Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-29

Cross-examination rules for appraisal materials in construction cost judicial appraisal: whether materials not cross-examined may serve as the appraisal basis, whether an opinion formed on them may serve as the basis for finding the facts of the case (the judgment), the statutory scenarios of 'cure', and the boundary of re-appraisal

In principle, no. Article 34(1) of Fa Shi [2019] No. 19: 'Materials not cross-examined may not serve as the basis for appraisal'; Article 34 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25: 'Where the appraiser uses materials that are disputed between the parties and not cross-examined as the appraisal basis, the people's court shall organise the parties to cross-examine those materials. Where on cross-examination they are found unfit to serve as the appraisal basis, the appraisal opinion made on the basis of those materials may not serve as the basis for finding the facts of the case.' The exclusion is limited to the part of the opinion 'made on the basis of those materials', not the whole opinion. Only three kinds of scenario can be cured and admitted: later supplementary cross-examination with acceptance; waiver of cross-examination / inability to contact / service by public notice confirmed by the collegial panel; and acceptance at the pre-trial preparation stage deemed cross-examined (or both parties raising no objection).

Applicable Codes

  • 法释〔2019〕19号《最高人民法院关于民事诉讼证据的若干规定》第二十四条、第三十条至第四十二条(尤其第三十四条、第三十七条至第四十条)
  • 法释〔2020〕25号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第三十一条、第三十三条、第三十四条
  • 法〔2020〕202号《最高人民法院关于人民法院民事诉讼中委托鉴定审查工作若干问题的规定》二、对鉴定材料的审查 第3~5条
  • 法释〔2015〕5号《最高人民法院关于适用〈中华人民共和国民事诉讼法〉的解释》(2022修正)第一百零三条
  • 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第七十一条
  • 《中华人民共和国仲裁法》(2025修订,2026年3月1日施行)第五十六条、第五十七条 https://policy.mofcom.gov.cn/claw/clawContent.shtml?id=103718
  • 法释〔2026〕12号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第十三条、第二十三条(2026年6月30日施行)
  • GB/T 51262-2017 · Code for Construction Cost Appraisal 第4.4.1条、第4.7节

Positioning

In judicial appraisal in construction contract disputes (cost, time, quality), whether the appraisal materials must first be cross-examined by the parties, whether an appraisal opinion formed on uncross-examined materials can serve as the basis of a judgment, the statutory scenarios that can be 'cured', and the boundary between cross-examination defects and re-appraisal. Applies to both the litigation and the arbitration route.

Core conclusions

1. Principle: uncross-examined materials cannot serve as the appraisal basis, and an opinion formed on them cannot serve as the basis of a judgment.

  • Article 34(1) of Fa Shi [2019] No. 19 (SPC Provisions on Evidence in Civil Procedure): 'The people's court shall organise the parties to cross-examine the appraisal materials. Materials not cross-examined may not serve as the basis for appraisal.' Paragraph 2 of the same article: 'With the permission of the people's court, the appraiser may collect evidence, inspect the physical evidence and the site, and question the parties or witnesses.'
  • Article 34 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 (Construction Contract Interpretation (I)): 'The people's court shall organise the parties to cross-examine the appraisal opinion. Where the appraiser has used materials that are disputed between the parties and not cross-examined as the appraisal basis, the people's court shall organise the parties to cross-examine that part of the materials. Where on cross-examination they are found unfit to serve as the appraisal basis, the appraisal opinion made on the basis of those materials may not serve as the basis for finding the facts of the case.'
  • The key qualifier is 'made on the basis of those materials': what is excluded is the part of the appraisal opinion corresponding to the uncross-examined materials, not the whole opinion voided wholesale. Where separable item by item, only the corresponding items are excluded; only where the appraisal procedure as a whole is seriously unlawful (for example, no cross-examination organised at all) does the matter fall within an application for re-appraisal.
  • Cross-examination is a precondition for the admissibility of the appraisal materials - a question of admissibility, not of probative force that can be reinforced afterwards.

