Priority right of payment for construction project prices: entitled parties, exercise procedure, scope of coverage and the 18-month exercise period
Under Civil Code Article 807 and Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Articles 35-41: the priority right is exercised by the contractor that concluded the construction contract with the employer (decoration contractors and contractors of uncompleted but quality-qualified works may also qualify when conditions are met), premised on the works being quality-qualified; the exercise path is demand, then overdue non-payment, then agreed discount of the works or petition to the court for auction according to law; the coverage is limited to the project price (labour cost, materials cost, plant and small tools cost, overheads (company and site), profit, statutory levies and fees, taxes and duties (VAT under the current standard), etc.), while interest for late payment, liquidated damages and damages rank as ordinary claims only; the right must be exercised within a reasonable period not exceeding 18 months from the date the price becomes payable - a peremptory period; it takes priority over mortgages and other claims, except the delivery claim of commodity-housing consumers who have paid all or most of the price.
Applicable Codes
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第八百零七条
- 法释〔2020〕25号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第二十七条、第三十五至四十一条
- 法释〔2026〕12号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第二十一条
- 法释〔2026〕12号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第二十三条
- 法释〔2023〕1号《最高人民法院关于商品房消费者权利保护问题的批复》
Topic Positioning
A complete map of the priority right of payment for construction project prices - entitled parties, exercise procedure, scope of coverage and time limit (Civil Code Article 807 plus SPC Interpretation (I) on Construction Contract Disputes, Articles 35-41) - for quickly locating provisions when a contractor asserts the priority or an employer defends against it.
Core Conclusions
- Basis of the claim and procedure (Civil Code, Article 807, original text): 'Where the employer fails to pay the price as agreed, the contractor may demand payment within a reasonable period. If the employer still fails to pay within that period, the contractor may, unless the nature of the works makes discount or auction inappropriate, agree with the employer to discount the works, or petition the people's court to auction the works according to law. The price of the construction works enjoys priority of payment out of the proceeds of the discount or auction.' Four requirements: (i) the employer failed to pay as agreed; (ii) the contractor has made a demand and allowed a reasonable period (demand is a procedural requirement); (iii) the works are not by nature unsuitable for discount or auction; (iv) satisfaction is achieved by agreed discount or petition for court-ordered auction.
- Entitled parties: the contractor that concluded the construction contract with the employer (Interpretation (I), Article 35); contractors of decoration works may enjoy priority over the price of the decoration works where they are capable of discount or auction (Article 37); contractors of uncompleted but quality-qualified works may exercise it for the part they built (Article 39); actual constructors do not in principle hold it directly and must proceed through the contractor or by subrogation.
- Precondition: the construction works are quality-qualified (Article 38); taking-over (completion acceptance) is not required, and the validity of the contract does not matter.
- Scope: determined per the pricing rules of the State Council's construction administration department (covering labour cost, materials cost, plant and small tools cost, overheads (company and site), profit, statutory levies and fees, taxes and duties (VAT under the current standard), etc.); interest on late payment of the project price, liquidated damages and damages do not enjoy priority and rank as ordinary claims (Article 40).
- Period: the right must be exercised within a reasonable period not exceeding 18 months from the date the project price becomes payable (Article 41); it is a peremptory period (fixed period), to which suspension, interruption or extension of the limitation period does not apply, and the right extinguishes on expiry; where the payable date is not agreed or unclear, refer to Article 27: for delivered works, the delivery date; for undelivered works, the date of submitting the final account documents; where neither delivered nor settled, the date of filing suit.
- Ranking: priority over mortgages and other claims (Article 36); exception 1: the delivery claim of commodity-housing consumers who have paid all or most of the price prevails over the priority right of payment (Fa Shi [2023] No. 1); exception 2: works unsuitable for discount or auction (public facilities, social housing, etc.) may not be discounted or auctioned for satisfaction (proviso to Article 807), but the price claim itself survives.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to the civil handling of construction contract disputes. Contract invalidity usually does not defeat the priority right for works that passed acceptance (mainstream judicial view); whether contractor advance financing (deferred payment) and profit fall within the covered scope varies by locality. Once the peremptory period lapses the right extinguishes - demand payment from the employer in writing early and expressly claim the priority in the claims or enforcement proceedings; suing for the price without claiming priority may be found not to have exercised it. The consumer-priority rule applies only to purchaser-consumers who have paid all or most of the price.
Further Reading
Civil Code, Article 807 (demand, agreed discount or court auction, priority of payment) and Article 808 (matters not covered follow the provisions on work contracts); SPC Interpretation (I) on Construction Contract Disputes, Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Articles 27 and 35-41; SPC Reply on the Protection of Commodity-Housing Consumers' Rights, Fa Shi [2023] No. 1; MOHURD, Measures for the Administration of Pricing in Contracting and Subcontracting of Building Works, on the composition of the project price.
