Priority ranking and bars to enforcement when works under construction or commercial housing are compulsorily enforced: the contractor's construction price priority right prevails over mortgages and other claims; auction proceeds are applied in priority; the three tests for commercial housing consumers to bar enforcement and their relation to mortgages; the seizure immunity of a third party who has paid the full price and taken possession; and the bar on auctioning residences necessary for living
The contractor's priority right to payment for construction of the works under Article 807 of the Civil Code prevails over mortgages and other claims (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 36); security interests and other priority payment rights originally existing on the auctioned property are extinguished by the auction and are paid in priority out of the proceeds (Fa Shi [2004] No. 16, Article 28). However, where a commercial housing consumer has paid all or most of the price and meets the three tests - a lawful and effective written sales contract signed before seizure, the purchased commercial housing being for living with no other housing for living under the buyer's name, and over 50% of the total contract price already paid - that consumer's right can bar enforcement and prevails over the mortgage; this exception must be applied strictly and confined to such consumers. In addition: a third party who has paid the full price and taken actual possession, and who is without fault for the pending title transfer, may not be sealed; a residence necessary for the living of the person subject to enforcement and the family members they support may be sealed but may not be auctioned, sold, or set off against debt.
Applicable Codes
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第八百零七条
- 法释〔2020〕25号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第三十五条至第四十二条
- 法释〔2004〕16号《最高人民法院关于人民法院民事执行中拍卖、变卖财产的规定》(2020修正)第二十八条
- 法释〔2015〕5号《最高人民法院关于适用〈中华人民共和国民事诉讼法〉的解释》(2022修正)第五百零六条、第五百零八条
- 法释〔2015〕10号《最高人民法院关于人民法院办理执行异议和复议案件若干问题的规定》(2020修正)第二十九条
- 法〔2019〕254号《全国法院民商事审判工作会议纪要》(九民纪要)第125条、第126条
- 法释〔2004〕15号《最高人民法院关于人民法院民事执行中查封、扣押、冻结财产的规定》(2020修正)第四条、第七条、第十五条、第二十一条
- 自然资源部令第5号《不动产登记暂行条例实施细则》(2019修正)第七十七条
Positioning of the topic
Answers, for compulsory enforcement over works under construction and commercial housing, 'whose right ranks first, who can bar enforcement, and which property cannot be auctioned' - that is, the ranking and blocking rules between the contractor's construction price priority right and mortgages, ordinary claims, and the rights of commercial housing consumers (as well as third parties who have paid the housing price and the residence of the person subject to enforcement). This sits on the negative/blocking side of the 'can it be auctioned' question.
Core conclusions
1. The contractor's priority right prevails over mortgages and other claims
Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 36: 'The priority right to payment for construction of the works that the contractor enjoys under Article 807 of the Civil Code prevails over mortgages and other claims.' Fa Shi [2004] No. 16 (2020 amendment), Article 28, paragraph 1: 'Security interests and other priority payment rights originally existing on the auctioned property are extinguished by the auction, and the auction proceeds shall be applied in priority to the claims of the security interest holders and other priority payment claimants, unless the parties agree otherwise.' Paragraph 2: lease rights and other usufructuary rights are not extinguished by the auction, but where their continued existence affects the realisation of a prior security interest or other priority payment right, the court shall remove them according to law before the auction. Participation in distribution: Fa Shi [2015] No. 5, Article 506, paragraph 2 - a creditor holding a priority right or security interest in sealed, detained, or frozen property may directly apply to participate in the distribution and claim priority payment; Article 508 - after the proceeds deduct enforcement costs and satisfy the claims entitled to priority, ordinary claims are in principle paid proportionally.
2. Commercial housing consumers barring enforcement (three tests)
Fa Shi [2015] No. 10 (2020 amendment), Article 29: 'In enforcement of monetary claims, where a buyer raises an objection to commercial housing registered in the name of the real estate development enterprise subject to enforcement, and the following circumstances apply and the buyer's right can bar enforcement, the people's court shall support it: (1) a lawful and effective written sales contract was signed before the people's court sealed the property; (2) the purchased commercial housing is for living and the buyer has no other housing for living under the buyer's name; (3) the price already paid exceeds 50% of the total contract price.'
Fa [2019] No. 254 (Ninth Conference Minutes), Article 125, refines these tests: 'no other housing for living under the buyer's name' may be understood as no housing for living under the consumer's name within the same city divided into districts or county-level city as the house in question; where the buyer already owns 1 house but the purchased house in floor area still meets basic living needs, this may be understood as conforming to the spirit of the provision; where the price paid is close to 50% and the remaining price has been paid to the enforcement applicant as agreed in the contract or delivered for enforcement as the court requires, this may likewise be understood as conforming to the spirit of the provision.
