Can final account review/audit adjust awarded all-in unit rates? — rate locking under re-measurable contracts, statutory exceptions, and the limits of audit authority
In principle, no. Under a re-measurable (unit-rate) contract, awarded all-in unit rates within the contractual risk range remain fixed at final account review; the review checks each rate item by item against the priced bill of quantities (BOQ); absent other contractual agreement, rates adjust only upon adjustment events such as variations, errors and omissions in the BOQ, quantity deviations exceeding 15%, changes in costs beyond the risk range, and substitution of provisional sums. Government fiscal review of project cost / audit is administrative supervision and does not affect contract validity — its conclusions serve as the basis for settlement only where the contract expressly provides that they do so.
Applicable Codes
- T/ZBD 100.5-2023 · Work Guideline for Settlement Audit of Construction Works 第1.1.7条、第3.1.6条
- GB/T 51095-2015 · Code for construction cost consultation 第8.2.5条
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第8.1.1条、第8.2.1条、第8.9.1条、第8.9.2条、第10.3.10条、第10.3.12条
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023 · Work Guideline for Construction Cost Appraisal 第4.4.4条
- DB42/T 823-2021 · Specification for Quality Control of Construction Cost Consulting (Hubei) 第8.1.5条
- 最高人民法院(2008)民一他字第4号《关于人民法院在审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件中如何认定财政评审中心出具的审核结论问题的答复》
- 法工备函〔2017〕22号、国法秘备函〔2017〕447号
Topic Positioning
This card addresses a frequent dispute at the final account stage: can final account review (popularly "settlement audit") directly adjust awarded all-in unit rates? It sets out the rate-locking rule under re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts, the statutory exceptions permitting adjustment, the boundary of government fiscal review of project cost / audit authority, and the procedural limits on settlement — for cost consultancy, final account review, project audit, and contract settlement disputes.
Core Conclusions
1. Basic rule: awarded all-in unit rates within the contractual risk range are fixed; the review checks item by item and does not re-price.
- T/ZBD 100.5-2023, 3.1.6(2): "For all-in unit rates of BOQ items within the construction contract, check item by item whether they are consistent with the all-in unit rates in the priced bill of quantities in the contract. Where a variation alters an item in the priced bill of quantities, the all-in unit rate for that item shall be adjusted in accordance with the relevant provisions of the current national standard. Absent other contractual agreement, all-in unit rates shall not be adjusted in other circumstances. Where cost fluctuation exceeds the risk range, adjustment may be made by reference to Clause 3.1.7 of these Guidelines."
- GB/T 51095-2015, 8.2.5: the final account shall be prepared by the method corresponding to the contract type — lump-sum contract: adjust the agreed adjustable contents and risk factors beyond the agreed range on the basis of the contract price; re-measurable (unit-rate) contract: "all-in unit rates within the contractual risk range shall remain fixed, measured in accordance with the contract and by the quantities actually completed"; cost-plus contract: calculate cost, fee and relevant taxes per the contract method.
- T/ZBD 100.5-2023, 1.1.7: final account review is the activity of confirming the contract price between employer and contractor; confirmation and adjustment of the contract price must have legal, contractual and factual bases.
2. Exceptions permitting adjustment of all-in unit rates at settlement.
- Adjustable events (GB/T 50500-2024, 8.1.1): errors and omissions in the BOQ, provisional sums, provisional sums for specified materials / nominated works, main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions, dayworks, changes in costs, changes in laws, regulations and policies, variations, additional works, claims, and other adjustment events agreed between employer and contractor.
- Where a variation or BOQ error or omission alters an item, or the billed quantity changes by <= 15% (inclusive): determine the all-in unit rate per 8.9.1 — billed items with identical item descriptions under identical construction conditions use the corresponding contract rate; similar descriptions under identical conditions, or identical descriptions under similar conditions, use the contract rate for a similar billed item converted and adjusted; where descriptions or conditions differ, a reasonable market all-in unit rate is determined by negotiation, taking account of the implementation, the pricing rules for similar contract rates and the pricing level; where deletion or cancellation of a billed item significantly changes the construction conditions, a varied all-in unit rate may be determined by negotiation.
- Quantity change > 15% (exclusive): per 8.9.2 — for increases in items and quantities, reasonably reduce the contract rate and the new all-in unit rate, taking account of the effect of discounts on labour and material procurement prices; for decreases in items and quantities, reasonably increase them, taking account of the loss of procurement discounts.
- Re-measurement for errors and omissions in the BOQ: per 8.2.1, with the 15% threshold determining whether 8.9.1 or 8.9.2 applies.
- Other rate adjustments in final account review (T/ZBD 100.5-2023, 3.1.6): provisional unit rates for materials and equipment, and employer-supplied materials, are adjusted per the prices confirmed by both parties and by reference to the contract's adjustment principles (item 4); where materials or equipment actually used differ from those agreed, the all-in unit rate may be adjusted per the contract's principles (item 3).
