Settlement rules for the construction contract price after contract termination (four scenario rules + three material states + lump-sum contract pricing + quality threshold)
Termination ends only the unperformed part; the performed part must be settled, and conformity of the completed works is the precondition for payment (if repaired to conformity the repair cost is borne; if still nonconforming after repair, no contract price is payable). Termination by agreement is settled per the agreement; termination for force majeure pays seven categories of costs with no liquidated damages or claims; on termination for contractor breach the employer may suspend payment and verify losses, and quality warranty liability is not exempted; on termination for employer breach liquidated damages are additionally payable and the retention money refunded. On-site materials are allocated across three states. For termination of a lump-sum contract with no agreement: contractor breach — contract lump sum minus the price of the unperformed works; employer breach — the completed-work price is computed per contemporaneous pricing bases (GB/T 51262-2017 §5.10.7).
Topic Positioning
Overview of the settlement rules for the construction contract price after termination of the construction contract (by agreement / force majeure / employer breach / contractor breach).
Core Conclusions
Termination ends only the unperformed part; the performed part must be settled, and conformity is the precondition for payment. Four scenario rules: ① termination by agreement — settle per the agreement (§10.4.1); ② force majeure termination — pay seven items including the completed works, ordered-and-delivered materials, return and contract-cancellation charges, and evacuation/dismissal costs, with no liquidated damages or claims; after payment the completed works and materials belong to the employer (§10.4.2); ③ contractor-breach termination — the employer may suspend payment and verify the completed-work price + material payments + loss claims, quality warranty liability not being exempted (§10.4.3); ④ employer-breach termination — pay per §10.4.2 and refund the retention money, plus liquidated damages and losses (§10.4.4). Materials in three states: physical works belong to the employer; ordered and delivered materials belong to the employer after payment; materials neither paid for nor delivered belong to the contractor. Lump-sum contracts with no agreement upon termination (GB/T 51262-2017 §5.10.7): contractor breach — contract lump sum minus the price of the unperformed works; employer breach — the completed-work price is computed per contemporaneous pricing bases. Nonconforming quality: repaired to conformity — the repair cost is paid; still nonconforming after repair — no contract price is paid (Judicial Interpretation I on Construction Contract Disputes, Article 10).
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to settlement after termination, excluding the normal final account; attribution of responsibility is determined by the client / judicial organs; failing negotiation, Chapter 11 dispute resolution applies.
Further Reading
GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 10.1.9, 10.4.1–10.4.4, 11.1.1; GB/T 51262-2017 Section 5.10; Civil Code Articles 566/567/806 and Article 10 of Judicial Interpretation I on Construction Contract Disputes.
Keywords
- 施工合同解除
- 工程价款结算
- 固定总价
- 比例折算法
- retention money
- 法释〔2026〕12号第十条
- 现场材料归属
- quality conformity
Cited By
- ←
Where the employer serves a notice of termination, the contractor promptly vacates, and the court later finds the termination invalid: whether the contractor's evacuation constitutes breach (stopping work and vacating the site characterised separately; three conditions of exemption), scenario comparison, loss sharing, and the effective dates of the legal bases
In principle the evacuation is not a breach by the contractor, but 'vacating the site' must be split into two acts: where the termination is invalid the contract still subsists, so if the employer merely served a termination notice it had no right to serve, without suspension or demobilisation instructions, the contractor that stops work on its own and removes its mobilised plant and materials may be found in breach for unauthorised suspension; by contrast, vacating on the strength of the employer's written termination notice and express instructions to stop work, demobilise and hand back the site is the creditor's refusal to accept performance plus a mitigation measure, is not attributable to the contractor, and the evacuation costs and suspension losses are claimable from the employer under Articles 803 and 804 of the Civil Code. Three conditions of exemption: a written notice or instruction as basis; evacuation proportionate to the instruction; prompt resumption once the employer withdraws the notice or requires resumption. Termination by notice does not take effect of itself: without a right to terminate, 'no effect of termination arises' (Fa Shi [2023] No. 13, Article 53), and the same holds even if the other party fails to sue within the objection period (Conference Minutes, Fa [2019] No. 254, Article 46).
