Splitting the final account for staged completion acceptance, deferred-item completion and the employer's premature use of unaccepted works: settlement basis, determination of the actual completion date, start of the warranty period and defects liability period, and tiered handling of quality objections (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 10.1.5 and 10.3.14)
Works accepted in stages are settled stage by stage: once each stage passes completion acceptance, the final account of the works accepted at that stage is dealt with as the contract provides, the warranty period runs from the date that stage passed completion acceptance, and warranty and final closure follow clause 10.5 of GB/T 50500-2024 (clause 10.1.5). Deferred-item completion requires a deferred-item completion agreement making clear that the completed and accepted parts are settled and paid under the final account application and review clauses (GF-2017-0201 clause 14.3); the deferred items must be consented to by the construction, design and operating units with their scope and completion plan defined, and outstanding tail works must have their content, quantity, investment and completion deadline fixed in one pass at acceptance (clause 6 of the Interim Measures for Completion Acceptance and Handover of Railway Capital Construction Projects). Where the employer uses unaccepted works without authorisation, quality disputes run under the warranty contract/clauses and the final account is dealt with as the contract provides (clause 10.3.14); the completion date is determined as the date of transfer of possession (GB/T 51262-2017 clause 5.7.3, GF-2017-0201 clause 13.2.3; Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 9(3)); for works completed but not accepted and not put to use, and for suspended or halted works, the parties may appoint a testing and appraisal agency for the disputed parts and settle per the results or per the quality supervision authority's decision, while parts without objection are settled as normal.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第10.1.5、10.3.14、10.5节
- GF-2017-0201《建设工程施工合同(示范文本)》第13.2.3、13.4、14.3、14.4款
- GB/T 51262-2017 · Code for Construction Cost Appraisal 第5.7.3条
- 《建设工程质量管理条例》(2019修订)第四十条、第五十八条
- 建质〔2017〕138号《建设工程质量保证金管理办法》(2017修订)第八条
- DB3502/T 078-2022《代建工作规程 第Ⅱ部分:房建专业篇》第2.0.4条(甩项验收定义)
- DB32/T 4062-2021《城市轨道交通工程质量验收统一标准》第8.1.1条
- 《铁路基本建设工程竣工验收交接暂行办法》第6条
What this card covers
This card answers what happens to the final account when the works are not accepted as one whole at once: on what basis staged completion acceptance splits the settlement, how deferred-item completion (handing over the works while deferring certain sub-items not yet completed) is settled by agreement, how the completion date and settlement are fixed when the employer prematurely uses unaccepted works, and how the settlement point connects with the warranty period, the defects liability period and tiered handling of quality objections. Based on GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 10.1.5 and 10.3.14, GF-2017-0201 clauses 13.2.3, 13.4 and 14.3, GB/T 51262-2017 clause 5.7.3, and Articles 40 and 58 of the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects.
Core conclusions
1. Staged completion acceptance - settle separately stage by stage Original wording of clause 10.1.5: 'For works whose contract provides completion acceptance in stages, after each stage passes completion acceptance the employer and the contractor shall settle the final account of the works accepted at that stage as agreed in the contract, the warranty period of those works runs from the date that stage passed completion acceptance, and the warranty and final closure are handled under clause 10.5 of this standard.' Splitting basis: (1) the object of settlement is the works accepted at that stage, without waiting for overall completion; (2) the warranty period starts separately from the date each stage passed acceptance, not from a single overall completion date; (3) the retention money for that stage is reserved and released under clause 10.5 (warranty and final closure); (4) the remaining unaccepted parts do not enter that stage's settlement and continue to be handled through interim settlement by construction stage and subsequent final accounts.
2. Deferred-item completion - sign the agreement first, settle the completed and accepted parts
- Definition of deferred-item acceptance (DB3502/T 078-2022 clause 2.0.4, original): 'leaving aside certain work sub-items not yet completed to the construction drawings but not affecting the main functions, in order to put the works to use early or for other special reasons, and accepting the whole unit work in advance.' Deferred-item is not full completion, so the scope and the settlement route must be locked by agreement.
- GF-2017-0201 clause 14.3, original: 'Where the employer requires deferred-item completion, the parties to the contract shall sign a deferred-item completion agreement. The agreement shall make clear that the parties settle the completed and accepted works as agreed in clause 14.1 [final account application] and clause 14.2 [final account review], and pay the corresponding contract price.' That is: the completed and accepted parts are settled and paid as normal, and the deferred parts are accounted for separately.