- Construction cost expert assessment (judicial appraisal) approach (T/ZBD 100.4-2023, 4.4.4): where a party to a re-measurable (unit-rate) contract requests adjustment of an all-in unit rate, the assessment follows the contract terms, limited to — (1) provisional sums for specified materials / nominated works: substitute the employer-certified equipment or material unit price, or the contractor's actual tender award price, for the provisional sum and adjust the all-in unit rate; (2) changes in costs: where the contract provides the risk range and adjustment principles, follow the contract; where only adjustability is provided without range or method, follow the pricing documents of the industry authority; where the contract expressly excludes adjustment, the contract prevails (unless the principal determines the contract or clause invalid and requires otherwise); (3) mismatch of item description (same drawing edition at tender and at construction); (4) quantity deviation exceeding the contractual band, or, absent an agreed band, per the national standard or industry practice.
3. Boundary of government fiscal review of project cost / audit authority: administrative supervision does not of itself alter the contractual settlement.
- Supreme People's Court reply (2008) Min Yi Ta Zi No. 4: "Fiscal appraisal of government-invested construction is the State's supervision and administration of the employer's capital construction funds; it does not affect the validity or performance of the contract between the employer and the contractor. However, where the construction contract expressly provides that the fiscal appraisal conclusion serves as the basis for settlement, that conclusion shall serve as the basis for settlement."
- Fa Gong Bei Han [2017] No. 22 and Guo Fa Mi Bei Han [2017] No. 447: "Provisions in local regulations that directly make audit results the basis for the final account, or that require this to be stated in tender documents or agreed in the contract, restrict civil rights and exceed local legislative authority; they should be corrected."
- That is: government audit / fiscal review cannot unilaterally overturn contract rates, and directly amending awarded rates lacks any basis; audit reductions can generally only be achieved through the contractual and factual routes of quantity reductions and review of variations / certifications / adjustment events; audit conclusions bind the settlement only where the contract expressly provides that "the audit (review) conclusion serves as the basis for settlement".
4. Procedural limits on settlement.
- GB/T 50500-2024, 10.3.12: once the final account check is completed and signed and sealed by both employer and contractor, the employer shall not require the contractor to repeat the check with any other construction cost consultant; unless otherwise provided by law or regulation, the final account documents signed and sealed by both parties shall take effect in accordance with the contract.
- GB/T 50500-2024, 10.3.10: where the consultant's checked result differs from the contractor's final account documents, it shall be submitted to the contractor for review; if the contractor raises no written objection within the agreed time, the checked final account documents are deemed accepted.
- DB42/T 823-2021, 8.1.5: for projects whose settlement review has reached consensus and been joint-signed on a settlement cost confirmation form, a de facto settlement agreement is formed and neither party may unilaterally overturn it; unless provided by law or consented to by the counterparty, other construction cost consultancy firms should not take on repeated settlement review (re-audit, review, re-check) of the same project for the same employer.
Applicable Boundaries
- Applies to: final account review / audit of works under re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts; lump-sum and cost-plus contracts follow the adjustment rules for their own contract types.
- The core premise is "absent other contractual agreement": where the contract provides for adjustable rates or makes the audit conclusion the basis for settlement, the contract governs.
- Adjustment bands and risk ranges follow the contract first; where the contract is silent, the national standard (GB/T 50500-2024, with 15% as the threshold) or industry practice applies.
- Fiscal review / audit conclusions do not serve as the basis for settlement unless expressly provided in the contract; a signed and sealed settlement shall not be re-checked (unless otherwise provided by law or regulation or agreed by the parties).
- This card does not cover the calculation of specific adjustment amounts or the treatment of regional quota norms and percentage rate differences; specific settlement disputes should be determined in light of the contract and the complete project records.
Further Reading
- T/ZBD 100.5-2023, 3.1.6 (final account review method for re-measurable contracts, also covering preliminaries, other items, and deductions for free-issue materials), 1.1.7 (operating principles).
- GB/T 50500-2024: 8.1.1, 8.2.1, 8.9.1, 8.9.2, 10.3.10, 10.3.12 (the "no repeat check" rule in Clause 11.3.8 of the 2013 edition is carried forward in Clause 10.3.12 of the 2024 edition).
- GB/T 51095-2015, 8.2.5 (final account prepared by contract type).
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023, 4.4.4 (assessment approach for adjustment of all-in unit rates under re-measurable contracts).
- DB42/T 823-2021, 8.1.5 (limits on repeated settlement review).
- Supreme People's Court reply (2008) Min Yi Ta Zi No. 4 (16 May 2008); Legislative Affairs Commission of the NPC Standing Committee, Fa Gong Bei Han [2017] No. 22; Legislative Affairs Office of the State Council, Guo Fa Mi Bei Han [2017] No. 447.