Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-29

Burden-of-proof allocation and element checklist for the employer alleging construction quality defects: the five elements - defect exists, attributable to the contractor, prior notice to repair, reasonable repair cost, within the liability period - plus the consequences of failure of proof and the rules on appraisal elucidation

An employer alleging construction quality defects (price reduction / counterclaimed repair costs / deduction from retention money) must prove five elements: (1) the defect objectively exists (non-conformity with the mandatory standards for engineering construction, the design documents or the construction contract); (2) the defect is attributable to the contractor; (3) the contractor was notified to repair and given a reasonable period, and refused to repair or failed within that period to repair to conformity; (4) the repair cost or loss is reasonable in amount (actually incurred or determinable by appraisal); (5) the claim is within the defects liability period or warranty period and outside the restricted scenarios - proof merely that 'the works have quality problems' falls far short of discharging the burden. Basis: Civil Code Article 801 makes 'causes attributable to the constructor' the precondition of liability; Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 16(1), 'where the employer, without notifying the contractor to repair, requests a judgment that the contractor first pay the repair costs, the people's court will not support it', with paragraph 2 supporting the reasonable repair cost only after repair; the party bearing the burden of proof suffers the adverse consequences of failure of proof (Fa Shi [2015] No. 5 Article 90(2)).

Applicable Codes

  • 《中华人民共和国民法典》第五百八十二条、第七百九十三条、第七百九十九条、第八百零一条
  • 法释〔2026〕12号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第十六条、第二十三条(2026年3月17日审判委员会第1969次会议通过,2026年6月30日施行)https://www.court.gov.cn/fabu/xiangqing/504221.html
  • 法释〔2020〕25号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第十二条、第十三条、第十四条、第十六条、第三十二条
  • 法释〔2015〕5号《最高人民法院关于适用〈中华人民共和国民事诉讼法〉的解释(2022修正)》第九十条、第九十一条
  • 建质〔2017〕138号《建设工程质量保证金管理办法(2017修订)》第二条、第九条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第10.3.13条、第10.5.3条

Issue and scope

In construction quality defect disputes, who proves what, and to what standard - a layered structure. It covers all situations where the employer claims a price reduction by way of defence, counterclaims repair costs, or deducts repair costs from the retention money or the bank guarantee within the defects liability period; the core is upgrading 'a defect is shown' to 'five elements satisfied plus one period limitation'.

Core conclusions

1. The four-layer burden-of-proof structure (layers first, proof second)

Layer Proving party Fact to be proved Basis
Layer 1 (claim in chief) Contractor Works of acceptable quality (completion taking-over passed) - the precondition of the price claim, not a matter for the employer to prove Civil Code Article 799: 'where taking-over passes, the employer shall pay the price as agreed and receive the works'; 'works not taken over, or failing taking-over, may not be put into use'
Layer 2 (defence / counterclaim) Employer Defect exists; attributable to the contractor; notice to repair given and the contractor refused or failed to repair in time; cost reasonable Civil Code Article 801; Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 16; Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Articles 12, 16
Layer 3 (rejoinder) Contractor The defect was caused by the employer's fault (defective design supplied; building materials, components or equipment supplied or nominated for purchase not conforming to the mandatory standards; specialist works directly nominated to a subcontractor); or the employer used the works without taking-over; or improper use, force majeure Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Articles 13, 14
Layer 4 (specialist questions) Party bearing the burden of proof Defect causation, repair cost and other appraisal matters; failing to apply for appraisal after elucidation, applying but not paying the fee, or refusing to provide materials - adverse consequences of failure of proof Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 32

Two common errors must be corrected: first, 'the employer must prove the works conform' - conformity is the contractor's precondition to payment, and the burden sits on the contractor's side; the employer needs only to prove that the defect exists and is attributable to it; second, 'showing a defect justifies refusing payment as a whole' - a defect supports only the price reduction or repair-cost deduction for the corresponding part.

2. The employer's five elements (item by item)

  1. The defect objectively exists. Definition in Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138 Article 2(2): 'a defect means construction quality not conforming to the mandatory standards for engineering construction, the design documents, and the agreement of the construction contract'; Civil Code Article 801 speaks of 'quality not conforming to the agreement'. Evidence: the contract quality clauses, design drawings and technical verification sheets, inspection-lot / sub-item / sub-divisional / unit-works acceptance records, concealed works acceptance records, the supervisor's notices and rectification notices, test reports by qualified bodies, and photographs of the defect locations.
  2. The defect is attributable to the contractor (the constructor). Civil Code Article 801: 'Where the quality of the works does not conform to the agreement for causes attributable to the constructor, the employer may demand that the constructor repair, rework or alter it free of charge within a reasonable period. Where repair, rework or alteration causes delayed delivery, the constructor bears liability for breach.' Employer-side or third-party causes to be excluded: defective design, non-conforming materials or equipment supplied or nominated for purchase by the employer, directly nominated subcontracting, improper use, force majeure (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 13).
  3. The prior procedure of notice to repair was performed. Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 16, paragraph 1: 'where the quality of the works does not conform to the agreement for causes attributable to the contractor, and the employer, without notifying the contractor to repair, requests a judgment that the contractor first pay the repair costs, the people's court will not support it'; paragraph 2: 'where the contractor refuses to repair, or fails within a reasonable period to repair to conformity, and the employer, having repaired, claims that the contractor bear the reasonable repair costs, the people's court will support it.' Notice to repair plus a reasonable period is thus the procedural gate, and 'the employer has repaired' is the point at which the cost claim arises. Within the defects liability period a written demand is further required: GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 10.5.3, 'where the contractor refuses to repair, or fails within a reasonable period to remedy the defect and/or damage, and still fails to repair after the employer's written demand, the employer may repair itself or engage a third party to repair, and the contractor shall bear the costs of repair.'
  4. The repair cost / loss is reasonable in amount. A claim for 'advance payment of repair costs' is unsupported (no cost has arisen where nothing is repaired); the cost must have been actually incurred and be reasonable, or be determinable by appraisal. Article 16 of Interpretation (I) further allows the employer to counterclaim 'damages including the reasonable costs of repair, rework and alteration', which the people's court may hear together with the main claim.
  5. Within the liability period, and outside the restricted scenarios. The defects liability period is generally 1 year and at most 2 years, as agreed between employer and contractor (Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138 Article 2(3)); within it, contractor-caused defects are repaired by the contractor, which also bears the appraisal and repair costs; if it neither repairs nor bears the costs, the employer may deduct as agreed from the retention money or the bank guarantee, and claim further where the costs exceed the retention (Article 9 of the same Measures). Restricted scenario: Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 14, 'where the works have not undergone completion taking-over and the employer, after unauthorised use, claims rights on the ground that the used part does not conform to the agreed quality, the people's court will not support it; however, the contractor remains liable within the reasonable design life of the works for the quality of the foundation works and the main structure.'