Keywords
- 建设工程价款优先受偿权
- 十八个月
- 除斥期间
- 起算时点
- 应付款之日
- 工期顺延
- 结算协议
- 法释〔2026〕12号
Cited By
- ←
Statutory payment terms and late-payment liability for construction sums owed to small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), covering progress payments and settlement sums: 30 days, capped at 60, for government agencies and public institutions; 60 days for large enterprises; rules for when the clock starts; the overdue-interest benchmark; and the priority right to payment out of the works price (State Council Decree No. 802, Regulation on Ensuring Payment to SMEs, 2025 revision, Articles 9 to 20; Civil Code Article 807; Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Articles 26 and 41)
Government agencies and public institutions procuring works from SMEs must pay within 30 days of delivery; a contract may provide otherwise, but the payment term must not exceed 60 days; for large enterprises the outer limit is 60 days. Where the contract adopts stage settlement, periodic settlement or the like, the payment term runs from the date both parties confirm the settled amount (State Council Decree No. 802, Article 9). Late payment carries overdue interest: any agreed rate must be no lower than the 1-year loan prime rate at the time of contract conclusion; absent agreement, interest accrues at a daily rate of 0.05% (Article 17). The contractor may further claim the priority right to payment out of the construction price under Civil Code Article 807; that right must be exercised within 18 months at most, counted from the date on which the employer became obliged to pay the construction price (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 41).
- ←
Whether the construction payment priority (the statutory right to payment for construction works out of the proceeds of discount or auction of the works) is lost when a construction contract is held void for unlawful contract transfer, unlawful subcontracting or qualification borrowing (contracting under another enterprise's name): constitutive requirements (eligible claimant plus acceptable quality; contract validity not among them), comparison of claimant eligibility (the contractor contracting with the employer vs the actual builder accepting a transfer or unlawful subcontract vs the qualification borrower), the exercise period unchanged by invalidity, and staleness risks of outdated local guidance
Invalidity of the contract does not of itself extinguish the construction payment priority, but the claimant must satisfy both statutory requirements: being a contractor that has entered into a construction contract with the employer (Article 35 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25) and acceptable quality of the works (Articles 38 and 39). The judicial interpretations do not list contract validity as a requirement, so the reference-based compensation claim under a void but quality-passed contract can equally enjoy priority. The actual builder accepting a transfer or unlawful subcontract is not an eligible claimant and may only claim reference-based compensation from the contractor under the transfer or subcontract; its claim against the employer, with whom it has no contract, for compensation or damages will not be supported (Article 6 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12), though it may proceed by subrogation under Article 535 of the Civil Code. The 18-month exercise period runs from the date the employer ought to pay for the works; invalidity neither restarts nor extends it.
- ←
Whether an agreement signed when the employer cannot pay, settling the project payment with part of the properties (including shops) at a valued price, constitutes lawful exercise of the priority right to payment for construction works: the precondition that the subject be 'the very works' built by the contractor, the four requirements of Article 18 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, the distinction from prohibited forfeiture clauses, the effect on mortgagees and other third parties, agreed discounting compared with application for court auction, and retention of the valuation report
Yes, but 'having signed' is not 'having exercised'; every gate must be passed at once: (1) the subject of the discount must be 'the very works' built by the contractor (Civil Code Art. 807); if it is the employer's property elsewhere or from another project, there is only an ordinary debt-for-property settlement (Fa Shi [2023] No. 13 Art. 27), with purely personal-claim effect and no priority over mortgages; (2) the four conditions of Art. 18 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 must be met concurrently - acceptable quality of the works built by the contractor, the works being discountable, the employer being overdue in payment and still failing to pay within a reasonable period after demand, and the discounted amount being substantially equivalent to the actual value of the works at the time. Price equivalence is the key line against the forfeiture prohibitions (Civil Code Arts. 401, 428; Fa Shi [2023] No. 13 Art. 28): the legitimacy comes from liquidation consideration, not from the creditor directly acquiring ownership.
- ←
Whether the quality retention money (3% retention) can be brought within the contractor's priority right to payment out of the construction project price, and the accounting method of back-computing, from the defects liability period plus the return-verification procedure period, whether the 18-month preclusive period has expired
Retention money is 'withheld from the works price payable' and forms part of the works price; it can be brought within the priority scope, but only subject to quality of the works passing (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 38), the return condition maturing on expiry of the defects liability period, and the 18-month exercise period not being exceeded (Article 41); interest and liquidated damages for late return of retention money enjoy no priority (Article 40, item (2)). The 18 months is a preclusive period; the 'date payment falls due' is approximately the defects liability period (12 months where agreed at 1 year, or 24 months at the statutory 2-year cap) plus the return-verification procedure period (14 days verification plus, absent agreement, 14 days return after verification, about 0.5-1 month). Back-computed from 36 months after delivery: with a 1-year period the due date is around month 12.5, about 23.5 months ago, already exceeded by about 5.5 months; with a 2-year period the due date is around month 24.5, about 11.5 months ago, leaving a window of about 6.5 months.
- ←
Assessment and remedies once the 18-month period of the construction payment priority has run out: nature of the period and the layered consequences of expiry, back-solving the accrual date to rescue the claim, the differing effects of a written demand on the peremptory period versus the 3-year limitation period, and correction of the outdated from-completion six-month local position
Where 19 months have passed since 'the date the employer ought to pay for the works', absent an agreed variation of the payment date or a settlement agreement fixing another date, the 18-month period under Article 41 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 (a peremptory period - no interruption, suspension or extension) has expired, the priority right is extinguished and no priority claim can be made out of the discount or auction proceeds; but the principal debt survives and its 3-year limitation period (Article 188 of the Civil Code) is far from expiring - suit for the principal, interest and liquidated damages remains available, only demoted to an ordinary claim. A written demand cannot stretch the 18 months but constitutes 'a demand for performance made to the obligor' under Article 195(1) of the Civil Code, interrupting the 3-year period and fixing the accrual facts. Note also: 'the date of completion' is not the accrual point under the current position (that was the six-month local rule in Article 14 of the Jiangsu High Court's 2018 answers).
