Judging the code non-compliance of 'cut only, never add' in final account review, the clause basis for the contractor's claim to symmetric upward review (the full-review method, objective and fair deliverables, two-way quantity-difference pricing, BOQ errors on the employer), and the entrances for upward adjustment and the written-objection remedy
'Cut only, never add' has no code basis: GB/T 51095-2015 clause 8.3.5 requires the full-review method for final account review, barring key, sampling or analogy methods, and clause 1.0.3 requires fair stand, conduct, procedure, method and deliverables; T/ZBD 100.5-2023 clause 4.2.3 requires the review report to state the disallowed and the added prices and rates with item-by-item reasons. The quantity-difference rules are themselves two-way: GB 50500-2013 clause 9.6.2 lowers the all-in rate on the added part beyond +15% and raises it on the remaining part beyond -15%; GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.2.1 splits at 15% (inclusive / exclusive) with the mirrored pricing of clauses 8.9.1 and 8.9.2. The accuracy and completeness of unit-rate work-item lists rest on the employer (clause 3.1.8) - the normative entrance for upward review - but the contractor must file itemised written objections within the agreed time, silence being deemed acceptance (clauses 10.3.8, 10.3.10).
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第2.0.27、3.1.8、8.2.1、8.9.1、8.9.2、10.3.8、10.3.10、10.3.12条
- GB 50500-2013 · Code of Valuation with Bill Quantity of Construction Works 第4.1.2(强制性条文)、9.4、9.5、9.6.1、9.6.2、9.6.3、11.3.6条
- GB/T 51095-2015 · Code for construction cost consultation 第1.0.3、8.3.5、8.3.8条
- T/ZBD 100.5-2023 · Work Guideline for Settlement Audit of Construction Works 第1.4.7、3.1.4、4.2.3条
- GB/T 51262-2017 · Code for Construction Cost Appraisal 第5.5.1条
- DB42/T 823-2021 · Specification for Quality Control of Construction Cost Consulting (Hubei) 第8.3.10条(引 CECA/GC 7-2012 第9.3.4条)
- 住房和城乡建设部令第50号《工程造价咨询企业管理办法》(2020修正)第五条
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第六条、第七条、第四百六十六条
- 法释〔2026〕12号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第十三条、第二十三条(自2026年6月30日起施行)
- 法释〔2020〕25号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第十九条、第二十一条
- (2008)民一他字第4号《最高人民法院关于人民法院在审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件中如何认定财政评审中心出具的审核结论问题的答复》
- 财建〔2004〕369号《建设工程价款结算暂行办法》第十五条、第十六条
- 国务院令第802号《保障中小企业款项支付条例》(2025修订)第三十一条、第三十三条
Positioning
When final account review (the employer's own check or a commissioned cost consultant's review) 'cuts only, never adds', on what the contractor claims symmetric review: the clauses, the lawful triggers for upward adjustment, the procedure that must be followed, and the judicial reception. For BOQ-priced construction contracts at the final account stage.
Core conclusions
1. Conclusion first: cut-only has no code basis and breaches three rules at once
- Review method unlawful. GB/T 51095-2015 clause 8.3.5: 'Final account review shall use the full-review method. Save as otherwise agreed in the consultancy contract, key review, sampling review, analogy review and other methods shall not be used.' Commentary: 'to reflect the final cost fully and accurately and avoid disputes, full review is mandated and other methods strictly forbidden.' Cutting items only and skipping omitted or under-counted quantities is a unilateral truncation of the review scope.
- Professional principles unlawful. Clause 1.0.3: 'cost consultancy shall uphold legality, independence, objectivity, fairness and good faith' - 'fairness' read as fair stand, conduct, procedure, scientific method and deliverables; 'objectivity' as comprehensive, true, accurate and objective outputs. MoHURD Order No. 50 (2020) Article 5 the same.
- Deliverable form fails. T/ZBD 100.5-2023 clause 4.2.3 makes the report body state item 6 - 'submitted, approved, disallowed / added prices and rates' with internal consistency - item 7 - differences and reasons by division and discipline (quantities, prices, determination principles, liability) - and item 8 - explanations for incomplete or contested bases. A report with a zero addition column and no stated reason fails the form. A verifiable quality test: DB42/T 823-2021 clause 8.3.10 (from CECA/GC 7-2012 clause 9.3.4) - where a party disputes and withholds signature, 'on the same basis, the comprehensive error of the final account review result shall be within plus or minus 3%'.
