Effect of signed-off interim settlements by construction stage on the final account: the no-re-measurement and no-re-pricing principle, statutory exceptions that can overturn it, submission and deemed-approval rules for late response, and a clause comparison linking the two settlements (GB/T 50500-2024 + Cai Jian [2022] No. 183)
Except that preliminaries and main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions shall be recalculated under Clauses 10.2.7 and 10.3.3, interim settlement documents by construction stage signed and confirmed by both employer and contractor form part of the final account documents, and the final account shall not re-measure or re-price them. Where the contract provides that interim stage settlement amounts serve as the basis for the final account, after dual sign-off the employer may no longer engage another cost consultant to repeat the check. The only openings to break the lock-in are: fraud, gross mistake, obvious unfairness, duress (Civil Code Articles 147/148/150/151; preclusive periods of 1 year or 90 days, 5 years at most), lack of authority of the confirming party, invalidity of the basis of confirmation, contractual exclusion of the lock-in, statutory recomputation items (preliminaries and main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions), and other provisions of laws and regulations (government fiscal review or audit alone is not a ground for overturning).
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第7.1.5~7.1.8、8.11.22、10.2.3、10.2.4、10.2.7、10.2.8、10.3.1、10.3.3、10.3.5、10.3.8、10.3.12、10.3.16条
- 《财政部 住房和城乡建设部关于完善建设工程价款结算有关办法的通知》(财建〔2022〕183号)第二条
- http://czj.pingliang.gov.cn/zfxxgk/fdzdgknr/lzyj/sjzc/art/2022/art_64fff948f92c4e7890840e739d50d0e9.html
- 《建筑工程施工发包与承包计价管理办法》(住建部令第16号)第十八条、第十九条
- 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》(法释〔2020〕25号)第29条
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第140、147、148、150、151、152、155、157、171、172、199条
- 最高人民法院(2008)民一他字第4号答复
- DBJ/T 15-153-2019《广东省建设项目全过程造价管理规范》第7.8.3条
- DB42/T 823-2021 · Specification for Quality Control of Construction Cost Consulting (Hubei) 第8.1.5条
Topic positioning
Whether quantities and prices already signed off in interim settlements by construction stage remain binding once the final account opens, whether they can be re-measured and re-priced (colloquially 're-audit'), and under which statutory circumstances they can be overturned; together with the policy yardstick on the effect of stage settlement documents, the submission and late-response deemed-approval rules (fictive approval by silence), and a clause comparison linking stage settlement and final account.
Core conclusions
1. Basic effect: sign-off locks the result; the final account does not recompute
- GB/T 50500-2024 'China national pricing standard for BOQ', Clause 10.2.3, original text: 'Except as provided in Clause 10.2.7 of this standard, interim settlement documents by construction stage signed and confirmed by the employer and the contractor shall form part of the final account documents of the works, and the final account shall not re-measure or re-price them. The preliminaries and main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions governed by Clause 10.2.7 of this standard may be adjusted as provided in Clause 10.3.3 of this standard.'
- Clause 10.3.1: 'After completion of the works, the employer and the contractor shall, per the contract and Clause 10.2.1 of this standard and on the basis of all interim settlement documents by construction stage signed and confirmed by both parties, prepare and check the final account ... unless otherwise agreed in the contract, interim stage settlement amounts shall serve as the basis for the final account.'
- Clause 7.1.8 (extending the lock to measurement results), original text: 'Measurement results of the works signed and confirmed by the employer and the contractor shall serve as the basis for adjustment of the contract price and for settlement of the works, except where the contract provides otherwise, the parties expressly agree they serve only as the basis for progress payments, or the measurement results are rough estimates.'
- Clause 10.3.12 (a second lock): 'Where the final account check of the works is completed and signed and stamped for confirmation by both parties, the employer shall not require the contractor to have the final account re-checked with any other construction cost consultant. Unless otherwise provided by laws and regulations, ... the employer shall not re-check the final account.'
- Clause 8.11.22: once both parties have signed and determined the final account documents per the contract and completed final account confirmation, neither party shall raise any further claim for the works over events that arose before the final account, unless otherwise agreed in the contract.
