Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-29

Admission and scope of judicial construction cost expert assessment in fixed lump-sum construction contract settlement disputes: when a full re-assessment of the whole works cost is not supported, and when it should be permitted

In principle, no. Where the contract is valid and provides settlement at a fixed price, and the dispute targets the contract price itself, a party's application for assessment of the whole works cost is not supported (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 28); assessment is likewise refused where a settlement agreement was reached before suit, the final account documents were signed off by both parties, or the contract provided 'deemed approval of the final account documents upon failure to reply in time' and the time limit has lapsed. Even where an assessment proceeds, only the disputed facts are assessed (Article 31), and the fixed lump-sum pricing principle of the contract must be maintained: a 'recalculation from scratch' cannot replace what the contract agreed.

Applicable Codes

  • 法释〔2020〕25号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第二十一条、第二十八条、第二十九条、第三十条、第三十一条、第三十二条
  • 法释〔2026〕12号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第九条、第十条、第十一条、第十三条、第二十三条(2026年6月30日起施行)
  • 《中华人民共和国民法典》第五百三十三条、第七百九十三条
  • 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第七十九条、第八十一条
  • 法释〔2015〕5号《最高人民法院关于适用〈中华人民共和国民事诉讼法〉的解释》(2022修正)第一百二十一条
  • 法释〔2019〕19号《最高人民法院关于民事诉讼证据的若干规定》(2019修正)第四十条、第四十一条、第四十二条
  • 法〔2020〕202号《最高人民法院关于人民法院民事诉讼中委托鉴定审查工作若干问题的规定》第一部分第1条、第2条
  • GB/T 51262-2017 · Code for Construction Cost Appraisal 第5.5.2条、第5.5.3条、第5.10.7条
  • T/ZBD 100.4-2023 · Work Guideline for Construction Cost Appraisal 第4.4.2条
  • 住建部令第16号《建筑工程施工发包与承包计价管理办法》第十八条、第十九条
  • 《保障中小企业款项支付条例》(2025修订)第十二条
  • https://policy.mofcom.gov.cn/claw/clawContent.shtml?id=103718

Topic positioning

When a fixed lump-sum (package-price) construction contract enters litigation or arbitration, 'whether to redo a cost assessment of the whole works, and how wide its scope should be' is the first threshold in settlement disputes. This card maps the admission and scope rules in the order 'principle - refusal grounds - permission grounds - procedural gates'.

Core conclusions

I. General principle: a full re-assessment of the works cost is not supported. The SPC Interpretation on the Application of Law to Construction Contract Dispute Cases (I) (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25), Article 28: 'Where the parties agree to settle the works price at a fixed price and one party requests assessment of the construction cost, the people's court will not support it.' The rationale: assessment is an evidentiary means of ascertaining the specialised facts of a case, not a tool for overturning the pricing method the parties agreed. Where fixed-price settlement is agreed, the court determines the price directly under the agreement; only the disputed facts 'outside the agreed scope, unclear in the agreement, or with the agreement overturned' enter assessment. Key distinction: fixed lump-sum is not fixed unit-rate. Under a fixed unit-rate contract the quantities are measured as executed and quantity differences are in any event resolved by measurement or assessment; a fixed lump-sum contract wraps both quantity and price, and a 'recalculation' cannot replace the contractual agreement.

II. Situations where assessment (or recalculation of the total price) is not supported or not permitted - article by article:

  1. Agreed settlement at a fixed price: Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 28 - a request for assessment of the construction cost is not supported.
  2. Pre-suit agreement on the works price settlement (settlement statement, settlement agreement) without grounds of revocation or invalidity: Article 29 of the same Interpretation: 'Where the parties reached an agreement on the settlement of the works price before litigation, an application by one party in litigation for assessment of the construction cost will not be permitted.'
  3. Pre-suit joint commission of a consultancy for a cost opinion, with both parties expressly bound by it: Article 30: 'Where the parties jointly commissioned an institution or person before litigation to give a consultation opinion on the construction cost, and in litigation one party does not accept the opinion and applies for assessment, the people's court should permit it, except where both parties expressly declared themselves bound by the consultation opinion.' (Where they did not expressly bind themselves, assessment is permitted.)
  4. Final account documents already signed and confirmed by both parties: Article 19 of the Measures for the Administration of Pricing in Construction Contracting (MOHURD Order No. 16): 'Final account documents of a construction project confirmed by signature by both the awarding and the contracting parties shall serve as the basis for the project financial settlement; without the other party's consent, neither party may commission a construction cost consultancy to repeatedly review the final account documents that have taken effect. The employer shall pay the final account amount in good time according to the final account documents.'
  5. Agreement that 'the employer's failure to reply in time is deemed approval of the final account documents', with the employer indeed in arrears of reply: Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 21: 'Where the parties agree that if the employer, after receiving the final account documents, makes no reply within the agreed period, it is deemed to have approved the final account documents, the matter shall be handled as agreed. Where the contractor claims settlement of the works price according to the final account documents, the people's court shall support it.'
  6. Measurement dispute under a lump-sum contract, where the contract agrees a measurement standard: GB/T 51262-2017, Clause 5.5.3: 'Where the parties dispute the measurement under a total-price contract: if the total-price contract agrees a measurement standard, the assessment follows the agreement; if there is no such agreement, only the variation portion is assessed.'
  7. Signed measurement results challenged by one party with a bare objection and no specific evidence: GB/T 51262-2017, Clause 5.5.2: '1. Where a party merely raises an objection without providing specific evidence, the assessment follows the original measurement result; 2. where a party raises an objection and also provides specific evidence, the original measurement result shall be re-checked, on site where necessary, and the assessment is based on the re-checked measurement result.'
  8. An application merely to re-assess the total price inside a lump-sum contract for 'unfairness of the contract total price': T/ZBD 100.4-2023, Guideline for Construction Cost Expert Assessment Practice, Clause 4.4.2: the assessor should submit the question to the commissioning party to decide and assess as the commissioning party requires; where the commissioning party makes no decision, then on the premise of a valid contract, and apart from special agreement on the contract price or a supplementary agreement, the assessor should not recalculate the total-price portion within the total-price contract and should maintain its pricing principle.
  9. The matter proposed for assessment is not a 'specialised question for ascertaining facts': Fa [2020] No. 202, Part I, Article 1, lists the matters for which the people's courts will not commission assessment: (1) facts that can be presumed from common general knowledge and rules of experience; (2) questions unrelated to the facts to be proved; (3) questions meaningless for proving the facts to be proved; (4) non-specialised questions that should be proved by the parties' own evidence; (5) facts that can be ascertained through court investigation or inspection; (6) determinations of the allocation of responsibility between the parties; (7) questions of application of law; (8) lie detection; (9) other circumstances unsuitable for commissioned assessment. Part I, Article 2: where the assessment techniques and methods are seriously disputed and lack scientific reliability, no commission is made.

