority right, SME payment periods and overdue interest)
Refusal to pay cannot stand. The final account is only the procedure that fixes 'how much is payable'; it is not the condition on which the payment obligation arises: once the works pass completion acceptance, the payment obligation has fallen due, and for works actually delivered, interest on the arrears runs from the date of delivery (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 27); the employer may not indefinitely defer payment on the ground of its own delay in settling. But 'cannot refuse payment' does not mean 'pay the submitted price': only where the contract expressly agrees that 'failure to respond within the agreed period after receipt of the final account documents is deemed approval' may settlement be made at the contractor's submitted price (Article 21); absent such an agreement, the cost is determined through judicial assessment; and clauses making the price 'subject to audit / government fiscal review' cannot drag on indefinitely either -- where the conclusion is not issued within a reasonable period for reasons not attributable to the contractor (no more than one year from submission of the final account documents) or obviously contradicts the contract, judicial assessment may be applied for (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 13).
- ←
Grading the validity of the payment condition 'the works price is paid only after the audit authority's audit conclusion or the government fiscal review conclusion has been obtained' set by employers (including large state-owned enterprises): the divide between validity as a settlement basis and failure as a payment defence, the counter-move of judicial construction cost expert assessment where the audit is overdue or manifestly inconsistent, fictive fulfilment of conditions, and the subject and time boundaries set by the 2025 revision of the Regulation on Ensuring Payment to Small and Medium Enterprises and by Fa Shi [2026] No. 12
Layered conclusions: (1) as a 'settlement basis' - where the contract expressly agrees that the works price is determined by the audit authority's audit result or the government fiscal review institution's review conclusion, it is valid in principle ([2008] Min Yi Ta Zi No. 4; Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 13(1)); (2) as a 'payment condition' - in principle not upheld: audit is administrative supervision, not a statutory precondition of civil payment, and the agreement can only fix 'at what figure to settle', not suspend the payment obligation indefinitely; (3) where audit-based pricing is not agreed, the employer's request to determine the price by the audit result is not supported (Article 13(3)); (4) where it is agreed but the result is not issued within a reasonable period (at most one year from submission of the completion final account documents) for causes not attributable to the contractor, or is manifestly inconsistent with the contract, the people's court shall permit the contractor's application for judicial construction cost expert assessment (Article 13(1) and (2)); (5) where the employer improperly prevents fulfilment of the condition for its own benefit, the condition is deemed fulfilled (Civil Code Article 159); (6) where the contractor is a small or medium enterprise and the employer is an organ, a public institution or a large state-owned enterprise, from 1 June 2025 the employer may not compel use of the audit authority's audit result as the settlement basis (State Council Decree No. 802, Article 12; the old regulation's 'unless otherwise agreed in the contract' proviso is deleted), may not delay payment on the ground of awaiting final-account audit (Article 14), and overdue interest runs at the agreed rate, no lower than the 1-year LPR, or at 0.05 percent per day where not agreed (Article 17).
- ←
Start point of the exercise period (18 months at most) of the contractor's priority right to payment for construction works - determining 'the date the project price ought to be paid': where the payment date was varied by agreement due to objective causes, take the varied date; where a settlement agreement expressly fixes the date, take that date (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 21); where neither exists, the three presumptions of Article 27 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, and the effective-date threshold of Article 23
The exercise period of the priority right is 18 months at most, running from 'the date the project price ought to be paid', with the start point determined in sequence: (1) where the payment date agreed in the contract was varied by agreement for objective causes such as extension of time, take the varied date (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 21, paragraph 1); (2) where the contract is silent or unclear but the settlement agreement expressly fixes the payment date, take that date (Article 21, paragraph 2); (3) where neither exists, presume under Article 27 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25: works delivered - the date of delivery; not delivered - the date of submitting the final account documents; neither delivered nor settled - the date of filing suit. Article 21 settles only the start point and does not alter the 18-month length of the period; the interpretation took effect on 30 June 2026 and applies to first-instance cases newly accepted after that date.