- ←
Filing construction payment claims in bankruptcy proceedings: addressee and filing period (30 days minimum, 3 months maximum from the announcement of acceptance), the scope of claims that may be filed (unmatured claims deemed mature, interest stops accruing, conditional and time-limited claims and claims pending litigation or arbitration), filing materials, late supplementary filing and forfeiture, verification and confirmation of the schedule of claims and objection actions, and the procedural effect that lawsuits stop and claims are filed instead after acceptance
Yes - the claim can and must be pulled into the bankruptcy proceedings: after the people's court accepts the bankruptcy petition, the contractor may no longer bring a payment action for performance; it must file in writing with the administrator within the court-fixed filing period (running from the date of the announcement of acceptance, minimum 30 days, maximum 3 months - Enterprise Bankruptcy Law Article 45); unmatured claims are deemed mature at acceptance and interest-bearing claims stop accruing from acceptance (Article 46); conditional, time-limited and litigation/arbitration-pending claims may all be filed (Article 47); the filing must state in writing the amount and whether there is property security, with evidence (Article 49); a late filer may file supplementary before the final distribution of the bankrupt estate, but distributions already made are not topped up, the costs of examination and confirmation are borne by the supplementary claimant, and one who fails to file as the law requires may not exercise rights through the bankruptcy procedure (Article 56); the administrator registers, examines and compiles the schedule of claims (Article 57), which is submitted to the first creditors' meeting for verification - unobjected claims are confirmed by court ruling, objected claims go to suit before the accepting court (Article 58).
- ←
How a contractor realises the construction payment priority right in the bankruptcy of the employer (the project owner): treatment by reference to the separate satisfaction right, the ranking of payments out of the proceeds of the works, the chain of claim filing - administrator review - creditors' meeting verification - court ruling of confirmation, the differences in exercising security rights across liquidation / reorganization / composition, and the filing period and the 18-month time limit
It can be realised, but only by being channelled into the bankruptcy proceeding: the contractor's construction payment priority right (the statutory priority right under Article 807 of the Civil Code, in nature a statutory security right) is handled in bankruptcy by reference to the separate satisfaction right under Article 109 of the Enterprise Bankruptcy Law - it must be filed with the administrator within the filing period (not less than 30 days and not more than 3 months from the public notice of acceptance, Article 45), expressly claiming priority payment, then reviewed by the administrator into the schedule of claims (Article 57), verified by the first creditors' meeting (Article 58(1)), confirmed by court ruling if unchallenged, or, if challenged, made the subject of a claim-confirmation action before the court that accepted the bankruptcy (Article 58(3)); after acceptance no separate action for payment may be brought (new actions are not accepted; only claims may be filed), preservation must be released, and enforcement terminates on the declaration of bankruptcy. Ranking: out of 'the proceeds of the works', the construction payment priority right is superior to mortgages and other claims (Article 36 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25); the unsatisfied portion, or a waiver of the right, becomes an ordinary claim (Article 110); the bankruptcy estate (property not subject to separate satisfaction) follows Article 113: bankruptcy expenses and debts incurred for the common benefit -> employee claims -> social insurance and taxes -> ordinary bankruptcy claims. During the reorganization period the exercise of security rights is suspended (Article 75; restoration may be requested, ruled on within 30 days, reconsideration within 10 days, realisation commenced within 15 days of approval); from the date of the ruling of composition the security right holder may exercise its right (Article 96). The exercise period of the priority right, 18 months at most (Article 41 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25), is a peremptory period, not interrupted by the acceptance of bankruptcy; the priority scope excludes interest, liquidated damages and damages (Article 40(2)), and, for first-instance cases newly accepted after 30 June 2026, losses from suspension and idle resources (Article 17(2) of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12).
- ←
The contractor's remedies in bankruptcy against an administrator's reduction or refusal of a works-payment claim: claim review opinion -> verification of the schedule of claims at the creditors' meeting -> a claim-confirmation action before the court accepting the bankruptcy petition (arbitration where an arbitration clause exists), covering the measure of the amount asserted (interest counted to the bankruptcy acceptance date) and joint confirmation of the construction payment priority right
The administrator's review conclusion is not final and the contractor has remedies: the administrator's treatment of the claims recorded in the schedule is procedural review only; final judgment on the substantive amount rests with the people's court (or, where the contract contains an arbitration clause, the arbitration institution). The route: request a written claim review opinion from the administrator (Enterprise Bankruptcy Law Art. 57: the administrator registers, reviews and compiles the schedule of claims, open to interested parties for inspection) -> object at the first creditors' meeting's verification of the schedule, leaving a record (Art. 58(1)) -> where the objection is unresolved, 'sue in the people's court accepting the bankruptcy petition' under Art. 58(3) (or apply to the arbitration institution under an arbitration agreement). After bankruptcy acceptance no separate performance action demanding payment from the debtor lies; only a claim-confirmation action (SPC Civil and Commercial Trial Conference Minutes, para. 110). Amount = contract-agreed price of completed works +/- variation records, price adjustment and claims + interest counted to the bankruptcy acceptance date - payments made - retention money / liquidated damages validly deductible; unmatured claims are deemed matured at acceptance and interest-bearing claims stop accruing interest from acceptance (Art. 46); the priority right may be confirmed in the same proceedings (Civil Code Art. 807; Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Art. 36; Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Art. 17(1)).
