Settlement review vs fiscal appraisal vs audit: subject, nature, object, and effect
The final account is a civil-contract act of employer and contractor (checking and confirming the final account documents); fiscal appraisal is the finance department's administrative supervision of fiscally invested funds; audit is the audit institution's statutory audit supervision of government-invested projects under the Audit Law. Fiscal appraisal and audit conclusions in principle do not affect the validity of the employer-contractor contract, unless the contract expressly makes them the settlement basis.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准
- GB/T 51095-2015 建设工程造价咨询规范
- 最高人民法院〔2008〕民一他字第4号答复
- 中华人民共和国审计法(2021修正)
- 建设部令第107号 建筑工程施工发包与承包计价管理办法
Topic Positioning
Discriminating three easily confused concepts at the completion stage — final account review, fiscal appraisal, audit — across subject, nature, object, and effect, for positioning concepts in cost practice and contract disputes.
Core Conclusions
(1) Final account review is a civil-contract act: the employer checks, re-checks, and confirms the contractor's final account documents (GB/T 50500-2024, Clauses 10.3.4-10.3.10), may entrust a cost consultancy, and the deliverable, once signed by both parties, serves as the settlement basis (GB/T 51095-2015, Clause 8.3.8). (2) Fiscal appraisal is administrative fund supervision: the finance department's evaluation and review of estimates, budgets, settlements, and final accounts of fiscally invested projects — state administrative supervision that in principle does not affect the validity and performance of the employer-contractor contract (Supreme People's Court reply [2008] Min Yi Ta Zi No. 4), except where the contract expressly makes its conclusions the settlement basis. (3) Audit is statutory audit supervision: audit institutions supervise, per the Audit Law (2021 amendment), Article 23, the budget execution and final accounts of government-invested and predominantly government-invested projects; the object is the owner; conclusions bind administratively but likewise do not automatically alter the contractual settlement relationship. Practical essentials: final account review is a negotiable act between civil equals; fiscal appraisal and audit are government supervision in which the contractor mostly cooperates by providing materials; whether the contract stipulates "settlement per the appraisal/audit conclusions" decides whether those conclusions bind the project payment.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to the completion stage of government-invested and predominantly government-invested projects. The three differ in period rules, objection procedures, and remedies: settlement goes to negotiation/dispute review/arbitration/litigation; appraisal follows fiscal administrative rules; audit follows statutory procedures with rectification. This card only distinguishes concepts; the rule that "audit-based" clauses may not delay settlement is in the related card.
Further Reading
GB/T 50500-2024, Section 10.3 (submission, checking, re-checking, confirmation, deemed acceptance) and Chapter 11 (dispute resolution); GB/T 51095-2015, Sections 8.2, 8.3; Supreme People's Court reply [2008] Min Yi Ta Zi No. 4; Audit Law (2021 amendment), Article 23; Ministry of Construction Order No. 107, Article 16 (28 days absent agreement; overdue deemed acceptance).