- ←
Validity of 'back-to-back' clauses by which a large enterprise and an SME agree that 'payment is conditional on receipt of payment from a third party (the owner)' or that 'payment is made in proportion to the owner's payment progress' (void); handling of the payment period and overdue interest after nullity (three-step determination of the period + the 60-day / 30-day benchmarks and starting points under Article 9 of the Regulation + Article 27 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 on the starting point of interest + Article 21 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 on the starting-point rule); and the boundaries of applicable parties and temporal effect
Void (nullity is limited to that clause). Under Article 1 of Fa Shi [2024] No. 11, where a large enterprise agrees with an SME in construction, goods procurement or services that receipt of third-party payment is the precondition of payment, the clause violates Articles 6 and 8 of the Regulation on Ensuring Payment to SMEs (Articles 7 and 9 after the 2025 revision) and is void under Article 153(1) of the Civil Code; 'payment in proportion to the owner's payment' and disguised formulations are equally void. After nullity the original payment period is treated as not agreed: first a supplementary agreement; failing that, the period is reasonably determined under Article 510 of the Civil Code and Article 2 of the Reply, by reference to industry norms and trade usage (direct application of item 4 of Article 511, 'performance at any time', is inappropriate), with the statutory day counts of Article 9 of the Regulation as the benchmark - large enterprises 60 days from delivery, government agencies and public institutions 30 days (agreed periods capped at 60 days), counted from the date of delivery / passing acceptance (delayed acceptance: from expiry of the agreed acceptance period) / confirmation of the settled amount by both parties. Interest: as agreed if agreed; if the agreement is unlawful or absent, at the one-year LPR (Article 2 of the Reply); Article 17 of the Regulation separately provides that the agreed rate shall not be lower than the one-year LPR at the time of conclusion and that, absent agreement, 0.05% per day applies. Interest runs from the date the works price falls due; where the payment time is not agreed or is unclear, it is determined under the three situations of Article 27 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25.
- ←
Checklist of payment compliance obligations under the Regulation on Ensuring Payment to Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (2025 revision, State Council Decree No. 802): 30-day and 60-day-maximum payment terms for state organs and public institutions and 60-day terms for large enterprises, and the starting points of those terms; prohibition of third-party payment conditions; delayed acceptance treated as expiry of the term; prohibition of compulsory commercial bills of exchange; no compelling use of audit conclusions as the settlement basis; security limited to four types and not restricted to cash; overdue interest at 0.05% per day; payment of undisputed portions first; and information disclosure requirements
State organs and public institutions must pay within 30 days of delivery of the goods, works or services, and where the contract provides otherwise, the term may never exceed 60 days; large enterprises must pay within 60 days and may not agree that receipt of payment from a third party is a condition of payment, nor pay SMEs in proportion to the progress of a third party's payment (Article 9). The payment term runs from the date of passing inspection or acceptance, or from the date the parties confirm the settlement amount under progress-based or periodic settlement; where a state organ, public institution or large enterprise delays inspection or acceptance, the term runs from the expiry of the agreed inspection or acceptance period (Article 10). The agreed overdue interest rate may not be lower than the 1-year LPR at the time of conclusion of the contract; failing agreement, interest accrues at 0.05% per day (Article 17). In project construction only four types of security may be collected - tender security, performance security, works quality retention money and migrant worker wage security - and they may not be restricted to cash; guarantee letters from financial institutions must be accepted (Article 13); state organs, public institutions and state-owned large enterprises must not compel the use of the audit authority's audit conclusion as the basis for settlement (Article 12).
- ←
Payment time limits under the 2025 revision of the Regulation on Ensuring Payment to Small and Medium-sized Enterprises: 30 days (60 days at most) for state organs and public institutions, 60 days for large enterprises, when the period starts (acceptance and settlement), the ban on back-to-back clauses, the four permitted securities, and interest on overdue payment (1-year LPR floor / 0.05% per day)
Under the Regulation on Ensuring Payment to Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (2025 revision, State Council Decree No. 802): where state organs and public institutions procure works and the like from small and medium-sized enterprises, payment must be made within 30 days from delivery, and any contractual agreement may not extend the limit beyond 60 days; large enterprises must pay within 60 days and may agree periods reasonably per industry norms, but may not make payment conditional on receipt of third-party payment; where payment is by progress or periodic settlement, the payment period runs from the date the parties confirm the settled amount, and where acceptance is a payment condition, from the date of passing acceptance - or, where acceptance is delayed, from the expiry of the agreed acceptance period. Late payment attracts interest on overdue payment: an agreed rate may not be lower than the 1-year LPR at the time of contracting; absent agreement, 0.05% per day.
