Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-09-25

Validity of "settlement per government audit results" clauses in government-invested projects, and drafting guardrails (deadlines / pricing basis / re-review / payment segregation)

The audit clause itself is valid: government fiscal review of project cost does not affect contract validity (SPC [2008] Min-Yi-Ta-Zi No. 4), and Regulation on Payment to SMEs Article 11's "unless otherwise agreed by contract" endorses voluntarily included audit clauses. But a "bare clause" (just "per audit") is risky for the contractor; a sound clause needs four guardrails: (1) a fixed audit deadline, overdue = acceptance of the submitted settlement; (2) locked pricing basis—audit must not alter the contract's pricing method or all-in unit rates; (3) objection to reductions reviewable by a third party; (4) audit binds only the final account balance, not progress payments.

Applicable Codes

  • 最高法〔2008〕民一他字第4号答复
  • 《保障中小企业款项支付条例》第十一条
  • 《审计法》第二十三条
  • 建设部令第107号第十六条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第10.3.8条
  • 法释〔2020〕25号第21条

Topic Positioning

When a government-invested project contract stipulates that "government audit or government fiscal review of project cost findings serve as the final settlement basis" (colloquially the "per audit" clause): whether the clause is valid, whether it is reasonable, and how to draft it to balance both parties' interests. Applicable to contract review, settlement negotiation, and the handling of audit disputes.

Core Conclusions

Clause validity: audit is administrative supervision, not a precondition of civil settlement. The SPC [2008] Min-Yi-Ta-Zi No. 4 reply confirms that government fiscal review of project cost does not affect contract validity or performance; however, where the contract expressly makes the review conclusion the settlement basis, it shall be applied as the settlement basis; Article 11 of the Regulation on Payment to SMEs prohibits government agencies, public institutions, and large SOEs from compelling settlement by audit results, but "unless otherwise agreed by contract"—audit clauses voluntarily included are valid and the courts respect party autonomy; NPC Standing Committee Legislative Affairs Commission [2017] Fa-Gong-Bei-Han No. 2 corrected mandatory local legislation without negating contractual agreement between the parties.

Reasonableness: a "bare clause" is risky for the contractor, with three pain points: no audit deadline allows the settlement money to hang on the books indefinitely; audit reductions under quota norms/fiscal bases conflict with the contract's BOQ/market-price basis; conclusions are issued unilaterally with no reciprocal re-review. A sound clause should be fitted with four guardrails: (1) a fixed audit issuance deadline, with lapse of that period deemed acceptance of the contractor's submitted settlement; (2) locked pricing basis—the audit verifies only authenticity and compliance and must not change the contract's pricing method or all-in unit rates; (3) agreement that objections to reductions may be re-reviewed by a third-party construction cost consultancy or taken through the dispute-resolution procedure; (4) segregated payments—the audit binds only the final account balance, not progress payments for completed work.

Applicable Boundaries

Applies to government-invested and SOE-let scenarios. Validity decides only "at what figure" the settlement is made, not "when payment is made"—the payment obligation falls due as soon as the settlement conditions are met, and audit delay is no ground for withholding payment. The guardrails presuppose being written into the contract; if not written in, one can only invoke procedural backstops (MOHURD Order No. 107, Article 16; Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 21; GB/T 50500-2024, Article 10.3.8) to counter delay. A contractor that has already signed a bare clause should serve the settlement documents in writing and retain signed proof of receipt so as to start the backstop periods running.

Further Reading

SPC [2008] Min-Yi-Ta-Zi No. 4 reply; Regulation on Payment to SMEs (State Council Order No. 728), Article 11; Audit Law, Article 23 and Implementation Regulations of the Audit Law, Article 20; MOHURD Order No. 107, Article 16; GB/T 50500-2024, Article 10.3.8; Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 21; NPC Standing Committee Legislative Affairs Commission [2017] Fa-Gong-Bei-Han No. 2.

Keywords

Cited By