- ←
Priority ranking and bars to enforcement when works under construction or commercial housing are compulsorily enforced: the contractor's construction price priority right prevails over mortgages and other claims; auction proceeds are applied in priority; the three tests for commercial housing consumers to bar enforcement and their relation to mortgages; the seizure immunity of a third party who has paid the full price and taken possession; and the bar on auctioning residences necessary for living
The contractor's priority right to payment for construction of the works under Article 807 of the Civil Code prevails over mortgages and other claims (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 36); security interests and other priority payment rights originally existing on the auctioned property are extinguished by the auction and are paid in priority out of the proceeds (Fa Shi [2004] No. 16, Article 28). However, where a commercial housing consumer has paid all or most of the price and meets the three tests - a lawful and effective written sales contract signed before seizure, the purchased commercial housing being for living with no other housing for living under the buyer's name, and over 50% of the total contract price already paid - that consumer's right can bar enforcement and prevails over the mortgage; this exception must be applied strictly and confined to such consumers. In addition: a third party who has paid the full price and taken actual possession, and who is without fault for the pending title transfer, may not be sealed; a residence necessary for the living of the person subject to enforcement and the family members they support may be sealed but may not be auctioned, sold, or set off against debt.
- ←
Preservation and freezing of the employer's receivables (matured claims) by the contractor: whether it can apply, three preconditions, the three routes of pre-suit / in-suit / enforcement, the performance notice and secondary-debtor objection rules, security and reconsideration relief, and the limit that the priority right does not reach receivables
Yes, application is possible. Where the debtor's property cannot satisfy the preservation request but the debtor holds a matured claim against another person, the people's court may, on the creditor's application, rule that that person shall not discharge to the debtor in this case; if that person demands to pay, the people's court takes the property or the price into deposit (Civil Procedure Law Interpretation Art. 159). After enforcement proceedings open, the court may rule to freeze the claim and notify that person to perform to the enforcing applicant (Art. 499 of the same Interpretation). The employer's receivables from other units are part of the employer's responsible property, not personal to the debtor, and may be preserved; but three conditions must hold together: a qualified applicant (holding a matured works-payment claim against the employer), a qualifying object (a genuine, matured, disposable claim not effectively assigned), and necessity of preservation within the requested scope. If the secondary debtor objects within 15 days of the performance notice, the court may not enforce against it and does not examine the objection (Enforcement Provisions Art. 47); once enforced against a third party that truly has no property, its own matured claims against others may not be further enforced (Art. 52). The construction payment priority right reaches only the proceeds of discounting or auctioning that project, not the employer's general receivables: freezing receivables is an ordinary creditor's preservation route and yields no priority ranking.
- ←
The contractor's creditor's right of revocation against an employer transferring assets to evade works-payment debts: the constitutive requirements of Articles 538 / 539 of the Civil Code, the quantitative standards of 'manifestly unreasonable low price 70% / high price 30%', the scope / preclusive period / consequences of revocation under Articles 540-542, and the division of labour with subrogation, nullity for malicious collusion, bankruptcy avoidance and property preservation
Yes. Provided the employer has carried out a gratuitous disposition of property rights under Article 538 of the Civil Code (waiving claims, waiving security for claims, transferring property without consideration, or the like) or has maliciously extended the performance period of a due claim, or has done any of the Article 539 acts - transferring property at a manifestly unreasonable low price, acquiring property at a manifestly unreasonable high price, or providing security for another's debt (the latter three require that the counterparty knew or ought to have known) - and the realisation of the contractor's works-payment claim is affected, the contractor may request the people's court to revoke the act; once revoked, the act has no legal binding force ab initio under Article 542, the disposed property returns to the employer's assets available for satisfaction, and the contractor is then paid through a works-payment suit plus enforcement. Three boundaries: the exercise is limited to the extent of the claim, and necessary costs are borne by the debtor (Article 540); the right extinguishes if not exercised within 1 year from knowing or ought to have known of the ground, or within 5 years from the date of the act (Article 541); the direct effect of revocation is that the counterparty returns property to the employer, compensates at value or performs the due debt - the contractor cannot collect from the counterparty directly. 'Manifest unreasonableness' is judged by the standard of ordinary operators in the locality of the transaction, by reference to the market price there at the time or the guidance price of the price authorities: a transfer price below 70% is in general a manifestly unreasonable low price, an acquisition price more than 30% above is in general a manifestly unreasonable high price, and kinship or affiliation lifts those thresholds (Article 42 of Fa Shi [2023] No. 13).