2. The quantity-difference rules are two-way (the arithmetic of symmetry)
GB 50500-2013 clause 9.6.1: 'where the measured quantities deviate from the tender BOQ and clauses 9.6.2 / 9.6.3 are met, the employer and the contractor shall adjust the contract price' - the parties, not the reviewer alone. Clause 9.6.2: 'for any tender BOQ item, where deviation from quantity difference and variation exceeds 15%, adjustment applies: quantities increased over 15% - the all-in rate of the increased part is lowered; reduced over 15% - the rate of the remaining part is raised.' Both legs, symmetrical. Clause 9.6.3: rate- or single-price preliminaries rise with quantity growth and fall with reduction - two-way as well. GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.2.1 (the BOQ-error entrance, unit-rate): re-measure the work-item list per clause 7.2.1 against the contract drawings; item or quantity changes within 15% (inclusive) price under 8.9.1; beyond 15% (exclusive) under 8.9.2. Clause 8.9.1 (within band): five bands by 'item description x construction conditions' - same conditions and description, the contract rate; like description or conditions, the like rate converted; and so on down to negotiated market-reasonable rates. Clause 8.9.2 (beyond band, the symmetry core): added items and quantities - per 8.9.1 'combined with the labour and material purchase discounts of the larger volume, reasonably lowering the contract and new rates'; reduced - 'combined with the loss of those discounts, reasonably raising them.' The two drafting structures mirror exactly; the rules turn on neither side's commission, and reviewers are bound by them.
3. BOQ-error liability - the normative basis of upward review
Term: clause 2.0.27 - 'BOQ errors': differences in itemisation, description or quantity between the work-item list and the contract drawings and specification, including extra items, omissions, mismatched descriptions, quantity deviations and the like. Liability: clause 3.1.8 - 'unit-rate contracts: the accuracy and completeness of the work-item list rest with the employer; lump-sum: with the contractor; priced-by-item preliminaries lists always with the contractor.' Commentary: under unit-rate the employer answers for item completeness, description accuracy and quantity accuracy, tenderers may not alter them. The old mandatory clause (for contracts signed under it): GB 50500-2013 clause 4.1.2 - 'the tender BOQ must form part of the tender documents; its accuracy and completeness rest with the tenderer' - mandatory, strictly enforced. With it: section 9.4 (description mismatch - re-price per the as-built description under 9.3); section 9.5 (omitted items priced per 9.3.1, omitted preliminaries first on an approved scheme). Review practice: T/ZBD 100.5-2023 clause 3.1.4(4): 'omissions in the employer's tender BOQ settle per the as-built drawings and the parties' certified quantities on the contractual pricing basis, into the work-item or preliminaries costs - save lump-sum lists the tenderer was allowed to adjust and price.'
4. Lawful triggers of upward review (three main entrances + linked items)
- BOQ errors (omissions, mismatched descriptions, quantity deviation): employer's liability under unit-rate (3.1.8 / 2013's 4.1.2) - re-measure per 8.2.1 via 7.2.1, split at 15%, price under 8.9.1 or 8.9.2.
- Drawings-have / list-has-not quantities (omitted, under-counted): also BOQ errors. First test 're-measure or not' - T/ZBD 100.5-2023 clause 3.1.4(3): unit-rate contracts without re-measurement or interim settlement re-compute quantities from the settlement drawings; where re-measurement or interim settlement occurred, none save by mutual consent; unexecuted works found at completion deduct under either form. The clause opens the upward (re-measurement) and the downward (deduction) doors alike - neither may be applied selectively.
- Correcting wrong measurement rules: GB/T 51262-2017 clause 5.5.1 - with complete drawings and disputed bases, the expert appraiser measures per the current national codes (sector or local absent; contractual rules excepted). Under-counts from wrong editions, volumes or rules are corrections, not 'new claims'.
- Linked adjustments: preliminaries follow quantity moves (2013's 9.6.3); variations, additional works, claims, provisional-price confirmations and policy changes are all upward channels - always on quantities confirmed per clauses 7.1, 7.2 and 7.4.
