Setting rules and compliance red lines for the performance security and the quality retention (retention money): 10%/3% caps, mutual exclusivity before completion, and the boundary allowing coexistence at final settlement
The performance security guarantees contract performance, capped at 10% of the awarded contract amount (Implementation Regulations of the Tendering and Bidding Law, Article 58); over-collection may be ordered to correct and fined up to RMB 50,000 (Article 66). The retention money guarantees repair obligations during the defect liability period, capped at 3% of the total project price settlement amount (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 10.5.1 and Jianzhi [2017] No. 138 Article 7, with a bank guarantee substitute also capped at 3%); the defect liability period is generally 1 year, 2 years maximum. The mutual-exclusivity red line is time-divided: before completion a retention must not be reserved while a performance security has been paid; but at final settlement a retention of up to 3% of the total settlement price may still be reserved (the performance security covers construction-period performance while the retention covers defect-period repairs — different guaranteed objects may coexist); where an engineering quality guarantee or quality insurance is adopted, the employer must not further reserve retention money. At the end of the defect liability period, final clearance is handled, the remaining retention is returned, and interest should not be calculated (GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 10.5.5).
Topic Positioning
This card covers the setting rules and compliance red lines for the performance security and the quality retention (retention money): how the two are distinguished, the ratio caps (performance 10% / retention 3%), the time boundary of "mutual exclusivity before completion, coexistence allowed at final settlement", the defect liability period and return conditions — directly usable for drafting employer-contractor contract clauses, settlement review, and security compliance checks.
Core Conclusions
The two are in a relay relationship, not additive: the performance security guarantees contract performance (construction/supply on time, quality delivery), while the retention guarantees repair obligations during the defect liability period. Performance quantification: the performance security must not exceed 10% of the awarded contract amount (Implementation Regulations of the Tendering and Bidding Law, Article 58); over-collection is ordered to be corrected and may be fined up to RMB 50,000 (Article 66); procurement contracts generally take 3%~5%, large customized equipment up to 10%, and suppliers with good credit standing may substitute a bank guarantee.
Retention cap (three sources agree, all locked at 3% of the total settlement price, not to be breached by stacking): GB/T 50500-2024 Standard for Valuation of Construction Works with Bills of Quantities, Clause 10.5.1, original text: "The employer shall reserve the quality retention in the manner agreed in the contract; the accumulated retention, or the guarantee amount of a bond substituting the retention, must not exceed 3% of the total project settlement price"; Jianzhi [2017] No. 138 Article 7: "The total reserved ratio of retention must not be higher than 3% of the total settlement amount of the project price. Where the contract stipulates that the contractor substitutes a bank guarantee for the reserved retention, the guarantee amount must not be higher than 3% of the total settlement amount of the project price."
Mutual exclusivity / coexistence with the performance security is time-divided (No. 138 document Article 6 + Clause 10.5.1):
- Where a performance security has been paid and the works are not yet complete (payments during construction): the employer must not simultaneously reserve a quality retention — the two are mutually exclusive, only one may be held;
- At final settlement: a retention of up to 3% of the total settlement price may still be reserved — the performance security guarantees construction-period performance while the retention guarantees repair obligations in the defect liability period; the guaranteed objects differ, so they may coexist;
- Where an engineering quality guarantee, engineering quality insurance, or other assurance method is adopted: the employer must not further reserve retention money (the 3% cap likewise applies);
- Where the contractor voluntarily provides a bond/insurance as substitute: the amount must still not exceed 3% of the total settlement amount of the project price (Clause 10.5.1: the contractor may provide a bond or insurance in place of the reserved retention).
The defect liability period is generally 1 year, no more than 2 years; the tender documents and contract must stipulate seven items: the method of reservation and return, ratio and time limit, whether interest accrues, the defect liability period and its calculation, dispute handling, claim methods, and penalties for late return. Deduction boundary: defects caused by the contractor are repaired at its cost; deduction from the retention is allowed only if it does not repair; defects caused by others must not be deducted from the retention. After the defect liability period ends, final clearance is handled and the remaining retention is returned without calculating interest (GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 10.5.5). Red lines: before completion, where a performance security has been paid, a retention must not be simultaneously reserved; cash plus bonds together must not exceed the cap.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to employer-contractor contracts of construction projects; material/equipment procurement contracts may apply by reference; ratios such as 3%~5% are common industry practice rather than mandatory, and the contract prevails; some sectors have lower caps (e.g., performance security for highway supervision tendering not exceeding 5% of the contract amount). The time boundary of "mutual exclusivity before completion, reservation allowed at final settlement" takes completion acceptance / final settlement as the dividing point; during the construction payment stage, deductions in the name of retention must not coexist with a performance security; the defect liability period runs from the date of passing completion acceptance — where the employer delays acceptance, it automatically starts 90 days after the contractor submits the completion acceptance report.
Further Reading
Implementation Regulations of the Tendering and Bidding Law, Articles 58, 66; Jianzhi [2017] No. 138 Measures for the Administration of Construction Project Quality Retention Money, Articles 2, 3, 6, 7, 9, 10, 12 (Article 6: before completion, where a performance security has been paid, a retention must not be simultaneously reserved; Article 7: both the reserved ratio and the bond amount must not exceed 3% of the total settlement amount of the project price); GB/T 50500-2024 Standard for Valuation of Construction Works with Bills of Quantities, Clause 10.5.1 (original text of the reservation cap and mutual-exclusivity rules), Clause 10.5.5 (return of the remaining retention without interest at the end of the defect liability period).
Keywords
- performance security
- retention money
- 预留比例上限
- 结算总价3%
- 履约担保 互斥
- defects liability period
- 建质〔2017〕138号
- GB/T 50500-2024