- ←
Normative differences between property-in-lieu agreements concluded before and after expiry of the debt performance period: determination of the agreement's validity, the remedy route where the property in lieu is not delivered, the ban on outright-forfeiture (outright-transfer) clauses, and the liquidation rules of transfer-of-title security
Property-in-lieu agreements are split by the timing of conclusion. Those concluded after the debt performance period expires are effective upon the meeting of the parties' declarations of intent (consensual); where the property in lieu is not delivered, the creditor may demand performance of the agreement, and the original debt is extinguished only when it has been performed; where the agreement is not performed as agreed and, after demand, performance still does not occur within a reasonable period, the creditor may elect to demand performance of the original debt or of the property-in-lieu agreement (Fa Shi [2023] No. 13, Article 27). Those concluded before expiry have their validity determined on examination of the creditor-debtor relationship - an agreement that 'on non-payment at maturity the property may be auctioned, sold or taken at appraised value to satisfy the claim' is valid, while an agreement that 'on non-payment at maturity the property in lieu belongs to the creditor' is void (the ban on outright forfeiture, without affecting the validity of the other parts); where the property right has not been transferred into the creditor's name, no priority satisfaction may be claimed, and where it has, the matter is handled under the transfer-of-title security rules (Security System Interpretation, Article 68) by liquidation (Article 28); where the property in lieu is not delivered, the court should clarify that suit be brought on the original creditor-debtor relationship (Ninth Civil-Commercial Conference Minutes, Article 45).
- ←
The contractor's construction works payment priority over insurance proceeds, damages and expropriation compensation after the works are damaged, destroyed or expropriated (subrogation of the security interest): conditions for applying Article 20 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, the boundaries of amount and time limit, and the temporal dividing point between the old and new rules
Yes. Article 20 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 provides: 'Where the construction works are damaged, destroyed or expropriated, and the contractor claims priority payment out of the insurance proceeds, damages or compensation so obtained, the people's court shall support the claim.' The doctrinal basis is subrogation of the payment priority onto substitute payments, by reference to Article 390 of the Civil Code. But the subrogated subject matter remains subject to two hard boundaries: in amount it is limited to the works price itself (interest on overdue payment, liquidated damages and damages take no priority under Article 40(2) of Interpretation No. 25, and losses from suspension and idle labour and plant caused by the employer take no priority under Article 17(2) of Interpretation No. 12), and in time it is bound by the maximum 18-month exclusion period (Article 41, with the starting point under Article 21); quality up to standard is a precondition. The rule takes effect on 30 June 2026 and, under Article 23, applies to first-instance cases newly accepted after that date; for cases accepted earlier only analogy to Article 390 of the Civil Code is available.
- ←
Whether the employer's overdue non-reply to the final account documents is deemed acceptance of the submitted amount - the three-requirement test of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 21, and interface with GB/T 50500-2024
Where the contract stipulates 'overdue non-reply is deemed acceptance', under Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 21, the people's court shall support the contractor's claim for settlement per the final account documents (submitted price); three requirements must be met simultaneously: an express contractual stipulation, delivery of complete settlement documents, and no reply within the agreed period. Absent such stipulation, claims based only on ministerial rules or model contract texts containing 'deemed acceptance' wording are not supported by the SPC and the overwhelming majority of courts. GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 10.3.8, points the same way but is a recommendatory national standard that becomes a contractual obligation only when incorporated by the contract; at the rule level, Article 16 of the former MOC Decree No. 107 has been carried over by Article 18 of MOHURD Decree No. 16, with 28 days as the default period absent agreement.
- ←
Whether the contractor on incomplete works (the completed parts being of acceptable quality) can claim the statutory priority right of payment for the construction price: conditions, the boundaries of the scope covered, the 18-month period, and a positive-versus-negative scenario comparison
Yes. Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 39: 'Where the quality of construction works not completed is acceptable, and the contractor requests priority of payment of the price of the works it built out of the proceeds of the discount sale or auction of the part of the works it built, the people's court shall uphold the request.' The threshold is 'acceptable quality', not completion acceptance; but the right reaches only the part of the works built by the contractor; the claimant must be the contractor that concluded the construction contract with the employer (Article 35); the subject matter is limited to the construction price (excluding interest, liquidated damages, compensation for loss, and losses from stoppage and idle resources, Article 40(2) and Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 17(2)); and it must be exercised within at most 18 months from the date the employer ought to pay the construction price (Article 41).
- ←
Four statutory conditions for a contractor to exercise the construction payment priority right (the statutory priority right of the contractor to payment for the works under Article 807 of the Civil Code) through a discount agreement with the employer - acceptable work quality, works capable of discounted transfer, payment still overdue after demand, and a discount amount broadly equivalent to actual value - plus the subrogation rule under which the contractor claims priority payment out of insurance proceeds, damages or expropriation compensation when the works are damaged, destroyed or expropriated
Where a contractor claims to have exercised the construction payment priority right through a discount agreement with the employer, all four conditions of Article 18 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 must be met simultaneously: the quality of the works constructed is acceptable, the works are capable of discounted transfer, the employer still fails to pay within a reasonable period after the contractor's demand, and the discount amount is broadly equivalent to the actual value of the works at the time of the discount; where the works are damaged, destroyed or expropriated, the contractor may claim priority payment out of the insurance proceeds, damages or compensation obtained (Article 20).