- ←
The overlap of the two routes of 'deemed approval of the submitted final account upon failure to reply in time' and 'applying for judicial construction cost expert assessment' when the employer delays the audit or the government fiscal review: comparison of requirements, whether both may be asserted, and how to plead primary and alternative claims
The two routes may be raised side by side but only as layered primary and alternative claims; they cannot stand as two simultaneously granted claims, nor can the higher of the submitted price and the expert assessment price be taken: asserting 'deemed approval' (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 21) means the price is already determined under the contract, applying for expert assessment (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 13) means the price is undetermined and must be recalculated - their substantive effects are mutually exclusive; and Article 29 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 bars an application for construction cost expert assessment where a settlement agreement was reached before litigation, so on adjudication only one of the two can stand. Where no period is agreed, the reasonable period under Article 13 is fixed by the court in the round, but must not exceed one year from the contractor's submission of the final account documents.
- ←
Finality of a confirmed final account and subsequent price re-adjustment: principles, exceptions, and the audit/government fiscal review boundary
A final account confirmed by both parties' signatures and seals is in principle final: the employer may not demand re-checking (GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 10.3.12), neither party should claim for pre-settlement events (Clause 8.11.22), and a countersigned final account cannot be unilaterally overturned by either party (DB42/T 823-2021, Clause 8.1.5). Adjustable exceptions: a supplementary agreement by mutual consent, other statutory provisions, grounds for rescission of the final account, an express contractual provision that settlement is subject to the audit/government fiscal review conclusion, and post-settlement or mutually confirmed omissions. Audit and government fiscal review are administrative supervision and in principle cannot automatically overturn a confirmed final account, unless the contract expressly states that the audit/review conclusions govern.
- ←
Effect of signed-off interim settlements by construction stage on the final account: the no-re-measurement and no-re-pricing principle, statutory exceptions that can overturn it, submission and deemed-approval rules for late response, and a clause comparison linking the two settlements (GB/T 50500-2024 + Cai Jian [2022] No. 183)
Except that preliminaries and main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions shall be recalculated under Clauses 10.2.7 and 10.3.3, interim settlement documents by construction stage signed and confirmed by both employer and contractor form part of the final account documents, and the final account shall not re-measure or re-price them. Where the contract provides that interim stage settlement amounts serve as the basis for the final account, after dual sign-off the employer may no longer engage another cost consultant to repeat the check. The only openings to break the lock-in are: fraud, gross mistake, obvious unfairness, duress (Civil Code Articles 147/148/150/151; preclusive periods of 1 year or 90 days, 5 years at most), lack of authority of the confirming party, invalidity of the basis of confirmation, contractual exclusion of the lock-in, statutory recomputation items (preliminaries and main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions), and other provisions of laws and regulations (government fiscal review or audit alone is not a ground for overturning).
- ←
The "double 80%" rule for progress-payment and in-process settlement payment ratios: GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 9.1.7 and 10.2.4 vs GB 50500-2013 Clause 10.3.7 (60%-90%)
GB/T 50500-2024 raises the payment floor from 2013's 60% to 80% and removes the 90% cap, forming "double 80%": progress payments (9.1.7) - where the contract is silent, preferably not below 80% of the cumulative completed work value; in-process settlement payments (10.2.4, new in 2024) - not below 80% of the current in-process settlement amount. The two 80s differ in force: the progress-payment one is a fallback when the contract is silent ("preferably not below"); the in-process one is a floor that contractual agreement cannot breach ("shall not be below").