2. Policy yardstick (document level)
- Cai Jian [2022] No. 183 (MOF and MOHURD notice on settlement of payments measures, issued 14 June 2022, effective 1 August 2022), Article 2, key text: 'Newly commenced projects that start and cannot complete within the same year may adopt stage settlements. The employer and the contractor, through contractual agreement, divide construction into cycles by time or progress milestones, compute, confirm and pay the price of completed and undisputed quantities within the cycle (including variations, site instruction records, claims, etc.), and the payment shall not exceed the approved estimate (budget) corresponding to the completed portion. Stage settlement documents confirmed by both parties form part of the final account documents; after completion there is in principle no repeated review.' Three qualifications: (1) scope limited to newly commenced projects that cannot complete within the same year; (2) adoption through contractual agreement; (3) effect stated 'in principle', locking only completed and undisputed quantities.
- MOHURD Order No. 16 (measures for administration of pricing in contracting and subcontracting of building works), Article 19: 'Final account documents of construction works confirmed by signature of the employer and the contractor shall serve as the basis for the final accounts of the project; without the consent of the other party, neither party may engage a construction cost consultancy enterprise to repeat the review of final account documents already in effect. The employer shall pay the final account money in good time per the final account documents ...' Article 18 of the same measures prescribes the employer's response period, objections, negotiation, commissioned review and the time limits for the contractor to apply for mediation; where the contract is silent and the State has no provision, 'the agreed periods may all be taken as 28 days'.
- DBJ/T 15-153-2019 (Guangdong, whole-process construction cost management specification), Clause 7.8.3: 'Interim settlement results by construction stage signed and accepted by both contracting parties shall serve as the basis for measurement and payment of the contract price, for termination settlement and for the final account.' Commentary: 'At measurement and payment of the contract price, and at termination settlement and the final account, interim stage settlements signed and accepted by both contracting parties need no recomputation or re-check.'
- DB42/T 823-2021 (construction cost consultancy quality control specification), Clause 8.1.5: 'For settlement review projects on which the parties concerned have reached consensus and jointly signed the settlement cost confirmation form, a settlement agreement has in effect been formed and neither party may unilaterally overturn it... other construction cost consultancy enterprises should not accept from the same employer a commission for settlement review (so-called re-review, audit or re-check) of the same project.'
- Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 (SPC Interpretation (I) on construction contract dispute cases), Article 29: where the parties have already reached agreement on the settlement of payments for the construction project before litigation, the people's court shall not permit one party's application during litigation for construction cost expert assessment of the works - once the confirmation documents have the nature of a settlement agreement, the court will not commence cost expert assessment.
3. Overturnable exceptions (enumeration)
| Category | Basis (key original wording) | Typical situations | Time limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fraud | Civil Code Article 148: 'Where a party induces the other to perform a civil juristic act against its true intention by fraud, the defrauded party has the right to request the people's court or an arbitration institution to revoke it.' | Inflated quantities, forged site instruction records or concealed-works records, suppressed design changes | 1 year from knowing or constructively knowing the ground for revocation; 5 years from the act (Article 152) |
| Gross mistake | Civil Code Article 147: 'Where a civil juristic act is performed on the basis of a gross mistake, the actor has the right to request the people's court or an arbitration institution to revoke it.' | Wrong unit of measurement, wrong quota line item taken for the rate, decimal-point shift (must be gross, not the party's own review negligence) | 90 days; 5 years (Article 152) |
| Obvious unfairness | Civil Code Article 151: 'Where a party exploits the other's distress or lack of judgement so that the civil juristic act is obviously unfair at formation, the aggrieved party has the right to request the people's court or an arbitration institution to revoke it.' | Price squeezing conditioned on settlement, locking a low price on another's distress | 1 year; 5 years |
| Duress | Civil Code Article 150 | Sign-off forced by threats to suspend progress payments or withhold taking-over | 1 year from cessation of the duress; 5 years |
| Confirming party without authority | Civil Code Article 171 (agency without authority has no effect on the principal absent ratification), Article 172 (agency by estoppel) | Signatory unauthorised, exceeding authority, privately carved seals of the project department | Per agency rules |
| Invalid basis of confirmation | Civil Code Article 155 'a void or revoked civil juristic act has no legal binding force from the outset', Article 157 (restitution / compensation at value / damages) | Retrospectively certified or forged site instruction records, work beyond the construction drawings or approved variations, unlawfully subcontracted or re-let portions, works failing acceptance or requiring rework | - |