III. Situations where assessment should be permitted or supported

  1. Assessment of the disputed facts only (the basic scope-narrowing rule): Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 31: 'Where the parties dispute only part of the facts of the case, only the disputed facts are assessed, except where the scope of the disputed facts cannot be determined, or both parties request assessment of all the facts.'
  2. A fixed-price contract seeking price adjustment for major changes in labour costs or key material prices: the SPC Interpretation on Construction Contract Disputes (II) (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12), Article 9: 'Where a construction contract agrees settlement of the works price at a fixed price, and a party requests adjustment of the works price on the ground that the labour costs or the prices of key building materials changed majorly within the agreed construction period, the people's court will not support it, except where the parties agreed otherwise or Article 533 of the Civil Code on change of circumstances is met.' In principle, then, no adjustment and no assessment; only 'other agreement' by the parties, or a change of circumstances under Civil Code Article 533 ('... the fundamental conditions of the contract undergo a major change which the parties could not have foreseen at the time of contracting and which does not amount to a commercial risk, such that continued performance is obviously unfair to one party; the adversely affected party may renegotiate; failing agreement within a reasonable period, it may request the court or arbitration institution to vary or terminate the contract ... under the principle of fairness.'), opens the way to assessment of the adjustment quantum.
  3. Price of the completed portions after termination of a fixed lump-sum contract: Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 10: 'After a fixed lump-sum construction contract is terminated, where the parties have no agreement, and cannot reach agreement, on the price of the completed portions of qualified works, the people's court may, by reference to the pricing standards and pricing methods published by the construction administrative authority of the place of the works at the time the contract was concluded, or to the relevant standards of the construction field, determine the proportion of the works price payable for the completed portions to the works price of the whole project, and determine the works price of the completed portions by multiplying the fixed lump-sum price agreed in the contract by that proportion.' The assessment approach is in GB/T 51262-2017, Clause 5.10.7: (i) as agreed in the contract, where there is agreement; (ii) where the contractor's breach caused the termination, compute the price of the uncompleted works by reference to the pricing basis applicable at the place of the works in the same period, and deduct it from the contract total price; (iii) where the employer's breach caused the termination and the contractor claims the price of the completed works computed under the pricing basis applicable at the place of the works in the same period, the assessor may adopt that method for the commissioning party's judgement.
  4. Agreement that the price is determined by the audit result or the government fiscal review conclusion, but the conclusion is late for reasons not attributable to the contractor or obviously inconsistent with the contract: Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 13, paragraph 1: 'Where the employer and the contractor agree that the works price is determined by the audit result of the audit authority or the review conclusion of the government fiscal review institution, but the audit result or the review conclusion is not issued within a reasonable period for reasons not attributable to the contractor, or the contractor has evidence proving that the audit result or review conclusion is obviously inconsistent with the construction contract, and the contractor applies for judicial assessment of the construction cost, the people's court shall permit it.' Paragraph 2: 'The reasonable period in the preceding paragraph is as agreed by the parties; absent agreement, the people's court determines it comprehensively from the project scale, the amount of the works cost and the complexity of the case, but the period may not exceed one year from the date the contractor submits the final account documents.' Paragraph 3: 'Where the employer and the contractor have not agreed that the works price is determined by the audit result of the audit authority or the review conclusion of the government fiscal review institution, and the employer requests determination of the works price by the audit result or the review conclusion, the people's court will not support it.' See also Article 12 of the Regulation on Ensuring Payment to SMEs (2025 revision): 'Government agencies, public institutions and large state-owned enterprises may not compel that the audit result of an audit authority serve as the basis for settlement, except as otherwise provided by laws or administrative regulations.'
  5. Contract void but the works passed acceptance: Civil Code Article 793, paragraph 1: 'Where a construction contract is void but the construction works have passed acceptance, the contractor may be compensated in value by reference to the agreement of the contract on the works price'; Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 11, clarifies that 'the agreement of the contract on the works price, by reference to which compensation is made' 'includes the amount of the works price, the pricing method, the payment time, the adjustment method and the settlement method agreed in the construction contract' - the void contract does not automatically lead to repricing under the quota norms and re-assessment of the whole cost; the reference scope still includes the fixed price agreement and its settlement method.
  6. An opinion on a specialised question self-commissioned by one party, rebutted by the other party with evidence or reasons sufficient to refute it, with an application for assessment: the SPC Provisions on Evidence in Civil Procedure (Fa Shi [2019] No. 19), Article 41: 'Where one party has commissioned an institution or person to give an opinion on a specialised question, and the other party has evidence or reasons sufficient to rebut it and applies for assessment, the people's court shall permit it.'
  7. The four statutory grounds for re-assessment met: the same Provisions, Article 40, paragraph 1: 'Where a party applies for re-assessment and any of the following circumstances exists, the people's court shall permit it: (1) the assessor does not have the corresponding qualification; (2) the assessment procedure is seriously unlawful; (3) the assessment opinion is obviously insufficiently founded; (4) other circumstances in which the assessment opinion cannot be used as evidence.' Paragraph 2: in the first three circumstances the assessor shall refund the assessment fee already collected. Paragraph 4: 'On re-assessment, the original assessment opinion may not serve as the basis for finding the facts of the case.' Paragraph 3 adds a restriction: 'Where the defects of the assessment opinion can be resolved by correction, supplementary assessment, or supplementary or renewed cross-examination, the people's court will not permit the application for re-assessment.'

