Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-29

The liability regime when the winning bidder refuses to conclude the contract after the letter of acceptance is issued: when the contract is formed (the receipt theory), cancellation of the award and forfeiture of the tender security, damages for the excess loss, administrative fines of up to 10 per mille on projects subject to mandatory tendering by law, and the alternative remedies where the employer cannot demand that a written contract be signed

Refusal to sign is not a case of no contract signed and therefore no liability: under Article 4 of the SPC Interpretation on the General Provisions of the Contract Part of the Civil Code (Fa Shi [2023] No. 13), where a contract is concluded by tendering the contract is formed when the letter of acceptance reaches the winning bidder, and refusal to sign constitutes breach. Liability runs on three tracks: cancellation of the award plus forfeiture of the tender security (Implementation Regulations for the Bidding Law, Article 74); where the loss exceeds the amount of the tender security, compensation for the excess, and where no security was submitted, liability for the employer's loss (Article 81(2) of the Measures for Tendering and Bidding in Construction Projects, Order No. 30 of seven ministries; MOHURD Order No. 47, Article 46); and for projects subject to mandatory tendering by law, an order of rectification by the administrative supervision department and a fine of up to 10 per mille of the awarded project amount (Implementation Regulations, Article 74). Because signing the written contract is a non-monetary obligation whose subject matter is unsuitable for compulsory performance or too costly to enforce, the employer cannot request a judgment compelling the conclusion of a written contract; it should request a declaration that the contract is formed, have the contract content determined by the tender documents, the bid documents and the letter of acceptance, and claim damages (Civil Code Article 580).

Applicable Codes

  • 《中华人民共和国招标投标法》(2017修正,主席令第86号)第四十五条、第四十六条
  • 《中华人民共和国招标投标法实施条例》(2019修订,国务院令第709号)第二十六条、第七十四条
  • 《最高人民法院关于适用〈中华人民共和国民法典〉合同编通则若干问题的解释》(法释〔2023〕13号)第三条、第四条、第六十条、第六十三条
  • 七部委第30号令《工程建设项目施工招标投标办法》第八十一条
  • 《房屋建筑和市政基础设施工程施工招标投标管理办法》(住建部令第47号,2019修正)第四十六条
  • 《中华人民共和国民法典》第四百七十三条、第四百七十九条、第四百九十条、第五百条、第五百七十七条、第五百八十条、第五百八十四条、第一百八十八条
  • 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第三十四条;《最高人民法院关于适用〈中华人民共和国民事诉讼法〉的解释》第二十八条
  • 《中华人民共和国仲裁法》(2025修订,2026-03-01施行)第三十条 https://policy.mofcom.gov.cn/claw/clawContent.shtml?id=103718
  • 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》(法释〔2026〕12号,2026-06-30施行)第二十三条 https://www.court.gov.cn/fabu/xiangqing/504221.html

Scope

This card addresses the positions available to the employer (the tenderee) when, after the letter of acceptance is issued, the winning bidder abandons the award, refuses without justified reason to conclude the contract, raises additional conditions or changes substantive contract terms at signing, or refuses to submit performance security: the consequences for the security, civil damages, administrative penalties, the rules fixing when the contract is formed, why compelled signature cannot be demanded, and the alternative remedies.

Key conclusions

1. The contract is already formed; refusal to sign is breach, not 'no contract and hence no liability'.

Article 4(1) of the SPC Interpretation on Several Issues Concerning the Application of the General Provisions of the Contract Part of the Civil Code (Fa Shi [2023] No. 13): 'Where a contract is concluded by tendering and a party requests confirmation that the contract is formed when the letter of acceptance reaches the winning bidder, the people's court shall support the request. Where, after the contract is formed, a party refuses to conclude the written contract, the people's court shall determine the contract content on the basis of the tender documents, the bid documents and the letter of acceptance.' The written contract is only a formality of performance, not a requirement of formation (consistent with the second half of Article 490(1) of the Civil Code: 'before a party signs, seals or fingerprints, where one party has performed its main obligations and the other party has accepted them, the contract is formed'). The three elements of formation are in Article 3(1) of the same Interpretation: where the names of the parties, the subject matter and the quantity can be determined, the contract should in general be found formed.

2. The legal nature of the three tendering stages: the tender notice is an invitation to offer, the bid is an offer, the letter of acceptance is an acceptance.

Civil Code Article 473: 'An invitation to offer is a manifestation of intent whereby the inviter hopes that others will make offers to it. Auction announcements, tender notices, prospectuses, bond offering measures, fund prospectuses, commercial advertisements and publicity, and mailed price lists are invitations to offer.' Article 479: 'Acceptance is the manifestation of intent by which the offeree accepts the offer.'

