Works put into use before completion acceptance: payment, quality liability and warranty rules (the employer's unauthorized use deemed acceptance of quality)
The employer's unauthorized use of un-accepted works equals deemed acceptance of quality (presumed qualification): the project price remains payable, with the date of transfer of possession serving as the completion date and the payment due date (interest at the 1-year LPR absent an agreed rate); quality risk passes to the employer except for foundations and the main structure (for which the contractor remains liable within the reasonable service life), and only for the parts actually used; warranty duties are not discharged - minimum warranty periods per Article 40 of the Regulations on Quality Management of Construction Works (waterproofing 5 years; heating and cooling 2 heating/cooling seasons; electrical wiring, water supply and drainage piping, equipment installation and finishing 2 years; foundations and main structure, the reasonable design life); the employer additionally bears an administrative fine of 2%-4% of the contract price (Article 58).
Applicable Codes
- 法释〔2020〕25号 第9条、第14条、第27条
- 《建筑法》(2019修正)第61条
- 《建设工程质量管理条例》(2019修订)第40条、第58条
- 《建设工程质量保证金管理办法》(建质〔2017〕138号)第8条
Topic Positioning
Resolves the legal consequences of 'works put into use by the employer before completion acceptance': whether the project price is payable, how quality liability is allocated, warranty periods and administrative liability. General adjudication rules for construction contract disputes (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 plus the Construction Law plus the Regulations on Quality Management of Construction Works).
Core Conclusions
- Underlying prohibition: Construction Law (2019 amendment), Article 61(2): 'A construction project may be delivered for use only after passing completion acceptance; a project that has not been accepted, or has failed acceptance, may not be delivered for use.' The employer's unauthorized delivery into use is itself unlawful.
- The project price is payable: Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 9(3): where the works have not passed completion acceptance but the employer uses them without authorization, the date of transfer of possession of the works is the completion date - once fixed, the contractual payment conditions are satisfied and the employer may not refuse payment on the ground of 'no acceptance'. Article 27 of the same interpretation: where the payment time is not agreed or unclear and the works have been actually delivered, the delivery date is the payment due date, with overdue interest running from that date (absent an agreed rate, at the 1-year LPR for the corresponding period).
- Quality liability shifts: Article 14 - where the employer uses the works without authorization and then claims rights on the ground that the quality of the parts used does not conform to the agreement, the people's court will not support the claim; but the contractor remains civilly liable within the reasonable service life of the works for the quality of the foundation works and the main structure - a mandatory baseline. 'Deemed acceptance' extends only to the parts actually used; the right to object to the quality of unused parts is unaffected. Procedurally, after unauthorized use the employer's application for quality expert determination of the works is generally not granted; warranty claims require the employer to prove that it notified the contractor for repair within the warranty period and the contractor refused.
- Warranty duties not discharged: Regulations on Quality Management of Construction Works (2019 revision), Article 40, minimum warranty periods under normal use: foundation works and main structures of infrastructure projects and buildings - the reasonable service life specified in the design documents; roof waterproofing works and waterproofing of bathrooms, rooms and exterior walls requiring waterproofing - 5 years; heating and cooling systems - 2 heating periods and 2 cooling periods; electrical wiring, water supply and drainage piping, equipment installation and finishing works - 2 years; other items as agreed between employer and contractor. The warranty period runs from passing completion acceptance; with unauthorized use, the transfer-of-possession date is presumed to be the completion date, and judicial practice usually runs the warranty period from the transfer of possession. The employer may claim deduction of the quality retention from unpaid project payments.
- Administrative liability (employer): Article 58 of the Regulations - where the employer fails to organize completion acceptance and delivers the works for use without authorization (or delivers despite failed acceptance, or accepts failed works as qualified), it is ordered to correct and fined 2% to 4% of the project contract price; where losses are caused, it bears compensation liability according to law.
- Defects-liability period: where completion acceptance cannot proceed on schedule for reasons attributable to the employer, the defects-liability period starts automatically 90 days after the contractor submits the completion acceptance report, and the retention return period runs accordingly (Measures for the Administration of Construction Quality Retention Money, Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138, Article 8).
Applicable Boundaries
Applies where the employer knowingly uses un-accepted works without authorization (including handover to unit owners for fit-out and occupancy, or transfer to third parties to continue the works). 'Deemed acceptance' presupposes unauthorized use by the employer: where both parties agree to early use, or the contractor's refusal to cooperate in acceptance or to hand over documents prevents acceptance, the deeming rule does not apply and liability is allocated by fault. Deemed acceptance covers only the parts actually used; liability for foundations and the main structure remains with the contractor within the reasonable service life, subject to proof by the employer. Individual outcomes also depend on the contract terms and the determination of the scope of unauthorized use.
Further Reading
Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, SPC Interpretation (I) on Construction Contract Disputes: Article 9 (completion date/transfer of possession), Article 14 (limits on quality objections after unauthorized use), Article 27 (payment time and overdue interest); Construction Law (2019 amendment), Article 61; Regulations on Quality Management of Construction Works (2019 revision), Article 40 (minimum warranty periods) and Article 58 (administrative fine of 2%-4%); Measures for the Administration of Construction Quality Retention Money (Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138), Article 8 (90-day defects-liability period). Settlement interface: GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 10.3.14 (quality disputes over works already in use go to warranty; settlement proceeds as usual).