2. The general legal source of the cross-examination duty.

  • Civil Procedure Law of the PRC (2023 amendment), Article 71: 'Evidence shall be produced in court and cross-examined between the parties. Evidence involving state secrets, commercial secrets or personal privacy shall be kept confidential and, where it must be produced in court, shall not be produced at a public hearing.'
  • Article 103 of Fa Shi [2015] No. 5 (SPC Interpretation on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law): 'Evidence shall be produced in court and cross-examined between the parties. Evidence not cross-examined by the parties may not serve as the basis for finding the facts of the case. Evidence that the parties accepted at the pre-trial preparation stage is, after explanation by the adjudicators at the hearing, deemed evidence that has been cross-examined. Evidence involving state secrets, commercial secrets, personal privacy or confidentiality required by law may not be cross-examined in public.'

3. The court's three review requirements for the appraisal materials (Part 2, 'Review of the appraisal materials', of Fa [2020] No. 202, Provisions on Issues concerning the Review of Commissioned Appraisal in Civil Proceedings of the People's Courts).

  • Item 3: 'The people's court shall strictly review whether the appraisal materials meet the appraisal requirements, and shall inform the parties of the legal consequences of failing to provide appraisal materials that meet the requirements.'
  • Item 4: 'Materials (including supplementary materials) not cross-examined in court may not serve as appraisal materials. Where a party cannot be contacted, is served by public notice or waives cross-examination, the appraisal materials shall be confirmed by the collegial panel.'
  • Item 5: 'For materials disputed between the parties, the people's court shall determine them, and may not hand them directly to the appraisal institution or the appraiser for selection.'

4. The court's duties at the commissioning stage and the appraisal scope.

  • Article 33 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25: 'After permitting a party's application for appraisal, the people's court shall, according to the party's application and the needs of ascertaining the facts of the case, determine the matters, scope and time limit of the commissioned appraisal, and organise the parties to cross-examine the disputed appraisal materials.'
  • Article 31 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25: 'Where the parties dispute only part of the facts of the case, only the disputed facts are appraised, except where the scope of the disputed facts cannot be determined, or both parties request an appraisal of all the facts.'

5. Affirmative scenarios (admissible after cure).

  1. Later supplementary cross-examination with acceptance: the court organises cross-examination on that part of the materials; where after cross-examination they may serve as the basis, that part of the appraisal opinion is admissible (Article 34 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, second sentence).
  2. Waiver of cross-examination / inability to contact / service by public notice: the appraisal materials shall be confirmed by the collegial panel (Fa [2020] No. 202, Item 4(2)).
  3. Accepted at the pre-trial preparation stage: after explanation by the adjudicators at the hearing, deemed evidence that has been cross-examined (Article 103(2) of Fa Shi [2015] No. 5).
  4. Neither party objects: Section 4.7 of GB/T 51262-2017 (Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment): 'So long as no party objects to the evidence, the appraiser may use it as the appraisal basis, which both respects the parties' rights and ensures the efficiency of the appraisal'; 'Where a party objects to the evidence, or the evidence submitted conflicts, and the commissioning party has made no determination, the appraiser may, on its own professional judgement, issue separate appraisal opinions for the commissioning party to weigh and use.'
  5. Supplementary evidence cross-examined and determined by the commissioning party: GB/T 51262-2017, 4.4.1: 'During the appraisal, the appraiser may, as required by the appraisal, request the commissioning party to notify the parties to supplement the evidence; for supplementary evidence that the commissioning party has organised to be cross-examined and determined, the appraiser may use it directly as the appraisal basis; for evidence transferred by the commissioning party but not cross-examined, the appraiser shall request the commissioning party to organise cross-examination and confirm the probative force of the evidence.'