| Lock-in excluded by contract | Clause 10.3.1 'unless otherwise agreed in the contract'; Clause 7.1.8 exceptions for contrary agreement, progress-payment-only basis and rough estimates | Contract stipulating 'stage settlements are interim payments, the final account consolidates the determination' | Per the agreement |
| Statutory recomputation items | Clause 10.2.7: 'Preliminaries computed under Clause 10.2.5 of this standard and main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions computed under Clause 10.2.6 are used only to compute and pay interim stage settlement amounts and do not serve as the basis for determining the final account amount of the works.' Clause 10.3.3: 'Preliminaries charged in interim settlement by construction stage shall not serve as the basis for the final account of the works... main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions shall not serve as the basis for the final account of the works.' | Preliminaries (including adjustment of statutory safety provisions) and main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions: recomputed at final account under Section 7.3, Chapter 8 and Section 8.5 and adjusted up or down accordingly | Recomputed at final account |
| Other provisions of laws and regulations | Clause 10.3.12 catch-all; Reply [2008] Min Yi Ta Zi No. 4: 'Appraisal and review by finance departments of financial investment is state supervision and administration of the construction unit's capital construction funds and does not affect the validity and performance of the contract between the construction unit and the contractor. However, where the construction contract expressly agrees that the review conclusion on financial investment is the settlement basis, the review conclusion shall be the settlement basis.' | Audit disallowance or government fiscal review disallowance: alone not a ground to overturn, unless the contract expressly makes the review conclusion the settlement basis | - |
| Unconfirmed / disputed portions | Uncontested portions are first settled through a final account covering only the completed scope; contested portions go to negotiation or dispute resolution | Portions never signed off during the process, or expressly reserved as disputed at sign-off | - |
The preclusive period for the right of revocation (Civil Code Article 152): generally 1 year from knowing or constructively knowing the ground for revocation, 90 days for gross mistake, and 5 years at most from the date of the civil juristic act; the period admits no suspension, interruption or extension (Article 199) and lapses on expiry. Note: a large disallowance on review, a different review yardstick, or a change of cost consultant is not a ground for overturning.
4. Submission and late-response confirmation rules (fictive approval by silence)
The legal basis is Civil Code Article 140: 'A person may make a declaration of intent expressly or by conduct. Silence may be treated as a declaration of intent only where the law so provides, the parties so agree, or it accords with the course of dealing between the parties.'
| Level | Process | Effect of failure to respond in time | Clause |
|---|---|---|---|
| Measurement | Contractor submits measurement results -> employer checks | Employer fails to provide check results within the agreed time: the measurement results submitted by the contractor may be deemed approved by the employer and used as the basis for computing the price of the works, but not as evidence that the relevant works passed and were delivered | 7.1.5 |
| Measurement | Employer's check results -> contractor confirms / requests re-check | Employer fails to provide re-inspection results within the agreed time: the contractor's review comments are deemed approved; contractor neither confirms nor comments within the agreed time: the measurement results checked by the employer are deemed approved by the contractor | 7.1.6 |
| Measurement | Agreement reached | Both parties sign and confirm the agreed measurement results; continuing disagreement goes to dispute resolution | 7.1.7 |
| Stage settlement | Contractor fails to submit -> employer urges -> employer compiles from available records -> submits to contractor for confirmation | Contractor confirms without objection or gives no clear reply within the agreed time: the stage settlement documents compiled by the employer are deemed approved by the contractor and may serve as the basis for processing the interim settlement by construction stage and paying the price | 10.2.8 |
| Stage settlement | Contractor submits stage settlement documents -> employer checks | The national standard sets no clause deeming employer silence in checking to be approval; handle only per the contract, the implementing documents of the project locality, or the rules on notice and claims | Section 10.2 |
| Final account | Contractor fails to submit / confirm in time | The employer may compile from available records and request confirmation; if the contractor fails to reply in time, the employer-compiled settlement documents are deemed approved | 10.3.5 |
| Final account | Contractor submits -> employer checks | Employer fails to check within the agreed time or raises no check comments: the final account documents submitted by the contractor are deemed approved by the employer and the final account stands confirmed | 10.3.8 |
| Payment | Contractor submits the payment application for settlement money -> employer verifies and issues the payment certificate | Employer neither verifies nor issues in time: the payment application is deemed approved and shall be paid within the prescribed time at the amount stated | 10.3.16 |
In addition, the quality conformity evidence for interim settlement by construction stage shall include the contractor's own quality conformity records for the works to be measured and priced and the process acceptance records meeting contract requirements, but process acceptance cannot substitute for taking-over (10.2.8).