- ←
Start point and time chain of final account handling: starts once taking-over is passed; deadlines for each link and the 28-day fallback
Final account handling starts once the whole contract works pass taking-over (completion acceptance) (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 10.1.4): the contractor submits the final account documents within the agreed period; the employer checks and replies within the agreed period, and failure to reply in time is deemed acceptance; objections must be raised within the reply period and negotiated; if negotiation fails, a construction cost consultancy is engaged to carry out the review. Where the contract is silent on these periods, each is deemed to be 28 days (Ministry of Construction Order No. 107, Article 16); the review period runs from the employer's receipt of complete final account documents; the project completion summary final account is compiled within 15 days after the last single-project final account is reviewed and confirmed, and is reviewed within 30 days after submission to the employer.
- ←
Preventing over-settlement and duplicate settlement of subcontracted quantities: dual-signature locking of measurement + interim settlement by construction stage merged into the final account + the list of items not measured
Preventing over-settlement/duplicate settlement relies on procedural control rather than account-checking error correction: measurement results, once signed and confirmed by both parties, are locked as the basis for settlement (GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 7.1.7/7.1.8); signed interim settlement by construction stage documents are merged into the final account and are not re-measured or re-priced (Clause 10.2.3); after dual signing of the final account no repeated checking is allowed (Clause 10.3.12); quantities with unapproved commencement reports, failed acceptance, beyond the construction drawings, unlawful subcontracting or contract transfer (re-letting of the whole works), rework, etc. are not measured at all (TB 10402-2019 Clause 6.0.6 and others).
- ←
"Measures for the Administration of Pricing of Construction Contracting and Subcontracting" edition history: MOHURD Order No. 16 (current) vs. the repealed MOC Order No. 107 — final account rules compared
The current edition is MOHURD Order No. 16 (effective 2014-02-01), whose Article 27 repealed the former MOC Order No. 107. The final account rules moved from old Order 107 Article 16 into current Article 18, with main changes: the trigger point changed to "after completion of the works"; state-funded vs. non-state-funded procedures distinguished (for state-funded projects the employer must engage a cost-consulting enterprise to review); overdue non-response is handled first per the contract, deemed acceptance only absent agreement; the 28-day fallback retained but national rules applied first; the mediation target for objections changed from the county-level-or-above construction administrative department to the engineering-cost management agency or industry organization.
- ←
Works in use but final account not processed: quality disputes go to warranty, final account proceeds (GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 10.3.14)
Works already in use cannot have the final account delayed on grounds of "not taken over / quality objections": GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 10.3.14 provides that for works having passed taking-over (completion acceptance) or subject to premature use of the works without taking-over by the employer, quality disputes are handled under the warranty contract/clauses and the final account is processed as agreed in the contract; the supporting path is notice of demand -> overdue non-check deemed acceptance (Order No. 107, Article 16; 28 days absent agreement) -> interest on overdue payment (Decree No. 728, Article 15; 0.05% per day absent agreement) -> negotiation/arbitration/litigation.
- ←
Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 "Construction Interpretation II" and its overall impact on existing judicial interpretations, statutes, and pricing/appraisal standards (23 articles, effective 30 June 2026)
The SPC "Interpretation (II) on the Application of Law in Cases of Construction Contract Disputes" (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, adopted at the 1969th meeting of the Adjudication Committee on 17 March 2026, effective 30 June 2026, 23 articles) does not wholesale-repeal the current "Interpretation (I)" (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25), but per its Article 23 — "for construction contract dispute cases newly accepted at first instance by the people's courts after this Interpretation takes effect, this Interpretation applies ... where earlier SPC interpretations are inconsistent with this Interpretation, this Interpretation prevails" — provisions inconsistent with Interpretation I yield to the new one. Major changes: mandatory-tender projects not tendered are no longer automatically void (Art. 1); pre-bid substantive negotiations void the awarded contract (Art. 2); "audit-as-basis" narrowed (Art. 13 — unsupported absent agreement; with agreement, judicial appraisal available if results are overdue beyond 1 year or manifestly inconsistent); fixed prices not adjusted for major labor/material changes (Art. 9); lump-sum contracts priced proportionally upon termination (Art. 10); standstill/idle losses enjoy no priority right (Art. 17); etc.
