The evidentiary character of a settlement report produced by a cost consultancy unilaterally commissioned by the contractor, and the court's rules for admitting it: its positioning as a private document, admissible scenarios with a comparison table, and the statutory channel by which it is displaced by judicial appraisal (Article 41 of Fa Shi [2019] No. 19; Articles 29 and 30 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25)
A settlement report from a cost consultancy unilaterally commissioned by one party is not an expert opinion but a private document formed on a party's own commission: where the other party raises no objection, or, on cross-examination, makes no valid rebuttal, the court may admit it as the basis for finding facts; where the other party has evidence or reasons sufficient to rebut it and applies for appraisal, the court 'shall permit' under Article 41 of Fa Shi [2019] No. 19, and the report is displaced by the judicial appraisal. Where the parties reached a price-settlement agreement before litigation, or expressly agreed to be bound by a jointly commissioned consultancy opinion, the application for appraisal is not permitted (Articles 29 and 30 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25).
Applicable Codes
- 中华人民共和国民事诉讼法(2023修正)第六十六条、第七十一条
- 最高人民法院关于民事诉讼证据的若干规定(法释〔2019〕19号,2019修正)第四十条、第四十一条、第四十二条、第八十七条至第九十七条
- 最高人民法院关于适用《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》的解释(法释〔2015〕5号)第一百零三条至第一百零五条
- 最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)(法释〔2020〕25号)第二十九条、第三十条
- 最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)(法释〔2026〕12号)第十三条、第二十三条
- GB/T 51262-2017 建设工程造价鉴定规范 第4.7节 证据的采用
- GB/T 51095-2015 建设工程造价咨询规范 第9.3.6条
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第10.1.2条
- 建办标〔2021〕26号 住房和城乡建设部办公厅关于取消工程造价咨询企业资质审批加强事中事后监管的通知 第一条
- 财建〔2004〕369号 建设工程价款结算暂行办法 第十五条至第十七条
Positioning
In construction contract disputes, the evidentiary character and admissibility of a settlement report or settlement review report produced by a cost consultancy commissioned unilaterally by the contractor (or the employer) once it enters litigation or arbitration, and the line between 'admission' and 'displacement by judicial appraisal', with the corresponding provisions. For counsel, cost consultants, and settlement and legal staff in evidence evaluation and proof planning.
Core conclusions
1. Character: not an expert opinion, but a private document.
Article 66 of the Civil Procedure Law of the PRC (2023 amendment) divides evidence into eight kinds: '(1) statements of the parties; (2) documentary evidence; (3) physical evidence; (4) audio-visual material; (5) electronic data; (6) witness testimony; (7) expert opinions; (8) records of inspection. Evidence must be verified as true before it can serve as the basis for finding facts.' An expert opinion is formed on commission by a court or arbitral tribunal; an opinion produced on a party's own commission can only pass through the documentary-evidence (private document) channel.
2. Authenticity and probative force of private documents.
Article 92 of the SPC Provisions on Evidence in Civil Procedure (Fa Shi [2019] No. 19): 'The authenticity of a private document is borne as a burden of proof by the party relying on it to prove the facts of the case. A private document bearing the signature, seal or thumbprint of its maker or of the maker's agent is presumed authentic. A private document containing deletions, alterations, additions or other formal defects - the people's court shall assess its probative force in the light of the concrete circumstances of the case.' Formal regularity thus raises a presumption of authenticity, but probative force is a separate question; the negative list of Article 90 ('cannot alone serve as the basis for finding the facts of a case': statements of the parties, testimony disproportionate to a witness's capacity, testimony of interested witnesses, questionable electronic data, copies unverifiable against originals) does not include such reports, so there is no automatic exclusion, though in practice corroboration with other evidence is normally required.