3. Liability runs on three tracks, not merely forfeiture of the security.

  • Security consequences plus administrative liability (Implementation Regulations for the Bidding Law, Article 74): 'Where the winning bidder, without justified reason, does not conclude the contract with the employer, raises additional conditions to the employer at signing, or does not submit performance security as required by the tender documents, its award shall be cancelled and the tender security shall not be refunded. For the winning bidder on a project subject to mandatory tendering by law, the relevant administrative supervision department shall order rectification and may impose a fine of not more than 10 per mille of the awarded project amount.'
  • Civil damages (Article 81(2) of the Measures for Tendering and Bidding in Construction Projects, Order No. 30 of seven ministries): 'Where, after the letter of acceptance is issued, the winning bidder abandons the awarded project, refuses without justified reason to sign the contract with the employer, raises additional conditions or changes substantive contract terms at signing, or refuses to submit the required performance security, the employer may cancel the award and forfeit its tender security; where the loss caused to the employer exceeds the amount of the tender security, the winning bidder shall compensate the excess; where no tender security was submitted, the winning bidder shall be liable for the employer's loss.'
  • The same position for building and municipal works (Article 46 of the Measures for the Administration of Tendering and Bidding for Building and Municipal Infrastructure Works, MOHURD Order No. 47, 2019 revision): 'The employer and the winning bidder shall, within 30 days from the date the letter of acceptance is issued, conclude a written contract in accordance with the tender documents and the winning bidder's bid documents, and may not conclude other agreements departing from the substantive content of the contract. Where the winning bidder does not conclude the contract with the employer, the tender security shall not be refunded and the award shall be cancelled; where the loss caused to the employer exceeds the amount of the tender security, the excess shall be compensated; where no tender security was submitted, liability for the employer's loss shall be borne. Where the employer, without justified reason, does not conclude the contract with the winning bidder and causes loss, the employer shall compensate.'

4. Signing period and the bar on side agreements. Bidding Law Article 46: 'The employer and the winning bidder shall, within 30 days from the date the letter of acceptance is issued, conclude a written contract in accordance with the tender documents and the winning bidder's bid documents. The employer and the winning bidder may not conclude other agreements departing from the substantive content of the contract. Where the tender documents require the winning bidder to submit performance security, the winning bidder shall submit it.'

5. The division of labour between the dispatch theory and the receipt theory must not be confused. Bidding Law Article 45: 'After the winning bidder is determined, the employer shall issue the letter of acceptance to it and at the same time notify all unsuccessful bidders of the result. The letter of acceptance is legally binding on the employer and the winning bidder. Where, after the letter of acceptance is issued, the employer changes the award result, or the winning bidder abandons the awarded project, legal liability shall be borne according to law.' That article fixes the starting point of binding force (the dispatch theory); Article 4 of Fa Shi [2023] No. 13 fixes when the contract is formed (the receipt theory). In the marginal case where the notice was dispatched but genuinely never reached the winning bidder, the contract is not yet formed and the employer can only claim pre-contractual liability for the reliance interest under Civil Code Article 500: 'Where a party, in the course of concluding a contract, causes loss to the other party in any of the following circumstances, it shall be liable: (1) negotiating in bad faith under the pretext of concluding a contract; (2) intentionally concealing important facts relating to the conclusion of the contract or providing false information; (3) other conduct violating the principle of good faith.' Proof of receipt must be secured before claiming.

6. A judgment compelling conclusion of the written contract cannot be obtained. Civil Code Article 580: where a party fails to perform a non-monetary obligation or performs it inconsistently with the agreement, the other party may demand performance, except where '(1) performance is impossible in law or in fact; (2) the subject matter of the obligation is unsuitable for compulsory performance or the cost of performance is excessively high; (3) the creditor does not demand performance within a reasonable period'. The obligation to sign the written contract is non-monetary and unsuitable for compulsory performance; the correct path is to request confirmation that the contract is formed, determination of the contract content by the tender documents, the bid documents and the letter of acceptance, and a claim for damages for breach, or termination followed by damages.

7. Scope and scale of damages. Civil Code Article 584: damages shall equal the loss caused by the breach, including the interests obtainable after performance of the contract, but may not exceed the loss that the breaching party foresaw or should have foreseen at the time of concluding the contract (Article 577 separately provides the forms of breach liability such as continued performance, remedial measures and damages; Article 63 of Fa Shi [2023] No. 13 refines the foreseeability factors, namely the purpose of concluding the contract, the parties, the content, the transaction type, trade usage and the negotiation process; Article 60 confirms that the performance interest may be calculated as production, operating or resale profit after deducting the reasonable costs incurred by the non-breaching party in concluding and performing the contract). The tender security itself may not exceed 2% of the estimated price of the tendered project (Implementation Regulations Article 26: 'The tender security may not exceed 2% of the estimated price of the tendered project. The validity period of the tender security shall be consistent with the bid validity period. For domestic bidders on projects subject to mandatory tendering by law, a tender security submitted in cash or cheque shall be transferred out of their basic account. The employer may not misappropriate the tender security.'), so the first layer of cost is usually within 2% of the accepted price; the real exposure lies in the excess (the re-tendering price difference, re-evaluation costs, delay losses), subject to the foreseeability rule.