- ←
Admission and scope of judicial construction cost expert assessment in fixed lump-sum construction contract settlement disputes: when a full re-assessment of the whole works cost is not supported, and when it should be permitted
In principle, no. Where the contract is valid and provides settlement at a fixed price, and the dispute targets the contract price itself, a party's application for assessment of the whole works cost is not supported (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 28); assessment is likewise refused where a settlement agreement was reached before suit, the final account documents were signed off by both parties, or the contract provided 'deemed approval of the final account documents upon failure to reply in time' and the time limit has lapsed. Even where an assessment proceeds, only the disputed facts are assessed (Article 31), and the fixed lump-sum pricing principle of the contract must be maintained: a 'recalculation from scratch' cannot replace what the contract agreed.
- ←
After termination of the construction contract, the boundary of the payment defence for parts of the works the employer has actually taken over and put to use (without completion acceptance): a blanket refusal to pay on the ground of 'not accepted' is barred; refusal is allowed only 'to the corresponding extent' for undelivered parts and for foundation and main structure defects; repair costs require prior notice of repair
No blanket refusal. Termination only ends the unperformed part; for completed works of acceptable quality the corresponding price is still payable as agreed (Civil Code Article 806(3)); where the employer makes premature use of parts not accepted, the date of taking over possession of the works is the completion date (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 9(iii)), and later claims on the ground that 'the quality of the used part does not conform to the agreement' are not supported (Article 14 of the same interpretation, excepting the foundation and the main structure). Refusal of payment is limited to: parts not delivered for use, foundation and main structure defects of used parts, and repair costs where repair was requested but still not carried out; and under Civil Code Article 526 only the 'corresponding' request for performance may be refused, not the whole price held back; retention money may be reserved on the base of the price of the works payable to the contractor (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 14).
- ←
The contractor's obligation to hand over the construction site and construction documents after termination of a construction contract (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 15), and evidence preservation before the contractor leaves the site (Article 84 of the Civil Procedure Law): legal routes, the commencement threshold and practical points
Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 15, paragraph 1: after termination of a construction contract, where the employer requests the contractor to hand over the construction site, the construction documents and the like, the people's court shall support the request in accordance with law - handover is a statutory obligation upon termination, not conditioned on settlement of the works payment, and the contractor may not resist settlement by refusing to hand over. Paragraph 2: where a party applies for evidence preservation before the contractor leaves the site, the people's court shall handle it under Article 84 of the Civil Procedure Law (application during the proceedings; in urgent circumstances a pre-suit application may be made before instituting proceedings or applying for arbitration to the court at the place where the evidence is located, the place where the respondent is domiciled or the court having jurisdiction; the court may also preserve evidence on its own initiative). The interpretation takes effect on 30 June 2026 and applies to first-instance cases newly accepted after that date (Article 23).
- ←
The requirements, statutory basis, points of proof and post-termination winding-up rules for the employer to terminate the construction contract where the contractor suspends the works for a long period without authorisation (non-performance of principal obligations)
Termination is available, but the mere length of the suspension does not itself create a right to terminate: the contractor's unauthorised suspension is a breach in the form of non-performance of principal obligations, and the employer must bring itself within Article 563(3) of the Civil Code (failure to perform within a reasonable period after demand) or item (4) of that article (the purpose of the contract cannot be achieved), or a contractually agreed termination ground (GF-2017-0201 cl. 16.2.3; GF-2020-0216 cl. 16.1.1 sub-item (8): 'suspension attributable to the contractor exceeding 56 days and affecting the whole of the works, or suspension attributable to the contractor exceeding 182 days'); Article 806(1) of the Civil Code lists only transfer of the works in breach and unlawful subcontracting as the employer's statutory termination grounds and does not include suspension, so a termination notice resting on 'long duration' alone, without demand or without the agreed threshold being met, has no terminating effect. Termination must be made by written notice reaching the other party (Article 565) and exercised within one year from knowing the ground (Article 564); after termination the employer must still settle the price of completed work that is up to standard, and the contractor's quality assurance liability and liability for breach are not discharged.