- ←
The procedural path and statutory periods for a non-party's written objection to the subject of enforcement: the court's 15-day review, suspension of enforcement if upheld or rejection if not, the split between the trial supervision procedure and an enforcement objection action brought within 15 days, the bar on disposing of the subject for 15 days after service of a rejection ruling, and where the substantive test of 'rights sufficient to exclude compulsory enforcement' lands
The non-party must first file a written objection with the enforcing court, which reviews it within 15 days of receipt: if the non-party holds rights sufficient to exclude compulsory enforcement, the court rules to suspend enforcement against that subject, otherwise it rules to reject. A party dissatisfied with the ruling who considers the original judgment or ruling in error proceeds under the trial supervision procedure; a party whose objection is unrelated to the original judgment or ruling may bring an enforcement objection action within 15 days from service of the ruling. For 15 days from service of a rejection ruling on the non-party, the court may not dispose of the subject of enforcement.
- ←
Fixing the start point of the contractor's priority right to payment of the construction price (18 months at most) after rescission of the construction contract: the payment date expressly agreed in a rescission agreement or settlement agreement; the due date of the original payment clause as a settlement and winding-up clause; the date of rescission where a payment condition becomes unattainable upon rescission; the three deemed situations under Article 27 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25; and the distinction from the start of the retention money return period
Rescission does not change the 18-month length of the period; it only changes which day counts as 'the date the employer ought to pay the works price': where a rescission agreement or settlement agreement expressly agrees a payment date, that date governs (Article 21(2) of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12); where the original payment clause is a 'settlement and winding-up clause' still applicable after rescission, the due date of its payment term governs (Article 567 of the Civil Code); where payment was conditioned on completion, acceptance or completed settlement review and the condition fails upon rescission, the date of rescission governs (some courts take the contractor's withdrawal from the site or handover of the works; count back conservatively from the earlier date); where none applies and the works are undelivered and unsettled, the date of filing suit (or applying for arbitration) is deemed (Article 27(3) of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25). The length is fixed at 18 months at most by Article 41 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, and the period is a peremptory exclusion period.
- ←
Interest, liquidated damages and damages for late payment of the project price do not enjoy the contractor's priority right of payment out of the works - the scope locked by the composition of the project price, separating principal and interest in blended settlements, and 'agreement cannot expand the statutory priority scope'
Not included. The scope of the priority right is confined to the project price itself: Article 40(1) of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 provides that the scope 'is determined under the provisions of the relevant administrative department of the State Council on the scope of construction project prices', and paragraph 2 states expressly that 'where the contractor claims priority for interest, liquidated damages or damages arising from late payment of the construction project price, the people's court will not support the claim'. The interest claim itself stands and may be sued for (the rate follows Article 26 of the same interpretation, the start date Article 27), but only as an ordinary claim, without priority over mortgages or other claims; Article 17 of the 2026 Interpretation (II) (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12) further requires the court to ascertain and 'state in the operative part of the judgment' the amount of project price enjoying the priority right and the corresponding works, and paragraph 2 restates that suspension and idle-resource losses are not supported.
- ←
Whether an assignee of a construction payment claim can assert the construction payment priority right after assignment: the four-factor review of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 19, the accessory-transfer doctrine (Civil Code Article 547), exclusions from the scope of priority, the start of the 18-month exercise period, and jurisdiction and procedure
Yes, but not automatically - the assignee may, in its own name, claim priority payment out of the proceeds of the works sold by discount or auction, and the court must decide under Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 19 by weighing factors such as 'whether the works passed completion acceptance, whether the price has been settled, whether the assignment contract is valid, and whether a reasonable assignment price has been paid'. The doctrinal basis is that the priority right, as an accessory right, transfers together with the construction payment claim (Civil Code Article 547); failure to notify the debtor does not prevent the assignee suing directly (Article 546; Fa Shi [2023] No. 13 Article 48 paragraph 2). However, interest, liquidated damages, damages, and suspension and idle-cost losses within the assigned subject matter enjoy no priority (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 40 paragraph 2; Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 17 paragraph 2), and the maximum 18-month exercise period still applies (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 41, start point per Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 21).
- ←
Defining the scope of the priority right to payment of the construction project price: the object scope (the part of the works the contractor itself built, passing quality, capable by nature of discounted transfer or auction, decoration and fit-out works as a separate object) plus the amount scope (composition of the works price, excluding interest / liquidated damages / damages / suspension and idle-time losses), and the requirement that the operative part of the judgment list 'amount + corresponding works' item by item
The 'works scope' of the priority right is limited to the part of the construction project that the contractor itself built, that passes quality acceptance, and that is not by nature unsuitable for discounted transfer or auction (for uncompleted works, only the completed part built by it; decoration and fit-out works form a separate object). The 'amount scope' is limited to the works price of that project (under the provisions of the competent department of the State Council on the scope of the works price, i.e. the cost composition of Jian Biao [2013] No. 44), excluding interest on overdue payment, liquidated damages and damages; for cases newly accepted at first instance from 30 June 2026 it also excludes losses from suspension and idle time of labour and plant caused by the employer (Article 17 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12); and the operative part of the judgment must list item by item 'the amount enjoying priority + the corresponding works'.
- ←
How the eighteen-month exercise period of the construction price priority right runs when the construction payment is paid by instalments: per-instalment accrual and separate accrual for retention money; the presumption where the payment time is not agreed; accrual where the date is varied by agreement or fixed in a settlement agreement (with the old/new boundary of Articles 21 and 23 of the 2026 Interpretation (II))
The eighteen months (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 41) is a preclusive period; the limitation rule of Civil Code Article 189 that 'for a debt performed by instalments the limitation period runs from expiry of the last instalment' does not apply. Instalment payment does not change the length of the eighteen months; it merely creates several 'dates on which payment falls due' - for each instalment the period starts on the day that instalment's payment conditions are satisfied, running and expiring instalment by instalment; the priority right for instalments whose period has expired is extinguished. Retention money accrues separately from the expiry of its return period (no agreement = two years after the works passed completion acceptance; failure to carry out acceptance due to the employer = 90 days after submission of the completion acceptance report), and may not serve as the starting point for the whole construction price.
