Validity of a quality retention money percentage exceeding the 3% cap, and routes for return or payment of the excess (including expiry of the defects liability period, substitution by performance security or a guarantee bond, and the time-point distinctions for contract termination and for a void contract with incomplete works)
The 3% cap comes from Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138 Article 7 and GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 10.5.1; the former is a departmental normative document and the latter a recommended national standard, and neither is a mandatory validity provision of a law or administrative regulation, so an agreed 5% is not thereby invalid in general - it creates only the administrative regulatory risk of unlawful retention; during the defects liability period the contractor cannot demand early return of the difference merely because it 'exceeds 3%', but after the period expires the full amount must be returned (less the actual repair costs of defects due to the contractor); where a performance security was paid before completion, or a quality guarantee or quality insurance was provided, or the actual retention exceeds the agreed percentage, the excess must be returned or paid as works payment.
Applicable Codes
- 建质〔2017〕138号《建设工程质量保证金管理办法》(2017修订)第二条、第三条、第六条、第七条、第九条、第十条、第十一条
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第10.5.1条、第10.5.5条
- 国办发〔2016〕49号《国务院办公厅关于清理规范工程建设领域保证金的通知》第三条、第四条
- 国务院令第728号《保障中小企业款项支付条例》第十二条
- 法释〔2026〕12号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第十四条、第二十三条
- GF-2017-0201《建设工程施工合同(示范文本)》第15.3.3项
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第一百五十三条、第四百六十五条、第五百零九条、第五百七十七条
Topic positioning
This card addresses the most frequent retention money dispute between employer and contractor: the contract retains 5% of the total project settlement amount as quality retention money, while the regulation and the national standard lock the cap at 3% - can the 2% excess be demanded back early, and is the agreed percentage clause invalid? For contract clause review, settlement negotiation and issue mapping in retention return litigation.
Core conclusions
I. The cap rules (original wording; consistent in three places and covering bonds)
- Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138, Measures for the Administration of Construction Quality Retention Money, Article 7: 'The employer shall retain the retention money in the manner agreed in the contract; the total percentage retained may not exceed 3% of the total settled project price. Where the contract provides that the contractor substitutes a bank guarantee bond for the retained money, the bond amount may not exceed 3% of the total settled project price.'
- GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 10.5.1: 'The employer shall retain the quality retention money in the manner of quality assurance agreed in the contract; the accumulated retention money, or the bond amount where a guarantee bond substitutes for the retention money, may not exceed 3% of the total settlement price of the works. Where the contractor has already provided performance security, the employer should not retain quality retention money before completion of the project. Where quality guarantee security, quality insurance or other means of assurance is adopted, the employer may not retain retention money again.'
- Guo Ban Fa [2016] No. 49, Article 4 (issued 23 June 2016): 'The cap on the retention percentage of construction quality retention money may not exceed 5% of the total settled project price. Where performance security has already been paid before completion of the project, the employer may not at the same time retain quality retention money.' 5% was thus once the compliant cap; after Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138 (2017 revision) it dropped to 3%. To judge whether an agreed percentage is excessive, one must first fix the regulatory period in which the contract was concluded and the settlement acts occurred; contracts concluded before the 2017 revision are lawful when measured against the 5% cap.
- State Council Decree No. 728, Regulation on Ensuring Payment to SMEs, Article 12: 'Apart from the lawfully established tender security, performance security, construction quality retention money and migrant worker wage security, no other security may be collected in construction projects. The percentages of security collected shall comply with the relevant state provisions. Government agencies, public institutions and large enterprises may not restrict security to cash. Where an SME provides security by a financial institution bond, government agencies, public institutions and large enterprises shall accept it.'
II. Validity of an agreed 5%: generally not invalid The 3% cap originates from a departmental normative document (Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138) and a recommended national standard (GB/T 50500-2024); neither falls under the 'mandatory provisions of laws or administrative regulations' referred to in Article 153 of the Civil Code, nor do they constitute prohibitive norms governing validity; the percentage rule is administrative in nature and addressed to the employer. Conclusion: an agreed 5% generally remains valid; the employer bears the risk of unlawful retention and administrative regulation; the contractor cannot claim invalidity merely because 'the clause exceeds the 3% cap'.
III. During the defects liability period the excess may not be demanded back early merely for exceeding the cap Where the 5% reflects the parties' true intention, is not a standard-form term, and the settlement was signed off at 5%, the 2% difference remains contractually agreed retention money during the defects liability period, serving to secure the contractor's repair obligations for defects (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 10.5.1, second paragraph); an application to withdraw it early lacks basis; where a signed settlement agreement expressly confirms the retention or waives the difference, later resiling is generally unsupported.
IV. Situations where the excess must be returned or paid as works payment
- Expiry of the defects liability period: once the contractor applies for return, the full 5% (less the actual repair costs of defects due to the contractor) must be returned, the 2% difference included; the employer verifies jointly within 14 days and, absent an agreed return period, returns within 14 days after verification; failure to reply within 14 days of the application, or within a further 14 days after being urged, is deemed approval of the return application (GF-2017-0201, item 15.3.3); late return can attract liquidated damages.