- ←
When a notice of termination of a construction contract takes effect: effectiveness on arrival (Article 565 of the Civil Code), the precondition of a termination right (Article 53 of Fa Shi [2023] No. 13; Article 46 of the 2019 Conference Minutes), automatic termination and termination by suit or arbitration, and the preclusive period of the termination right (Article 564)
The contract is terminated when the notice of termination reaches the other party (paragraph 1 of Article 565 of the Civil Code), but the people's court must substantively examine whether the notifying party held a statutory or agreed right to terminate: where it did, the contract terminates on arrival of the notice; where it did not, no effect of termination occurs even if the other party failed to sue within the agreed or a reasonable objection period (Article 46 of the 2019 Conference Minutes; Article 53 of Fa Shi [2023] No. 13). Where the party sues or applies for arbitration directly without notice, the contract terminates when the copy of the statement of claim or of the arbitration application is served on the other party; where the suit is withdrawn and a later suit is upheld, termination occurs when the copy of the statement of claim in the later suit is served (except where, after withdrawal, a notice was given and has reached the other party - Article 54 of Fa Shi [2023] No. 13). The termination right must be exercised within the preclusive period: where a statutory or agreed period exists, the right lapses on its expiry; absent agreement, the right lapses if not exercised within one year from the day the holder knew or should have known of the grounds, or within a reasonable period after being urged by the other party (Article 564). Where termination is by mutual agreement without dealing with breach liability, settlement and winding up, the contract is still found terminated and those issues are handled under Articles 566 and 567.
- ←
Validity and application path of a construction contract clause providing that 'upon termination only 70% of the price of the work performed is settled': a three-way characterisation (payment percentage / settlement method / consequence of breach), the basis of validity (Civil Code Article 567 + Construction Interpretation I Article 19), five grounds on which the clause may be defeated or reduced (liquidated damages reduction, unfair standard terms, contract invalidity, deviation from the awarded contract, unmet trigger condition), and the amount basis
Such a clause is valid in principle: settling at a percentage of the price of the work performed after termination is a 'settlement and winding-up provision', and Civil Code Article 567 expressly preserves its validity despite the termination of the contractual relationship; Judicial Interpretation [2020] No. 25 Article 19 para 1 provides that 'where the parties have agreed on the pricing standard or pricing method of the construction works, the price shall be settled in accordance with the agreement', while the proportional-conversion method of Judicial Interpretation [2026] No. 12 Article 10 presupposes 'no agreement on the price of the part of the works already constructed and of acceptable quality, and no consensus' - where there is an agreement, the agreement governs. Invalidity therefore cannot be found merely because 'the discount percentage is below the actual value of the work performed'. But the clause must pass five gates: (1) characterisation (payment-percentage clause / settlement-method clause / breach-consequence clause); (2) whether the discount, as liquidated damages, is grossly excessive (Article 585; exceeding the loss by 30% is generally found grossly excessive - Judicial Interpretation [2023] No. 13 Article 65; must be raised by counterclaim or defence); (3) whether it is an unfair standard term (Articles 496, 497); (4) contract validity and divergent black-and-white contracts (Article 793 + Judicial Interpretation [2026] No. 12 Article 11, whose scope of reference includes the settlement method; Judicial Interpretation [2020] No. 25 Article 2 determines rights and obligations by the awarded contract); (5) whether the agreed trigger condition (e.g. 'termination for the contractor's breach') is actually met.