- ←
Whether losses from suspension of the works and idle time can be brought within the priority right of repayment of the construction project price (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 17(2): not supported; the debt claim may be pursued but enjoys no priority ranking)
No. Article 17(2) of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 reads: 'Where a contractor claims the priority right of repayment of the construction project price for losses such as suspension of the works or idle time caused by reasons attributable to the employer, the people's court shall not support the claim.' In character such losses are economic loss caused by the employer's breach (claim money), of the same category as the interest, liquidated damages and damages excluded by Article 40(2) of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25: the debt itself is established, can be sued for and paid, but enjoys no ranking ahead of mortgages and other claims; the character is not changed by the loss being certified in a site instruction record or included in the settlement total, and under Article 17(1) of the same interpretation the court must state in the operative part of the judgment 'the amount of the construction price enjoying the priority right of repayment and the corresponding works'.
- ←
Reviewing the employer's defence of long-term refusal to pay the project price on the ground that 'the final account is not settled / review is not completed': whether the payment obligation has fallen due (Civil Code Articles 799, 577, 579), the three trigger points for interest on arrears (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 27), settlement at the submitted price requires an 'deemed approval upon failure to respond in time' agreement (Article 21), and the statutory cost of delay (the 18-month priority right, SME payment periods and overdue interest)
Refusal to pay cannot stand. The final account is only the procedure that fixes 'how much is payable'; it is not the condition on which the payment obligation arises: once the works pass completion acceptance, the payment obligation has fallen due, and for works actually delivered, interest on the arrears runs from the date of delivery (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Article 27); the employer may not indefinitely defer payment on the ground of its own delay in settling. But 'cannot refuse payment' does not mean 'pay the submitted price': only where the contract expressly agrees that 'failure to respond within the agreed period after receipt of the final account documents is deemed approval' may settlement be made at the contractor's submitted price (Article 21); absent such an agreement, the cost is determined through judicial assessment; and clauses making the price 'subject to audit / government fiscal review' cannot drag on indefinitely either -- where the conclusion is not issued within a reasonable period for reasons not attributable to the contractor (no more than one year from submission of the final account documents) or obviously contradicts the contract, judicial assessment may be applied for (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 13).
- ←
Validity rules on the assignment and factoring of construction project price claims (receivables): the point at which notice of the assignment takes effect against the debtor, accessory rights passing with the claim, three special factoring rules (fictitious receivables / form of notice / amendment of the underlying contract), the ban on assigning receivables already pledged, the discharge order under multiple assignments and determination of notice arrival time, the court's overall review where the assignee claims priority of payment out of the construction project price (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 19), and the new-old application boundary
An assignment of a claim not notified to the debtor has no effect on the debtor (Civil Code Article 546); where the assignee sues the debtor directly, the assignment takes effect on the debtor upon service of a copy of the statement of claim, and the debtor may claim that expenses increased or losses caused by the absence of notice be deducted from the claim amount (Fa Shi [2023] No. 13 Article 48). The assignee acquires the accessory rights related to the claim, unaffected by any failure to complete transfer registration or to transfer possession (Article 547). In factoring: with fictitious receivables, the debtor may not set up the non-existence of the receivable against the factor (except where the factor knew of the fiction, Article 763); the factor's notice must identify its status and attach the necessary vouchers (Article 764); after notice, an amendment or termination of the underlying trading contract by creditor and debtor without justified reason, to the detriment of the factor, has no effect on the factor (Article 765). Where the assignee claims priority of payment, the court rules comprehensively on whether the works passed completion acceptance, whether the project price is settled, whether the assignment contract is valid, and whether the assignee has paid a reasonable assignment price, among other factors (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 19); that interpretation takes effect on 30 June 2026 and applies to first-instance cases newly accepted after its entry into effect (Article 23).
- ←
Whether an actual constructor (a transferee of contract transfer or unlawful subcontract, or a qualification borrower) can, through an outsider's objection to enforcement and an objection-to-enforcement action, exclude other creditors' enforcement against the project-price debt payable by the employer: the conclusion is that in principle it cannot, because an ordinary monetary claim has no exclusive effect, the burden of proof lies on the outsider, and the holder of the priority right does not fit; with the procedural linkage (Article 499(2) of the Civil Procedure Law Interpretation -> Article 238 of the Civil Procedure Law), the rules on effective judgments from other cases (Article 26 of the Enforcement Objection and Reconsideration Provisions; Article 124 of the Ninth Minutes), and the narrowing of the claim basis by Articles 6 and 7 of the 2026 Interpretation (II)
Where an actual constructor (a transferee of contract transfer or unlawful subcontract, or a qualification borrower) brings an outsider's objection or an objection-to-enforcement action against the project-price debt payable by the employer to the contractor, seeking to exclude other creditors' enforcement, the claim is in principle unsupported: whether the claim against the employer proceeds under Article 43(2) of the Construction Interpretation (I) or the subrogation route, it is an ordinary monetary claim with no priority or exclusivity (Enforcement Objection and Reconsideration Provisions Article 26(1)(ii); Ninth Minutes Article 124); the burden of proof lies on the outsider (Civil Procedure Law Interpretation Article 309). Procedurally, under Article 499(2) of the Civil Procedure Law Interpretation the case may pass into the outsider-objection procedure of Article 238 of the Civil Procedure Law and an action may be filed within 15 days of service of the ruling, but it usually stops at the procedural blockage of 'this due claim is not enforced for now'. In addition: the holder of the construction payment priority right is limited to the contractor that concluded the contract with the employer (Civil Code Article 807; Interpretation (I) Articles 35 and 36); an actual constructor does not hold it and cannot exclude enforcement through it; Article 6 of the 2026 Interpretation (II) further denies its direct claim against an employer with which it has no contract (Article 23: effective 30 June 2026, applying to first-instance cases newly accepted after that date).
