Repair responsibility for quality defects within the defects liability period and the warranty period, bearing of repair costs and the retention money deduction rules (GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 10.5.2-10.5.4 and 10.3.13 + Jianzhi [2017] No. 138 Article 9 + Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects)
Divided by cause of the defect: for defects or damage caused by the contractor, the contractor repairs and bears the appraisal and repair costs; where the contractor refuses to repair, or still fails to repair within a reasonable period after written notice from the employer, the employer may repair itself or engage a third party, the costs are borne by the contractor and may be deducted from the retention money or the quality warranty bond, and any excess over the retained amount is claimed from the contractor under GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 8.11.18 (Clauses 10.5.2 and 10.5.3; Jianzhi [2017] No. 138 Article 9). For defects not caused by the contractor, the employer organises the repair and bears the costs, and nothing may be deducted from the retention money (Clause 10.5.4). At settlement, repair and rework costs may be deducted in the final account under Clause 10.3.13. Within the warranty period the construction enterprise shall perform its warranty duty and bear liability for losses caused (Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects, Article 41); failure or delay attracts an order to rectify and a fine of no less than CNY 100,000 and no more than CNY 200,000 (Article 66).
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第10.3.13条、第10.5.2条、第10.5.3条、第10.5.4条、第8.11.18条
- 建质〔2017〕138号 建设工程质量保证金管理办法(2017修订)第九条
- 建设工程质量管理条例(国务院令第714号,2019修订)第四十条、第四十一条、第六十六条
- 建建〔2000〕185号 房屋建筑工程质量保修书(示范文本)第三条、第四条
Subject Positioning
This card fixes who repairs, who pays and from which pot once quality defects appear: it separates the defects liability period from the warranty period, allocates repair responsibility and cost by cause of defect (contractor-caused or otherwise), and gives the operational path for retention money deduction and claims. It is a different facet from the judicial route of claiming repair costs after refusal of repair (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 16); this card concentrates on the deduction path under the contract and the pricing standard.
Core Conclusions
1. Defects liability period: allocation by cause (GB/T 50500-2024)
- Clause 10.5.2, original text: 'During the defects liability period, the contractor shall repair defects or damage caused by the contractor and bear the appraisal and repair costs. The contractor repairing and bearing the corresponding costs does not relieve it of liability for losses of the works agreed in the contract. During the defects liability period, repair of defects or damage caused by the contractor shall be carried out by the contractor; where the contractor fails to perform its repair responsibility, the employer may organise the repair otherwise, the costs incurred shall be borne by the contractor and deducted from the retention money or the bond.'
- Clause 10.5.3, original text: 'During the defects liability period, for defects or damage of the works caused by the contractor, where the contractor refuses to repair or fails to repair within a reasonable period, and still fails to repair after written notice from the employer, the employer may repair by itself or engage a third party to repair; the contractor shall bear the repair costs, and the employer may deduct them from the retention money or the quality warranty bond. Where the costs exceed the retained amount, the employer may claim from the contractor under Clause 8.11.18 of this standard.' The key point is the precondition of written notice.
- Clause 10.5.4, original text: 'During the defects liability period, for defects or damage caused otherwise than by the contractor, the employer shall organise the repair and bear the costs, and the employer shall not deduct the costs incurred from the contractor's retention money. ... Where the employer requires the contractor to repair, the employer shall pay the contractor the corresponding repair costs.'
2. Warranty period: statutory duty and administrative liability (Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects, State Council Decree No. 714)
- Article 41: 'Where a quality problem occurs within the warranty scope and warranty period of a construction project, the construction enterprise shall perform its warranty obligations and bear liability to compensate losses caused.'
- Article 66: 'Where, in violation of this Regulation, the construction enterprise fails to perform or delays performance of warranty obligations, it shall be ordered to rectify, fined no less than CNY 100,000 and no more than CNY 200,000, and shall bear liability to compensate losses caused by quality defects within the warranty period.'
- Article 40 (minimum warranty periods): '(1) for the foundation works and main structure works of infrastructure projects and building works, the reasonable design service life of the project specified in the design documents; (2) for roof waterproofing works and leakage-proofing of bathrooms, rooms and exterior walls subject to waterproofing requirements, 5 years; (3) for heating and cooling systems, 2 heating periods and 2 cooling periods; (4) for electrical wiring, water supply and drainage pipes, equipment installation and fit-out works, 2 years. The warranty period of other items is agreed by the employer and the contractor. The warranty period of a construction project runs from the date of passing completion acceptance.'
