Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-31

Whether the quality retention money (3% retention) can be brought within the contractor's priority right to payment out of the construction project price, and the accounting method of back-computing, from the defects liability period plus the return-verification procedure period, whether the 18-month preclusive period has expired

Retention money is 'withheld from the works price payable' and forms part of the works price; it can be brought within the priority scope, but only subject to quality of the works passing (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 38), the return condition maturing on expiry of the defects liability period, and the 18-month exercise period not being exceeded (Article 41); interest and liquidated damages for late return of retention money enjoy no priority (Article 40, item (2)). The 18 months is a preclusive period; the 'date payment falls due' is approximately the defects liability period (12 months where agreed at 1 year, or 24 months at the statutory 2-year cap) plus the return-verification procedure period (14 days verification plus, absent agreement, 14 days return after verification, about 0.5-1 month). Back-computed from 36 months after delivery: with a 1-year period the due date is around month 12.5, about 23.5 months ago, already exceeded by about 5.5 months; with a 2-year period the due date is around month 24.5, about 11.5 months ago, leaving a window of about 6.5 months.

Applicable Codes

  • 《民法典》第八百零七条
  • 法释〔2020〕25号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第三十六条、第三十八条、第四十条、第四十一条、第四十五条
  • 法释〔2026〕12号《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第十四条、第十七条、第二十一条、第二十三条
  • 建质〔2017〕138号《建设工程质量保证金管理办法》第二条、第七条、第十条、第十一条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第10.5.1条
  • 苏高法〔2018〕《建设工程施工合同纠纷案件若干问题的解答》第14~20问(地方参考口径)

Positioning

This card resolves a specific dispute: years after delivery of the works, where the 3% quality retention money has never been returned, can that sum be brought within the priority scope as 'construction project price'; and how, using the defects liability period and the return-verification procedure period as parameters, to back-compute whether the 18-month preclusive period has already expired. For the time-feasibility assessment of post-completion tail-payment recovery and priority claims.

Core Conclusions

1. Characterisation: retention money is a component of the works price and falls within the priority scope

  • Civil Code Article 807, verbatim: 'Where the employer fails to pay the price as agreed, the contractor may demand payment within a reasonable period. Where the employer fails to pay within that period, the contractor may, except where the nature of the works makes conversion at value or auction inappropriate, agree with the employer to convert the works at value, or request the people's court to auction the works according to law. The price of the construction works enjoys priority of payment out of the proceeds of the conversion at value or the auction.'
  • The scope is locked by Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 40, paragraph 1: 'The scope of the contractor's priority right to payment of the construction project price is determined by the provisions of the relevant administrative department in charge of the State Council on the scope of the construction project price.'
  • Retention money is no newly created charge independent of the works price. Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138, Article 2, defines it as 'funds agreed in the construction contract between the employer and the contractor, withheld from the works price payable, to secure the contractor's repair of defects arising in the works during the defects liability period'; GB/T 50500-2024, 10.5.1, likewise takes the 'total settled price of the works' as the withholding base. Its character is therefore a portion of the completed-works price temporarily retained and deferred for payment, within that scope, and it is not among the exclusions of Article 40, paragraph 2.
  • Layered conclusion: the principal of the retention money can be brought within the priority; interest and liquidated damages arising from its late return cannot - Article 40, paragraph 2, verbatim: 'Where the contractor claims priority of payment for interest on late payment of the construction project price, liquidated damages, damages and the like, the people's court will not support the claim.'
  • Inclusion further requires three preconditions: (1) quality of the works passing - Article 38: 'Where the quality of the construction works passes and the contractor claims that the price of the works it built enjoys priority of payment out of the proceeds of the conversion at value or the auction, the people's court shall support the claim'; (2) expiry of the defects liability period and maturity of the return condition; (3) non-expiry of the exercise period (Article 41).

2. 'Period not yet expired' affects only when it can be claimed, not whether it belongs to the works price

These are two layers: attribution of the right (whether it is works price) and exercise of the right (when it matures). Before the defects liability period expires, the employer owes no duty to pay over the withheld sum, so the 'date payment falls due' cannot be earlier than expiry of the return period; once expired, the claim is definitively due and falls on the start point of Article 41, 'running from the date the employer ought to pay the construction project price'. Conflating the two layers is the common error in this kind of dispute.

3. Back-computing the time window (18-month preclusive period)

Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 41, verbatim: 'The contractor shall exercise its priority right to payment of the construction project price within a reasonable period, but the longest shall not exceed 18 months, running from the date the employer ought to pay the construction project price.' That period is a preclusive period: no interruption, no suspension, no extension by demand.