3. Relation between consumer rights and mortgages (strict application)
Ninth Conference Minutes, Article 126: under Articles 1 and 2 of the SPC Reply on the Issue of the Priority Right to Payment for Construction of the Works, the right of a commercial housing consumer who has paid all or most of the price prevails over the mortgagee's mortgage; where a mortgagee applies to enforce commercial housing sold to a consumer and the consumer raises an enforcement objection, the court shall support it. However, 'this is an exceptional rule made to protect the subsistence right of consumers against irregular pre-sale practices that exist in practice; the conditions must be strictly applied and the scope must not be expanded, lest the basic principle that a mortgage enjoys priority be shaken.' It is confined to commercial housing consumers meeting Article 125; buyers under ordinary housing sales contracts cannot invoke the rule.
4. Seizure immunity and limits on enforceable property
Fa Shi [2004] No. 15 (2020 amendment), Article 4: 'As to a residence necessary for the living of the person subject to enforcement and the family members they support, the people's court may seal it, but may not auction it, sell it, or set it off against debt.' Article 15: 'Where the person subject to enforcement sells to a third party property they own that requires transfer registration, and the third party has paid part or all of the price and actually possesses the property but title transfer registration has not been completed, the people's court may seal, detain, or freeze it; where the third party has paid the full price and actually possesses the property but transfer registration has not been completed, and the third party is without fault for this, the people's court may not seal, detain, or freeze it.'
5. Creation and scope of mortgages over works under construction (the factual basis affecting ranking)
Ministry of Natural Resources Order No. 5, Implementation Rules of the Interim Regulation on Real Estate Registration (2019 amendment), Article 77: construction land-use rights, buildings and other attachments to land, and buildings under construction may apply for mortgage registration; where a construction land-use right is mortgaged, the buildings on that land are mortgaged together, and vice versa (land and buildings as one); where multiple mortgages are created on the same real estate, ranking is fixed by registration in the order of acceptance; where a mortgage is created on a construction land-use right together with all or part of the buildings under construction, first registration of the mortgage over the buildings under construction shall be applied for at the same time, and 'the mortgaged property does not include pre-purchased commercial housing that has completed advance notice registration or commercial housing that has completed pre-sale filing.'
Scope of application
- The priority right itself remains subject to prior requirements: the holder must be the contractor that concluded the construction contract with the employer (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 35), the works quality must be acceptable (Articles 38 and 39), the scope excludes interest, liquidated damages, damages, and costs of suspension and idle labour and plant (Article 40; Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 17, paragraph 2), and it must be exercised within the eighteen-month preclusive period (Article 41); with any of these defects, no priority arises even after the auction procedure is completed.
- Limits of the consumer exception: the three tests must be met together and it is confined to commercial housing for living; investment purchases, or holding existing housing (within the same city divided into districts or county-level city), generally cannot bar enforcement; where the payment ratio is close to 50%, the remaining price must be delivered for enforcement to obtain support.
- The Article 15 immunity presupposes 'full price paid + actual possession + absence of fault' together; payment of only part of the price permits sealing but no bar.
- Sealing of registered real estate requires notice to the registration authority to complete registration formalities; without registration it cannot prevail over a sealing act that has been registered (Fa Shi [2004] No. 15, Article 7).
- Timing boundary: Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 takes effect on 30 June 2026 and applies to first-instance cases newly accepted after that date; where earlier judicial interpretations conflict with it, it prevails (Article 23).
Further reading
Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Articles 35 to 42 (especially Articles 36, 37, 39, 40, 41, and 42); Fa Shi [2004] No. 16, Article 28; Fa Shi [2015] No. 5, Articles 506 and 508; Fa Shi [2015] No. 10, Article 29; Fa [2019] No. 254 (Ninth Conference Minutes), Articles 125 and 126; Fa Shi [2004] No. 15, Articles 4, 7, 15, and 21; Ministry of Natural Resources Order No. 5, Implementation Rules of the Interim Regulation on Real Estate Registration (2019 amendment), Article 77 (first registration of mortgages over buildings under construction and the scope of mortgaged property). For whether fitting-out works form a separate object, see Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 37.
Keywords
- 优先受偿权优于抵押权
- 商品房消费者
- 执行异议
- 排除执行
- 参与分配
- 拍卖价款优先清偿
- 在建建筑物抵押登记
- 生活必需居住房屋