Keywords
- 未经竣工验收
- premature use of the works without taking-over
- deemed acceptance / deemed approval
- 竣工日期
- 转移占有
- 保修期限
- 最低保修期
- 工程款
Related Cards
- →
Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 "Construction Interpretation II" and its overall impact on existing judicial interpretations, statutes, and pricing/appraisal standards (23 articles, effective 30 June 2026)
The SPC "Interpretation (II) on the Application of Law in Cases of Construction Contract Disputes" (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, adopted at the 1969th meeting of the Adjudication Committee on 17 March 2026, effective 30 June 2026, 23 articles) does not wholesale-repeal the current "Interpretation (I)" (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25), but per its Article 23 — "for construction contract dispute cases newly accepted at first instance by the people's courts after this Interpretation takes effect, this Interpretation applies ... where earlier SPC interpretations are inconsistent with this Interpretation, this Interpretation prevails" — provisions inconsistent with Interpretation I yield to the new one. Major changes: mandatory-tender projects not tendered are no longer automatically void (Art. 1); pre-bid substantive negotiations void the awarded contract (Art. 2); "audit-as-basis" narrowed (Art. 13 — unsupported absent agreement; with agreement, judicial appraisal available if results are overdue beyond 1 year or manifestly inconsistent); fixed prices not adjusted for major labor/material changes (Art. 9); lump-sum contracts priced proportionally upon termination (Art. 10); standstill/idle losses enjoy no priority right (Art. 17); etc.
- →
Priority right of payment for construction project prices: entitled parties, exercise procedure, scope of coverage and the 18-month exercise period
Under Civil Code Article 807 and Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Articles 35-41: the priority right is exercised by the contractor that concluded the construction contract with the employer (decoration contractors and contractors of uncompleted but quality-qualified works may also qualify when conditions are met), premised on the works being quality-qualified; the exercise path is demand, then overdue non-payment, then agreed discount of the works or petition to the court for auction according to law; the coverage is limited to the project price (labour cost, materials cost, plant and small tools cost, overheads (company and site), profit, statutory levies and fees, taxes and duties (VAT under the current standard), etc.), while interest for late payment, liquidated damages and damages rank as ordinary claims only; the right must be exercised within a reasonable period not exceeding 18 months from the date the price becomes payable - a peremptory period; it takes priority over mortgages and other claims, except the delivery claim of commodity-housing consumers who have paid all or most of the price.
- →
Whether the employer's overdue non-reply to the final account documents is deemed acceptance of the submitted amount - the three-requirement test of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 21, and interface with GB/T 50500-2024
Where the contract stipulates 'overdue non-reply is deemed acceptance', under Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 21, the people's court shall support the contractor's claim for settlement per the final account documents (submitted price); three requirements must be met simultaneously: an express contractual stipulation, delivery of complete settlement documents, and no reply within the agreed period. Absent such stipulation, claims based only on ministerial rules or model contract texts containing 'deemed acceptance' wording are not supported by the SPC and the overwhelming majority of courts. GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 10.3.8, points the same way but is a recommendatory national standard that becomes a contractual obligation only when incorporated by the contract; at the rule level, Article 16 of the former MOC Decree No. 107 has been carried over by Article 18 of MOHURD Decree No. 16, with 28 days as the default period absent agreement.
- →
The relation between the Construction Law and the Quality Management Regulations for Construction Projects: upper-law framework and supporting administrative detail (parent law - subsidiary rules)
The Regulations are administrative rules made under the Construction Law (State Council Decree No. 714, 2019 revision): Construction Law Article 52 authorizes the State Council to set specific quality management measures — the Law sets the principles while the Regulations detail, chapter by chapter and party by party, quality responsibilities, warranty periods, completion acceptance conditions, and penalties, and extend the scope from buildings to civil engineering works.
- →
Works in use but final account not processed: quality disputes go to warranty, final account proceeds (GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 10.3.14)
Works already in use cannot have the final account delayed on grounds of "not taken over / quality objections": GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 10.3.14 provides that for works having passed taking-over (completion acceptance) or subject to premature use of the works without taking-over by the employer, quality disputes are handled under the warranty contract/clauses and the final account is processed as agreed in the contract; the supporting path is notice of demand -> overdue non-check deemed acceptance (Order No. 107, Article 16; 28 days absent agreement) -> interest on overdue payment (Decree No. 728, Article 15; 0.05% per day absent agreement) -> negotiation/arbitration/litigation.
Cited By
- ←
Defining the scope of arbitrable matters in a construction contract arbitration clause: where the clause covers only payment (payment/final account) disputes, do disputes over repair costs and loss compensation caused by defective works quality fall within arbitration - a three-layer test of arbitrability, agreed scope, and form of claim, plus the set-aside risk for excess of scope and the procedural timing points
Two layers. Legally, compensation for defective works quality is a contract dispute between parties equal in status and is arbitrable (Arbitration Law (2025 revision), Articles 3 and 4); but whether it falls within 'this' arbitration clause depends on the wording of the agreed arbitrable matters (Article 27, paragraph 2, item (2)). Where the clause is confined to payment or final account disputes, an employer who pleads defective quality to seek reduced payment, or deducts repair and rework costs in the final account, remains within a payment dispute and may raise it in the payment arbitration (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 12; GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 10.3.13). By contrast, standalone claims beyond repair costs (business interruption, rent, third-party compensation) are in principle outside the agreed arbitrable matters; separately filing them in arbitration risks the award being set aside for 'deciding matters outside the scope of the arbitration agreement' (Article 71, item (2); Fa Shi [2018] No. 5, Article 13, item 1), and that part of the dispute returns to the courts to be accepted under the exclusive jurisdiction for real estate disputes (Civil Procedure Law, Article 34, item 1; Fa Shi [2015] No. 5, Article 28).