3. The statutory 'rebuttal + appraisal application' channel.
Article 41 of Fa Shi [2019] No. 19: 'Where a party has, on a specialised question, obtained on its own commission an opinion from an institution or person, and the other party has evidence or reasons sufficient to rebut it and applies for appraisal, the people's court shall permit the application.' This is the only routine route by which the effect of a unilaterally commissioned report is overturned - both 'evidence or reasons sufficient to rebut' and 'an application for appraisal' are required; bare denial, without rebutting evidence or an appraisal application, gives the court no duty to initiate appraisal.
4. Admission compared.
| Scenario | Conclusion | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| The other party expressly accepts the report, or raises no substantive objection on cross-examination | To be confirmed; may serve as the basis for finding facts | Fa Shi [2019] No. 19, Articles 89, 92 |
| Both parties jointly commissioned the opinion before litigation and expressly agreed to be bound by it | The appraisal application is not permitted; the cost is determined by that opinion | Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 30, proviso |
| A price-settlement agreement was reached before litigation (including settlement review reports or cost confirmation forms signed by both parties, partial signing included) | A later application for appraisal by one party is not permitted | Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 29 |
| The other party merely denies generally, neither rebutting with evidence nor applying for appraisal | The court may admit it together with other evidence; no duty to initiate appraisal | Fa Shi [2019] No. 19, Article 41 a contrario; Articles 87, 88 |
| The report was compiled under the pricing basis and pricing method agreed in the contract, with quantity take-off sheets, price bases and the registered cost engineer's signature and seal complete | High admissibility; may ground the court's assessment or part of an appraisal | Fa Shi [2019] No. 19, Article 87; GB/T 51095-2015, 9.3.6 |
| The other party has evidence or reasons sufficient to rebut it and applies for appraisal | To be permitted; the report is displaced by the judicial appraisal | Fa Shi [2019] No. 19, Article 41 |
| The report has formal defects - alterations, no signature or seal, no calculation process | Not automatically excluded, but probative force much weakened; for the court's overall assessment | Fa Shi [2019] No. 19, Article 92(3) |
| Seeking to negate the report wholesale because 'the consultancy lacks a qualification' | Unavailing - approval of construction cost consultancy enterprise qualifications ceased from 1 July 2021; administrative organs, enterprises, public institutions and industry bodies may not require proof of qualification | Jian Ban Biao [2021] No. 26, Article 1 |
| The report was jointly commissioned pre-litigation but one party rejects it and no binding agreement was made | The appraisal application is to be permitted (even a joint commission does not automatically bind; a unilateral commission cannot rank higher) | Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 30, main text |
5. Interface with the 're-appraisal' rules.
A unilaterally commissioned report is not an expert opinion, so 're-appraisal' does not apply; once the court has commissioned an appraisal and an expert opinion exists, overturning it proceeds under Article 40 of Fa Shi [2019] No. 19: 'Where a party applies for re-appraisal and any of the following exists, the people's court shall permit it: (1) the appraiser lacks the requisite qualification; (2) the appraisal procedure is seriously unlawful; (3) the appraisal opinion is manifestly insufficiently grounded; (4) other circumstances in which the opinion cannot be used as evidence. Under items (1) to (3), the appraisal fees already collected by the appraiser shall be refunded; if refund is refused, Article 81(2) of these Provisions applies. Where the defects of the appraisal opinion can be resolved by correction, supplementary appraisal, or supplementary or renewed cross-examination, the people's court shall not permit the application for re-appraisal. On re-appraisal, the original appraisal opinion may not serve as the basis for finding the facts of the case.'
6. Appraisal admission where an audit / government fiscal review clause exists.
Article 13 of the SPC Interpretation (II) on Construction Contract Disputes (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12): 'Where the employer and the contractor agree that the project price is to be determined by the audit result of an audit organ or the review conclusion of a government fiscal review institution, but the audit result or review conclusion is not issued within a reasonable period for reasons not attributable to the contractor, or the contractor has evidence proving that the audit result or review conclusion manifestly contradicts the construction contract, and the contractor applies for judicial appraisal of the construction cost, the people's court shall permit it. The reasonable period in the preceding paragraph is as agreed by the parties; absent agreement, the people's court determines it comprehensively by the scale of the works, the amount of the construction cost and the complexity, but the period may not exceed one year from the contractor's submission of the final-account documents. Where the employer and the contractor did not agree that the project price is determined by the audit result of an audit organ or the review conclusion of a government fiscal review institution, and the employer requests determination of the project price by the audit result or review conclusion, the people's court will not support it.'