6. Negative scenarios and follow-up handling.

  • Where on cross-examination the materials are found unfit to serve as the appraisal basis -> the appraisal opinion made on the basis of those materials may not serve as the basis for finding the facts of the case (Article 34 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, third sentence).
  • The four statutory grounds permitting re-appraisal (Article 40 of Fa Shi [2019] No. 19): '(1) the appraiser lacks the requisite qualification; (2) the appraisal procedure is seriously unlawful; (3) the appraisal opinion is manifestly insufficiently grounded; (4) other circumstances in which the appraisal opinion cannot be used as evidence.' Under the first three, the appraisal fees already collected by the appraiser shall be refunded, and on refusal Article 81(2) of these Provisions applies; 'where the defects of the appraisal opinion can be resolved by correction, supplementary appraisal, or supplementary or renewed cross-examination, the people's court shall not permit the application for re-appraisal'; 'on re-appraisal, the original appraisal opinion may not serve as the basis for finding the facts of the case'.
  • Objections and the attendance procedure: after receiving the appraisal report the court shall promptly deliver copies to the parties; a party with an objection shall raise it in writing within the specified period, and the court shall require the appraiser to explain, clarify or supplement (Article 37); where an objection remains after the written reply, the court, under Article 11 of the Measures on the Payment of Litigation Fees, notifies the objecting party to advance the appraiser's attendance fee and notifies the appraiser to attend the hearing - 'an objecting party that does not advance the appraiser's attendance fee is deemed to have waived the objection'; where both parties object, they share the advance (Article 38); the attendance fee is computed at the standard for a witness attending court and borne by the losing party, and where attendance is needed because the opinion is unclear or defective, it is borne by the appraiser itself (Article 39); where the court, at commissioning, already determined that the attendance fee is included in the appraisal fee, no advance is notified (final paragraph of Article 39).
  • Review of the contents of the appraisal report: whether it contains the seven items - the name of the commissioning court, the content and requirements of the commission, the appraisal materials, the principles and methods on which the appraisal rests, an account of the appraisal process, the appraisal opinion, and the letter of commitment - with the appraiser's signature or seal and the corresponding qualification certificates attached; where an institution is commissioned, the institution seals and the persons conducting the appraisal sign (Article 36).
  • Appraiser responsibility: before the appraisal begins the court shall require the appraiser to sign a letter of commitment stating the guarantees of objectivity, fairness and honesty, of attendance at court, and of legal liability for a false appraisal (Article 33(1)); for an intentionally false appraisal, order refund of the appraisal fees and punishment under Article 111 of the Civil Procedure Law (Article 33(2)); where the appraiser withdraws an opinion after it has been adopted without justified reason, order refund of the appraisal fees with possible punishment, and a party's claim that it bear the reasonable increased costs thereby is supported (Article 42).
  • No contamination of the evidence: in investigating and collecting evidence that may require appraisal, the people's court shall observe the relevant technical rules to ensure the evidence is not contaminated (Article 24 of Fa Shi [2019] No. 19).

7. The arbitration route.

  • Arbitration Law of the PRC (2025 revision), Article 56: 'A party may apply to the arbitral tribunal for appraisal of specialised questions for ascertaining the facts. Where the arbitral tribunal, on a party's application or on its own judgement, considers that appraisal of a specialised question is needed, it may have the question appraised by an appraiser agreed by the parties or by an appraiser designated by the arbitral tribunal. At a party's request or the tribunal's requirement, the appraiser shall attend the hearing when notified by the tribunal. With the tribunal's permission, a party may put questions to the appraiser.'
  • Article 57 of the same law: 'Evidence shall be produced at the hearing, and the parties may cross-examine it.'

8. Interface with audit results / government fiscal review conclusions.

  • Article 13 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 (Construction Contract Interpretation (II)): where the employer and the contractor agree that the project price is determined by the audit result of the audit organ or the review conclusion of the government fiscal review institution, but the audit result or review conclusion is not issued within a reasonable period for reasons not attributable to the contractor, or the contractor has evidence proving that it manifestly contradicts the construction contract, the contractor's application for judicial appraisal of the construction cost shall be permitted by the people's court; the reasonable period is as agreed, and absent agreement the court determines it comprehensively by the scale of the works, the amount of the cost and the complexity, but the period may not exceed one year from the contractor's submission of the final-account documents; where the parties did not agree on determination by the audit result / review conclusion, the employer's request to determine the project price thereby is not supported.

