Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-31

Assessment and remedies once the 18-month period of the construction payment priority has run out: nature of the period and the layered consequences of expiry, back-solving the accrual date to rescue the claim, the differing effects of a written demand on the peremptory period versus the 3-year limitation period, and correction of the outdated from-completion six-month local position

Where 19 months have passed since 'the date the employer ought to pay for the works', absent an agreed variation of the payment date or a settlement agreement fixing another date, the 18-month period under Article 41 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 (a peremptory period - no interruption, suspension or extension) has expired, the priority right is extinguished and no priority claim can be made out of the discount or auction proceeds; but the principal debt survives and its 3-year limitation period (Article 188 of the Civil Code) is far from expiring - suit for the principal, interest and liquidated damages remains available, only demoted to an ordinary claim. A written demand cannot stretch the 18 months but constitutes 'a demand for performance made to the obligor' under Article 195(1) of the Civil Code, interrupting the 3-year period and fixing the accrual facts. Note also: 'the date of completion' is not the accrual point under the current position (that was the six-month local rule in Article 14 of the Jiangsu High Court's 2018 answers).

Applicable Codes

  • 《中华人民共和国民法典》第八百零七条
  • 《中华人民共和国民法典》第一百八十八条
  • 《中华人民共和国民法典》第一百九十五条
  • 法释〔2020〕25号 最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)第二十七条、第四十一条
  • 法释〔2026〕12号 最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)第十七条、第十八条、第二十一条、第二十三条
  • 苏高法〔2018〕 江苏省高级人民法院《建设工程施工合同纠纷案件若干问题的解答》四、第14~20条

Scope and Positioning

This card answers the frequent practical question: more than 18 months (say 19) have passed since 'the date the employer ought to pay for the works' - is it too late for the contractor to assert the construction payment priority now? It gives the conclusion plus the nature of the period, the layered consequences of expiry, the back-solving routes on the accrual date, and what 'asserting by letter for the record' actually achieves (against the 18 months or against the 3-year limitation). It also corrects the outdated 'runs from completion' and 'six-month period' positions.

Core Conclusions

1. Conclusion first. Article 807 of the Civil Code, verbatim: 'Where the employer fails to pay as agreed, the contractor may demand that the employer pay within a reasonable period. If the employer still fails to pay upon expiry of that period, the contractor may, except where the nature of the works makes discount or auction inappropriate, agree with the employer on discounting the works, or request the people's court to auction the works according to law. The payment for the works enjoys priority out of the proceeds of the discount or the auction.' The exercise period is in Article 41 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25: 'The contractor shall exercise its construction payment priority within a reasonable period, which shall not exceed 18 months at the longest, running from the date on which the employer ought to pay for the works.' The 18 months are a 'longest' ceiling and by nature a peremptory period - no interruption, suspension or extension. If 19 months have truly passed since the due date with no accrual-shifting event, the period has expired, the priority right is extinguished, and no priority claim lies over the discount or auction proceeds.

2. Three back-solving steps - any one succeeding may keep the claim within period (test the accrual date first; do not stop at the arithmetic of '19 months').

(1) The contract fixed a payment date, later varied by agreement for objective reasons such as an extension of the time for completion: Article 21(1) of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 - 'Where the construction contract fixes the date on which the employer ought to pay for the works, and the parties vary the payment date by agreement for objective reasons such as an extension of the time for completion, and the contractor claims that the exercise period of the construction payment priority runs from the varied due date, the people's court shall support the claim' - accrual runs from the varied date (a variation agreement, a supplemental agreement or minutes of meetings all serve as basis).

(2) The contract is silent or unclear, but a settlement agreement expressly fixes the payment date: Article 21(2) of the same interpretation - 'Where the construction contract does not fix the date on which the employer ought to pay for the works, or fixes it unclearly, but the parties expressly fix the payment date in a settlement agreement, and the contractor claims that the exercise period of the construction payment priority runs from that date, the people's court shall support the claim' - accrual runs from the date fixed in the settlement agreement (in practice often later than the payment milestones of the original contract).

(3) Neither exists: only then fall back to the presumptions in Article 27 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 - 'Interest is calculated from the date the construction payment falls due. Where the payment time is not agreed or is unclear, the following times are deemed the payment due time: (1) where the works have been actually delivered, the date of delivery; (2) where the works have not been delivered, the date of submitting the final account documents; (3) where the works have not been delivered and the price has not been settled, the date of the plaintiff filing suit.' A case falling within item (3) accrues on the filing date and is exercised simultaneously with the filing - necessarily within period.

3. Layer the consequences - expiry of the priority does not mean expiry of the payment claim. Article 188 of the Civil Code: 'The limitation period for applying to the people's court for protection of civil rights is 3 years, unless the law provides otherwise. The limitation period runs from the date the right holder knows or should know that the right is harmed and who the obligor is ... but where 20 years have passed from the date the right was harmed, the people's court will not protect the right; in special circumstances the people's court may, on the right holder's application, decide to extend it.' Nineteen months is nowhere near the 3-year limitation: the contractor may still sue for the principal, interest and liquidated damages, only losing the priority ranking and sharing as an ordinary claim (where the employer has granted mortgages, the real recovery rate drops sharply). Litigation strategy should shift from 'fighting for the priority' to 'racing the clock and chasing asset leads'.