3. Legal basis for retention money deduction and claims
Jianzhi [2017] No. 138, Article 9, original text: 'During the defects liability period, for defects caused by the contractor, the contractor shall repair and bear the appraisal and repair costs. Where the contractor neither repairs nor bears the costs, the employer may deduct from the retention money or the bank bond as agreed in the contract; where the costs exceed the retained amount, the employer may claim from the contractor as agreed in the contract. After the contractor repairs and bears the corresponding costs, it remains liable for losses of the works. For defects caused by others, the employer organises the repair, the contractor bears no costs, and the employer shall not deduct costs from the retention money.'
4. Deduction at settlement (GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 10.3.13)
Key points of the original text: 'Where the quality of the works is unqualified for reasons attributable to the contractor, the employer may require the contractor to rectify to qualified; where the contractor fails to rectify or does not rectify, the employer may, as agreed in the contract, require the contractor to bear the costs of repair, rework and the like, and deduct in the final account of the works the repair, rework and other costs borne by the contractor. Where this causes losses to the employer, the employer may claim from the contractor under Clause 8.11.18 of this standard. The employer may deduct from the total price of the final account the price of works quality defects that remain unqualified after rectification and cannot be repaired; repairable works quality defects shall be repaired by the contractor and the costs incurred borne by the contractor. Where the employer and the contractor dispute works quality defects, they shall jointly entrust a professional quality appraisal institution to appraise and determine handling measures according to the appraisal results; the costs of engaging the appraisal institution may be borne by the responsible party among them.'
5. Grips that can be written straight into contract documents
Jianjian [2000] No. 185, Quality Warranty Letter for Building Construction Projects (model text), Article 3(1): 'For items within the warranty scope and content, the contractor shall dispatch personnel to repair within 7 days from receipt of the warranty notice. Where the contractor fails to dispatch personnel within the agreed period, the employer may engage others to repair.' Article 4: 'Warranty costs are borne by the party responsible for the quality defect.' Writing the 7-day and similar periods into the particular conditions at signing turns 'engaging others to repair' into an enforceable contractual right.
Scope of Application
- The defects liability period is not the warranty period: the defects liability period is contractually agreed (usually 1 year, at most 2 years) and secured by the retention money; the warranty period is statutory (Article 40). Expiry of the defects liability period triggers release of the retention money but does not relieve the contractor of its continuing warranty duty.
- Preconditions for deduction: the defect must be contractor-caused, and the contractor must still refuse repair, or fail to repair within a reasonable period after written notice; for defects not caused by the contractor (defects in the employer's design documents, unqualified employer-supplied (free-issue) materials and equipment, nominated subcontracting, causes of others), nothing may be deducted from the retention money.
- The deduction scope is capped: first deduct from the retention money or the quality warranty bond; the excess over the retained amount is claimed separately under Clause 8.11.18; deducting repair costs does not relieve liability for losses (No. 138, Article 9; Clause 10.5.2).
- Where the parties dispute a defect, they shall jointly entrust a professional quality appraisal institution, and the appraisal costs are borne by the responsible party (Clause 10.3.13).
- Irreparable defects take the path of deducting the corresponding price from the total price of the final account, which differs from the cost deduction for repairable defects.
- For the burden-of-proof structure when the employer raises quality problems as a defence in retention money release disputes, see the dedicated card on defences to retention money release.
Further Reading
- GB/T 50500-2024, China national pricing standard for BOQ, Clauses 10.3.13, 10.5.2, 10.5.3, 10.5.4 and 8.11.18 (Chapter 10, settlement and payment of the works)
- Jianzhi [2017] No. 138, Measures for the Administration of Retention Money for Construction Projects (2017 revision), Article 9
- Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects (State Council Decree No. 714, 2019 revision), Articles 40, 41 and 66
- Jianjian [2000] No. 185, Quality Warranty Letter for Building Construction Projects (model text), Articles 3 and 4
Keywords
- defects liability period
- 保修期
- 质量保证金扣除
- 修复费用承担
- 拒绝维修
- 书面催告
- 保修义务
- 建设工程质量管理条例第四十一条