- ←
Procedural rules for an employer's counterclaim for quality losses after the contractor has commenced arbitration over the project payment: legal basis of the counterclaim right, the line between defence and counterclaim, institutional counterclaim deadlines and late acceptance, out-of-scope awards and the risk of being set aside
Yes, it can be raised: Article 38 of the Arbitration Law (2025 revision) expressly provides that 'the respondent may admit or rebut the claim and has the right to file a counterclaim'. Quality breach, repair costs and compensation for quality losses are property-rights disputes under the same construction contract and fall within the arbitration agreement on which the main claim relies. But three gates must be passed: (1) the counterclaim must rest on the same arbitration agreement as the claim (matters under another contract, against another party, or administrative fines can only be pursued in a separate case); (2) it must be filed within the deadline in the institutional rules (BAC 2026 Rules Article 18: within 30 days of receipt of the notice of defence; CIETAC 2024 Rules Article 71 for domestic arbitration: within 20 days of receipt of the notice of arbitration), and if late, the arbitration institution (before constitution of the tribunal) or the tribunal (after constitution) decides whether to accept it; (3) substantively, it must satisfy contractor cause + notice to repair with a reasonable period given + refusal or failure to repair to the agreed standard + actual repair completed at reasonable cost. Merely seeking a price reduction or withholding payment is a defensive defence that can be made in the answer; once the employer demands payment from the contractor (repair costs, liquidated damages, third-party claims, delay losses), a counterclaim is mandatory, otherwise the award rules on matters beyond the arbitration agreement and risks being set aside under item (2) of paragraph 1 of Article 71 of the Arbitration Law.
- ←
Burden-of-proof allocation and element checklist for the employer alleging construction quality defects: the five elements - defect exists, attributable to the contractor, prior notice to repair, reasonable repair cost, within the liability period - plus the consequences of failure of proof and the rules on appraisal elucidation
An employer alleging construction quality defects (price reduction / counterclaimed repair costs / deduction from retention money) must prove five elements: (1) the defect objectively exists (non-conformity with the mandatory standards for engineering construction, the design documents or the construction contract); (2) the defect is attributable to the contractor; (3) the contractor was notified to repair and given a reasonable period, and refused to repair or failed within that period to repair to conformity; (4) the repair cost or loss is reasonable in amount (actually incurred or determinable by appraisal); (5) the claim is within the defects liability period or warranty period and outside the restricted scenarios - proof merely that 'the works have quality problems' falls far short of discharging the burden. Basis: Civil Code Article 801 makes 'causes attributable to the constructor' the precondition of liability; Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 16(1), 'where the employer, without notifying the contractor to repair, requests a judgment that the contractor first pay the repair costs, the people's court will not support it', with paragraph 2 supporting the reasonable repair cost only after repair; the party bearing the burden of proof suffers the adverse consequences of failure of proof (Fa Shi [2015] No. 5 Article 90(2)).
- ←
Attribution of the rework and repair period after completion acceptance fails: whether it counts as contractor delay, and in what situations an extension of time may be granted (Civil Code Article 801 + Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Articles 9-11 + Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 16 + GF-2017-0201 clauses 5.3.4 and 5.4)
In principle the period counts against the contractor's time and no extension is granted: where completion acceptance fails for reasons attributable to the contractor, the period of rework, repair and strengthening up to acceptance rests on the contractor, and the completion date is the date of passing re-acceptance after repair (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 9(1)); any part falling after the contract completion date is late delivery, for which the contractor bears liability for breach (Civil Code Article 801: 'where overdue delivery results after repair or rework or reconstruction, the constructor shall bear liability for breach'). The only reversal valves lie in the cause: where the failure is due to the employer, or a pre-completion quality dispute is resolved by appraisal finding the quality compliant (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 11), or the employer delays acceptance or puts the works to premature use without taking-over (Article 9(2) and (3) of the same interpretation), the period is not counted as contractor delay and the time is extended accordingly.
- ←
Checklist of elements of proof for an employer claiming liquidated damages for delay (late completion) and the measurement of the days of delay: the liquidated damages clause; the commencement date and the contract period; determination of the actual completion date under three scenarios; deduction of approved extensions; attribution of the delay and apportionment of concurrent delay; and the rule of sharing concurrent delays in proportion to liability
Claimable, but the amount is not fixed directly by 'how many days late it actually was': days of delay = actual completion date - (commencement date + contract period + extension approved by the employer), multiplied by the contractually agreed daily rate (subject to any cap). Civil Code Article 585(1) is the basis of the claim, and the employer bears the burden of proof under Civil Procedure Law Article 67(1); where the contractor proves statutory or agreed grounds for extension, or that it applied for an extension within the agreed period, the days are reduced (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Articles 9 and 10). The employer need not first prove actual loss - the burden of proving that 'the liquidated damages are excessively higher than the loss' lies on the defaulting party - but to withstand a judicial reduction the employer should still have loss evidence ready.