- ←
Rules for judicial adjustment where agreed liquidated damages are excessively high: how adjustment is triggered (counterclaim or defence), the loss-based measure and the 'exceeding the loss by 30%' test, allocation of the burden of proof, and the court's duty to clarify
Liquidated damages stand as agreed; the court adjusts only on a party's request (counterclaim or defence both suffice): where the damages are below the loss, an increase may be sought; where they are grossly above the loss, an appropriate reduction may be sought. The measure is the loss as defined in Civil Code Article 584, weighing the contract parties, the type of transaction, the performance of the contract, the degree of fault and the background of performance, and following the principles of fairness and good faith - 'where the agreed liquidated damages exceed the loss caused by 30%, the people's court may generally find them grossly above the loss caused'; a request for reduction by a party in bad-faith breach is generally refused. The breaching party bears the burden of proving 'grossly above'; the non-breaching party asserting reasonableness must also produce evidence; a defence resting only on a contractual clause that no adjustment shall be made is not upheld; where a defence succeeds but no adjustment is claimed, the court must clarify.
- ←
Preserving evidence of completed quantities when the construction contract is terminated or the contractor is forcibly evicted: the window, the procedure, and the quantity-price determination routes (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 15, Civil Procedure Law Article 84, Interpretation on the Civil Procedure Law Article 98, Construction Interpretation (I) Article 20, GB/T 51262-2017 Article 5.10.1)
Preservation is possible, but the full window exists only before the contractor leaves the site: Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 15(1) provides that after termination of the contract the employer's request for handover of the site and the construction documents is supported by the court (handover is not conditioned on settlement of payment, and withholding handover cannot be used to pressure settlement), and Article 15(2) states 'before the contractor leaves the site, where a party applies for preservation of evidence, the people's court shall handle it under Article 84 of the Civil Procedure Law'. The core of preservation is not site photos but a quantity evidence chain of 'location + dimensions + calculation sheets': measurement results signed and confirmed by both parties serve directly as the basis for settlement (GB/T 50500-2024 Article 7.1.8); disputed quantities are confirmed by written documents such as site instruction records formed during construction, and absent such records other evidence may confirm the quantities actually performed (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 20); after site exit only the expert-assessment fallback of GB/T 51262-2017 Article 5.10.1 remains - counting completed locations, measuring quantities, counting site labour, materials and plant, compiling registers with sign-off and pricing separately - with probative force falling off a cliff.
- ←
Measurement basis for completed quantities and the list of payable cost items in settlement upon termination (suspension) of the contract: re-measurement for unit-rate contracts, completed share x BOQ lump price for lump-sum contracts, and cost scope grouped by the defaulting party (GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 7.2.1/9.4.2/9.4.3/10.4.1-10.4.4; GB/T 51262-2017 Clauses 5.10.3/5.10.4)
Termination settlement first fixes quantity by contract type (unit-rate contracts: re-measure the completed billed quantities per the contractually agreed quantity take-off standard x contract unit rates; lump-sum contracts: 'completed billed quantity of each BOQ item as a share of its total quantity in the contract BOQ x the lump price of that item'), then groups costs by the defaulting party: the common must-count items are the price of permanent works completed, the amounts of paid-for materials and equipment (vesting in the employer on payment), the amortised costs of temporary works and site establishment, site instruction records, claims and other payables, and the costs of vacating the site and dismissing staff; the differing item is the loss for breach - on the employer's breach the employer additionally pays liquidated damages and refunds the retention money; on the contractor's breach the employer may suspend payment, the contractor remains liable for quality warranty, and the contractor bears the liquidated damages and losses.
- ←
Whether the employer may refuse payment for completed works when the contractor exits without handing over construction records: the legal nature of the record-handover obligation, the proportionality limit of the defence of refusal to perform, the two exceptions permitting suspension of payment, and the remedies of a handover claim and evidence preservation (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 15)
As a rule there is no blanket refusal to pay: the consideration for the works price is the accepted completed quantities of passing quality (Civil Code Articles 799 and 793), while handing over construction records is an ancillary duty of cooperation and a procedural condition for taking-over and archiving (Article 509(2), Article 16 of the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects, GB/T 50328-2014 Clause 6.0.3); the two are not reciprocal performances. Even where a defence of refusal to perform is invoked, Articles 525 and 526 permit refusal only of the 'corresponding' performance, and a substitutable duty of cooperation cannot be set against the entire price. The employer's proper remedies are: a claim for handover of the site and construction records under Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 15(1); application for evidence preservation before exit under Article 15(2) (referring to Article 84 of the Civil Procedure Law); and damages under Civil Code Article 584, or set-off under Article 568, for losses caused by the missing records. Payment may be suspended, to an extent corresponding to the obligation, only where the contract expressly makes record handover a precondition of payment, or where the payment condition (passing taking-over) has genuinely not been satisfied because the records are incomplete.