IV. Procedural gates and legal consequences

  • Application timing and formal threshold: Civil Procedure Law (2023 revision), Article 79: 'A party may apply to the people's court for assessment on specialised questions for ascertaining facts. Where a party applies, the parties shall negotiate to determine a qualified assessor; failing agreement, the people's court designates one. Where no party has applied but the court considers assessment necessary, it shall commission a qualified assessor.' The SPC Interpretation on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law (Fa Shi [2015] No. 5, 2022 revision), Article 121: 'An application for assessment may be made before the expiry of the evidence production period. Where the matter for which assessment is applied is unrelated to the facts to be proved, or is meaningless for proving the facts to be proved, the people's court will not permit it.'
  • Clarification and failure of proof: Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 32, paragraph 1: 'Where the parties dispute specialised questions such as the construction cost, quality or repair costs, and the people's court considers assessment necessary, it shall clarify this to the party bearing the burden of proof. A party which, after clarification, fails to apply for assessment, or applies but fails to pay the assessment fee or refuses to provide the relevant materials, shall bear the legal consequences of failure of proof.' Paragraph 2: 'Where the party bearing the burden of proof failed to apply for assessment in the first-instance proceedings, or applied but failed to pay the assessment fee or refused to provide the relevant materials, and applies for assessment in the second-instance proceedings, and the people's court considers it truly necessary, it shall deal with it under item (iii) of paragraph 1 of Article 170 of the Civil Procedure Law.'
  • The assessor attending court: Civil Procedure Law, Article 81: 'Where a party objects to the assessment opinion, or the people's court considers it necessary for the assessor to attend court, the assessor shall testify in court. Where the assessor, having been notified by the people's court, refuses to attend court to testify, the assessment opinion may not serve as the basis for finding the facts; the party which paid the assessment fee may demand a refund of the fee.'
  • The old-new rule boundary: Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 23: 'This Interpretation takes effect on 30 June 2026. It applies to first-instance construction contract dispute cases newly accepted by the people's courts after its entry into force. Where judicial interpretations previously issued by the Supreme People's Court are inconsistent with this Interpretation, this Interpretation prevails.'

Applicability boundaries

  • Article 28 presupposes a valid contract and a dispute targeting the agreed fixed price itself. Where the contract is void but the works passed acceptance, Article 793 of the Civil Code on compensation in value by reference applies (reference scope per Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 11); mid-way termination follows the proportional method of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 10 and GB/T 51262-2017, Clause 5.10.7 - none of these is 'recalculate the whole cost under the quota norms'.
  • Fixed lump-sum and fixed unit-rate must not be conflated: quantity differences under a unit-rate contract are resolved by measurement or assessment in any event and are not blocked by Article 28.
  • Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 applies only to first-instance cases newly accepted after its entry into force on 30 June 2026; first- and second-instance cases accepted earlier follow the original rules; Articles 9, 10 and 13 have no retroactive effect.
  • GB/T 51262-2017 is a recommended national standard and T/ZBD 100.4-2023 an association practice guideline; both bind the assessor's assessment conduct and opinion approach, and do not directly decide whether the court permits assessment, but the court's adoption of the assessment opinion is influenced by them.
  • Admission to assessment is not substantive victory: it only opens an evidentiary route, and the final price is still determined under the pricing method agreed in the contract; conversely, the party whose assessment application is refused should instead organise its evidence around 'outside the agreed scope / variation / invalidity / termination / change of circumstances'.
  • The threshold for change of circumstances is high (unforeseeable at contracting, not a commercial risk, continued performance obviously unfair) and cannot be equated with ordinary market price rises; fluctuations within the agreed band or normal commercial risk are unsupported.

Further reading

  • Fa Shi [2020] No. 25: Articles 21, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32.
  • Fa Shi [2026] No. 12: Articles 9, 10, 11, 13, 23.
  • Civil Code: Articles 533, 793.
  • Civil Procedure Law (2023 revision): Articles 79, 81; Fa Shi [2015] No. 5: Article 121.
  • Fa Shi [2019] No. 19: Articles 40, 41, 42.
  • Fa [2020] No. 202: Part I, Articles 1 and 2.
  • GB/T 51262-2017: Clauses 5.5.2, 5.5.3, 5.10.7.
  • T/ZBD 100.4-2023: Clause 4.4.2.
  • MOHURD Order No. 16: Article 19; SME Payment Regulation (2025 revision): Article 12.
  • Official text: https://policy.mofcom.gov.cn/claw/clawContent.shtml?id=103718

Keywords

  • 固定总价
  • 造价司法鉴定
  • 重新鉴定
  • 建工解释一第二十八条
  • 鉴定范围
  • 有争议的事实
  • 法释〔2026〕12号第九条
  • 逾期不答复视为认可

Cited By