Boundaries of application

  • Applies to civil litigation and commercial arbitration of construction contract disputes (appraisal of cost, time and quality); 'no appraisal basis without cross-examination' is a rule of admissibility, not to be conflated with the weight of the appraisal opinion itself.
  • The exclusion is limited to the part of the opinion 'made on the basis of those materials': where a single material affects only some items, the remaining parts, cross-examined and sufficiently grounded, remain admissible; the whole appraisal opinion may not be negated on that account.
  • Where the cross-examination defects can be resolved by correction, supplementary appraisal, supplementary cross-examination or renewed cross-examination, the court will not permit re-appraisal (Article 40(3) of Fa Shi [2019] No. 19); only 'seriously unlawful procedure' falls within a permitted re-appraisal.
  • Confidential evidence (state secrets, commercial secrets, personal privacy or confidentiality required by law) may not be cross-examined in public, but must still be cross-examined in an appropriate manner.
  • Versions and temporal lines: the 2025 revision of the Arbitration Law takes effect on 1 March 2026; Article 23 of the Construction Contract Interpretation (II) (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12) provides 'this Interpretation takes effect on 30 June 2026. First-instance construction contract dispute cases newly accepted by the people's courts after this Interpretation takes effect apply this Interpretation. Where SPC judicial interpretations issued earlier conflict with this Interpretation, this Interpretation prevails' - that is, first-instance cases accepted before 30 June 2026 still apply Fa Shi [2020] No. 25; the Civil Procedure Law applies in its 2023 amendment; Fa Shi [2015] No. 5 in its 2022 amendment.
  • When citing normatively, note the article-number versions: the 'Article 68' of the Civil Procedure Law and the 'Article 45' of the Arbitration Law cited when Section 4.7 of GB/T 51262-2017 was drafted were the numbers of the versions then in force; the current Civil Procedure Law (2023 amendment) corresponds at Article 71, and the Arbitration Law (2025 revision) at Article 57. Cite the current article numbers.

Further reading

  • Fa Shi [2019] No. 19, SPC Provisions on Evidence in Civil Procedure, Articles 30-42 (appraisal applications and explanation, the application period and advance payment, agreed or designated appraisers, the letter of commitment, cross-examination of appraisal materials, report contents and review, replies to objections, appraiser attendance and fees, re-appraisal, self-commissioned opinions, withdrawal of opinions).
  • Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Construction Contract Interpretation (I), Articles 31, 33, 34.
  • Fa [2020] No. 202, SPC Provisions on Issues concerning the Review of Commissioned Appraisal in Civil Proceedings of the People's Courts, Part 2, 'Review of the appraisal materials', Items 3-5.
  • Fa Shi [2015] No. 5, SPC Interpretation on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law, Article 103; Civil Procedure Law of the PRC (2023 amendment), Article 71.
  • Arbitration Law of the PRC (2025 revision, effective 1 March 2026), Articles 56, 57; original text at https://policy.mofcom.gov.cn/claw/clawContent.shtml?id=103718 .
  • Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Construction Contract Interpretation (II), Article 13 (audit results / government fiscal review and judicial appraisal), Article 23 (effective date and old-new transition).
  • GB/T 51262-2017, Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment, 4.4.1 (cross-examination and adoption of supplementary evidence), Section 4.7 (adoption of evidence: the relation of proof, cross-examination and determination, and the handling of the appraiser issuing separate opinions).

Keywords

  • 鉴定材料质证
  • 未经质证 鉴定依据
  • 鉴定意见采信
  • 重新鉴定
  • 补充质证
  • 合议庭确认
  • 工程造价司法鉴定
  • 法释〔2020〕25号第三十四条