- ←
After termination of the construction contract, the boundary of the payment defence for parts of the works the employer has actually taken over and put to use (without completion acceptance): a blanket refusal to pay on the ground of 'not accepted' is barred; refusal is allowed only 'to the corresponding extent' for undelivered parts and for foundation and main structure defects; repair costs require prior notice of repair
No blanket refusal. Termination only ends the unperformed part; for completed works of acceptable quality the corresponding price is still payable as agreed (Civil Code Article 806(3)); where the employer makes premature use of parts not accepted, the date of taking over possession of the works is the completion date (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 9(iii)), and later claims on the ground that 'the quality of the used part does not conform to the agreement' are not supported (Article 14 of the same interpretation, excepting the foundation and the main structure). Refusal of payment is limited to: parts not delivered for use, foundation and main structure defects of used parts, and repair costs where repair was requested but still not carried out; and under Civil Code Article 526 only the 'corresponding' request for performance may be refused, not the whole price held back; retention money may be reserved on the base of the price of the works payable to the contractor (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 14).
- ←
Determining the commencement date in disputes: the date stated in the commencement notice (commencement order) versus the date of actual entry onto site with the employer's consent, and how that determination cascades into the start of the construction period, extensions of time, delay damages, and suspension and idle-resource losses
In principle the commencement date stated in the commencement notice (commencement order) governs; if the start conditions were not yet ready when the notice was issued, the time at which the start conditions became ready is the commencement date; if the start time was postponed for reasons attributable to the contractor, the time stated in the commencement notice still governs; if the contractor has actually entered the site and commenced the works with the employer's consent, the time of actual entry and commencement governs; if no commencement notice was issued and no evidence proves the actual commencement date, the date is determined by comprehensively weighing the times stated in the commencement report, the contract, the construction permit, the completion acceptance report or the completion acceptance filing record, together with the facts of whether the start conditions were ready (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 8). In short: the formal document (the order) prevails, subject to two factual corrections - start conditions not ready, and actual entry with consent.
- ←
The procedural timeline chain of completion taking-over of construction projects (notice for acceptance of sub-divisional works, review by the supervising engineer, taking-over organised by the employer, issue of the Taking-Over Certificate) and the contractual consequences where the employer is late in organising taking-over or issuing the certificate (deemed passing of taking-over, the certificate deemed issued, liquidated damages for delay), together with the administrative acceptance procedure requirements
Under the general conditions of GF-2017-0201, the timeline chain of completion taking-over runs: the contractor submits the application report for completion taking-over -> the supervising engineer reviews it within 14 days and forwards it to the employer -> the employer, within 28 days after receiving the report as reviewed by the supervising engineer, completes approval and organises taking-over -> where taking-over passes, the Taking-Over Certificate is issued within 14 days (where it is overdue without justified reason, it is deemed issued from the 15th day after passing). Where the employer uses the works prematurely without taking-over, the certificate must be issued within 7 days after transfer of possession and is deemed issued from the 15th day. Where the employer is late in organising taking-over or in issuing the certificate, liquidated damages are payable for each day of delay, calculated on the priced contract sum at the benchmark interest rate for loans of the same type and period published by the People's Bank of China (wording of the model text). GF-2020-0216 adds a 42-day deemed-passing rule (except where force majeure prevents taking-over). Administratively, under Article 6 of Jian Zhi [2013] No. 171 the employer must notify the project quality supervision agency in writing 7 working days before taking-over and, after receiving the completion report from the contractor, organise the acceptance group.
- ←
Whether the employer may refuse payment for completed works when the contractor exits without handing over construction records: the legal nature of the record-handover obligation, the proportionality limit of the defence of refusal to perform, the two exceptions permitting suspension of payment, and the remedies of a handover claim and evidence preservation (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 15)
As a rule there is no blanket refusal to pay: the consideration for the works price is the accepted completed quantities of passing quality (Civil Code Articles 799 and 793), while handing over construction records is an ancillary duty of cooperation and a procedural condition for taking-over and archiving (Article 509(2), Article 16 of the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects, GB/T 50328-2014 Clause 6.0.3); the two are not reciprocal performances. Even where a defence of refusal to perform is invoked, Articles 525 and 526 permit refusal only of the 'corresponding' performance, and a substitutable duty of cooperation cannot be set against the entire price. The employer's proper remedies are: a claim for handover of the site and construction records under Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 15(1); application for evidence preservation before exit under Article 15(2) (referring to Article 84 of the Civil Procedure Law); and damages under Civil Code Article 584, or set-off under Article 568, for losses caused by the missing records. Payment may be suspended, to an extent corresponding to the obligation, only where the contract expressly makes record handover a precondition of payment, or where the payment condition (passing taking-over) has genuinely not been satisfied because the records are incomplete.
- ←
Time limits for the buyer's quality or quantity objection notice and the 'deemed conformity' rule (Civil Code Article 621): agreed inspection periods; absent agreement, a reasonable period plus a 2-year outer limit from receipt; priority of the quality guarantee period; no notice limit where the seller acted in bad faith - applied where the purchaser rejects goods on grounds of non-conforming quality
Civil Code Article 621: where an inspection period is agreed, the buyer must notify the seller within that period of any non-conformity in quantity or quality, and failure to notify in due time is deemed conformity in quantity or quality; where no inspection period is agreed, notice must be given within a reasonable period after the buyer discovers or should have discovered the non-conformity, and failure to notify within 2 years of receipt of the subject matter is likewise deemed conformity, except that where the subject matter has a quality guarantee period that period applies instead of the 2-year rule; where the seller knew or should have known that the subject matter was non-conforming, the buyer is not bound by the notice periods. So where a purchaser rejects custom-made components on grounds of non-conforming quality, whether the objection was raised within the statutory period directly determines whether the rejection stands; where no objection is raised in time, the quality is deemed conforming, the rejection becomes rejection without cause, and damages are payable for breach.