- Performance security already provided before completion: where performance security was paid before project completion, the employer may not retain quality retention money at the same time; where quality guarantee security, quality insurance or other means of assurance was adopted, no further retention is allowed; a bond or insurance substituting for cash retention is still capped at 3% in amount (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 10.5.1; No. 138, Article 6).
- Withholding lacking the nature of retention money: where the contract merely states 'retain 5% of the works payment' without agreeing the seven items listed in Article 3 of No. 138 (method of retention and return; percentage and time limit; whether interest accrues and how it is computed; duration of the defects liability period and its computation; dispute resolution procedure; method of defect claims; liquidated damages for late return), the withholding can hardly be recognised as retention money and may be claimed as works payment falling due.
- Actual retention exceeding the agreement: duplicate retention, computation on a base including advance payments or price adjustment amounts, cumulative retention by progress exceeding the total - the excess must be returned.
- Standard-form terms or obvious unfairness: where the employer unilaterally sets a markedly excessive percentage in a standard-form contract without drawing attention to it and explaining it, it may be argued that the term does not become part of the contract or should be adjusted to 3%; government agencies, public institutions and large enterprises may not restrict security to cash and must accept a financial institution bond from an SME (Decree 728, Article 12).
- Contract terminated, or contract void with works incomplete (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 14): 'Where a construction contract is terminated and the contractor claims to retain quality retention money computed on the works price it ought to receive, the people's court shall support it. The return period of the quality retention money runs from the date the contractor leaves the site; where the contract is terminated after the contractor leaves the site, it runs from the date of termination. Where a construction contract is void and the works are incomplete, and the contractor claims to retain quality retention money computed on the compensation for value it ought to receive, the people's court shall support it. The return period of the quality retention money runs from the date the contractor leaves the site.' The return period thus no longer waits for 'expiry of the defects liability period' but runs from site exit or termination, and the base changes from 'total settlement amount' to 'works price receivable (or compensation for value)'; the excess over the cap exits once the amount is recomputed on that base.
- Time-point distinction: Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 23: 'This Interpretation takes effect on 30 June 2026. It applies to first-instance construction contract dispute cases newly accepted by the people's courts after its entry into force. Where judicial interpretations previously issued by the Supreme People's Court are inconsistent with this Interpretation, this Interpretation prevails.' Whether Article 14 applies therefore depends on whether the first-instance case was accepted after 30 June 2026, not on when the contract was concluded.
V. Practice pointers (essentials) Points of proof: the original contract clauses and tender documents (whether expressly in the name of 'quality retention money'), the agreed defects liability period, settlement sign-off documents, bond, insurance and performance security vouchers, the written return application with evidence of service, and evidence of the site exit or termination date. Procedural periods: 14 days' verification plus 14 days' urgence leading to deemed approval - keep the records of urgence to fix the 'deemed approval'. Risk points: where a signed settlement or settlement agreement confirms retention at 5%, later claiming the difference carries an estoppel risk; where contractor-caused defects genuinely exist within the defects liability period and repair costs remain unsettled, deduction at the actual amount is allowed, free of the 3% cap.
Applicability boundaries
- The 3% and 5% caps govern percentage retention on the base of the 'total settled project price (total settlement price of the works)', not deductions within individual payment cycles; bonds, insurance and other non-cash means share the same amount cap as cash.
- 'An agreed 5% is valid' presupposes the true intention of both parties, no standard-form term, and no obvious unfairness; where the employer exploits a dominant position to set an extremely high percentage (e.g. 8%-10%) without notice, the standard-form term and fairness route remains open.
- The defects liability period differs from the warranty period: generally 1 year, at most 2 years (No. 138, Article 2); retention money secures only the repair obligations during the defects liability period, and return upon expiry does not release the warranty liability.
- Decree 728 applies only where government agencies, public institutions and large enterprises collect security from SMEs; the Regulation on Ensuring Payment to SMEs has since been revised (published as State Council Decree No. 802), so article numbers must be checked against the version applicable to the case (the 2020 Decree 728 text versus the current revised version).
- Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 14 covers only the two situations of 'contract termination' and 'void contract with incomplete works'; it must not be mixed with the return timing rules for a normal final account.
Further reading
Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138, Measures for the Administration of Construction Quality Retention Money (2017 revision): Article 2 (definition and defects liability period), Article 3 (the seven items the contract should agree), Article 6 (relationship with performance security), Article 7 (the 3% retention and bond caps), Article 9 (deduction of repair costs), Articles 10 and 11 (return and liquidated damages for late payment). GB/T 50500-2024, national BOQ pricing standard: Clause 10.5.1 and Clause 10.5.5 (final closure of accounts after the defects liability period, without interest). Guo Ban Fa [2016] No. 49: Article 4 (the historical 5% cap and the mutual exclusion rule), Article 3 (liquidated damages for late return). Decree 728, Article 12. GF-2017-0201 model construction contract, item 15.3.3 (verification of return applications and the deemed approval procedure). Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 (SPC Interpretation on Construction Contract Disputes (II)), Articles 14 and 23.
Keywords
- 工程质量保证金
- 质保金预留比例3%
- 超出比例返还
- 建质〔2017〕138号
- GB/T 50500-2024 10.5.1
- 法释〔2026〕12号 第十四条
- 缺陷责任期届满返还
- Regulation on Ensuring Payment to Small and Medium-sized Enterprises