- Compliance procedure for deferred items (urban rail transit, DB32/T 4062-2021 clause 8.1.1): one condition of passing completion acceptance is that 'deferred items not affecting operational safety and the basic service level shall be consented to by the construction, chief design, operating and other relevant units and reported to the local rail transit construction administrative authority; the deferred items shall have a defined scope and a planned completion time'.
- Handling of outstanding tail works (clause 6 of the Interim Measures for Completion Acceptance and Handover of Railway Capital Construction Projects, original): 'Works unfinished at preliminary acceptance, or works with quality problems needing rectification, shall be completed by the contractor before formal acceptance. Where, by agreement, individual works genuinely cannot be completed at handover but do not affect the safe use of the whole construction project, acceptance and handover shall still proceed. For the outstanding tail-work items, their content, quantity, investment and completion deadline shall be fixed in one pass at acceptance on the basis of the design documents and the actual situation. The tail works should in principle be completed by the contractor, or by the receiving unit as negotiated. After completion, the construction unit or the receiving unit handles the acceptance and handover formalities.' - tail works do not block acceptance and handover, but their 'content, quantity, investment and completion deadline' must be fixed in one pass; none of the four may be missing, or a final account dispute is likely to follow.
3. Use before acceptance - settlement proceeds; completion dated to the transfer of possession
- Settlement itself does not stall for lack of acceptance. Clause 10.3.14 provides in tiers: where the employer objects to the quality of the works, 'for works that have passed completion acceptance, or that are completed but not accepted yet used by the employer without authorisation, the quality dispute shall be handled under the works warranty contract or the warranty clauses of the contract, and the final account shall be dealt with as agreed in the contract; for works completed but not accepted and not put to use, and for suspended or halted works, where there is a quality dispute the employer and the contractor may jointly appoint a testing and appraisal agency with construction quality testing and appraisal capability to test the disputed parts and determine a solution from the test results, or settle the final account after implementing the decision of the construction quality supervision authority; the final account of the parts without quality objection shall be dealt with as agreed in the contract.'
- Rules for determining the actual completion (completion) date:
- GB/T 51262-2017 clause 5.7.3 (expert assessment basis, three tiers, original): '1 where the assessed project has passed completion acceptance, the date of completion acceptance is the completion date; 2 where the contractor has submitted the completion acceptance report and the employer should have completed the completion acceptance within the time agreed in the contract from the date of receiving the report but did not, the date the contractor submitted the completion acceptance report is the completion date; 3 where the assessed project has not passed completion acceptance and the employer uses it without the contractor's consent, the date of taking possession of the assessed project is the completion date.'
- GF-2017-0201 clause 13.2.3 (contract basis, original): where the works pass completion acceptance, the date the contractor submitted the completion acceptance application report is the actual completion date, and it is stated in the taking-over certificate for the works; where, for reasons attributable to the employer, completion acceptance is not completed within 42 days of the supervising engineer receiving the contractor's completion acceptance application report, or completion acceptance is completed but the taking-over certificate is not issued, the date of submitting the completion acceptance application report is the actual completion date; where the works have not passed completion acceptance and the employer uses them without authorisation, the date of transfer of possession of the works is the actual completion date.
- Judicial basis: under Article 9(3) of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, where a construction project has not passed completion acceptance and the employer uses it without authorisation, the date of transfer of possession of the project is the completion date; Article 14 provides that where the employer, after such unauthorised use, claims on the ground that the quality of the parts used does not conform to the agreement, the people's court will not support the claim, but the contractor remains liable in civil law within the reasonable design working life for the quality of the foundation works and the main structure; Article 27 provides that where the works have actually been delivered, the delivery date is the date the payment falls due (see the card on use before acceptance).
- Early handover of unit works: GF-2017-0201 clause 13.4.1 - where the employer needs to use a unit work before completion of the works, or the contractor proposes early handover of a completed unit work with the employer's consent, acceptance of that unit work may proceed (under the clause 13.2 procedure); on passing, the supervising engineer issues a unit work taking-over certificate countersigned by the employer; unit works for which a taking-over certificate has been issued are in the employer's care, and that acceptance and its conclusions serve as an attachment to the completion acceptance application report for the whole works; clause 13.4.2 provides that the additional costs and/or the delay thereby caused are borne by the employer, together with reasonable profit.