4. The correct use of 'asserting by letter for the record' (a common error). A letter cannot stretch or preserve the 18 months: local adjudication positions have held that asserting the priority by filing suit or applying for arbitration is effective exercise, while assertion by letter is not recognised as exercise. The letter's real value lies with the other period - Article 195 of the Civil Code: 'Under any of the following circumstances the limitation period is interrupted, and it is recalculated from the time of the interruption or the conclusion of the relevant proceedings: (1) the right holder makes a demand for performance on the obligor; (2) the obligor agrees to perform the obligation; (3) the right holder files a suit or applies for arbitration; (4) other circumstances with the same effect as filing a suit or applying for arbitration.' A written demand letter plus proof of service constitutes item (1): it interrupts the 3-year limitation on the principal debt and restarts it, while fixing facts such as 'the time of the demand' and 'the employer's default' for later disputes (also serving the 'demand' element of Article 807 of the Civil Code and of the four discount-agreement conditions). Hence: for the 18 months, the paper trail is useless - suit or arbitration is a must; for the 3-year limitation, the paper trail is both useful and mandatory.

5. Correcting the old position: the completion date is not the accrual point. Article 14 of the Answers of the Jiangsu High Court on Several Issues in Construction Contract Dispute Cases (Su Gao Fa [2018]) once provided: 'The period for the contractor of a construction contract to exercise the construction payment priority is six months, fixed as follows: (1) where the works are complete and the settlement payment has fallen due, from the date of completion of the works or the completion date stipulated in the construction contract ...' That was the local position of the six-month era; it conflicts with the current Article 41 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 ('18 months at the longest, running from the date on which the employer ought to pay for the works') and no longer applies; under the current regime the completion date itself triggers no accrual - the starting point must still land on 'the date the employer ought to pay' (Article 41 -> Article 27).

6. Accrual where the contract is terminated. The current provisions do not list it separately; practice combines the rules above: where the termination agreement or settlement agreement fixes a payment date, take it (Article 21(2) of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12); where the original payment terms continue to apply as settlement-and-cleanup content and the period has already expired, take the expiry date; where payment was conditioned on completion, acceptance or settlement review and the condition is defeated by the termination, take the termination date; where nothing is agreed, take the filing date (Article 27(3)). Termination usually postdates the original payment milestones and is often the realistic route to 'rescuing' the period.

7. What can still be argued even after expiry (scope, in passing). Invalidity of the construction contract does not defeat the contractor's priority (accrual rules unchanged, but the above periods apply equally); while interest on the payment, liquidated damages, damages, and costs of suspension and idle labour and plant caused by the employer all fall outside the priority scope - Article 17(2) of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12: 'A contractor's claim to enjoy the construction payment priority for losses from suspension, idle labour and plant and the like caused by the employer will not be supported.' Packaging 'overrun losses' into the priority scope in negotiation or litigation is pointless; the principal is the true reach of the priority.

Scope Limits

  • The '18 months' is a 'longest' ceiling; Article 41 also demands a 'reasonable period', which in individual cases may be held shorter - do not treat 18 months mechanically as the safe boundary.
  • The fact-finding on the accrual date decides the outcome: a claim of being within period needs documentary support such as a variation agreement, a supplemental agreement, minutes of meetings or a settlement agreement; oral discussions or an exchange of letters without a clear agreed variation of the payment date may not be credited by the court.
  • Instalment payments / progress payments and retention money accrue separately ('accrue and expire period by period'; 'retention accrues separately from expiry of its return period'); they are not pooled with the overall price.
  • The Jiangsu answers (Su Gao Fa [2018]) are a local judicial document; Article 14's six-month rule conflicts with the current judicial interpretations and must no longer be used; its Article 16 allowing the actual builder to claim the priority must yield, for first-instance cases newly accepted after 30 June 2026, to the corresponding provisions of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 (one accepting a transfer or an unlawful subcontract cannot directly claim payment from an employer with whom it has no contract).
  • Old-new transition: Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 took effect on 30 June 2026; its Article 23 sets 'first-instance cases newly accepted after effect' as the boundary, and Article 21's new accrual rules do not reach back to already-accepted cases.
  • Where the employer enters bankruptcy proceedings, expressly asserting the priority in the proof of claim is generally treated as exercise; it must be asserted within the claim-filing window, failing which it is demoted to an ordinary claim (practical position, not statutory text).
  • This card maps the rules; whether a period has expired in a specific case, and where accrual lands, must be verified against the contract, the variation documents and the delivery and settlement timing before any conclusion.

Further Reading

  • Civil Code Article 807 (mode of exercise: demand -> agreed discount / request judicial auction -> priority), Article 188 (3-year limitation), Article 195 (the four interruption events), Article 189 (instalment debts run from expiry of the last instalment - note it does not apply to the 18-month priority period).
  • Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Interpretation I on Construction Contract Dispute Cases: Article 27 (three presumptions of the due time); Articles 35 to 41 (claimant, scope and period of the priority).
  • Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Interpretation II: Article 17 (the operative part of the judgment must state the amount and the corresponding works; suspension and idle labour and plant losses are not priority-ranked); Article 18 (the four discount-agreement conditions, verbatim: acceptable quality of the works; the works capable of discount; the employer in arrears and still unpaid within a reasonable period after demand; the discounted amount substantially equivalent to the actual value of the works at discount); Article 21 (the two accrual paragraphs); Article 23 (effective-date boundary).
  • Jiangsu High Court, Answers on Several Issues in Construction Contract Dispute Cases (Su Gao Fa [2018]), Part IV, construction payment priority, Articles 14 to 20 (historical position and local reference; Article 14's six-month accrual rule has been superseded by the current judicial interpretations).

Keywords

  • 建设工程价款优先受偿权
  • 十八个月
  • 除斥期间
  • 应当给付工程价款之日
  • 超期主张
  • 发函催告
  • 诉讼时效中断
  • 竣工之日起算