- ←
Reconciling accounts receivable and contract settlement data: cross-validation between the financial ledger and the commercial ledger
Taking the contract as the smallest reconciliation unit and unifying the tax-inclusive/tax-exclusive basis, reconcile receivables through four layers: ledger-vs-voucher checks — periodic reconciliation with the employer — aging analysis — bad debt provisions; settlement runs the closed loop of "submission — verification — recheck — confirmation" per GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 10.3.6–10.3.12, where failure to reply within the agreed time is deemed acceptance and the consultant's conclusion is tri-party signed.
- ←
Settlement review vs fiscal appraisal vs audit: subject, nature, object, and effect
The final account is a civil-contract act of employer and contractor (checking and confirming the final account documents); fiscal appraisal is the finance department's administrative supervision of fiscally invested funds; audit is the audit institution's statutory audit supervision of government-invested projects under the Audit Law. Fiscal appraisal and audit conclusions in principle do not affect the validity of the employer-contractor contract, unless the contract expressly makes them the settlement basis.
- ←
Can final account review/audit adjust awarded all-in unit rates? — rate locking under re-measurable contracts, statutory exceptions, and the limits of audit authority
In principle, no. Under a re-measurable (unit-rate) contract, awarded all-in unit rates within the contractual risk range remain fixed at final account review; the review checks each rate item by item against the priced bill of quantities (BOQ); absent other contractual agreement, rates adjust only upon adjustment events such as variations, errors and omissions in the BOQ, quantity deviations exceeding 15%, changes in costs beyond the risk range, and substitution of provisional sums. Government fiscal review of project cost / audit is administrative supervision and does not affect contract validity — its conclusions serve as the basis for settlement only where the contract expressly provides that they do so.
- ←
Responding to an employer that long delays final account review: the deemed approval upon lapse of the response period and the escalating remedy ladder
Where the employer fails to check or respond to the final account documents within the prescribed time, the documents are deemed accepted per Ministry of Construction Order No. 107, Article 16 and GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 10.3.8 (response period 28 days absent agreement; the review period runs from the employer's receipt of the complete final account materials); the contractor may then assert deemed acceptance of the payment application (Clause 10.3.16), interest on overdue payment (State Council Decree No. 728: no less than the 1-year LPR or 0.05% per day), a cost consultancy's separately issued review report, administrative mediation, and finally arbitration or litigation.
- ←
Validity of "settlement per government audit results" clauses in government-invested projects, and drafting guardrails (deadlines / pricing basis / re-review / payment segregation)
The audit clause itself is valid: government fiscal review of project cost does not affect contract validity (SPC [2008] Min-Yi-Ta-Zi No. 4), and Regulation on Payment to SMEs Article 11's "unless otherwise agreed by contract" endorses voluntarily included audit clauses. But a "bare clause" (just "per audit") is risky for the contractor; a sound clause needs four guardrails: (1) a fixed audit deadline, overdue = acceptance of the submitted settlement; (2) locked pricing basis—audit must not alter the contract's pricing method or all-in unit rates; (3) objection to reductions reviewable by a third party; (4) audit binds only the final account balance, not progress payments.
- ←
Impairment risk assessment for projects completed but long unsettled: a two-step method of recoverable amount measurement and aging matrix
Two-step impairment assessment for completed-but-unsettled projects: individually, recoverable amount = expected settlement amount × (1 − expected reduction rate) ÷ (1 + discount rate)^(expected recovery years), providing for the shortfall below carrying amount; in bulk, provide by aging matrix (>3 years at 50% is a common reference). Link with the legal levers of "deemed acceptance upon overdue silence + limitation-period interruption + overdue interest" to compress the impairment exposure.
- ←
Definition, classification hierarchy, and bases for handling the final account for construction works (GB/T 50500-2024)
The final account is the total-price settlement handled by the employer and contractor in accordance with the contract after the works pass taking-over (completion acceptance), and is the aggregation of interim settlements by construction stage (China's 2020-introduced staged settlement system, with no exact international equivalent); it is composed level by level from unit works -> single works -> project final account. Unless otherwise agreed in the contract, the amounts in the interim settlement by construction stage shall serve as the basis for the final account; the basis for settlement comprises five categories — contract documents; as-built drawings and variation documents; technical data and material-substitution approvals; pricing documents and bills of quantities (BOQs); and mutually confirmed site instructions / variation records and claim documents.