- ←
The contractor's four-level remedy ladder when the owner delays payment (demand -> suspension and claims -> administrative complaint -> termination/priority of payment)
Four escalating levels — "gentle demand -> pressure by suspension -> administrative complaint -> legal remedies": (1) written demand (GB/T 50500-2024 §10.2.12/§10.3.17) + undisputed portion first (§9.4.11) + overdue interest (Decree No. 728, Article 15: agreed rate no less than the 1-year LPR, 0.05% per day absent agreement); (2) statutory suspension rights (prepayment §9.2.4, safety measure fees §9.3.3) + 28-day dual-node claims (§9.4.12); (3) complaint to the SME authority (Decree No. 728, Article 17, with credit blacklisting); (4) termination + priority of payment for the project price (Civil Code Articles 563/807, 18-month exclusion period).
- ←
Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 "Construction Interpretation II" and its overall impact on existing judicial interpretations, statutes, and pricing/appraisal standards (23 articles, effective 30 June 2026)
The SPC "Interpretation (II) on the Application of Law in Cases of Construction Contract Disputes" (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, adopted at the 1969th meeting of the Adjudication Committee on 17 March 2026, effective 30 June 2026, 23 articles) does not wholesale-repeal the current "Interpretation (I)" (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25), but per its Article 23 — "for construction contract dispute cases newly accepted at first instance by the people's courts after this Interpretation takes effect, this Interpretation applies ... where earlier SPC interpretations are inconsistent with this Interpretation, this Interpretation prevails" — provisions inconsistent with Interpretation I yield to the new one. Major changes: mandatory-tender projects not tendered are no longer automatically void (Art. 1); pre-bid substantive negotiations void the awarded contract (Art. 2); "audit-as-basis" narrowed (Art. 13 — unsupported absent agreement; with agreement, judicial appraisal available if results are overdue beyond 1 year or manifestly inconsistent); fixed prices not adjusted for major labor/material changes (Art. 9); lump-sum contracts priced proportionally upon termination (Art. 10); standstill/idle losses enjoy no priority right (Art. 17); etc.
- ←
Works put into use before completion acceptance: payment, quality liability and warranty rules (the employer's unauthorized use deemed acceptance of quality)
The employer's unauthorized use of un-accepted works equals deemed acceptance of quality (presumed qualification): the project price remains payable, with the date of transfer of possession serving as the completion date and the payment due date (interest at the 1-year LPR absent an agreed rate); quality risk passes to the employer except for foundations and the main structure (for which the contractor remains liable within the reasonable service life), and only for the parts actually used; warranty duties are not discharged - minimum warranty periods per Article 40 of the Regulations on Quality Management of Construction Works (waterproofing 5 years; heating and cooling 2 heating/cooling seasons; electrical wiring, water supply and drainage piping, equipment installation and finishing 2 years; foundations and main structure, the reasonable design life); the employer additionally bears an administrative fine of 2%-4% of the contract price (Article 58).
- ←
Contractor cash-flow risk control when progress-payment review runs overdue: deemed approval of measurements, payment of undisputed portions, and four-layer defense (GB/T 50500-2024)
Review deadlines are not bottomless: absent contractual deadlines, GB/T 50500-2024 Article 7.1.5 establishes "overdue silence = measurement accepted," Article 9.4.11 "undisputed portions paid first," and Article 9.1.7 payment no less than 80% of cumulative completed work value; overdue non-payment supports claims under 9.4.12, and in extreme cases priority-of-payment under Civil Code Article 807 (exercisable within 18 months) and the Regulation on Payment to SMEs. Defense deploys across four layers: contract clauses - process management - legal remedies - self-rescue financing.
- ←
The relation between the Construction Law and the Civil Code rules on construction contracts: dual-track interface of public-law regulation + private-law adjustment
The Construction Law is an administrative supervision statute (public law) governing permits, qualifications, letting order, safety, quality, and administrative penalties; Civil Code contract chapter Articles 788-808 are civil basic law (private law) governing contract formation, validity, performance, price, and breach liability. For the same matter each governs one end (subletting/qualification/acceptance/supervision); the Construction Law's mandatory provisions enter contract-validity review through Civil Code Article 153 (invalid contracts compensated by reference under Article 793), while the Civil Code alone provides the Article 807 priority of payment and Article 808 reference to work-contract rules.