- ←
Whether the employer may withhold payment when acceptance records of concealed works are missing: whether missing records constitute a defence to payment of the works price, a comparison of refusable and non-refusable scenarios, and the legal bases (Civil Code, Articles 798, 799 and 801; Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 20; Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 16)
The employer cannot refuse payment of the corresponding works price solely on the ground that 'acceptance records of concealed works are missing' - acceptance records are quality-control and measurement-procedure documents, not a constitutive element of the price claim; the legal consequence of missing records is 'determining the quantity from other evidence' or 'the party unable to prove bears the adverse consequence' (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 20; Civil Procedure Law, Article 67; CPL Interpretation, Article 90), not the creation of a right to refuse payment. What is genuinely refusable or reducible is limited to: work completed by the contractor but not conforming to the contract drawings and contract specifications (GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 7.1.4, item 3), parts confirmed non-conforming by testing and expert assessment (prior notice to repair as the precondition, Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 16), and quantities with no evidence at all and impossible to survey (T/ZBD 100.4-2023, Clause 4.3.6(5)).
- ←
When interest on unpaid project payments starts accruing — agreement first, plus three "deemed payable date" nodes
Interest runs from the date the project price becomes payable: where the contract expressly states payment dates, they govern (the start day itself excluded, accruing from the next day); absent or unclear agreement: for delivered works, from delivery; undelivered, from the contractor's submission of the final account documents; neither delivered nor settled, from the date of suit (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 27, continuing Fa Shi [2004] No. 14, Article 18 — long consistent in judicial practice). Supporting: overdue non-response to settlement documents is deemed acceptance (Order No. 107, Article 16; 28 days absent agreement); for late payment by government agencies/public institutions/large enterprises to SMEs, the agreed rate may not be below the 1-year LPR at contract conclusion, and absent agreement 0.05% per day (Decree No. 728, Article 15).
- ←
Whether the contractor may claim the works price where the works are in use but completion taking-over was not obtained: maturity of the payment obligation (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 9(3), transfer of possession deemed completion; Article 14 cutting off the quality defence) and determination of the amount (Article 27 deemed due dates, Article 21 the submitted price, GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 10.3.14 final account proceeds, retention deducted), the situations barring the claim (Civil Code Articles 799 and 793(2)) and the cut-over point of the 2026 Interpretation (II)
The claim lies and the payment obligation is already due: where the works, not having undergone completion taking-over, are used by the employer without authorisation, the date of transfer of possession is the date of completion under Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 9(3), the contractually agreed payment condition thereby matures, and the employer's defences of 'not taken over' or 'the used part does not conform to the agreed quality' fail under Article 14; yet maturity of the obligation does not mean the amount fixes itself - settlement still runs under the contract (with a 'failure to answer in time deemed approval' clause, settlement on the submitted price under Article 21; otherwise review or appraisal), retention money is withheld, and liability for foundations and the main structure is not discharged. Where the works are neither delivered nor taken over and quality fails (Civil Code Article 799), or the contract is void and the works still fail after remedial work (Article 793(2)), payment as agreed cannot be claimed.
- ←
Whether the contractor on incomplete works (the completed parts being of acceptable quality) can claim the statutory priority right of payment for the construction price: conditions, the boundaries of the scope covered, the 18-month period, and a positive-versus-negative scenario comparison
Yes. Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 39: 'Where the quality of construction works not completed is acceptable, and the contractor requests priority of payment of the price of the works it built out of the proceeds of the discount sale or auction of the part of the works it built, the people's court shall uphold the request.' The threshold is 'acceptable quality', not completion acceptance; but the right reaches only the part of the works built by the contractor; the claimant must be the contractor that concluded the construction contract with the employer (Article 35); the subject matter is limited to the construction price (excluding interest, liquidated damages, compensation for loss, and losses from stoppage and idle resources, Article 40(2) and Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 17(2)); and it must be exercised within at most 18 months from the date the employer ought to pay the construction price (Article 41).
- ←
Reviewing the employer's defence of long-term refusal to pay the project price on the ground that 'the final account is not settled / review is not completed': whether the payment obligation has fallen due (Civil Code Articles 799, 577, 579), the three trigger points for interest on arrears (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 27), settlement at the submitted price requires an 'deemed approval upon failure to respond in time' agreement (Article 21), and the statutory cost of delay (the 18-month priority right, SME payment periods and overdue interest)
Refusal to pay cannot stand. The final account is only the procedure that fixes 'how much is payable'; it is not the condition on which the payment obligation arises: once the works pass completion acceptance, the payment obligation has fallen due, and for works actually delivered, interest on the arrears runs from the date of delivery (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 27); the employer may not indefinitely defer payment on the ground of its own delay in settling. But 'cannot refuse payment' does not mean 'pay the submitted price': only where the contract expressly agrees that 'failure to respond within the agreed period after receipt of the final account documents is deemed approval' may settlement be made at the contractor's submitted price (Article 21); absent such an agreement, the cost is determined through judicial assessment; and clauses making the price 'subject to audit / government fiscal review' cannot drag on indefinitely either -- where the conclusion is not issued within a reasonable period for reasons not attributable to the contractor (no more than one year from submission of the final account documents) or obviously contradicts the contract, judicial assessment may be applied for (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 13).