3. Consequences of failure of proof

Fa Shi [2015] No. 5 Article 90(2): 'Before judgment is rendered, a party that fails to produce evidence, or whose evidence is insufficient to prove its factual claim, bears the adverse consequences, being the party with the burden of proof.' Article 91 fixes the allocation: a party asserting that a legal relationship exists proves the basic facts of its creation; a party asserting its change or extinguishment, or that a right is hindered, proves those basic facts. In disputes on specialist questions the court shall elucidate to the party bearing the burden of proof; a party that, after elucidation, does not apply for appraisal, or applies but does not pay the appraisal fee, or refuses to provide the relevant materials, bears the legal consequences of failure of proof; where no application was made at first instance but is made at second instance and the court deems it genuinely necessary, Article 170(1)(3) of the Civil Procedure Law applies (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 32).

4. Route of claim and scope of deduction

  • Price-reduction route: Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 12, 'where the quality of the works does not conform to the agreement for causes attributable to the contractor, and the contractor refuses to repair, rework or alter it, the employer's request to reduce the works price will be supported'; Civil Code Article 582 allows the aggrieved party to 'reasonably elect to require the other party to bear repair, redo, replacement, return, price reduction or other contractual remedies for breach'.
  • Settlement-deduction route: GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 10.3.13 - where the contractor's rectification fails or is not carried out, the employer may as agreed require it to bear the costs of repair, rework and the like and deduct them in the final account; for irreparable defects, the price of that part may be deducted from the final account total; repairable defects are repaired by the contractor at its cost; where the parties dispute the defect, they jointly appoint a specialist quality appraisal body, the cost being borne by the responsible party.
  • Void-contract route: Civil Code Article 793 - contract void but the works passing acceptance: price compensation by reference to the agreed contract price; works failing acceptance: where remedial work passes, the employer may claim the repair cost from the contractor; where it still fails, the contractor has no right to price compensation; an employer at fault for the losses caused by the non-conformity bears corresponding liability.

Boundaries of application

  • The card addresses the allocation of defect liability for quality not conforming to the agreement; disputes over time, price and settlement are outside its scope.
  • Prior notice to repair is an express requirement of the 2026 rules, with a divide by date of conduct: Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 takes effect on 30 June 2026 (adopted 17 March 2026 at the 1969th meeting of the SPC Judicial Committee, published 29 June 2026); under its Article 23, first-instance cases newly accepted after the effective date apply it; cases accepted earlier, and points where the new and old interpretations diverge, are resolved by the timing divide and the 'this interpretation prevails' rule.
  • The defects liability period (generally 1 year, at most 2 years) is not the warranty period; warranty scope and periods follow Article 40 of the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects, and returning the retention money does not discharge the warranty obligations.
  • Where the employer used the works without taking-over, it loses claims only as regards 'the used part' and only for quality matters other than the foundation works and the main structure (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 14).
  • Satisfying the proof elements is not the same as winning: even with all five satisfied, the deduction or compensation is capped at the actual reasonable cost, and a local defect cannot be set against payment as a whole.

Further reading

  • Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 16 (prior notice to repair; repair costs), Article 23 (temporal effect); text at the SPC website: https://www.court.gov.cn/fabu/xiangqing/504221.html
  • Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 (Interpretation (I)) Article 12 (price reduction), Article 13 (employer fault), Article 14 (unauthorised use), Article 16 (counterclaim heard together), Article 32 (appraisal elucidation; consequences of failure of proof)
  • Civil Code Articles 582, 793, 799, 801
  • Fa Shi [2015] No. 5 (Interpretation on the Civil Procedure Law) Articles 90, 91
  • Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138, Measures for Administration of Construction Quality Retention Money, Article 2 (definition of defect; defects liability period), Article 9 (repair and deduction; further claims)
  • GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 10.3.13 (settlement deduction; irreparable defects), Clause 10.5.3 (repair within the defects liability period; deduction from the guarantee)

Keywords

  • 工程质量缺陷
  • 举证责任
  • 发包人举证
  • 通知修复
  • 修复费用
  • 法释〔2026〕12号
  • defects liability period
  • 鉴定释明