5. Clause comparison linking stage settlement and final account
| Item | Clause | Key points |
|---|---|---|
| Incorporated into the final account | 10.2.3 | Signed stage settlement documents form part of the final account documents, no re-measurement or re-pricing (except 10.2.7) |
| Basis for compiling the final account | 10.3.1 | Compiled and checked on all signed stage settlement documents; unless otherwise agreed, stage settlement amounts are the basis of the final account |
| Preliminaries / attendance provisions | 10.2.7, 10.3.3 | Used only for stage settlement payment, not a basis for the final account; recomputed per the contract at completion and adjusted up or down |
| Stage settlement payment ratio | 10.2.4 | 'The payment ratio of interim stage settlement amounts shall be agreed in the contract and shall not be less than 80% of the total interim stage settlement amount of the period' |
| No repeated checking | 10.3.12 | After dual sign-off no repeated check with another consultant; unless laws and regulations provide otherwise, no repeated check |
| Claims closed | 8.11.22 | After final account confirmation no further claims over pre-settlement events (unless otherwise agreed) |
| Measurement locked | 7.1.7, 7.1.8 | Agreement signed and confirmed on measurement; confirmed measurement results are the basis for price adjustment and settlement (with exceptions) |
Applicable boundaries
- GB/T 50500-2024 is a recommended national standard; clauses such as 10.2.3 bind only when incorporated by the contract (the particular conditions stating performance under this standard); absent incorporation, the effect rests mainly on the 'in principle' wording of Cai Jian [2022] No. 183 and the agreement nature of the confirmation documents themselves (Civil Code contract book; Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 29).
- The 'in principle no repeated review' of Cai Jian [2022] No. 183 does not define its exceptions; it covers only newly commenced projects completing beyond the same year, requires contractual adoption, and locks only 'completed and undisputed quantities' - no lock-in attaches to disputed or unsigned portions.
- 'Deemed approval' must rest on law, the parties' agreement or course of dealing (Civil Code Article 140): employer silence deemed approval at the stage settlement phase has no basis in the national standard; check the implementing documents of the project locality or the specific contract clauses item by item.
- Recomputation of preliminaries and main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions is a statutory recomputation, not 're-audit': it still takes the priced BOQ as its base and is determined under the contract and the pricing standard; on the same yardstick the result usually matches the stage settlement (differences being time value and adjustment items), and 'recomputation' must not serve as a pretext to rebuild rates for signed-off component quantities and all-in unit rates.
- Disallowance by audit or government fiscal review does not mean a confirmed stage settlement can be overturned ([2008] Min Yi Ta Zi No. 4), unless the contract expressly makes the review conclusion the settlement basis.
- The preclusive period for revocation admits no suspension, interruption or extension and lapses on expiry; the party asserting fraud or gross mistake bears the burden of proof.
- Process acceptance does not substitute for taking-over; confirmation of stage settlement documents does not affect quality liability and repair obligations within the defects liability period.
Further reading
- GB/T 50500-2024: Clauses 7.1.5 to 7.1.8, 8.11.22, 10.2.3, 10.2.4, 10.2.7, 10.2.8, 10.3.1, 10.3.3, 10.3.5, 10.3.8, 10.3.12, 10.3.16.
- Cai Jian [2022] No. 183 (settlement of payments notice), Article 2.
- MOHURD Order No. 16 (pricing administration measures), Articles 18 and 19.
- Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 (SPC construction contract interpretation I), Articles 21 and 29.
- Civil Code, Articles 140, 147, 148, 150, 151, 152, 155, 157, 171, 172, 199.
- SPC Reply [2008] Min Yi Ta Zi No. 4 (government fiscal review conclusions in construction contract disputes).
- DBJ/T 15-153-2019 Clause 7.8.3 and its commentary; DB42/T 823-2021 Clause 8.1.5.
- Recomputation yardstick of preliminaries and main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions at final account (Section 7.3, Chapter 8, Section 8.5): see the dedicated card; constituent elements of the two settlements: see the dedicated card.