- ←
The undisputed-portion-first payment principle in price disputes: progress payment, final account, and wage protection
Where the project price is disputed, the undisputed portion must be paid first: at the progress payment stage, payment certificates are issued and paid for undisputed BOQ items per GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 9.4.11; where final account re-checking raises objections, the unobjected portion undergoes a partial final account (incomplete final account) first (10.3.7); additional works (10.1.8) and quality disputes (10.3.14) may not delay the undisputed portions; and labor costs may never be withheld under any dispute per Article 35 of the Regulations on Wage Payment for Migrant Workers. The disputed portion itself goes negotiation -> review/mediation -> arbitration/litigation.
- ←
Rules for deducting from the works payment or discounted compensation for construction quality defects: the three layers of failed acceptance, quality not conforming to the agreement, and the defects liability and warranty layer; deduction caps and the repair-notice precondition; and the negative scenarios where deduction is not supported
Deduction is possible, but only conditionally and within limits: qualified quality is the precondition for claiming the works payment or discounted compensation; quality defects may be deducted only within the 'price attributable to the defect' or the 'reasonable repair costs', and only where the defect is attributable to the contractor, repair was notified, and the costs were actually incurred or determined by expert assessment; an employer who has not notified the contractor to repair cannot obtain an advance order for repair costs (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 16(1)); where the works still fail acceptance after repair, the contractor has no right to discounted compensation (Civil Code Article 793(2), item 2); defects not caused by the contractor may not be deducted from retention money; retention is capped at 3% of the total settled price of the works (Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138 Article 7).
- ←
The elements, structure of proof and scope of deduction of the employer's 'quality problems' defence in retention money return disputes (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Art. 17 + Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Arts. 14, 16 and 23 + Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138 + GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 10.5)
The right to return of the retention money arises on expiry of the defects liability period, and a refusal by the employer pleading merely 'the works have quality problems' is in principle not sustained. The defence is partially sustained only where the three elements are all present - the defect is attributable to the contractor + repair has been demanded (GB/T 50500-2024 requires a written demand) and the contractor refused or failed to repair within a reasonable period + a reasonable repair cost has actually been incurred or can be determined by expert assessment - and its effect is only deduction of that reasonable repair cost from the retention money or guarantee with return of the balance, the excess being claimed separately; and return does not release the warranty obligations (Article 17(2) of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25). The start of the return period and the withholding base follow Article 14 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 (where the contract is terminated or void and the works incomplete, the period runs from the contractor's exit from site, and the base becomes the construction price payable to the contractor / the discounted-price compensation).
- ←
Rules for the start point of the defects liability period (the period secured by retention money): the statutory deemed start 90 days after submission of the completion-acceptance report where the employer delays or fails to organise completion acceptance, and a comparison of the start points for normal acceptance, contractor-caused delay, premature use of the works without taking-over, and early acceptance of units or sections
Where for reasons attributable to the employer the works cannot undergo completion acceptance within the prescribed period, the defects liability period is entered automatically 90 days after the contractor submits the completion-acceptance report (Article 8 of Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138); the base is thus 'submission date plus 90 days' - it runs neither from the date of actual passing of acceptance nor immediately from the submission date. In the normal case it runs from the date of passing completion acceptance; where the contractor is the reason, from the date of actual passing; the period is generally 1 year, 2 years at most.
- ←
Rules for determining whether the contractor's warranty and compensation liabilities survive expiry of the defects liability period (after return of the retention money): separation of the two regimes, affirmative and exempted scenarios, layering of the liabilities by nature
Expiry of the defects liability period and full return of the retention money do not release the contractor from its quality warranty liability for the works. Core reason: the defects liability period is only the security period of the retention money (generally 1 year, no more than 2 years - Article 2 of Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138), whereas the warranty period is the statutory minimum quality guarantee period set by Article 40 of the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works (foundations and main structure: the reasonable service life specified in the design documents; waterproofing 5 years; heating and cooling 2 heating periods/cooling periods; electrical wiring, water supply and drainage pipes, equipment installation and finishing 2 years, running from the date of passing completion acceptance); Article 17 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 states that 'the employer's return of the project quality retention money does not affect the contractor's performance of its works warranty obligations under the contract or under law', and Article 41 of the Regulation provides that where quality problems occur within the warranty scope and warranty period the constructing enterprise shall perform the warranty obligation and bear liability to compensate the losses caused. Only the two scenarios of Article 17 of the Warranty Measures fall outside the warranty scope: defects caused by improper use or by a third party, and defects caused by force majeure.
- ←
The duration cap of the defects liability period (generally 1 year, no more than 2 years, i.e. 24 months) against the start events for each situation: taking-over, taking-over delayed by the contractor or by the employer, prior taking-over of unit works, premature use with transfer of possession, extension for defect repair, and the three-way distinction from the retention money return period and the warranty period
The defects liability period is capped at 24 months (2 years): Article 2 of Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138 - 'the defects liability period is generally 1 year and may not exceed 2 years at most, as agreed by the employer and the contractor in the contract'; the model general conditions further state 'not exceeding 24 months at most' and 'including the extension, it may not exceed 24 months in total'. Start: generally from the date the works pass taking-over (completion acceptance); where the contractor causes failure to take over on schedule, from the date the works actually pass taking-over; where the employer causes it, the works automatically enter the defects liability period 90 days after the contractor submits the taking-over report; where a unit work is taken over first, from the date that unit work passes taking-over; where the employer uses the works without taking-over, from the date of transfer of possession. The defects liability period is not the retention money return period and not the warranty period (the latter under Article 40 of the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works: 5 years for waterproofing, the design working life for the main structure).