7. The cost-standard side: who compiles, and how the report is used as evidence.
GB/T 50500-2024 (China national pricing standard for BOQ), 10.1.2: 'The final account shall be compiled by the contractor or a construction cost consultant commissioned by it, and checked by the employer or a cost consultant commissioned by it. Where a cost consultant is commissioned to compile or check the final account and a party disputes the quality of the settlement documents issued by the consultant and consultation fails to reach agreement, the matter may be handled as agreed in the contract.' Commissioning a consultant to compile the settlement is itself the regular practice recognised by the standard; the dispute is whether the report is credible, not 'who paid for it'.
Where a settlement review report or settlement review opinion has been issued but disputes remain, GB/T 51095-2015 (Code for Construction Cost Consultancy), 9.3.6: 'For disputed projects for which a final-account review report has been issued or a settlement review opinion has been formed, with the consent of both parties, the parts of the issued review report or review opinion to which neither party objects may be adopted directly' - the matter may be converted into an appraisal on that review report, appraising only the disputed facts and accelerating the appraisal.
GB/T 51262-2017 (Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment), Section 4.7, gives the approach to adopting appraisal evidence: first, cross-examination is a right of the parties, but evidence that has been cross-examined is not necessarily usable as the appraisal basis (it may still be rejected where a party objects or produces contrary evidence); second, determining evidence is the power of the commissioning party, which usually does not determine evidence separately before commissioning the appraisal; third, construction evidence is voluminous and submitted more than once, so each item cannot be cross-examined at the hearing. Hence two operating rules: 'so long as no party objects to the evidence, the appraiser may use it as the appraisal basis'; 'where a party objects to the evidence, or the submitted evidence conflicts, and the commissioning party has made no determination, the appraiser may, on its own professional judgement, issue separate appraisal opinions for the commissioning party to weigh'.
8. The prior cross-examination requirement.
Civil Procedure Law (2023 amendment), Article 71: 'Evidence shall be produced in court and cross-examined between the parties. Evidence involving state secrets, commercial secrets or personal privacy shall be kept confidential and, where it must be produced in court, shall not be produced at a public hearing.' Article 103 of the SPC Interpretation on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law states that 'evidence not cross-examined by the parties may not serve as the basis for finding the facts of the case'; Article 104(2) provides that 'evidence that reflects the true circumstances of the case, is relevant to the facts to be proved, and conforms to law in source and form shall serve as the basis for finding the facts'; Article 105 requires the court to examine evidence comprehensively and objectively and to state openly its reasons on the existence and weight of probative force. The reasons for admitting or excluding evidence in the judgment documents must be stated under Article 97 of Fa Shi [2019] No. 19 (for uncontested evidence, the reasons for admission need not be stated in the judgment).
9. Proof and review points for a unilaterally commissioned report (practice tips).
- The party relying on the report to prove the cost bears the burden of proving the authenticity of the private document (Article 92(1)): produce the original report, the registered cost engineer's signature and seal, the explanatory notes and quantity take-off sheets, the price bases (contract pricing clauses, material price confirmation forms, statements on applying published price information), and the delivery and receipt records.
- The rebutting party must have 'evidence or reasons sufficient to rebut': point out that the pricing basis contradicts the contract, that quantities lack site-instruction-record support, that the price basis is wrong, that items are omitted or double counted, or formal defects such as missing seals or alterations, and at the same time apply for appraisal (without the application, Article 41 produces no effect).
- Risk points: a report lacking the calculation process or the cost engineer's seal, giving only a conclusory total price, or pricing on quota norms where the contract is a fixed lump sum - such defects tilt the court toward permitting appraisal, reducing the report to a reference opinion.
