Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-29

Rules for determining whether the contractor's warranty and compensation liabilities survive expiry of the defects liability period (after return of the retention money): separation of the two regimes, affirmative and exempted scenarios, layering of the liabilities by nature

Expiry of the defects liability period and full return of the retention money do not release the contractor from its quality warranty liability for the works. Core reason: the defects liability period is only the security period of the retention money (generally 1 year, no more than 2 years - Article 2 of Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138), whereas the warranty period is the statutory minimum quality guarantee period set by Article 40 of the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works (foundations and main structure: the reasonable service life specified in the design documents; waterproofing 5 years; heating and cooling 2 heating periods/cooling periods; electrical wiring, water supply and drainage pipes, equipment installation and finishing 2 years, running from the date of passing completion acceptance); Article 17 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 states that 'the employer's return of the project quality retention money does not affect the contractor's performance of its works warranty obligations under the contract or under law', and Article 41 of the Regulation provides that where quality problems occur within the warranty scope and warranty period the constructing enterprise shall perform the warranty obligation and bear liability to compensate the losses caused. Only the two scenarios of Article 17 of the Warranty Measures fall outside the warranty scope: defects caused by improper use or by a third party, and defects caused by force majeure.

Applicable Codes

  • 法释〔2020〕25号 最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)第十七条
  • 法释〔2026〕12号 最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)第十六条
  • 《建设工程质量管理条例》(国务院令第714号,2019修订)第四十条、第四十一条
  • 《中华人民共和国建筑法》(主席令第91号)第六十二条
  • 《中华人民共和国民法典》(主席令第45号)第八百零二条
  • 《房屋建筑工程质量保修办法》(建设部令第80号)第十七条
  • 建质〔2017〕138号《建设工程质量保证金管理办法》(2017修订)第二条
  • https://www.court.gov.cn/zixun/xiangqing/504221.html

Positioning

This card answers a frequent dispute: after the defects liability period expires, and even after the retention money has been returned in full, does the contractor still bear quality warranty (and damage) liability for the works? It sets out, item by item, the affirmative and negative (exemption) scenarios with their bases, the layering of the liabilities by nature, and the procedural preconditions. It complements the card on the boundary between the defects liability period and the warranty period - this card focuses on whether the liability survives and where exemption lies.

Core conclusion

1. Conclusion: yes, no discharge. The defects liability period is only the security period of the retention money; it and the warranty period are two parallel regimes with different purposes, and returning the retention money produces no discharge. Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 17, reads: 'In any of the following circumstances, the people's court shall support a contractor's request that the employer return the project quality retention money: (1) the agreed return period of the project quality retention money has expired; (2) where no return period is agreed, two years have passed since the works passed completion acceptance; (3) where completion acceptance was not carried out within the agreed period for reasons attributable to the employer, the agreed return period expires ninety days after the contractor submits the completion acceptance report; where no return period is agreed, two years expire ninety days after the contractor submits the completion acceptance report. After the employer returns the project quality retention money, the contractor's performance of its works warranty obligations under the contract or under law is not affected.'

2. The defects liability period = the security period of the retention money (Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138, Article 2) 'The project quality retention money in these Measures (retention money) means the money agreed by employer and contractor in the construction contract to be withheld from the construction price payable, to secure the contractor's repair of defects arising in the works during the defects liability period. A defect means a failure of the works to conform to the compulsory standards for construction works, the design documents, or the agreed terms of the construction contract. The defects liability period is generally 1 year and no more than 2 years, agreed by employer and contractor in the contract.' That is, the retention money covers only up to expiry of the defects liability period and is returned then; afterwards there is no money held as security, but the obligation itself survives.

3. Warranty period and warranty obligation (Regulation, Articles 40 and 41) Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works (State Council Decree No. 714, 2019 revision), Article 40: 'Under normal use, the minimum warranty periods of construction works are: (1) for foundation works and main structure works of infrastructure projects and building works, the reasonable service life of the works specified in the design documents; (2) for roof waterproofing works, and waterproofing of bathrooms, rooms and external walls where required, 5 years; (3) for heating and cooling systems, 2 heating periods and 2 cooling periods; (4) for electrical wiring, water supply and drainage pipes, equipment installation and finishing works, 2 years. The warranty periods of other items are agreed by employer and contractor. The warranty period of construction works runs from the date the works pass completion acceptance.' Article 41: 'Where quality problems occur within the warranty scope and warranty period, the constructing enterprise shall perform its warranty obligation and bear liability to compensate the losses caused.'