- ←
Fixing the start point of the contractor's priority right to payment of the construction price (18 months at most) after rescission of the construction contract: the payment date expressly agreed in a rescission agreement or settlement agreement; the due date of the original payment clause as a settlement and winding-up clause; the date of rescission where a payment condition becomes unattainable upon rescission; the three deemed situations under Article 27 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25; and the distinction from the start of the retention money return period
Rescission does not change the 18-month length of the period; it only changes which day counts as 'the date the employer ought to pay the works price': where a rescission agreement or settlement agreement expressly agrees a payment date, that date governs (Article 21(2) of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12); where the original payment clause is a 'settlement and winding-up clause' still applicable after rescission, the due date of its payment term governs (Article 567 of the Civil Code); where payment was conditioned on completion, acceptance or completed settlement review and the condition fails upon rescission, the date of rescission governs (some courts take the contractor's withdrawal from the site or handover of the works; count back conservatively from the earlier date); where none applies and the works are undelivered and unsettled, the date of filing suit (or applying for arbitration) is deemed (Article 27(3) of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25). The length is fixed at 18 months at most by Article 41 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, and the period is a peremptory exclusion period.
- ←
The effect of liquidated damages clauses in void construction contracts and the route to damages: application of Civil Code Articles 155, 157, 507 and 567, Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 6, and Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Articles 11 and 12
They cannot directly ground a claim for 'liquidated damages', but can be referred to in quantifying 'damages'. A void construction contract has no binding force ab initio and the liquidated damages clause falls with it - it is neither a 'dispute resolution clause' preserved by Civil Code Article 507 nor a 'settlement and winding-up clause' surviving independently only upon 'termination' under Article 567. The parties may only claim damages under Article 157, proving fault, the amount of loss and causation (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 6); where the loss is hard to fix, the court may determine it by reference to the contractually agreed quality standard, construction period, payment time and the like, but the award is 'damages' not 'liquidated damages', capped at actual loss and not exceeding the performance interest. Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 11 confines 'reference to the contract terms on the price of the works' to the amount, pricing method, payment time, adjustment method and settlement method - excluding liquidated damages.
- ←
The base for computing works retention money under a fixed lump-sum construction contract: the total settled project price (including contractually adjustable items and excluding unused provisional sums) rather than the signed contract price, capped at 3%; on rescission or void incomplete works the base shifts to the price due to the contractor or the discounted compensation due
For a fixed lump-sum contract the retention money base is 'the total settled project price', not the signed contract price: total settled price = the fixed contract price + contractually adjustable additions (variations, site instruction records, claims, provisional price adjustments, provisional sums actually incurred, cost fluctuation adjustment, changes in laws and policies, etc.) - deductions such as unused provisional sums; both the retention percentage and the guarantee amount are capped at 3% of that total (Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138 Article 7; GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 10.5.1), not computed on the signed price, the audit conclusion or the unpaid balance. Exception: in first-instance cases newly accepted after 30 June 2026, where the construction contract is rescinded the base is the price due to the contractor, and where the contract is void and the works incomplete the base is the discounted compensation due, with the return period running from site demobilisation (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 14).
- ←
Start point, calculation base and length of the retention money return period after termination of a construction contract (or invalidity with the works unfinished) - aligning Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 14 with Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 17 and Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138
Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 14: where the construction contract is terminated, the retention money return period runs from the date the contractor withdrew from the site; where the contract is terminated after the contractor has withdrawn, it runs from the date of termination; where the contract is invalid and the works are unfinished (the base changing to the discounted compensation payable), it likewise runs from the withdrawal date. The article changes only the start point and the base (the project price payable / the discounted compensation, not the total contract price), not the length - the defects liability period is generally 1 year and at most 2 years (Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138, Article 2), and the retention cap remains 3% of the settled total project price (Article 7). The interpretation took effect on 30 June 2026 and applies only to first-instance cases newly accepted after that date (Article 23).