4. Linking the settlement point with the warranty period, the defects liability period and retention money
- Warranty period: Article 40 of the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects (2019 revision), original - for infrastructure works, and for the foundation works and main structure of buildings, the reasonable working life specified in the design documents; 5 years for roof waterproofing works and for bathrooms, rooms and exterior walls with waterproofing requirements; 2 heating seasons and 2 cooling seasons for heating and cooling systems; 2 years for electrical conduits, water supply and drainage pipework, equipment installation and finishing works; other items as agreed by the employer and the contractor. The warranty period of construction works runs from the date of passing completion acceptance (for staged acceptance, separately from the date each stage passed; for unauthorised use, from the transfer of possession presumed to be the completion date, usually from that date).
- Defects liability period: counts from the date the works pass completion acceptance; where acceptance cannot be achieved on schedule for reasons attributable to the contractor, from the date actually accepted; where acceptance cannot be achieved on schedule for reasons attributable to the employer, the works automatically enter the defects liability period 90 days after the contractor submits the completion acceptance report (Article 8 of Jianzhi [2017] No. 138).
- Retention money: reserved at final account in the manner agreed in the contract, with the accumulated retention or bond amount not exceeding 3% of the total settlement price of the works; where performance security has been provided, no retention may be reserved before completion; where a quality guarantee bond, quality insurance or other instrument is used instead, no retention is reserved (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 10.5.1, Article 7 of Jianzhi [2017] No. 138); after the defects liability period ends, final closure under clauses 10.5.5 and 10.5.6 returns the remaining retention or bond without interest.
5. Administrative liability Article 58 of the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects (2019 revision), original: where the construction owner delivers the works for use without organising completion acceptance, delivers them for use although completion acceptance has failed, or accepts unqualified construction works as qualified works, it is ordered to correct this and fined no less than 2% and no more than 4% of the works contract price; where losses are caused, it is liable in compensation under law.
Applicable boundaries
- Staged completion acceptance presupposes that 'the contract provides for staged acceptance'; where the contract is silent and one party unilaterally demands staged settlement, the stage-by-stage settlement basis of clause 10.1.5 does not apply.
- Deferred-item completion presupposes 'the employer requires it / the parties agree', and the deferred items must not affect the main functions or safe use; the building and urban rail transit sectors set separate administrative approval/consent procedures for deferred items, which must also be satisfied.
- Unauthorised use turns on the employer acting 'without authorisation': where both parties agree to early use, or where acceptance is impossible because the contractor refuses to cooperate with acceptance or to hand over documents, the deemed approval presumption does not apply and sharing follows fault.
- 'Deemed approval' reaches only the parts actually used; quality liability for the foundation works and the main structure remains with the contractor within the reasonable working life.
- Clause 10.3.14 does not apply to the settlement of works whose contract has been terminated (the termination settlement clauses govern); the burden and effect of testing and appraisal costs follow the findings of the appraisal agency or the quality supervision authority.
Further reading
GB/T 50500-2024 clause 10.1.5 (settlement of staged completion acceptance), clause 10.3.14 (tiered quality objections and how settlement proceeds), clause 10.5 (warranty and final closure, incl. 10.5.1, 10.5.5, 10.5.6). GF-2017-0201 clause 13.2.3 (completion date), clause 13.4 (acceptance of early handover of unit works), clause 14.3 (deferred-item completion agreement), clause 14.4 (final closure). GB/T 51262-2017 clause 5.7.3 (expert opinion on disputed actual completion dates). Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects (2019 revision) Articles 40 and 58. Measures for the Administration of Retention Money for Construction Works (Jianzhi [2017] No. 138) Articles 8, 9 and 11. DB3502/T 078-2022 clause 2.0.4 (definition of deferred-item acceptance), DB32/T 4062-2021 clause 8.1.1 (consent and reporting procedure for deferred items), clause 6 of the Interim Measures for Completion Acceptance and Handover of Railway Capital Construction Projects (individual unfinished works and tail works).
Keywords
- 分期竣工验收
- 甩项竣工
- 甩项验收
- 未验收先使用
- premature use of the works without taking-over
- 实际竣工日期
- 转移占有
- 质量异议结算