8. Evidence and procedure points in practice. Fix the evidence of receipt (platform dispatch and receipt records, EMS or notarized delivery vouchers, emails and chat records); issue a written demand to sign within 30 days and a written decision cancelling the award and forfeiting the security (for a guarantee, notify the issuer); start re-tendering or determine the next-ranked bidder promptly, to avoid a deduction for failure to mitigate; keep own standing and documents, and retain invoices for announcement, evaluation, venue and agency service fees. The limitation period is three years, counted from the date the right holder knew or should have known of the harm and of the obligor; claims made more than 20 years after the harm are not protected (Civil Code Article 188). Jurisdiction: construction contract disputes are governed as real estate disputes and fall to the court at the place of the immovable property (Civil Procedure Law Article 34(1) plus Article 28 of the SPC Interpretation on the Civil Procedure Law).

Application boundaries

  • The direction of the rules must not be reversed: the fine of up to 10 per mille and the forfeiture of the security described above target a winning bidder that walks away; where the employer, without justified reason, refuses to sign or changes the award result, under Article 81(1) of Order No. 30 the administrative supervision department gives a warning and orders rectification, may impose a fine of up to 30,000 yuan according to the circumstances, and compensation is due for losses caused to the winning bidder (same position in Article 46(3) of MOHURD Order No. 47).
  • The administrative fine presupposes a project subject to mandatory tendering by law; on a voluntarily tendered project not subject to mandatory tendering, the winning bidder's walk-away mainly produces the security and civil damages consequences.
  • Forms of refusal: (1) express abandonment of the award; (2) refusal without justified reason; (3) raising additional conditions or changing substantive contract terms at signing; (4) refusing to submit performance security. Late signing and passive delay are treated in practice as (2). Where the employer itself acted unlawfully (for example negotiating departures from substantive tender content or collecting security above the permitted ratio), the winning bidder has more room for defence.
  • Where an arbitration clause exists: the arbitration agreement exists independently, and whether the contract is formed, or is modified, ineffective, terminated, revoked or void does not affect the validity of the arbitration agreement reached; the arbitral tribunal has power to confirm the validity of the contract (Arbitration Law, 2025 revision, Article 30), so formation of the contract and damages can be pursued in arbitration.
  • Normative time point: the SPC Interpretation (II) on Construction Contract Disputes (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12) takes effect on 30 June 2026 and applies to first-instance construction contract dispute cases newly accepted after that date; earlier SPC interpretations inconsistent with it yield to it (Article 23). It sets no special rule for a winning bidder's refusal to sign, so that liability still follows the Bidding Law and its Implementation Regulations, Order No. 30 of seven ministries, MOHURD Order No. 47 and Fa Shi [2023] No. 13; transition points between the old and new interpretations are decided by the date of acceptance under Article 23.
  • Where the winning bidder submitted performance security (or a bank guarantee) rather than tender security, claims proceed under the guarantee or security documents; the cap on performance security and the retention money rules are governed by separate rules (Implementation Regulations Article 58, cap 10% of the awarded contract amount).

Further reading

  • Bidding Law (2017 revision): Articles 45, 46.
  • Implementation Regulations for the Bidding Law (2019 revision, State Council Order No. 709): Articles 26, 74.
  • Fa Shi [2023] No. 13: Articles 3, 4, 60, 63, 64-66.
  • Order No. 30 of seven ministries, Measures for Tendering and Bidding in Construction Projects: Article 81.
  • MOHURD Order No. 47 (2019 revision): Article 46.
  • Civil Code: Articles 473, 479, 490, 500, 577, 580, 584, 188.
  • Civil Procedure Law (2023 revision) Article 34; SPC Interpretation on the Civil Procedure Law Article 28.
  • Arbitration Law (2025 revision, effective 1 March 2026) Article 30.
  • Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 (effective 30 June 2026): Article 23.

Keywords

  • 中标通知书
  • 拒签合同
  • 取消中标资格
  • 投标保证金不予退还
  • 中标项目金额10‰罚款
  • 合同自中标通知书到达时成立
  • 缔约过失责任
  • 招标投标法实施条例第七十四条