Parameters and formula (in months):

  1. Defects liability period D: Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138, Article 2, 'the defects liability period is generally 1 year, at most not exceeding 2 years' -> D = 12 or 24 months;
  2. Return-verification procedure period R: Document 138, Article 11, 'upon receiving the contractor's application for return of the retention money, the employer shall, within 14 days, verify jointly with the contractor the contents agreed in the contract... where no return period is agreed or the agreement is unclear, the employer shall return the retention money to the contractor within 14 days after verification' -> about 1 month; conservatively take 0.5;
  3. Date payment falls due P = D + R, running from the date of passing completion acceptance (taking-over); where the employer causes delay in acceptance, from 90 days after submission of the completion acceptance report; where the contract is terminated or void and the works incomplete, from the contractor's evacuation (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 14);
  4. Months elapsed M = months since delivery (or evacuation) - P; M > 18 means the preclusive period has expired and the priority over that portion is extinguished; remaining window = 18 - M.

Taking 36 months after delivery: D = 12 -> P about 12.5, M about 23.5, already exceeded by about 5.5 months; D = 24 -> P about 24.5, M about 11.5, still within the period, about 6.5 months remaining. Likewise, at 3 full years after delivery the defects liability period (2-year maximum) has necessarily expired, so maturity of the return condition is generally not the issue; the issue lies in the start point and the preclusive period.

Facts that can push the start point later (check the contract and settlement documents first):

  • where the contract fixes a payment date and it is varied by agreement for objective reasons such as extension of time, the varied date governs (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 21, paragraph 1);
  • where the contract fixes no payment date or fixes it unclearly, but a settlement agreement expressly fixes one, that date governs (Article 21, paragraph 2);
  • where the contract sets a further grace-period condition for payment, compute from expiry of the grace period.

4. Ranking, mode of exercise and requirements for the judgment

  • Ranking: Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 36, 'the priority right to payment of the construction project price enjoyed by the contractor under Civil Code Article 807 prevails over security interests and other claims.'
  • Judgment: Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 17, paragraph 1, requires the court to 'ascertain the amount of works price enjoying the priority right and the corresponding works, and make them specific in the operative part of the judgment'; paragraph 2, 'where the contractor claims a priority right to payment for losses caused by the employer's reasons, such as suspension and idle labour and plant, the people's court will not support the claim.'
  • Mode of exercise: filing suit or applying for arbitration is an effective mode; a mere letter of claim is not recognised as exercise under the Jiangsu High Court view (Su Gao Fa [2018] Answers, question 18) - a local reference, not to be taken as a nationwide conclusion. Whatever the mode, a demand does not extend the 18 months.
  • Liability for late return: Document 138, Article 11, 'failing to return within the time, it bears breach liability according to law' - that claim to breach liability stands but enjoys no priority ranking.

5. Practical tips (demand and damage control)

  • Demand within the period: apply in writing for return of the retention money and complete the demand chain (Document 138, Article 10, 'upon expiry, the contractor applies to the employer for return of the retention money' + Article 11, 14-day verification, 'where the employer fails to reply within 14 days after demand, the contractor's application for return of the retention money is deemed approved'), the purpose being to fix the due date and the fact of delay and to bring about the deemed approval - not to extend the preclusive period.
  • Where the 18 months have passed: extinguishment of the priority right does not extinguish the claim - pursue it as an ordinary claim (principal of the price + overdue interest / liquidated damages), while checking whether facts exist that can push the start point later: varied payment dates, a separately fixed date in a settlement agreement, termination of the contract after evacuation.
  • Procedurally, verify three things before suing: the defects liability period and payment conditions agreed in the contract; the payment date in the settlement or variation agreement; the actual date of completion acceptance (taking-over) (or evacuation).

Scope and Limits

  • The retention percentage follows the contract, capped at 3% of the total settled price of the works (Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138, Article 7; GB/T 50500-2024, 10.5.1); the percentage, high or low, does not affect the 'belongs to the works price' characterisation.
  • The defects liability period follows the agreement, generally 1 year, at most 2 years; agreements exceeding 2 years are not supported.
  • Old yardstick alert: the 'exercise period of six months' stated in question 14 of the Su Gao Fa [2018] Answers was a yardstick formed under Article 286 of the former Contract Law before the Civil Code took effect; it is now uniformly 18 months (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 41); the Answers' statements that letters do not count as exercise, that the actual constructor may claim by subrogation, and that the priority right transfers with the works-price claim are all local reference views. Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 took effect on 1 January 2021 (Article 45).
  • Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 took effect on 30 June 2026; first-instance construction contract disputes newly accepted by the people's courts after its effectiveness apply it, and where it conflicts with earlier interpretations it prevails (Article 23).
  • Not applicable / not supported: quality failing and not cured; works unsuited by nature to conversion at value or auction; the contractor having validly waived the priority right; interest, liquidated damages, damages, and suspension and idle labour and plant losses enjoy no priority ranking.

Further Reading

Civil Code Article 807; Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Articles 36, 38, 40, 41 and 45; Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Articles 14, 17, 21 and 23; Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138, Measures for the Administration of Construction Quality Retention Money, Articles 2, 7, 10 and 11; GB/T 50500-2024, China national pricing standard for the bill of quantities (BOQ) of construction works, 10.5.1 (withholding cap and guarantee substitution); Su Gao Fa [2018] Answers to Several Questions on Construction Contract Dispute Cases, questions 14 to 20 (local reference views; note that the six-month yardstick has been superseded).

Keywords