Defining the scope of the priority right to payment of the construction project price: the object scope (the part of the works the contractor itself built, passing quality, capable by nature of discounted transfer or auction, decoration and fit-out works as a separate object) plus the amount scope (composition of the works price, excluding interest / liquidated damages / damages / suspension and idle-time losses), and the requirement that the operative part of the judgment list 'amount + corresponding works' item by item
The 'works scope' of the priority right is limited to the part of the construction project that the contractor itself built, that passes quality acceptance, and that is not by nature unsuitable for discounted transfer or auction (for uncompleted works, only the completed part built by it; decoration and fit-out works form a separate object). The 'amount scope' is limited to the works price of that project (under the provisions of the competent department of the State Council on the scope of the works price, i.e. the cost composition of Jian Biao [2013] No. 44), excluding interest on overdue payment, liquidated damages and damages; for cases newly accepted at first instance from 30 June 2026 it also excludes losses from suspension and idle time of labour and plant caused by the employer (Article 17 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12); and the operative part of the judgment must list item by item 'the amount enjoying priority + the corresponding works'.
Applicable Codes
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第八百零七条、第三百九十九条
- 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》法释〔2020〕25号第三十五条至第四十二条
- 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》法释〔2026〕12号第十七条至第二十一条、第二十三条(2026年6月30日施行)
- 《建筑安装工程费用项目组成》建标〔2013〕44号
- 《建设工程造价鉴定作业指引》T/ZBD 100.4-2023 第3.2.2条
- 《最高人民法院关于人民法院办理执行异议和复议案件若干问题的规定》法释〔2015〕10号(2020年修正)第二十九条
- 江苏省高级人民法院苏高法〔2018〕《建设工程施工合同纠纷案件若干问题的解答》第14~20条(地方参考)
Positioning of the topic
When a contractor asserts the priority right to payment of the construction project price, the dual scope question of 'over which part of the works does priority run, and for how much': the object scope (drawing and excluding the works) and the amount scope (composition of the works price and the excluded items), and how to phrase the claims and the operative part of the judgment so that the court can rule with precision.
Core conclusions
I. Legal origin (Article 807 of the Civil Code, full text)
'Where the employer fails to pay the price as agreed, the contractor may demand that the employer pay within a reasonable period. If the employer still fails to pay after that period, the contractor may, unless the project is by nature unsuitable for discounted transfer or auction, agree with the employer on a discounted transfer of the project, or request the people's court to auction the project according to law. The price of the construction project enjoys priority of payment out of the proceeds of the discounted transfer or auction of the project.'
The scope is limited in two places: the proviso 'unless the project is by nature unsuitable for discounted transfer or auction' limits the object; 'the price of the construction project' limits the amount.
II. Object scope: four sieves (excluding layer by layer)
- Link of party and works: Article 35 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 - 'Where the contractor that concluded the construction contract with the employer claims, under Article 807 of the Civil Code, that the price of the works it built enjoys priority out of the proceeds of the discounted transfer or auction of the works, the people's court shall support it.' Priority can therefore only be claimed over 'the works it built', not over parts constructed by others, nor over content outside the scope of this contract within the project boundary.
- Quality passing as a precondition: Article 38 - 'Where the quality of the construction project passes and the contractor claims that the price of the works it built enjoys priority out of the proceeds of the discounted transfer or auction of the works, the people's court shall support it.' Uncompleted works: Article 39 - 'Where the quality of the uncompleted construction project passes and the contractor claims that the price of the works it built enjoys priority out of the proceeds of the discounted transfer or auction of the part it built, the people's court shall support it.' For uncompleted works the scope narrows to 'the part it built' (completed and quality-accepted); it cannot reach unconstructed parts or parts later completed by others.
- Exclusion by nature (unsuitable for discounted transfer or auction): under the Article 807 proviso, educational, medical and other public-welfare facilities of non-profit legal persons established for public-welfare purposes (schools, kindergartens, medical institutions and the like), public roads, bridges, tunnels, parks and other public utilities, military facilities, government office buildings and the like are by nature unsuitable for discounted transfer or auction and cannot be satisfied out of such proceeds (the price claim itself survives; only the vehicle for priority is lost). Reference may be made to the list of property that may not be mortgaged in Article 399 of the Civil Code, in particular item (3), 'educational, medical and other public-welfare facilities of non-profit legal persons established for public-welfare purposes, such as schools, kindergartens and medical institutions', and items (1), (2), (4), (5) and (6) (land ownership; collective land use rights such as homestead land; property whose ownership is unclear or disputed; property seized, detained or placed under supervision; other property that laws or administrative regulations prohibit from being mortgaged).
