Engineering Knowledge Cards.

retention money

16 knowledge cards · sorted by most recently updated

Concept Guide

Concept

In Chinese construction contracting, retention money is the amount an employer withholds from payments due to the contractor as security for the contractor's obligation to remedy defects during the defects liability period. It belongs to the same family of project securities as the performance security and the bid security, but its scope is narrower: it secures post-completion defect rectification only, not time, progress or the whole of the contract obligations.

How the mechanism works. First, withholding and cap: the employer normally deducts a percentage from each interim payment, and the applicable Chinese regulation caps the total at 3% of the settled contract price, so any agreed figure above that ceiling is not enforceable. Second, alternative form: the contractor may substitute a bank guarantee, and the employer cannot refuse it, moving the arrangement from tied-up cash to committed credit lines. Third, release and deduction: if a defect appears during the defects liability period and the contractor fails to remedy it within the agreed time, the employer may engage others and deduct the cost from the retention; once the period expires with no outstanding defects, the balance must be returned promptly.

A distinction worth keeping. The defects liability period is not the statutory warranty period. The former is the lifespan of the retention, agreed in the contract and usually relatively short; the latter follows quality regulations, sets minimum warranty terms by discipline, and runs longer but carries no retention link. Pricing and settlement disputes often arise from confusing the two, or from withholding retention and performance security at the same time.

FIDIC Mapping

Corresponding term. FIDIC (Red Book / Yellow Book, 2017) uses Retention Money: defined in Sub-Clause 1.1.69 of the Red Book (1.1.70 in the Yellow Book), withheld under Sub-Clause 14.3 and released under Sub-Clause 14.9. The correct English is retention money; a Chinese-style rendering as a separate reimbursement "fund" has no counterpart among the FIDIC payment clauses and will confuse readers.

Similarities and differences. Both systems deduct a percentage from interim payments to secure defect rectification. Differences: the percentage and the cap come from the Contract Data under FIDIC, while China imposes a statutory ceiling; release under Sub-Clause 14.9 is in two halves — half after the Taking-Over Certificate, the remainder after the latest expiry of the Defects Notification Periods — whereas Chinese practice normally releases once, at the end of the defects liability period; and FIDIC expressly contemplates retention security given by a financial institution, matching the Chinese bank guarantee option although the documentary basis differs.

Usage warning. When reading FIDIC contracts or pricing overseas work, do not carry over the domestic ceiling or the domestic defects liability period: check the Contract Data for the retention percentage and limit. Do not equate the Defects Notification Period with the Chinese warranty period; the former triggers final release of the retention, the latter sets statutory minimum warranty terms. Because Sub-Clause 14.9 releases half of the retention early, the cash-flow impact is smaller than a full withholding until the end of the period — adjust financing cost estimates accordingly.

Chinese TermEnglish TermFIDIC TermRelationNotes
质量保证金retention moneyRetention Money(红皮书定义 1.1.69/黄皮书 1.1.70;扣留 14.3、返还 14.9)identical功能对等:均逐期扣留以担保缺陷修复。差异在比例与封顶由合同数据约定而非法定 3% 上限,且 FIDIC 两段释放保留金。
缺陷责任期defects liability periodDefects Notification Period (release of the second half under Sub-Clause 14.9)adjacentFIDIC 缺陷通知期最迟届满触发保留金后一半释放;中国缺陷责任期与保修期分离,保修期为法定最低年限,二者不可互替。

Updated 2026-09-13