- ←
Commencement of the defects liability period in all scenarios: where the employer uses the works prematurely without completion acceptance, the period runs from transfer of possession, distinguished from the 90-day automatic-entry rule and from the contractor's exit on termination or invalidity of the contract (Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138, Article 8 + Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 9 + Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 14)
Where the employer uses the works prematurely without completion acceptance, the defects liability period runs from 'the date of transfer of possession of the works' (expressly so provided in GF-2017-0201, Clause 15.2.1, and GF-2020-0216, Clause 11.2; under Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 9(3), the date of transfer of possession is deemed the completion date); the duration follows the contract, generally one year and at most two years. Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138, Article 8, provides only three commencement points - 'the date of passing completion acceptance / the date of actually passing completion acceptance / 90 days after submission of the completion report' - and does not list premature use, so the 90-day rule cannot be transplanted to premature use. Where the contract is terminated, or is void and the works are incomplete, Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 (effective from 30 June 2026), Article 14, instead runs the time limit for return of the retention money from the date of the contractor's exit from site (or from the date of termination where the contract is terminated after exit).
- ←
Splitting the final account for staged completion acceptance, deferred-item completion and the employer's premature use of unaccepted works: settlement basis, determination of the actual completion date, start of the warranty period and defects liability period, and tiered handling of quality objections (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 10.1.5 and 10.3.14)
Works accepted in stages are settled stage by stage: once each stage passes completion acceptance, the final account of the works accepted at that stage is dealt with as the contract provides, the warranty period runs from the date that stage passed completion acceptance, and warranty and final closure follow clause 10.5 of GB/T 50500-2024 (clause 10.1.5). Deferred-item completion requires a deferred-item completion agreement making clear that the completed and accepted parts are settled and paid under the final account application and review clauses (GF-2017-0201 clause 14.3); the deferred items must be consented to by the construction, design and operating units with their scope and completion plan defined, and outstanding tail works must have their content, quantity, investment and completion deadline fixed in one pass at acceptance (clause 6 of the Interim Measures for Completion Acceptance and Handover of Railway Capital Construction Projects). Where the employer uses unaccepted works without authorisation, quality disputes run under the warranty contract/clauses and the final account is dealt with as the contract provides (clause 10.3.14); the completion date is determined as the date of transfer of possession (GB/T 51262-2017 clause 5.7.3, GF-2017-0201 clause 13.2.3; Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 9(3)); for works completed but not accepted and not put to use, and for suspended or halted works, the parties may appoint a testing and appraisal agency for the disputed parts and settle per the results or per the quality supervision authority's decision, while parts without objection are settled as normal.
- ←
Panorama of final account rules: starting point, basis of preparation, the 13 price components, review and confirmation, and finality (GB/T 50500-2024)
The final account is the activity of computing, adjusting, confirming, and paying the contract price after taking-over (completion acceptance) — the summary of interim settlements by construction stage (GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 2.0.35); it starts after the whole project passes taking-over (Clause 10.1.4), with 28 days as the period absent contractual agreement (Ministry of Construction Order No. 107, Article 16). The settlement price is itemized in 13 items in order (Clause 10.3.2), with preliminaries and the main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions recomputed (Clause 10.3.3); the employer's overdue non-checking is deemed acceptance (Clause 10.3.8), and after both parties sign and seal, no re-checking and no claims over pre-settlement events (Clauses 10.3.12, 8.11.22).
- ←
The boundary between the defects liability period (secured by retention money) and the warranty period: differences of length and start, whether funds are held, and refunding retention does not release the warranty duty
Retention money secures only the defects liability period (normally 1 year, 2 years at most, Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138 Article 2); the warranty period follows Article 40 of the Quality Management Regulation for Construction Works: foundations and main structure for the reasonable service life in the design documents; roof waterproofing, watertight bathrooms, rooms and external walls 5 years; heating and cooling 2 heating/cooling seasons; electrical wiring, water supply and drainage pipes, equipment installation and fit-out 2 years - all from the date of passing completion acceptance. Expiry of the defects liability period and refund of retention do not affect the contractor's continuing warranty duty; within the warranty scope and period the contractor performs repairs and compensates losses caused (Article 41).
- ←
Works in use but final account not processed: quality disputes go to warranty, final account proceeds (GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 10.3.14)
Works already in use cannot have the final account delayed on grounds of "not taken over / quality objections": GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 10.3.14 provides that for works having passed taking-over (completion acceptance) or subject to premature use of the works without taking-over by the employer, quality disputes are handled under the warranty contract/clauses and the final account is processed as agreed in the contract; the supporting path is notice of demand -> overdue non-check deemed acceptance (Order No. 107, Article 16; 28 days absent agreement) -> interest on overdue payment (Decree No. 728, Article 15; 0.05% per day absent agreement) -> negotiation/arbitration/litigation.
- ←
Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works art. 37: without the supervision engineer's / chief supervision engineer's signature, materials may not be used, the next process may not proceed, progress payments are not made, and completion acceptance is not held
Art. 37 of the Regulation (2019 revision, Decree No. 714) sets a two-tier signature gate: without the supervision engineer's signature, building materials, components and equipment may not be used or installed on the works and the contractor may not proceed to the next process; without the chief supervision engineer's signature, the employer makes no progress payments and holds no completion acceptance. The railway industry matches: art. 39 of the Provisions on Quality Supervision and Administration of Railway Construction Projects (MOT Order No. 35 of 2021) expresses the same gating in terms of "certification/verification signing" and specifies supervision by witness-standing, patrol inspection and parallel testing.