- Decoration and fit-out works as a separate object: Article 37 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 - 'Where decoration and fit-out works meet the conditions for discounted transfer or auction, and the contractor of those works claims that its works price enjoys priority out of the proceeds of the discounted transfer or auction of those works, the people's court shall support it.' The decoration and fit-out contractor cannot reach the building itself; it is satisfied only out of the proceeds of those works, and only if they 'meet the conditions for discounted transfer or auction'.
III. New rule in 2026: the operative part of the judgment must list 'amount + corresponding works' item by item
Article 17(1) of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 - 'Where the contractor requests confirmation that it enjoys the priority right to payment of the construction project price, the people's court shall ascertain the amount of the works price enjoying priority and the corresponding works, and make them clear in the operative part of the judgment.' Claims and the operative part must therefore be phrased as 'priority, up to XX yuan, out of the proceeds of the discounted transfer or auction of XX works (listed by contract section, individual works, building)'; multi-section or group projects must not be stated wholesale as 'priority over all works', which cannot be ascertained or enforced.
IV. Amount scope: within the works price, three (later four) categories excluded
Article 40 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, full text - 'The scope of the contractor's priority right to payment of the construction project price is determined under the provisions of the competent department of the State Council on the scope of the construction project price. Where the contractor claims priority for interest on late payment of the price, liquidated damages or damages, the people's court shall not support it.'
The supporting cost yardstick: Composition of Construction and Installation Project Costs (Jian Biao [2013] No. 44) - labour cost, material cost, plant and small tools cost, overheads, profit, statutory levies and fees, taxes and duties (in construction cost expert assessment, 'the cost make-up and classification of the works, unless otherwise agreed by the parties, shall comply with the relevant provisions of the Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development and the Ministry of Finance in the Composition of Construction and Installation Project Costs (Jian Biao [2013] No. 44)', see T/ZBD 100.4-2023, Section 3.2.2).
New exclusion in 2026: Article 17(2) of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 - 'Where the contractor claims the priority right to payment of the construction project price for losses from suspension and idle time of labour and plant caused by the employer, the people's court shall not support it.' Such losses are ordinary claims outside the 'amount' in paragraph 1 and must be stripped out of the priority amount.
Fixing the amount: fix the total price by settlement agreement, audit conclusion or construction cost expert assessment, then split it into 'works price' and 'interest / liquidated damages / damages / suspension and idle-time losses'; only the former enters the priority scope.
V. Extension and limits in special situations
- Exercise by discounted-transfer agreement: Article 18 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 - 'Where the contractor claims, under a discounted-transfer agreement concluded with the employer, to have exercised the priority right to payment of the construction project price under Article 807 of the Civil Code, the people's court shall support it if the following conditions are met: (1) the quality of the works the contractor constructed passes; (2) the project is capable of discounted transfer; (3) the employer is overdue in paying the works price and, after demand by the contractor, still fails to pay within a reasonable period; (4) the discounted amount is substantially equivalent to the actual value of the project at the time of the transfer.' Item (4) in substance caps the discounted amount so that it may not visibly depart from actual value.
- Transferee of the claim: Article 19 - 'Where the transferee of a claim to the construction project price claims priority out of the proceeds of the discounted transfer or auction of the project, the people's court shall rule weighing whether the project passed completion acceptance, whether the works price has been settled, whether the transfer contract is valid, and whether the transferee has paid a reasonable transfer price.' (Local practice once held that the priority transferred automatically with the claim, e.g. Jiangsu Higher People's Court [2018] Answers, question 20; the new interpretation changes this to a weighing review.)
- Subrogation in rem: Article 20 - 'Where the construction project is damaged, destroyed or expropriated, and the contractor claims priority over the insurance proceeds, compensation or indemnities obtained, the people's court shall support it.' Physical disappearance of the project does not prevent substitution of the object of the priority.