- Even if not admitted wholesale, the report's itemised data can still serve as the basis for direct adoption of uncontested parts or as the appraisal check basis (the GB/T 51095-2015, 9.3.6 approach).
Boundaries of application
- This card covers the evidence review of cost consultancy opinions / settlement reports / settlement review reports produced on a party's own (unilateral) commission; opinions formed on commission by a court or arbitral tribunal (including on the parties' joint application) are outside it and follow the expert-opinion cross-examination and re-appraisal rules (Fa Shi [2019] No. 19, Article 40).
- 'Joint commission + express agreement to be bound' is an exclusion from appraisal (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 30, proviso) and requires written proof of the express submission; mere joint commission without such submission allows a dissenting party to apply for appraisal.
- 'A settlement agreement reached' must be evidenced by settlement documents, settlement agreements or cost confirmation forms signed by both parties; oral or unilateral signing does not qualify (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 29).
- Temporal line: Article 23 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12: 'This Interpretation takes effect on 30 June 2026. First-instance construction contract dispute cases newly accepted by the people's courts after this Interpretation takes effect apply this Interpretation. Where SPC judicial interpretations issued earlier conflict with this Interpretation, this Interpretation prevails.' First-instance cases newly accepted after 30 June 2026 therefore apply its Article 13 on appraisal admission under audit / fiscal review clauses; earlier-accepted cases remain under the Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 framework.
- Whether a report is admitted lies within the court's free assessment of evidence; this card gives the normative admission and exclusion rules, not a guarantee of the admission outcome in any given case.
- The probative force of a unilaterally commissioned report neither rises nor falls with the identity of the commissioning party (contractor or employer), nor with the consultancy's qualification (whose approval has been abolished).
Further reading
- SPC Provisions on Evidence in Civil Procedure (Fa Shi [2019] No. 19, 2019 amendment): Articles 89-97 (Part 5, review and determination of evidence), especially the Article 90 negative list, Article 92 private documents, Articles 93-94 authenticity of electronic data; Articles 40-48 (Part 2, investigation, collection and preservation of evidence), especially Article 40 re-appraisal grounds, Article 41 self-commissioned opinions, Article 42 refund of fees and sanctions on withdrawal of opinions.
- Civil Procedure Law of the PRC (2023 amendment): Article 66 (kinds of evidence), Article 67 (burden of proof), Article 71 (cross-examination).
- SPC Interpretation on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law (Fa Shi [2015] No. 5): Articles 103-105 (cross-examination and evidence review), Articles 112-113 (document production orders and consequences of refusal to produce).
- SPC Interpretation (I) on Construction Contract Disputes (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25): Article 29 (pre-litigation settlement agreement bars appraisal), Article 30 (pre-litigation jointly commissioned consultancy opinion).
- SPC Interpretation (II) on Construction Contract Disputes (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12): Article 13 (appraisal admission under audit / fiscal review clauses), Article 23 (effective date and old-new transition).
- Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment GB/T 51262-2017, Section 4.7 ('adoption of evidence').
- Code for Construction Cost Consultancy GB/T 51095-2015, 9.3.6 (disputed-part appraisal and direct adoption of uncontested parts where a review report has been issued).
- China national pricing standard for BOQ, GB/T 50500-2024, 10.1.2 (who compiles and checks the final account).
- Notice of the MOHURD General Office on Abolishing the Approval of Construction Cost Consultancy Enterprise Qualifications and Strengthening In-process and Ex-post Supervision (Jian Ban Biao [2021] No. 26), Article 1 (approval ceased from 1 July 2021; proof of qualification may not be demanded).
- Interim Measures on the Settlement of Construction Project Prices (Cai Jian [2004] No. 369), Chapter 3, Articles 15-17 (written formalities for site instruction records and claims; approval deemed where no objection to the settlement report within the time limit; payment periods for settlement money).
Keywords
- 单方委托造价咨询
- 结算报告采信
- 私文书证
- 鉴定意见
- 法释〔2019〕19号第四十一条
- 重新鉴定
- 法释〔2020〕25号第三十条
- 书证质证