4. Affirmative and negative scenarios side by side

# Scenario Conclusion Basis
1 Defects liability period (about 1 year as agreed) expired and retention money returned, but the 5-year waterproofing warranty of roofs/bathrooms/external walls unexpired The warranty obligation must still be performed, with liability to compensate the losses caused Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Art. 17; Regulation Art. 40(2), Art. 41
2 Both the defects liability period and the ordinary-item warranty period expired, but the defect concerns foundation or main structure works Liability persists within the reasonable service life specified in the design documents Regulation Art. 40(1); Construction Law Art. 62; Civil Code Art. 802
3 Warranty period expired, but personal injury or property loss within the reasonable service life caused by the contractor No further free-repair obligation, but damage liability remains Civil Code Art. 802
4 Contractual warranty period below the statutory minimum An agreed period below the statutory minimum cannot derogate from it; the statutory minimum governs Regulation Art. 40
5 Employer claims an order that the contractor pay repair costs upfront, without first notifying it to repair Not supported; where the contractor refuses to repair, or fails to repair to the agreed standard within a reasonable period, and the employer, having repaired itself, claims the reasonable repair cost, it is supported Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Art. 16
6 Quality defect caused by improper use or by a third party Outside the warranty scope; the constructing enterprise bears no warranty liability Warranty Measures Art. 17(1)
7 Quality defect caused by force majeure Outside the warranty scope Warranty Measures Art. 17(2)
8 'Expiry of the defects liability period = discharge of warranty' or 'retention money returned = discharge' The reading fails; no discharge occurs Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Art. 17

5. Three layers of liability by nature (determining the basis of the claim and the remedy) (1) Warranty obligation (free repair): confined to warranty scope + warranty period (including the reasonable service life of foundations and main structure), per Regulation Article 41. (2) Damage liability: does not automatically end with the warranty period; personal injury or property loss within the reasonable service life caused by the contractor, per Article 802 of the Civil Code: 'Where for reasons attributable to the contractor the construction works cause personal injury or property loss within their reasonable service life, the contractor shall bear liability to compensate.' (3) The superior basis of the quality warranty regime: Article 62 of the Construction Law: 'Building works are subject to a quality warranty system. The scope of warranty shall include foundation works, main structure works, roof waterproofing works and other civil works, as well as installation of electrical wiring and water supply and drainage piping, heating and cooling systems and similar items; warranty periods shall be determined under the principle of ensuring normal use within the reasonable service life of the building and protecting the lawful rights and interests of users. The specific warranty scope and minimum warranty periods are prescribed by the State Council.'

6. Practice points

  • Proof: a warranty claim must fall within 'warranty scope + warranty period'; a constructor claiming exemption (improper use, third party, force majeure) bears the burden of proving those facts.
  • Procedural precondition: the employer seeking repair costs must first notify the contractor to repair and allow a reasonable period; claiming 'upfront payment of repair costs' without notice is unsupported.
  • Time management: the defects liability period (retention money) and the warranty period (statutory minimum) run separately; 'retention money returned / defects liability period expired' cannot be set against a warranty claim within the warranty period.

Boundaries of application

  • Article 40 of the Regulation sets statutory minima; contracts may agree longer, never shorter; warranty periods for 'other items' are for the parties, and absent agreement are judged by trade usage and reasonableness - a live dispute area.
  • The Measures on Quality Warranty of Building Works (Ministry of Construction Decree No. 80) apply to building works; its Article 17 exemptions should not be extended directly to municipal, highway or other sector works, where exemption turns on the sector's own rules and the contract.
  • The defects liability period is fixed by contract (generally 1 year, no more than 2); its length cannot be back-derived from the warranty period, nor vice versa.
  • The effective date and old-to-new transition of Article 16 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 (applying to first-instance cases newly accepted after it takes effect) are governed by the official text released by the Supreme People's Court; check the acceptance date before citing it to a case; do not apply it mechanically.
  • Where the employer prematurely uses works that have not passed acceptance, transfer of quality risk and the warranty-period question belong to another rule set (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 on premature use), on a different level from 'whether expiry of the defects liability period discharges liability'; do not mix them.
  • Quality periods under material and equipment purchase contracts follow the purchase contract and product quality law; the Regulation's warranty-period table does not apply.

Further reading

  • Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, SPC Interpretation on the Application of Law in Construction Contract Dispute Cases (I), Article 17 (three return scenarios + return does not affect the warranty obligation).
  • Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, SPC Interpretation (II), Article 16 (no upfront repair costs without notice of repair; bearing of repair costs upon refusal to repair) - text and transition on the SPC website: https://www.court.gov.cn/zixun/xiangqing/504221.html
  • Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works (State Council Decree No. 714, 2019 revision), Articles 40 (minimum warranty periods and start) and 41 (warranty obligation and damage liability).
  • Construction Law of the PRC (Presidential Decree No. 91), Article 62 (quality warranty system and scope principles).
  • Civil Code of the PRC (Presidential Decree No. 45), Article 802 (liability to compensate personal and property damage within the reasonable service life).
  • Measures on Quality Warranty of Building Works (Ministry of Construction Decree No. 80), Article 17 (the two exclusions from warranty scope).
  • Jian Zhi [2017] No. 138, Measures for the Administration of Project Quality Retention Money (2017 revision), Article 2 (definitions of retention money, defect, defects liability period and its length).
  • Related cards: the triple difference between the defects liability period and the warranty period (length / start / security), the itemised statutory minimum warranty periods, and the timing and procedure of retention money return (see the cards cited in this card).

Keywords

  • 缺陷责任期届满
  • 保修责任
  • 质量保证金返还
  • 法定最低保修期限
  • 保修范围免责情形
  • 合理使用年限
  • 损害赔偿责任
  • 法释〔2020〕25号第十七条

Cited By