- ←
Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works — prohibited acts of employer and contractor: fragmented awarding, contract transfer, illegal subcontracting, arbitrary compression of reasonable duration (arts. 7/10/25/78)
Per the Regulation (2019 revision, Decree No. 714): the employer must not fragment a project for awarding (art. 7), must not force bidders below cost, arbitrarily compress the reasonable duration, or expressly/impliedly direct designers or contractors to violate mandatory standards and lower quality (art. 10); contractors must work within their qualification grade, may not exceed it or use another's name, may not lend their name, and must not transfer or illegally subcontract (art. 25). Art. 78 gives the statutory definitions of fragmented awarding, illegal subcontracting (four situations) and contract transfer — the benchmark for administrative determination and judicial decisions.
- ←
Calculating guarantee fees, retention money occupation costs, and financing costs for construction projects
Guarantee (letter of guarantee) fee = guaranteed amount × rate (reference 1‰–5‰, 4‰ recommended; absent agreement the guaranteed amount may take 15% of the total contract price); retention occupation cost = retention amount × occupation time × capital cost rate; capital cost = financing cost (one-off) + capital occupation cost. Red lines: performance security ≤10% of the awarded contract amount; quality (retention) money ≤3% of the total settled project price (replaceable by a bank guarantee; where performance security has been provided, no further retention before completion); overdue interest absent agreement at 0.05‰ per day. Where a guarantee is allowed to replace cash, prefer the guarantee.
- ←
Can payment be made when acceptance fails: measurement-and-payment preconditions, the repair route, and the unauthorized-use exception
Qualified quality is the precondition of measurement and payment: work failing process acceptance may not be measured or paid as progress payment; failed completion acceptance does not start the settlement — payment follows rework/repair to conformity (repair costs self-borne by the contractor), and work still unqualified after repair is not paid; where part qualifies and part does not, the unobjected part settles per contract; where the employer uses the works without acceptance, this is deemed acceptance — payment is due, subject to an administrative fine of 2%-4% of the contract price.
- ←
Return of the quality retention money: timing, procedure, and the final account interface (Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138 + GB/T 50500-2024 §10.5)
The retention money is returned when the defect liability period (generally 1 year, 2 years maximum) expires and the contractor has fulfilled its defect-repair duties, upon application; the period runs from completion acceptance, or — where acceptance is impossible for employer reasons — automatically 90 days after the contractor submits the completion acceptance report; the employer verifies within 14 days and returns within 14 days after verification absent an agreed return period; failure to respond within 14 days of the application, and again 14 days after a demand, is deemed acceptance; upon expiry, final account clearance proceeds per GB/T 50500-2024 §10.5.5, returning the guarantee or remaining retention money without interest.
- ←
Completion-acceptance filing for construction projects: the 15-day deadline, the document checklist, and the distinction from fire-protection filing (5 working days)
Within 15 days of passing completion acceptance, the employer (construction unit) shall file with the filing authority (the county-level-or-above local housing/construction department where the works are located) (Regulations on Quality Management Article 49, consistent with Ministry Order on Filing, Article 4). Six categories of documents are filed per Article 5, housing projects adding the residential quality warranty and instruction booklets; late filing: correction within a time limit plus a 200,000-500,000 yuan fine (Article 9). Note: fire filing is separate and shorter - within five working days of acceptance for "other construction works", filed with the fire design-review authority (MOHURD Order No. 58, Article 36).
- ←
The relation between the Construction Law and the Quality Management Regulations for Construction Projects: upper-law framework and supporting administrative detail (parent law - subsidiary rules)
The Regulations are administrative rules made under the Construction Law (State Council Decree No. 714, 2019 revision): Construction Law Article 52 authorizes the State Council to set specific quality management measures — the Law sets the principles while the Regulations detail, chapter by chapter and party by party, quality responsibilities, warranty periods, completion acceptance conditions, and penalties, and extend the scope from buildings to civil engineering works.
- ←
The FIDIC Performance Certificate (Red Book Clauses 11.9/11.10) mapped against the domestic completion acceptance - defect liability period - final settlement system: correspondences and differences
Performance Certificate is not Performance Bond. FIDIC Red Book 11.9: the Engineer issues the Performance Certificate within 28 days after the latest DNP expiry - "Only the Performance Certificate shall be deemed to constitute acceptance of the Works"; the 2017 edition adds deemed issue (a further 28 days after the due date); 11.10 keeps unperformed obligations alive after issue. The domestic system has no single counterpart: the function is shared by completion acceptance (taking over of the works), the defect liability period (generally 1 year, max 2, Jianzhi [2017] No. 138 Article 2), final settlement (GB/T 50500-2024 10.5.5/10.5.8 - silence deemed consent and deemed issuance of the payment certificate), and retention return (cap 3% of the settlement total, no interest). Biggest difference: after the FIDIC certificate the contractor is essentially discharged from defect duties; domestically, DNP expiry only releases the retention - statutory warranty duties persist.
- ←
Legal consequences where contractors fail or delay warranty performance: correction order + 100k-200k fine running in parallel with damages (Regulations Articles 66/41, Construction Law Article 75, Ministry Order No. 80 Article 19)
A contractor failing or delaying warranty performance shall be ordered to correct and fined 100,000-200,000 yuan, and shall compensate losses from quality defects within the warranty period - the fine (administrative) and damages (civil) run in parallel; paying the fine does not exempt compensation. Basis: Regulations on Quality Management Article 66, Measures for Quality Warranty of Housing Projects Article 19, Construction Law Article 75; Regulations Article 41 requires the contractor to perform warranty and compensate for losses for quality problems within the warranty scope and period.