- ←
Recognition criteria for force majeure events, item-by-item sharing of losses, costs and time, supporting insurance, and the conditions for terminating the contract for force majeure (GF-2017-0201 clauses 17.1/17.3/17.4 compared with GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 8.11.12 to 8.11.15)
Force majeure is recognised by the three criteria of being unforeseeable at contract signing, unavoidable and insurmountable during performance (GF-2017-0201 clause 17.1). The sharing basis: the employer bears damage to the permanent works and to materials/construction equipment delivered to site, third-party casualties and property losses caused by damage to the works, wages that must be paid to workers during suspension, care/cleaning/repair costs and the wages of necessary personnel kept on site at the employer's request, and acceleration costs requested by the employer; the contractor bears damage to its own construction plant and preliminaries facilities, and each party bears its own casualties and other property; the contractor's other suspension costs are reasonably shared by both parties and the time for completion is extended accordingly; losses enlarged by failure to mitigate are borne by the party that failed to mitigate, and force majeure encountered during delayed performance does not relieve liability for breach (clause 17.3.2; GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.11.12). Where force majeure prevents performance of the contract continuously for more than 84 days or cumulatively for more than 140 days, either party may terminate; after termination the seven heads of payment under clause 17.4 are paid within 28 days of being agreed or determined.
- ←
Repricing the remaining works after a subcontractor's exit (subcontract termination): splitting into two accounts and three repricing modes for the successor
A subcontractor's exit is a subcontract termination, and pricing splits into two accounts: (1) settle the completed works with the exiting subcontractor under the termination rules (pay the agreed price for completed work that passes quality checks; a re-measurable (unit-rate) contract at completed quantity x the agreed unit rate; a lump-sum contract at the contract total price less the price of the unfinished works, or the completed price computed directly on the pricing bases); (2) reprice the works for the successor by choosing one of three options — continuing the original contract unit rates, deriving new (built-up) rates, or cost plus fee / an all-in lump sum — with reference to the review principles for additional works, and with interface treatment costs included where new rates are derived.
- ←
Settlement during suspension: completed qualified work settled as normal + suspension costs shared by cause (employer/contractor/force majeure)
Suspension settlement splits into two ledgers: qualified completed work is measured per actual completion up to the suspension date and settled as normal (disputed portions — undisputed paid first, labor costs never withheld); suspension costs follow the cause — employer-caused: the employer bears all reasonable costs (protection, custody, machinery standstill, wages of workers and managers, resumption preparation, profit, demobilization, etc., GB/T 51262-2017 §5.8.3 + T/YJXB 0001-2023); contractor-caused: self-borne; force majeure/government control shared per GB/T 50500-2024 §8.11.12/13 (permanent works and delivered materials on the employer, machinery and measure losses on the contractor, retained-site wages and care/cleaning/repair on the employer, with extension of time). Contract agreement governs; termination after suspension settles per §10.4.4.
- ←
Settlement of unfinished works: pricing method by contract type and termination cause (unit rate measured per actuals / lump-sum deduction or direct pricing)
Settlement of unfinished works settles only the completed part: re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts measure completed quantities × the contract all-in unit rate per actuals; on termination for contractor breach, lump-sum contracts use the "contract price − unfinished work price" deduction method, and on termination for employer breach the contractor may claim direct pricing of the completed work per the pricing bases (GB/T 51262-2017 §5.10.7), together with the BOQ-ratio method (GB/T 50500-2024 §9.4.3); cost-plus is on agreed cost + fee. Six classes of chargeable cost (completed work costs including changes plus amortised temporary works and site establishment costs and management fees; materials and equipment delivered to site; materials already purchased and paid for, or return losses; demobilisation costs; claims; other losses); the procedure is inventory and measurement → checking → certification and sign-off → separate pricing; quality acceptance is the precondition for pricing, and the assessor does not judge termination liability.