5. Procedural iron law: written objection first, symmetry second
Silence is acceptance. Clause 10.3.10: 'where the employer commissions a consultant's check, the consultant's confirmed result is deemed the employer's... the contractor failing to object in writing within the agreed time is deemed to have accepted the checked final account.' Clause 10.3.8: the employer failing to check or comment in time is deemed to have accepted the contractor's file. 2013's 11.3.6 says it more bluntly; Cai Jian [2004] No. 369 Article 16 likewise. So step one is not arguing symmetry but filing an itemised, quantified, evidenced written objection within the agreed time (28 days as the customary fallback): per omission or under-count - the item code or name, the drawing basis (sheet, part), the quantity per the contractual measurement rule, the proposed rate and its clause. If the objection stands overridden: T/ZBD 100.5-2023 clause 1.4.7 - the professional reviews independently, disputes are discussed with the commissioning and dissenting parties together, baseless demands to alter the report may be refused, and the dissent is recorded and stated in the report: 'confront - record - state' - demand a tripartite checking meeting and the recording of the dissent in report item 8. Signature and separate issue: GB/T 51095-2015 clause 8.3.8 - the review conclusion is signed jointly by employer, contractor and consultant; failing joint signature over substantive disagreement, the consultant may issue its review book alone and answer for it. The conclusion is no unilateral award - a missing signature means no 'confirmed' effect. Dispute channel: clause 10.3.12 - once both parties sign and seal the completed check, no repeated check by another consultant; conversely, an unsigned account remains open to dispute resolution.
6. Judicial reception
- Audit or fiscal review conclusions do not bind absent agreement. Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 13(3): no agreement to settle by audit or fiscal review - the employer's claim on those conclusions fails.
- Agreed, but late or plainly off - judicial appraisal lies. Article 13(1)-(2): agreed conclusions unduly late without the contractor's fault, or proven plainly contrary to the contract - the contractor's application for judicial appraisal of the cost is granted; the reasonable period defaults by scale and complexity, never beyond one year from submission.
- Fiscal review positioned: the (2008) Min Yi Ta Zi No. 4 reply - fiscal review supervises state construction funds and touches neither validity nor performance, save express contractual agreement to settle by it.
- Pricing-standard disputes: Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 19 - agreed standards govern; design changes leaving quantity or standard unagreed may settle by the local standards current at contracting.
- Two-way quantity logic in judgments: (a) 2013's 9.6.2 and 2024's 8.9.1/-2 mirroring directly ground 'quantity differences adjust both ways' - a cut-only review departs from the codes; (b) unit-rate list accuracy on the employer (4.1.2 mandatory) bars treating omissions as contractor concessions; (c) Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 21 with the deemed-acceptance rules (express clause + complete service + silence in time) favours the contractor.
- Public-law tightening: the SME Payment Regulation (Order No. 802, 2025) Articles 31 and 33 - audit-as-basis demands without legal ground, or payment refusals pending filing or completion-record audit, draw correction orders and sanctions; the same for large state enterprises.
- Civil-code roots: Article 6 (fairness), 7 (good faith) and 466 (contract interpretation) - a cut-only reading of the review-scope clause may be attacked by interpretation per the contract's terms, nature, purpose and good faith.
Applicable boundaries
- The two-way rules bind unit-rate contracts. Under lump-sum, work-item lists are the contractor's (3.1.8) and upward review lives mainly in agreed adjustable matters (variations, provisional prices, policy); preliminaries lists are the contractor's under either form - no upward claim from their errors.
- Full review carries 'save as the consultancy contract provides': an agreed scope governs first, but agreement neither ousts mandatory clauses and objective fairness nor reads silence as cuts-only.
- The 15% thresholds: exactly 15% falls inside 8.9.1; only beyond 15% (exclusive) takes 8.9.2; 2013's trigger reads 'exceeds 15%'.
- Upward review is conditional - BOQ errors, variations, wrong measurement rules or claims, with quantities confirmed per 7.1 / 7.2 / 7.4; a mere mismatch between settlement and contract totals is no ground.
- GB 50500-2013 is superseded by the recommended GB/T 50500-2024; cite the edition the contract signed under; Order No. 107's current force must be verified before use.
- A survey of codes and case rules, not legal advice on any case; limitation, appraisal deadlines and priority rights need separate verification.
Further reading
- GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 2.0.27, 3.1.8, 8.2.1, 8.9.1, 8.9.2, 10.3.8 / 10.3.10 / 10.3.12.
- GB 50500-2013 clauses 4.1.2, sections 9.4-9.5, clauses 9.6.1~9.6.3, 11.3.6.
- GB/T 51095-2015 clauses 1.0.3, 8.3.5, 8.3.8; T/ZBD 100.5-2023 clauses 1.4.7, 3.1.4, 4.2.3.
- GB/T 51262-2017 clause 5.5.1; DB42/T 823-2021 clause 8.3.10; Order No. 50 Article 5.
- Civil Code Articles 6, 7, 466; Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 13; Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Articles 19, 21; the (2008) reply; Cai Jian [2004] No. 369 Articles 15-16; Order No. 802 Articles 31, 33.
Keywords
- 只审减不审增
- 审减审增对等
- 全面审核法
- errors and omissions in the BOQ
- 工程量偏差15%
- 综合单价调低调高
- 竣工结算审核异议
- 造价咨询客观公正