- Agreement to waive or limit: Article 42 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 - 'Where the employer and the contractor agree to waive or limit the priority right to payment of the construction project price, to the detriment of the construction workers, and the employer claims on that agreement that the contractor does not enjoy the priority right, the people's court shall not support it.'
VI. Ranking boundary (affects realisation, not the scope itself)
Article 36 - 'The priority right to payment of the construction project price that the contractor enjoys under Article 807 of the Civil Code prevails over mortgages and other claims.' The exception is the commercial housing consumer: Article 29 of Fa Shi [2015] No. 10 - in the enforcement of a monetary claim, where the buyer raises an objection to commercial housing registered in the name of the real estate development enterprise subject to enforcement, the people's court shall support it where the buyer 'has signed a lawful and effective written sales contract before the seizure; the housing purchased is for occupation and the buyer has no other housing for occupation; the price paid exceeds 50% of the total contract price', and its right excludes enforcement.
Boundaries of application
- Temporal effect: Article 23 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 - 'This Interpretation takes effect on 30 June 2026. It applies to first-instance construction contract dispute cases newly accepted after its effective date; where SPC interpretations issued before it conflict with it, this Interpretation prevails.' 'Listing amount + corresponding works in the operative part' and 'suspension and idle-time losses outside priority' therefore apply only to first-instance cases newly accepted after 30 June 2026; earlier accepted cases follow Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Articles 35-42, and Article 40 itself already excluded interest, liquidated damages and damages.
- Period and scope are two things: scope answers 'which works, how much'; the exercise period (at most 18 months from the date the employer ought to pay the works price, Article 41 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25) answers 'is it still in time'. Once out of time, even the clearest scope loses priority.
- Reference is not basis: Article 399 of the Civil Code is a mortgage prohibition clause; it can only serve as a reference for judging 'unsuitable by nature for discounted transfer or auction' and cannot alone ground a denial of the priority right; the works price claim itself survives exclusion.
- Do not cite outdated local practice: the 'six months' period in question 14 of the Jiangsu Higher People's Court [2018] Answers predates Interpretation (I) and has been replaced by 'at most eighteen months'; question 17 of those Answers, 'interest on the price is outside the priority scope', aligns with current Article 40 and may still be consulted.
- Unwritten but common practice: the decoration and fit-out contractor is usually also required to show that the employer has ownership or a right of disposal over those works; fit-out of leased premises generally cannot reach the building itself; whether advance financing falls within the priority scope differs by locality.
- This card resolves scope, not all the requirements for the priority right to arise (the demand procedure, contract validity, standing of the actual constructor and the like are decided separately).
Further reading
- Civil Code Article 807 (demand - discounted transfer by agreement / request for auction - priority out of the proceeds), Article 399 (property that may not be mortgaged, incl. item (3) public-welfare facilities).
- Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Interpretation (I) on Construction Contract Disputes: Article 35 (party), 36 (ranking), 37 (decoration and fit-out), 38 (quality passing), 39 (uncompleted works, the part built), 40 (amount scope and exclusions), 41 (18 months), 42 (waiver or limitation).
- Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Interpretation (II): Article 17 (operative part lists amount + corresponding works; suspension and idle-time losses outside priority), 18 (four conditions for discounted-transfer agreements), 19 (transferee of the claim), 20 (subrogation to insurance proceeds, compensation and indemnities), 21 (starting point of the 18 months), 23 (effective date and transition).
- Composition of Construction and Installation Project Costs, Jian Biao [2013] No. 44 (cost yardstick of the works price); Guideline for Construction Cost Expert Assessment Work, T/ZBD 100.4-2023, Section 3.2.2 (assessment opinions must follow Jian Biao [2013] No. 44).
- Provisions of the SPC on Enforcement Objections and Reconsideration (Fa Shi [2015] No. 10, as amended in 2020), Article 29 (three conditions for commercial housing consumers to exclude enforcement).
- Jiangsu Higher People's Court, Su Gao Fa [2018] Answers on Construction Contract Disputes, questions 14-20 (local reference; the 'six months' period is outdated).
Keywords
- 建设工程价款优先受偿权
- 优先受偿范围
- 承建工程部分
- 折价拍卖
- 停工窝工损失
- 判决主文
- 建标〔2013〕44号
- 法释〔2026〕12号